Contract Performance Dispute and Payment Refusal
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe plaintiff sued for payment after contracting for services, but the defendant refused, claiming the work performed did not conform to the contract's specifications, leading to a dispute over performance quality and resulting costs. The court ultimately ruled in favor of the defendant, reasoning that the contractor failed to meet the express contractual requirements regarding the nature and quality of the work, thus justifying the withholding of payment and potentially entitling the defendant to damages for non-conforming performance.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF, Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF; Contract Performance Dispute and Payment Refusal: The court ultimately ruled in favor of the defendant, reasoning that the contractor failed to meet the express contractual requirements regarding the nature and quality of the work, thus justifying the withholding of payment and potentially entitling the defendant to damages for non-conforming performance.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the respondent to pay the costs of the proceedings to the appellant.
Cited in the dispositive (Order 1) to declare the appeal inadmissible based on this procedural provision.
Cited in the dispositive (Order 2) to declare the appeal inadmissible based on this procedural provision.
Testo completo
!"
#$! %$&"!
'() !" *+ !"#$%"#&&# '()%**+ $,$%)%$ ** !$$ # #% %#
,, - ./ + "! ! 0( + 1!#! 2 $%$!) 34!5 6 '$! 78 + 9"3) !5!+ ': 13"8 !5 ': !"5" ;+ 4!) ))!))!")
-
,
. & $# /0000000000' ) 1% 23' 4#) "# ,$ * "$%# ## #$. "#)%)$"$%)% %*%#5$*"$!$226.
-. 3 % 7# 228' $ *)" ) *!* * "#%%$ * (# $5$*$%) "#9 * :,,$ % * :#$5$*$%) ;$"#9 : <' #$ *(%%$%4==.
>. ,)5#$#228'(#))%) !$?"#!$9#4"#%$!)*$ *$% "# # 0000000000' ")$$% !)*$ $%#' ? *!* * !)*$ $*$!*$& .%4"#%*$@ %$+)%% "#9 *4 )"$ * ! $ *(=)"%$% $+' $##= )%=A$+ 5 =A"#%$ " #%' %% "#9 7%)#$)!$ ? %"=A + * #) # #%=#$%%%$+*==@=579*,*# $%%*#$' %% "#9 ""*$% !$. (4"#% + "$%) * %#5$ * (#)()5$%?B. %%$"$%))%$%! %$5)"#,%$@ %%% ($% )#?(,, #%. "# %$?! A% @%#!)%$%#)#5).
C. *#*"#%%$ 5#)"#$!*$D&/'(#) ,$% ( 7E% *( *4$9! 4"#%$ E$% 228' *$% "# # 0000000000' ")$$% !)*$ $%# % #=!% @$. % 4"#% *$@ %$+) *$79% $$ *)"*% $$ +( ")#$#%=# "%=$ * ==*# $% , #!*(%*$$%*!"A#!$*. ! #7$*$%) "#)%))%$%$5%F%%"#9=)"%$% $+!$2265 #)$*$5 1% 223' %!% @)#$G %% "#9 7%)#$)!$ ? %"=A + * #)' 5 79 * , *# $% % * #$' !"@) *( #%=#$% * == @= 1% 226. # 0000000000 %$!) + "$%) * %#5$ % * (4"#%$) ()5$% ? 6B *9 # 1% 226%?B*9 1%228.
6. #"" #% * 2 E5$# 22H ? ( ' # 0000000000' 5 !)*$ %#$%%' *$@ %$+) %% "#9 7%)#$)!$ ? %"=A + * #) 5 #%=#$% "%$+ * == @=' %% "#9 =)"%$% $+5$##= !$226'%%"#9"#)%$%%*$79%" % "#)%$+% 4#%=# @=#)$*. ($"$%)*%#5$* "%$%)%$%% %. >
3. #0000000000'*4$9!!)*$%#$%%')@!%*#)#"" #% ? ( ' *% * H !$ 22H. " ) *$@ %$ $5%F $##= )%=A$+5=A"#%$ " #%' 4#%=# @="#9#%=#$%"%$+ * == @=' ""*$% !$ % *$79% * %A" . %$!) "$%)*%#5$* "%$%*"$-8E$%223%, #!) #!#+ $5%F I& $# /0000000000 "#)% * *$79% $$ %#$%) # , * * $##= )%=A$+ %!% !. #$ *( 4#%=# $!" #%% *$# ? #%=#$% "%$+' $ "% *)"#+*$,,$$!%% 5%'?($**. #% %#$ ' *!* I ?BJ.
