Governmental Entity Denied Withholding Public Records Due to Insufficient Exemption Justification
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sued a governmental entity seeking access to certain records under a public records law, claiming the entity failed to properly respond to multiple requests, including those seeking correspondence and internal communications regarding specific regulatory matters and litigation. The court determined that the entity's reliance on broad statutory exemptions, without adequately demonstrating how specific requested documents fell within those exemptions as required by the law, was insufficient to justify withholding the records, and thus the entity failed to meet its burden to justify the redactions and denials, necessitating disclosure of the requested materials except where specific, itemized exemptions were properly established.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; AC ; ORGANE(PERSONNE MORALE) ; INDEMNITÉ EN CAS DE TRAVAIL RÉDUIT ; COLLABORATION PROFESSIONNELLE DU CONJOINT ; ENTREPRISE ; CONJOINT ; ASSOCIÉ GÉRANT ; REGISTRE DU COMMERCE
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProvision cited for the order regarding court costs.
Testo completo
!""#$!"%%& !'%'!"%%'
( )(* *+* (* +)
, - '
# "%%'
+.......... !"##$# %%%%%%%%%%& ''( '"'!(!"'$)(' *+ , * -(&
('
) *+* /*0+) 1+ / ( ! !'$(-' (./"(00123033 0
+0433+
* 2)
3# $ %%%%%%%%%% 6( ' ( 0 7!8' ' 0//. 9 677 ( 6" : ;7 -!!7 '6 (!&<=>(((#
0# 6 (! =!57!8' '0//.!'!8 '('8 ! ' ' 3?"(-'315@0/!-'311."'* !(! A ( 8 ' '! ! ('( ('8 9 ='# !=(( !"8 '!(!"'( 9'""'(('8 "(" B ' 6!( (' 7(!.C8 '311?35 C8 ' 3115 ( 0. 0///# 7 D! D6 &'& ( " 9 ?/E#
2# '! . 0//.6 '7!96'! (!&<= ( 7D'(! +'"'=! (07!8' '0///3'7!8' ' 0//. "8 ( C( 7 ' 6 "!' ( ( # ( 7 -!'( "8 (" F('"" D!#
.# ''' '3G 0//.6'!7'!'!( ('((! ( " ((9( (6(' 6 (!C' >'# H"!8 '7 (('8 !("' (96"" ''( 7 ( ' "' !'( 6 "<( !(- 00 ' 0//. "' !(! %%%%%%%%%%*9'((((6'8-'(30I50G7'#2?"'"!' 3' C8 ' 23 !-' 0//2 (((( ' "J! '( 6! 0//2 !(- G 0//. "' F !(! "' '8 -'( F ((78'(H(' ("( 8 !(- 32 0//. "' "( K + $ D 8 ( !(! ' ! ( !(! 3' C8 ' 311G 23 !-' 0//2 "' ' 30I50G7'#0//230I///7'#0///90//03/I///7'#3111(@I/// 7'#311G93115#
