Asset Valuation in Dissolution Proceeding
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant sought to overturn a decision regarding the valuation of an asset in a dissolution proceeding, arguing that the lower court erred by using an appraisal methodology that failed to account for the asset's non-transferability and restricted marketability, resulting in an inflated value. The court reasoned that the trial court correctly applied the relevant valuation standards, which permit the use of a market approach even if a market adjustment for lack of marketability is deemed unnecessary or inappropriate under the specific facts presented, and that the appellant failed to demonstrate that the chosen valuation method was clearly erroneous or an abuse of discretion given the evidence presented regarding the asset's actual potential for realization.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; AI(ASSURANCE) ; RENTE COMPLÉMENTAIRE(AVS/AI) ; FORMATION PROFESSIONNELLE ; FORMATION(EN GÉNÉRAL) ; CONDITION DU DROIT À LA PRESTATION D'ASSURANCE | LAI.35; LAVS.25.al.4; LAVS.25.al.5
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAImposed the costs of the appeal on the appellant, as is standard procedure when an appeal is unsuccessful.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'(() "&%)"'((&
*
+ ,+ ! - +! -!,
'' . '((&
#/ !0 1 2222222222 !"#$!#%%%%%%%%%%& -33,! 4+! ,5, , -+ ''! + , 4 $ !''' ( $! $)&*+,"(
! -./+-
3,
*4 # ' %%%%%%%%%% !' 56' $7 '" $7'('$'& ' !!$7 !!' 6(6($ %%%%%%%%%%&* 8*0+*4
.4 %%%%%%%%%% !! 8 *00+ '9 $ )' 5 : 8.22*4 !' $$0;'*0 5 .22*4 '9 ( $7'9 $ 9' ' $ ( <' " $ =%%%%%%%%%% .> (' .22. ' (6 !' $"*0 8.22.4
34 $'' $ *0 !5 .22.& 766' $ 7-'('$' '$ , 79 ?'-" @& " ( ' $ ( !!' $" 7 5' $ : $ )'& , ( $ ',$"* 8.22.4
14 A (!5 .22.& ' ' $ !' <'B , #$! #%%%%%%%%%% B 6' (' $ (! '6 $ !!' $' * !5 .22*& ! '6 B7' 7(' ' ! 6 !' 66 $ 4 7 & $'' $ *0 $!5 .22.& 6'! '' & ' B7C'$7<!''&%%%%%%%%%%) ''$ !!
6 !' $ $ !'&B' !$6 $ $ ', $76$$5$ ('9D4
A4 %%%%%%%%%%& !"& '; *A ;(' .223& " $ !!'' 6$ $ !'" $7 E- '$,794 '&$'' $.F;('.223& $' ! !' $ ' , !!'' $ E- $ $"(4
>4 $,$' !!'' &7 ;$ 4
F4 (' , $!'& #$! #%%%%%%%%%% $ B7 C' G ' $ B7 5'9' 9$766 ('!'''!H) ! 6' $ '( '!!$'! 6 !' 4 7)G )" I ' 7'$87G !&'($ 'B7'
/*+01/.223 -3/+-
'9 6 !' !!'& $ B $''($7: E?J3.>0@'BC B' !' $ (' !''' ?K@ $ 6 !' '$ !! 6 !' B7''('6 !' ;B7, (' B7 " ('D '5 $7"D4
-,
*6 @ ' 9( ' 7 9'' ;$''' ?@ ! $'6' ''& $" * 8 .223& '5 $ ' ?4 * 4 @4
H$32!.221&$& '5$!'''6?'-" @ $7 66''$74*4& '$B E(' (' ' $74*3*$ '' 9( '- -4
5@ : $ B ' '' '5$&< ! '6'(L
- 6'9 $ $' ''6 $ 7H4 & $' ''6 $7 ;9! B' 7 ' $ ) ;9& ! '64 7 '$) ;97$,<-'B$! I $' ''6 G ( ' <! I ' , B' ''9' ? : 0> .0AM N& ' $ $ ' $!'''6& 1"! $'' & *00*& 4 .1+ M O5)'$& $ ' ;$''' '( '& *0+* 43*34@4