8. #* * ($%#%$ * * $#' ( #* ) 4"#%$ "#$*$$"$$# +$ )%) *$% %# *( 7#5%$ !)*$ * (#$5$*$%);$"#9& <E5$#-.%% $ ' (4"#%$),$%( 7E%*( $$!*"A=$%#$E5$#-%*( $$!*# @$-E5$#-. (4"#%"A=$%#*$@ %$+) "# $%) )! %$ !% 7$' %A" $!"$, $$ +( %# 7 * (*"%%$ 5 #)%$ !$4% 4$ *)"#$5G F I% 4"#%$)"#)%%# 7*"# $%)*%A"7 #*#$*+ #95 = #!$ "% $!"$, % * %* "@ ? (%' * %#$% #$$+. #95 )@!% %!% #)%$ 4$ *)"#$5 " $!" #%% + ) "#))*% "$+($ %% *)@K%7$"# #"." $%*5"A=$%#$+($"$%)*%#5$ "#L%M%#*( #*#*6B. %#$%!%%$*)"##"#$=$7$%# * #"%# * )# % $' "# 4!" N 4$,#' "#L% $*$+)J. (4"#%# @$+%?$%$!)"$%)*%#5$'*" $%*5 %#$%!%# @$+'?6B! $*%$5$%)*"%). #"" #% * C !$ -' 9@ * 4"#% " ) *$@ %$ $5%F I# 7 * (*"%%$ 5 #)%$ !$4% 4$ *)"#$5' "# $%) )! %$ !%7$'%A"$!"$,' 4#%=# *$#@=! *)#) ?#%=#$%"%$+'#5$ * # !7@$**#*(A*# ! * #4 !% , #! "#$%%' *$79% $$ #+)#% 5 " A# "%=$*( #$@$!$4%; '*$79%<'%))*%**)"*? ( '$##= =)"%$+$@*(%)#%$ =)"%$+'49" *)#J. 4"#% % +*"$*)7%22H'"$%)*%#5$)%$%*6B *"# ,$ *"%)+$%$ !"%*$!$%%$ ;"*" $%$ *7 % "# @)' " * " $%$ %%$+' !#=' " * " #% * =#@ ")#$# ? 6 O@<. ($"$%) )%$% % % * "# ,$ * "$%# ## #$ % ! 7$. % , #!) #!#+ $5%F I $*)# +"%$%$"$%)% %*%#5$*!$226?,$ *)!7# 228. / $"$%) * ($ "# ,$ * "$%# C
## #$#%% %, $% %%$*!$9#*),$$%$5.# %#'*"$ *)7% 22H' $*)# + "%$% "$%) * %#5$ * 6B * "# ,$ *"%) +$ %$ !"% *( "#% * $!$%%$ *)#$% !$ )@!% * !")% % * (4")#$ "# ,$ +$ #*)J.
H. # *)$$ * > E$% -' ( %# A) ? (#) *!$#% *($5$*$%)?"#%$#*#E$%-" #*#)$*)%#!$).
2. # *)$$ * - 1% -' ( ( !$ 7)),$ *( #% %$9# *:$5$*$%) * # % 7# 223 > !# 22H' "$ *( *!$#% *($5$*$%)*#5#$22H>E$-.
. # ##$#*2!#-'(#)'#"#)%)"#&L%# ' $$%) "#9 * ( 5#!% "$% *( ! %% * 6: ,#. ,$ * " 5 $##"#*### #$.
. # *)$$ * 6 E5$# --' ( #,) %% *!*' ! %$, + (#)#!"$$%" *$%$ " #( %# $*( $* "$%G ,,%' $ " 5$% " #$5# (4#$ *( %$5$%) #%$5 *)"*% % (5$% *9 # " *# $% ? $* "$%. # $#' (%$5$%) +($ !"%$% %#"#*# ##" *$% " ? %$5$%) *($*)"*%' )%% * )+($#$%!" A)*( $)%) A!.
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
"# $%) #$$+ %# 7 !"%. ? #' * % %$% ,$% +(*$@ %$*%# 7*"# $%)4$@ 7#5%$ #)")%)# " * %!" Q )%*. ;...< $ ' $ !(""#L% + & $# /0000000000 "#)% " * "%= @$ "A=$%#$+ %)#% * !$9# *#7 $%#!$%%% "$%) * E@!%' * ! $ %% + !!%$ !$5*( #"#*"." $%*5'$(A"* %#$*$%$ !)*$ ? ( %$ *( "$% $ *( #%. #5='$%5#$+))!%*"# $%)#$$+!$)5$* "#(4"#%$#"#)%%" %%$!%#$+" #@%$ *("$%' "##%$!%$ *"$%).#$+%$!" $7?+%$,$#."' $%$)?*))!%*"# $%)% "?"%= @$"A=$%#$+ ,#=%$*$%7J.