?# !(!%%%%%%%%%%*9'( ' ('= (''" ?C 311G ( ( -( L' '!"'( ('"'( "'(( ( H"'(( (!' ( DM# 6'! ( !"H $ ' ! %%%%%%%%%% J ( ' ( " (( ( !+ =!'( 8 =(' 8 ' >' "' "'( 3I/// 7'# ( !"H"'"'(316///7'#
@# *!677 (""( : ;6'!!"! $ ' ! %%%%%%%%%% G C ( 3112 ( !"H ( !"'! @ 7!8' '0//.#
G# ''' '23N(0//.6 7'!6'!D"'"( " ( "'-96"J' ' 7( (4
4003540//. +2433+ ' "'( "( 7 >' 68 ( " ' ( 9 6 (! &<= "' "'(6" D6" (' !(!9 D(( ' >'N(!6H ('D6('"(( 8#! 3."(-'0//.!( ('!6 (!'!"'7 '"'8 '-'8( 'D( #
5# ''' '32"(-'0//.6'!"'6 ('! ' H"! D6 68 ( C "' ! !(! ' ( D6 !( ( !"'! " !# ' ' 8 ( "' ' 7 9 '( ('8 8'(D66!( ('(! !+=!'(D' "" '# 6H'O (( 8 (!6('"' 68 ("8 ' ! # ' ' 7 ( "!' "'( 340/> !(! 9 '"- (! (! ( " ( (# ('8 ( (' (( H('F( 77 "( ( 7 ( D6 68 ( " '8 ( D (' -( 6('( 68 ( " ' !(! 7 H! "'C=#
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
3/# '(01(-'0//.6'!'"'!(!"' 7'!'' ('((! (9( (96(' (! &<= ( !"# '!"!(! D6 6H'O ( 7 =( 6('"' ' (D66!( (F"(' !9J ((' " # 68 ( " > H "( 6('"' ( "' (! # !=('""!D'6 !(!9 '"- (! (! ! "' ( 9 C' (! - 8 H
4003540//. +.433+ ! - =( : ;#'"! (96!8 " C' (! !(!# (' '8! D C' "' ( >' !( ( D( "'!! D6 C ( "'(= ( " (! " ( 6(''D!"H('8 (F('"' # (( "'!"( !( (6'''8'!' !"'( !"H( 6- (( (( 6'! 8 6('"' # ' '" ''('"' '=(( (!' '#
33# '!"018-'0//.6 ( !'C(''# '"' '=(( (!' ' ( '!"!(! D !" ( "'( ( 6('"' ''( !( ( !'! "' " ( ( !(! %%%%%%%%%% *9' !"( '< H( > ' D6 '8F( ( ((( 6 !+=!'( 8 =(' 8 #
30# '!" D2C8 '0//?''("' (! #
7 ''-'' 'D!( (!"'!!"H "' ( 'DF( ' "'((' 6 C= D + !"! "'> ' - "' >' (# " '=( 8D! "'!!( D! D !"H ( 7'( '( =( 6('"' # (' ' & ( "( ( (' ( 6> 9 H+ - D6 8 F(' (' ( !"'( ' ( "(7 )('6!((7 !(!('8' #!( ( ((('- (' ' !'' D6('8 (" ( ( !(!' #
32# 'DF('"'((' 6 C=!"!='77 ' - "' >' ( 01 (-' 0//. 6!"H ''( D!F('!"'!!"" 8-'0//2#
3.# " DG7!8' '0//?6 ( !'""!D '( 8 ( >' C ( 6 "' "( " ( "'- 9 6 "J' D ('8 ( F ('"' 68 ( " ' ( 9 6 (!"'"'(6" D6 " ( + ((D6 !"'( C' D6!( (" ('8#* "' " - ' -! 8 (! !''D''("8 ("'!('H (! &<= 8 (D6""'(P("'88'(77( 7 ' 78' D 8'( ( ( J '( 8#
3?# ' 6 6DF( 02 ' 0//? 6!"H ''( !(! ( 9 ( (' ' =(# ' !'! D 7 68 ( C ('8 !"'&( '8D6 H" ( ((D6 8 ("8'! '# 6!( (D"'' "(-D6 68 (!'!"J!
