Contract Modification and Mutual Assent Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose regarding a contract's modification concerning the use of specific terms and conditions, where one party claimed the contract was materially altered, thus invalidating the original agreement and associated liabilities. The court reasoned that the alleged modification was not supported by clear and unambiguous assent from both parties, as required by contract law for such significant changes; consequently, the court upheld the original terms and conditions of the contract, finding the attempted alteration ineffective because mutual assent to the new terms was absent.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF, Art. 93 BGG, Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF; Contract Modification and Mutual Assent Dispute: The court reasoned that the alleged modification was not supported by clear and unambiguous assent from both parties, as required by contract law for such significant changes; consequently, the court upheld the original terms and conditions of the contract, finding the attempted alteration ineffective because mutual assent to the new terms was absent.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.
Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs for the respondent.
Cited in order 1 to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Cited in order 1 to declare the appeal inadmissible by simplified procedure.
Testo completo
#$%$&#'(() #&#'((*
++
+, , + ,
- * ! % ./ '((*
!!!!!!!!!!"#$%$&'( % )*%''+*%'#
%
" %')')'%" %#* ,-#%%%."
!"
&2/.3&
0
.5 5 !!!!!!!!!!"*2.'*#6.01."#$7*##%88'$. # .009 $ :%$ !!!!!!!!!!" ; " *%* $%* ' %< '$22#233=;.9-"%%%*$!!!!!!!!!!"$*% -> %-$*'+" 24 < 233=" ? ' %% ' )* '';)*$%>>-+)$>-5
25 2@ < 233=" )#$7 '** )A% ' %< ' )* ; " &#' B&$C D + >* + )88% '% 88%)*$<%A%#*;#'$8'%' %':':'%B&$CE D5
=5 .#233="!!!!!!!!!!$%+*%-$'>>- ' )* ') '*- '*>**%< ' #*+ %" * -'>'=&1'7%5
45 4?233=":#$7*; 5
15 4 ? 2334" !!!!!!!!!! %%%* + )* *%% $%* ' %< %% '$ 2= < 233= % =3 ? 233= $** + )A% ' %<*%%$>*?+)=.F%233=%5
G5 1 ?% 233=" )* 8#* ; '#' ' & +) )>% $ ') '% # ' ' > >- #8%% '$$#5
95 !!!!!!!!!!%%%*'8#'$$%#*' <7* .2?233=$ +)*88%''>>-% ;)*$>-"%':'*>**B6D%>H ')*$5
@5 % ') $$% ')%% < )* ' 2 $%#6 233= + & %<% ## %88 '$ . # .009 ; ' 4. - $ #5 %% %<%*" + %% ; 8 ' 8I $8' % ' #% '*%8" I>% ' < 6 ) % %A% $-* C $#5 ' > >- *%% < $%C%<%>#%*$C%<'+%?+*%<% $% ; >I5 ' ; )*$ >- *%% *>#% %<$%C#%;)%<%*$8%*%% '< %C #$%%5 )<% $ ; #% 6 $ -% + 03J5 %I'$>-"*%%$$'#6* $<% % <% '*?; * A% ' %< ': # % '# 2332/233=5<%%*!!!!!!!!!!24<233='