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
C. 7#5%$ !")!%$# * -> !$ --' # #% #"") +($" 5$%%#5$#?B%%+*$#%#*(@#@' #+* "# ,$ * 5*# * 5 $%#' * + $ ,$% *)"# 5 $%# 3
*#%% %E #)'$"#)%$%+("$%)*%#5$*6B.,$'$ ,$% 5 $# +($ )%$% *$" ) ? + !! *!*) $ $% * "#!$#%!""#M%)%+"#M% $%$%%#, #!)$*"$% 7$@%$ * #!7 ##' #+($ #$% *)! %#)' *#% $+ ' 5$7$$%) * %#"#$. "#$%) " # #" * %#! % $ * # #.
6. *"$+ * - E$ --' ( "#$%) * %#! * *)$$ % $ * "#)5$.
. 5$% "#)7 * "#)$# + $ @5 $ # ( #@$%$ E*$$$#*-- 5!7#2C; <)%)! *$,$)%+(#$7% * # $ )%) $%$%) *9 # 1% ->' %%% $% $+' %!!%# %%%$ #%$5? $,)*)##(# $5$*$%) ;,. #%. ' %. # % 63' . ' %. ' =$,,# - <. , #!)!% ? (#%.>'.>* $*C 5!7#--! *$,$% '%#)5$@# # 1%->'"#)%'$%# *$%H,)5#$#--%"*%*5% !!$$ % * # # !%$9# *(#$5$*$%)' )%) %#!$*( ,,$#$7% *# $.
-. #$7*) %% %#+# #'$%#E%)%!"%$'% #57?, #!' , #!)!%4#%.32* $,)*)##(# $5$*$%)*2E$262; <%HC* $,)*)##(#5$$ %#5$5%*-*)!7#2C3; /<.
>. $,)*)##"#%$@))#**# $%*# $*3 % 7# -; <%%#)5$@##E5$#->%%#L)! *$,$%$ * !7# *$" $%$ * * !$ * (#$5$*$%). )@$%$ 5$@#E+(>*)!7#--*!#% %, $*)%#!$% ("9.,,%'*("#9E#$"#*')@$%$ ""$7* =@!%*#9@**# $%#%+$)%$%5$@# #*#)$%$ * ()%% * ,$% +$ * $% M%# ""#)$) E#$*$+!% +$ * )+ E#$*$+;N-6C38 $*.G-333 $*.C7<',$%#+ 8
(% #$%) * # # "% M%# !) ? "# # * *# *( "# )*# * # # * *# $% *!$$%#%$, )%% "# $# 4 +$ % "# *$% E+( ! !% * *)$$ *!$$%#%$5 $%$@$ ;N - >33 $*.7<.
C. # #%%7)),$*(*!$#%*($5$*$%)*"$"#!$#E$% -'" #*#)$*)%#!$)G$(%""%?4##"# ,$ * "$%### #$% ! 7$./ (4"#%$*& *C!$-'$ "#)%#5="$%)*%#5$*6B*"# ,$ *"%) +$ %$ !"% * $!$%%$ , %$ ;" * " $%$ *7 % "# @)' " * " $%$ %%$+' " * !#=' " * " #% * =#@ ")#$# ? 6 O$ <. $$%) $* "$% * 6: ,#.' ,$ * #"#*#? !"%@#@% ! 7$. ( #E%)*$%*!*.
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
##M%*6!#--.."#*/ --'".H6' #$7,)*)#*#;$"#9N<"#)$)+($*"$% *5$% M%# ) 4 #) +$ )%$% #$) 5% #5 * H
($5$*$%)!%$(4#$*(%$5$%)$*)"*%)%$%)$# #$ * ($5$*$%). /$' #5=' (#) " 5$% 4## %$5$%) #%$5#$)'$(5$%"*# $%?$*"$%.
C.7 ( ##'5% $5$*$%)'# #%4#R$%"# ,$ *"$%# ## #$. 4"#% * & % )5) +($ ()%$% " "7 *(4## %% "# ,$ ' !$ "#)%$% )! $ "$%) * %#5$ * 6B*%$5$%)*"%).
# #% %$%"*%+($" ##$%4##%$5$%)?"$%!" +$%) * *$#%# *( @#@' %$5$%) +$ $ "#!%%#$%' $' * "#5 $#@$! $)+$5%?$+($"#5$%5% $5$*$%).