4003540//. +?433+ 6('"' #6!( (!"'!!"'(6!0//2 '"" ( " H(# 68 ( " " ('8 ! &( ' 8 "'> !"'( # &- ( ( C'6& 3. ' &' '#J8 ((C'='!( # "("(' = 8 ( &- (! 8 7 & & &B "'( !"#" !"'( 8' (9((' >''!= >'( ' "( - '# > 3' C8 ' 0//? (' -( 9 ('( 6!8 (93I0//7'#"' #
(9''(7 '! '' D6 C ('8 ! &( ' 8# !=( !'! 8 ' ! 9 F(' (!"'6," =!!'' (( 7 >'"'! '# !( ( > ' 8 ( "' ('8' " # 8 ( 'O "' ' 8'(' "'>'!"'( 0.(-'0//.# 8 ((' =(' ' "( - ' &( ' 8 68 ( C ( !#* 6!( ("'( 7'(*9'( ( D( 7 ( D6 8 ( ( ( D "'( "( 7 >' + "'' ('( !' (!'Q( (!C9!" ! ((# 68 ("('8 !8(!"'( !"H"''' ( >'(9(' 7(#
(96 ( !((!D!"H!( (!"'!'8(D6 8 ((C'' 77!'(98 '"'6!"H''( 3.' &' '("'((' >'33& &# "'> '"'!(!"'( &=(6'68 (!(! =!#
3@# ( 0/ 8' 0//? $ %%%%%%%%%% !(! ( D (! (! # !'!('8 '"'6('"' %%%%%%%%%% &( '8*9' " 8 '@# J!( ("!'!( '# (9''( 6J 8 ( C ('8 !# 8 ( '( "! ( 6('"' 68 ( C ! ('( # (! (''=! 6' ("' '"6 !6H!(' ('( 8("'(> 'D!"H!( (C' ( '6('"' (6!( (C " '' 8!# 8( ' !"'( !"H 8 8 ( 9 & ( " + 6!"H ''(&- ( ( (3. ' &' ' ( 9 &+ '+!#
3G# $ '%%%%%%%%%%!=(!(!(((D(! (0/ 8' 0//?# ('8 ( 6('"' %%%%%%%%%% *9' " 3' (-' 0//2((D6"J!8"'(('(('8H'-(H#68 ( C 8('8 '''(((('"' (68 (""8 + # =' ( D6 !( ( ' ( (( D6 ! !(! '= (''(D68 ( =(''"(- '+ # 6' ('( ("H!(!''8("'('
4003540//. +@433+ ( 8 (! "'7 > ' D6 68 ( (( D68 ' # 68 ( C " 8 ( =! "' ''( 6('"' # ( 9 "(' &- ( ( 9 &+'+!# 32/ '( K'(H('8 (D-'H6('"' ("'' (" J &- ('#
35# 0@8' 0//?''("' (" >""!( '#
31# ''' '307!8' '0//.96 7'!(77 D68 ( ""' '!(D6 !( ( D!7 & 'D6!( ( !8 (' 7(32/'(K'(H#'68 (C &- (!9(( ' ( 6!( ( -' ' # 8 ( (C' &- (! &B "'(33& &# !(( 8 (!6 9"'!'9 &=(6'7 & 'D + 7 ((((( 0?'0//.#
0/# H (' 6(((( '! 6 01 8-' 0//. ''(8 (!"'!!"H#
* +)
3# =8 '6'= ( C ':;!(! 7 !( ( (!> 3'N(0//2 ' -(' "!?C= ("'! ((8 +"'! (?""!((3@C=':'(#3(# '(?@ ;#
* (96( 6!( 3@C='"' ' -7!!' 0GC8 '0//.: K32/3/@;' =8 "(!327!8' ' " ( (' ( ''=("'((( ' -(' !=' ' 9 (' C= ( ( ' 6((( 6!( 8HC='#
0# 7'!( 9 I'(# ?@ # 3 (# &# 5 ' - ( ' )( ( D((( "'!896'(#?@ '"'( =!!'' @(-'0///: ; D ( '( 8 9 7!!' ' 6'+&<= - =( ' ( 6 (!6 8- (!0?C 3150: ;#
*"!("'C='6">( !(- #
2# ('C(! ! ( 7' !=H '' ( '8- :'(# ?@ 9 @/ ;#