/.0.1/2334 &=/.3& %>''5)6%'6-$>-<%. $%#6233=5
05 '*'28*<2334" *;)*%%'%;'$%%5
.35 .9 8*< 2334" )% $$* ; '* $*%*5 % %*$$%=.#23345
..5 2G8*<2334")*)%*>#%$$*;%%'*<%+ ' ; )*$ % $ >- *%% % < %<%* $85
.25 =#2334"!!!!!!!!!!%%%*+)<%%%*)*'24< 233=.#23345)*<%*%%%#%8<65 #$%%'' #*%'%88" #6%+$%->'$%%B*$%$D $%A%'**###'$85
.=5 .1#2334"!!!!!!!!!!%%%*+)**%%$%*' %<%%'$2=<233=5
.45 2 ? 2334" !!!!!!!!!!" #*' ')'#% ' " ' $$*% #*'5 * ' ' )*$ >- % )%-%$*K&#*%$'$>-8%$$%'% '#'$85"-K)*"*')*$*%% '*>**%<%')>#%8%%$<%'$A%%%6*' #C$*$'*%;$85 %;'$"*%%*>#% '*>**%<5)>%'$')#'$85
.15 .1 ? 2334" ?%* )$$% ' )* 8'% )$$*%'!!!!!!!!!!%<%+ $%>%)<' 5"!!!!!!!!!!)*%%#%*;%%%+)#6% + * $% A% $ -> ' ' ' #' $85
.G5 .=$%#62334")*;)%''*$$% ' $C ' 6 % ' 5 )%<%* ' %88 *%% I%A##% $*6 % ')%- ; )*$ *%% %C 8*+%-K<'$'435<%-+?'-> '*6 % %<% 6 <* $#5 $'% * ')I%%')*%'%8+$#%%%')*%6%%7$')%<%* I* $ &#A# % 88%5 '#'% + 5 !!!!!!!!!!" *%7' 7'%'%LM%#%B D;C<%%'5 )%% #* $ *%% 88% % I$% #*' 8*;#*'$*%#*''%<'<%A%'*5
/.0.1/2334 &4/.3& .95 =3 <#6 2334" ?% ' <% + * *%% ')> '*>**%< % $<% 'C A% '** ###'$85%%*$#%%%$' + ' %" %6 %%* <% ') #' $85I$%*%%%%$85
.@5 '#'' 6'*"!!!!!!!!!!$**".1'*#6 2334"+) >8% N $*6# %*%*O5 7<% +%>''>'*5 *%%>**'*>**%8"" % *%% %#%+" % ; ' -%" %% 65 -K ' $%8'-%<"'#&%#%#*%%# $-K$%%+<%88%*%<I%A##%'88%%<5 " $% ; #' $85 )7 <% $ ' '%%88%')*$%'#>-5
.05 2G<2331" 6'*8*#'%':I$%?%#% $8!!!!!!!!!!"-8'<-#%> %-$% <% <' B PD % !!!!!!!!!!" #*'&-8 ; :%%% #''%*%<5'**+:;%':<'!!!!!!!!!! % ' '% #*' <* '" ' <%>% #$*#% *%% * 8 ' '*%# :I% ': % %%#%$*$'*%"<I<%*;:*$%$' :*%%<%*'%885
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
:>% ' $%-> ' $ >- C<% + -K%- '% :*88%#%8%"$%*;%'+% $ $<% < ; '*<$$ ' :%-5 '# ' %% >**" $-*#C *%* '*%" # $%Q% ## <#%$*'%%5 'C%'+$66%*' 91S+>8%8*++%8$*<*'-K%-' $'#*%:%$#$'5
$*':%'%' 88' %%+%% %' $%% 8% + :* :% $ # ':I :%<%* ' %885 '#%;'$%"'C%+%%$%* #%2=<233=5
:* $% $66#% I %<%* ' %7$ *'% #%% %%'##6$*%$%'->58%%%8< + :A% ' %< #% #%% ; 'I " + ' ':%% $ '88-':$$85'%$$*>> 8%+%6#+%+%$%->*%<# $ +" :*%% % ' *>%" : 88 #% $->5 <%$*+#$*-'
/.0.1/2334 &G/.3& $%'$%%*'%*+$7->+$%*' %<$<%A%#$%%5
%#%+:<'%'*I###%$%%$%6**8 ':$>##''%8%5
2.5 29%62331" ?%'6':I$%5
225 .1 '*#6 2331" % <* + :I$% '#%%% +: $<%A%8%%%<%*$8%*%88%# +: $<% *%6 %* $*$'*% % : % $$%* ; :$$*% ' 6 ' * +% ; *%* ':88% ' <%>%#$*#%5
2=5 +*%*>'*;?>5
+
.5 ><)>%?'BD*%*#'8*%%%*"'C .F%233=" 6%'"#$*'1?>" '% $*'% % <&$*'%" 1 $$*% % .G ?> B%5 . %5%1G D5