#$7 * ) %% + # #% ( ? E # E!$ )%) $*)"*%%"%7%7$ %$#?4##%$5$%)#$)#"" #% 5 !")% % $!$%%$ , %$ . (4#$ *( %$5$%) $*)"*% (% * " $% * 5 * (#$5$*$%) " *)%#!$) 4$5!%"#)$%)+()"# 5# #%*7)),$$#*%%$* " ##! %# 7%)"#($5$*$%). *!**(#)"#L% 7$ "%S% *$%) "# * #$ * = $4 "# . 5$*# "*% *(4!$#'$'"#9*!#*#)*"%%$ '*#$##$%""%? 4## %$5$%) #$) ? "$ %!"' !! "# 4!" *( *$#%#*5%*@#@' % %%#%$5$%)*"%)?$!$%%$ , %$ ' "$+ # #% (%$! "7 * %#5$# ? "$ %!" *%$5$%))@9#;,.=$,,#6$"#9<.
$$' #% ($* "$% "# "#!% *$%' $ * $% M%# #,)' )@#*?E#$"#*$#*N' +$(#)"%4## %$5$%) #%$5 #$)' +$ % ("9' ($* "$% "% M%# %# A).
5*! %$,', #%* %%#+# #%!, *).
C. ## L%'#$7*)#95+4"#%*& % %!!% " ) !! *$@ %$ %# 7 * (*"%%$ 5 #)%$ !$4% 4$ *)"#$5' $$ +( "# $%) )! %$ !% 7$' %%$% "A=$+ +$ % $, # "$%) * %#5$. *$% 4"#% % )@!% #5) + *"$ 5$# %# $ ' "%$% )%$% 7%$%' +$ )%$% ,$#!)"#()5 %$ $$+%"#4!*7 #% $#. #$+ *#)$*$5!7$%% %, $ )@$@7%$)%$%$!" #%%;"#$$"!% #$ *%# 7*"# $%)%*($%%$ "#)$#<+"%$% "$ 7)),$$# * " #$% *( %$ %=)#"%$+ #)@$#. %#' 2
#0000000000'"A=$%#!*%)"## #%" #4"#%$ "#$5)'*#$#"#)%"*"%= @$"A=$%#$+%)#%*!$9# *#7 $%#!$%%% "$%) * E@!%' * ! $' %% + !!%$ !$5 *( #"#* ". #5=' $ % 5#$ + ))!%*"# $%)#$$+!$)5$*"#(4"#%$#"#)%% " %%$!% #$+ " # @%$ *( "$%' "# #%$!%$ * "$%)G#$+%$!" $7?+%$,$#%%*## L%$)?*))!% *"# $%)% "?"%= @$"A=$%#$+,#=%$*$%7.
$$' *( " $% * 5 !)*$' ( %# $ *( $* "$% (""#L% " *)) * % % #$+ % * % )@$@7 7$% +% ? 5 $# $ # #%%"%'*"#"$%)"A=$+'?@)##"$%%?4## %$5$%)#%$5$*)"*%. (* *$%$ *( %# $*($* "$%' ? 5 $# * " )*# +$%) "# +(4$@ (4#$ *(%$5$%)$*)"*%',$%)@!%*),%.
#! %$,)@!%'# #* $%M%##E%).
C.* #$7 * ) %% " # #" + 7$ % !"% *(4" $%%$ 22H%222, #$"#(#)"#!%%%"*()5#+ #$% #5 +($ %$##$% *( %$5$%) $*)"*%G ,,%' " % $#%=#@ $ %"*)%$)G( $@ #"#4!" !7$ * #$) $)%) A! P0000000000 / !" $' * !M! + ! %%*$#*(%*$#%#.
5*+$"#)9*', #%* %%#+# #%#!"$%" *$%$ *( %# $" #$*"$%.
9 ' , + 6
555
8 <("$! 6
. R $%# #G
<( 6
-. #E%%G
>. $%+"# )*#%@#%$%G
C. , #! "#%$ * +: "5% , #!# # # %# "#)% ##M% * *)$ * > E # *9 %$,$%$ "# "$ # !!*) *#) #$7 ,)*)# * #' /=T$Q#= ,+$ 3' 3C ' %# $ 4!"$#. *)$ "% M%# "# @). !)! $# * $% F < $*$+# 4%!% +: *)$$ # #% *)$# 7%$# $ % " * *)$$ %%+)G7<4" #" #+! %$,$%$!" 5 $#*!*#%% %#*)$$ G<" #%#$@%# * #"#)%%./$!)! $# %$% " %# $ ))!% )!)#) %%# < 7< % < $*' #$7,)*)#*#" ##"%##!%$9### #+:$ *5#*)##$##57. !)! $#*# #!%$ # #! A * "#5' +$ # % E $%' $$ + *)$$ %%+) % :5 "" * +)%)4")*$)# #%;#%.>-'3%H<.
@#,,$#F #)$*%F U$* !# $ *)
#)%$#E#$%FN#)*)#$+#
"$ , #!*"#)%##M%% %$,$)4"#%$ $$+:?:,,$,)*)#* # $"#@#,,