4003540//. +G433+ .# 7'!(96'(#5#3 6'!' (96 (!&<=9 ( ((6F('" "'( (" :'(#3/; - ' "'( ('8 9 "'' !'( :'(# 33; 6F(' "( "(:'(#3?;'" ' ( '( 89"!' ( ( 6F(' -!'!:'(#32(3.;(( 7 'HH =('<:'(#3G;#
*C' "' H (!(' ("'! ('' (96 (! '!( 6&' '('8 (' (96 (!&<=: K "- ! 2??4//05'0//3 #0;#
"'( ('8 ( F(' ('<- H ( 6( "' D 6( " ' ( 9 (! "' D 7 H( ! D "' 6"J'R"8( 7' !'-(RD (!6 ! -' 6 '= ' =( 6('"' ' !((' 6 "'( "( 7 >' 9 6('"' ( C ( "' D ( "!6('"' :'(#23#2(# S K"- ! 2??4//05 '0//3 #0;#
('8 ' D C ( 6 (( "'7 "'- 9 6 "J' 6 " ' ( 9 6 (! &<= 'D - D ! 7'("'('"' ( 97 H'! 6"J' 9 7' + >' !(' (# (' ' 77( !('' ( "' - " ( ' 6 (! &<= '!=(( ( >'6 (! '!( 6&' '('8 "'( '6'(#23#2(# :7# K302025 #G-4--;#
"''!('('>='D6('"' ( 6H ('+ 9 7 '""'( ('8 ( D 6'! '8 " ( "'-96"J'# "'6("'!D("' (9 6 (! &<= D6 7( 8 ' &<= "( "'( :*'!(' ( 6 (( 9 6! +"'> * ' ' C8 ' 0//2 &# 23;#
(( ( '8& 77!'( 'D ' ! ('8( " ( - 9 6 "J' D (( !7 ( 8( 6('"' ' 7'(' + S "' ' ( "'' 6 "'((8 (9!' #8FD6('"' ( 6H (' D6 ( ' ! "' ( '! ( ('( '"( !7 ( 8((( 8 !(!#6('6 (!'! "( "' " "'!(' 9 (! &<= :7# K 302 025 #G-4--S K"- ! 2??4//05'0//3 #0;#
'""''!D D ((!6('"' DC ( C ( " " ( "'- 9 6 "J' 6 "' " ' ( 9 6 (! D "' 6" D6 " ( &B
4003540//. +5433+ ('"J'(D6" "!' ( ( B &'6('"' C (:* ( $ 4 0//24.7 &.42 & 77'0;#
'>= 8 ( 9 !8 (' ( 7 ( 7# K '""! ( 7 D "'! (9H =#I= (8((("'(('('<"'( ('8 ' I" D ( ( ' ( 9 I (! &<= :7# '(# 5 # 3 (# - ;# ' ( ('< ( 7 (H!(-I= (I"J!D "'('8 ' (+D "'( ( I 8 " F "' "( 7( ' =( D - D 7'( ! "' 8( ( 8 (! "' "( !(!D ('8 (#"''" ( "'( >' "'"8(77(H'' 7'"'(('8 DI - ( D ' C(( ' &<= 77 ( ('<-# I( ' "'D K "!' (>'(' ("'(((8'I-! (( - =T(! '( 8( 9 IH ( ( 9 I "'( "'( ('8 I'!( (( "'7 ("'-9I"J'#
?# 6"> (''( DF(D''(67 (C ('8 ! "' %%%%%%%%%% *9' 6 "' ' D! 6 (!&<=57!8' '0//.( 8( "'>!"'( !"H# 77(> "' '7(6(( >'( '! 9 7 # ' !D( C' "' "'! (! ' ( 6"" D'9 (( 'Q8 D(('8 ' C (D (77( 8(('8 !6('"' D ">("'( "( 7 >'D ""'( (96('!"H#'F ''( ( ' ( !+=!'( '= (' ' 6%%%%%%%%%% &( ' 8 *9' 6J 9 6!8 C H'! ( 8 (!"'7 D!(!!(- "'(! ==' #
( ' (F(' !D6((( " #
@# 7 ("(D6'" ("6H ="!' ( ( 30 ( ! +' 8( ' "( = ( D6H =! "' 6'(# 32 # 3 # * " > ' D( 8 ' "(-!!7 '6( 7 -!'( ( '( 89 "!' ( ( "" ( 6'(#3. #*(( " ( ( -!'! ( '( 89"!' ( ( "'D (! +'("("30 ((6!( (""'( 9 '""'( ('8 ( "'(( 6( " '" ' ( '( 8 9 "!' ( ( 'D "' ( !"'( '" 8' 6 8 (!'('C ("'' --"' ""' ' '( 6 8 (! ( (' ( 6H''