%;)%')*%'.G?>"$ 68*'* 29?<2334B ,.=3.3GD"' ><'$%*".=8*<" '$%%%>%$#%%% 6%' ' *> ; % ?> %%" " ' )%%% ' )*%'<I?>5
#$*%$?>'')$C%*%65
25 %?%* %#$ % '<% ?'% #$*%%" % <6 B%5G3'8*'*$%>**''%''G %62333U %1G5.%5-51D5
=5 % %* <> . ?< 233=" %V% #'8% ' #6'$%*>''#')&'%5 *>' $$+C>$$6%<>##%W 8%?'+#%'*%#%%$'%B ,.294G9'5.D" %$$6')$C5
45 )%5 0 5 . ' 8*'* :&'% ' 23 # .0@. B D" % *$%* #' $8" #' B%5= D ' I<#% ' #C $*$'*% U ' )I ' )%<%* $8U;'6%<;%%<I5 8*'* '* I ' )' :&'% ' 23 '*#6
/.0.1/2334 &9/.3& .0@2B D"%UI-%<B .00@JG.$5440DU'88% '%<5 %%+*'%88%8%$$% '%%%"$*%C<')%5052 5
I %# ' )%5 0 5 2 " % *$%* #' $8 B'%>**D%#''%%$<*+)%*%* * I<#% ' #C %%#% $*$'*% $ )I ' )%<%* $85 %% >** *$' 6 ' #6 ')*<% + 6%% ' % + 8*'* % ->* ')*%6 <% ' )%5 0 5 . B , ..G .4. '5 1 % *8*D5 ?$'" )I> ') % I< %%#% $*$'*% % ** + #' $8 *% ; 91S#')%<%*$8B ,.2G.@G'526"..023. '5 26D5 ')% %#" 8% + ')%%% $ >$ $8'*%#*%+%8$#6I+I>%*' $$% >** B , ..G .4= '5 1X 2333 J 43@ $5439D5
)%505= $*<%+8'$%%"#'$8 % #* ; '% $8 'C ? W )% '**5 #' $8 % *$%* '** 'C + $ %%% '% #%% $ $#C 8 ; %%#% #*' % $6 ' %<B%5G D5
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
/.0.1/2334 &@/.3& W $< ': % ' %* +8* :I$* #*' $% $ A% $$%* ' #C >**" :'# ' & ' $% % I5 <-" #*' >** % #$%6<:I>*>':%%%#%$*$'*%" < I< % 88% % %<%* $8 '*%#*" 6%-#$$'<%>%#$*#%<':*%6" '$%":I%'%%%*+8*B ,.2G.@0<5 '54%*8*X , '23#233==@./233.D5
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
$$" ?> :*% $ #%8 #$*%8 ' ': I$% #*'" 8% ?'" %M- ' :I$% *%% $**#% ' #%% $* ; '$% ' ?% ' )'#%%8':*$%#*'I':*%%'8%'*5 ?$'" $% %% ' :*% ': I$% B?'D8%+&%'%'%"+:I$% '* $ %6 8# ' #C <%5 %" + ':% $*% *#%%% ' $ % $% ; #%% *#%'%$%''*'%':I$%"$%I" "%$*%%'<>%'''$?> " 6" %% #$*#% 8# ': < I$%#*'B ,.21=12'5=6/%*8*D5
95 :$C" 6'*%#*+'<%>%#$*#% *%% * % '* *+ I$%" + *$' I
/.0.1/2334 &0/.3& %C ?$'% $ + % $ < $6%5 %#%'%%I$%+%%*;:*$>-+ $ >-' %<%$+% 8$8*+##%-K %88 B#* I $% 6M%#% $ I$%D + ' $$% >**" 6 + I$% % $66%* $ #$%%'<'88%-K$%6M%#%5
@5 < ' " 7 ' %% + $< ': % ' %*+8*%:%<%*$8'%%88%'% 88:$*%*$$%*5
*+"$%+:A%?%*5
/.0.1/2334 &.3/.3&
+ 0 , +, , + ,
12343 5 633 3 7" $*' , 8
43
.5 *<65
! 43
25 ?%%5
=5 8# $% ' +) $<% 8# % $*% A% ' '* ' =3 ? 'C %8% $ $ ##'* '* 6 8*'* ' " -ZK-8+ G" G334 " % I#$5 '* $% A% $>*5 #*# '%E D '+ I%#%+'*%'*6%%$''* %%+*X 6D I$ $ + #%8 %# $< '#' %% % '*X D $% >% ' $*%%5 #*# %% $ % **#% *#** %% D 6D % D &'" 68*'*'$$%#%C+) '<'*<65#*#'#%#7 ' $<" + % ?%" + '* %%+* % )<$$ ' +*%*I$*'*%B%5.=2".3G%.3@D5 >88CE *'%E 7 *
$8#'$*%A%%%8*I$%+);)888*'* '%*$6+$>88
/.0.1/2334