4003540//. +1433+ ( 8 (! ' ! 6!('# (( " ( 6( "" - D 6!8!( D( '( " 9 " 6 ! ( "' '!!( (* (Q 6("' (#
6'(#3.#0 '"' >' =D"' D (' -7 >'(96('( 7 8 (9D'' '89 "')('# (( " ( "'-("'(!='"'D (""'!"'!9"''9'"'''9=('( 8 (! '( 8 ( D6 (( 7 >' "'! ' - = 9 "'' " ( ! ' ! '( 8( -'7 : K 30? 30. # # 0 ( '!7!';#
6'(# 3. # 0 ( "" - !=( !"'( 7 ( : 315/U03"#./S , *V('B '- (8' &'==(B W X8#U2?'(#3."#355;# -!'( ( '( 89 "!' ( ( 6'(#3.#0 6(" -D6 H ( (!('( 7 8D!(! (!"''6=(' ( 8 (! '( 8# "'8 (' ( (! "(( ( 7 D ( " F(' H =!# 6H ( 6 (! ( !C9F(' 'D6 ""')(" -('! -D8(!6'! "''( 8 (!'( 8!"(( '(( (!"'( 7 -!'( : K3032.. #?4--('!7!'S #@- "- ! 6''F( K 30. .//S ''F( ' - 7!!' ' 02 (-'0/// 3/?4//;#
(! ( !=( H (' (' ( 7 -!'( 8D! ( 6-'! ( ( :*0/// U3?"#.0 #@ "- ! 6 K 30. .//;# 6'(# 3. # 0 8 D (( Q 6 (!'! !(! "F&! 6" ' "!' ( ( "' D6 6( '! H 8( 9 ( != ( 7'( ( D 7 # ' - 7!!' ' +(+ C=!D"('8&"6"'!8 ' D 6"H'!6( 8 (! ' ! "' D6 H'O ( ( 8 (! !"( "= H+ C (:7# K30?30?8# #0#S #@"- !6 K30. .//;
G# 6">!"'( 7 (!"H'(6!0//2!(! ( 7 '! "' C ( ''( !=( "' (! # ' '8((' -( 96('( (6!"H ''( 7 ("' '"(D+ ((' (6H'' ( 8 (!' !" !"'( #'!D( 8 (6(('D ( -!'( ( '( 8 9 "!' ( ( ( "!96'(#3.#0 ('" #
4003540//. +3/433+ 5# 8 D "'!> J ((' D ''( ( 7 ( H ( != 7 -!!7 ' (! &<= '!'8 68 ' ( 7 ( H H = ('<# * '' ' > ' ! ((D! ! ( 6 ( ! ! " ( (! &<=>07!8' '0//.'!'8"'! (!#
1# ''( -(( = 6 ( ! ' ! 9 "J' 06///7'#9( ('!"#
+)2 )(* *+* (* +)
34565 7 855 5 9 #:" +;
65
3# !''''8-S
65
0# 6(S
2# ! ((''S
.# (' 9''( (!&<=>07!8' '0//.9 ( D6 (( 7 (HH =('< S
?# 6 ( ! 9 "J' 9 ''( 06/// 7'# 9 ( (' !"S
@# 7' "'( D6 "8( 7'' '' (' "'!( ''F( ! 2/ C' > ( 7 ( "' " '! '! ' - 7!!' ' *&Y B'&7D @ @//. (' H" '# ! "( F(' "'=!# ! ' (Z ; D' H((D! ''(! '-( ' ("! ((D!S -; H"' "' D ( 7 ( "8 ' ' (( (' ! S ; "'(' =(' '"'!((# * ! '
4003540//. +33433+ ( ( " (' !!( !!'! ((' ; -; ( ; + ' -7!!''"''"(''( >''''D6 8'!'' ''8-#! '''( ''J "'8 D '( C ( D ! ((D! ( 68"" D!(!H"! !''(:'(#3203/@(3/5;# ='77 >' '! (Z [\ ] $J $
" 7' "'!( ''F((( 7 !H"'( (*'!(' (6 ((9 6! "'='77
4003540//.