- 7 '$) ;9(B 'B7' 'B ! G B'5 ('<!'?64N& 4'44.A*@4&'P 7"$ <B $('&!H! ('&,7 ' $7 '; (' ' $ $ ' ''B H $ '$7 6'<$$7' $;9 E& Q '' '$ ''';'$'' 4
/*+01/.223 -1/+-
- '' '' 'H$4E&7' '' $ -' 5 ?64 -:R ' 5& $)$E)S'T&( 4&*00*&4*F+& 132@4 (' $(B7'5$ '"99$79'( & ''"! B B $ 7'
5 (' 9'! ;'$'B ? : . 3*3@4 !'6!''&$" B '$ 'B$7H$ (','7<'$7;'$'' B'6 ' $'* 8.223$;,&$ ;9''&''B;9& 9'"!4
@ E <!' $7 66' !M ( 7H $ $ 32 ! .221 ';B7, <'&'9!,('6' 6 !',74*3* $ '7''4
E;'$'' $!'''('&B7'$ $ !'''$ '4G'$B 74 AF $ ' 6$ ' 9 $ $ ' $ ' - -& ('9 * ;(' .223& )B '' '5 $ & B' ' 'B $ $ !' $ '4 $' '' 9 6$ 5'9 , 9 '< $ ' !H! '& '<;B,',"($'( !!'' $ 4 7'' $,7<'9 '6$ B9'9( ' E4
E 74*3*4* &C '5'$'5<! ;9 '(' M "9 !5& 7 9'' & ;'$'' !D4 $' $ *0F*&$' '' '' !'.&'5 !!'LC'5 $!'''6'' $$ '$!'''6$ I '( 'D4
'' 7'" !H!''B ' $''4 "9 $7'' ! ;9 $ $99 $7 $' '' L $' ' , '' '& )' 'B& 9'B G!'B$ !4;9$('' ''!$ < ' $ '4 & $ H $ 32 ! .221& '$ B < $ 74 *3* 4 . '' $ $7 '5< $ $ ' $!'''6M ' ' C '5D
/*+01/.223 -A/+-
!!'9'6' C'5D4&74*3*4. 'B '5 $!'''6 '' C$ I ' ( 'D4 7 $' B '! $ '< $!'''6 "( $7 ;'$'' 4 ''7'' '!,$ B !CD$ 'HB'6'&9!!'!&$7''$!'4
G $ 6'! '' )' 'B 9'B4 $ (< ' ?#! ' $ $ ' U # -*0F2&4AA14@B9'*0F2$'&<Q$ ;'$'' '(' <' ( , 74 *3* 4 * & '5$!'''6'$$$ ( '<'64 '5'$', ! 'U '$7 & !!'' $ &KB' (' , P $ $'' $ $!4 7' $B' B!! '9&' B '57'($ $ !$7'5' 4'('$B' !!'' ' $(' 5'& !! ' $ ! '' ''"? ! '' ''&<K@4E #! '$ $ '&4AAF&C$G"!('9& & '$7 !!'' ''$ !''$'$& ' $ ;'$'' $!'''( $'' '$$& B ' !D4
" * ;(' .222& !' 56' $7 9 $ !4 '' $( ;'$'' $!'''( ' $ $ ' !! ?4 A> @4 (& !'' $ !!'' $ '<!66'!?# *00F&40132@4 '' '$ ;'$'' 7$;!'!'&' :' : 4 ( '$ $'' B''!H)9'&BB $& $ 6' ! !'" $7 '& ;B,$( , !!'' $ &,;'$'' $!'''( '& E7 4
E'7 $(''(7'' $ $ H$32!.221& ! E& !' 9! !!'' $ '&G !') '-!H!'' '' 4 7!'6!5('9'4
( $ B' "$& ' $ E '' $ 6 !, '' 9( '4
/*+01/.223 ->/+-
7' $ ;9 G ' '5 6$&$ H$.F;('.221&$ '9( '$ & *3 6(' .221& $' '' ' ' ! E $ '9 , ' ;9 ''& & $ 7 $ 7' $ (< 4
.4 6 !! , 7' 3 ' 3 $ $' '' ' '& ' $'(7('9$ '$$( !!'' $ !' $7 66' '5 $ '& ' 'B ' !'" $7 E- ?64'A>@4E ! ;9$$7" ''5'4
34 ';!'"$ !!'' $ E- (5?'+1 E>0 @4
14 '6$'9$$ '$ '$> 5 .222? @('9*;('.223P! $'6'' $ !5$' '' 9$$ !'$7 E- 4$7" 6 '9'$' '' ('9;B73*$!5.22.& 9$ '' B "9 '5 ('9 ! ! I6';'$'B!$!' $'? :*.F1>F& '$4*M*.*3>>@4
A4 < ! $ 74 3A $ ' 6$ 7-'('$' U U ) !!6!!B'($$7'('$' $ ', )$6B'&$"$ &'$ ', $7 )' $ 7-('' ('(4 E 74 .A 4 1 A E& $ ' , $7 )' $ ' !' ; $ ! ' '( $" $ " $ !"4 7' *+"! '(' $"$7 )'4 6B' !'6 !' &$ ', 7$;B7!$6 !' &!';B7,7V9$.A ( 4
E '$ !! 66 6 !' B'& $ ' !& !' $ ! ' ! ' , 6 !' 6' 6B $ $ 4 G 6 !' 6' B7 !',$7'$ '6$6 !' 6' 4
/*+01/.223 -F/+-
7'' $ $ $ 7'9 P '' '' $$ ',4
: ,9$7 ' $'B$ ' ! B7'G&!'$5$$'(''& $< ! $ ' $B 76 6' $ (' !''' 5'9 '&!B' 6B7'('&7-,- $' G'(!'&$<' $$('? *0>F& 4A23@4
!H!--' '$B6 !' 7' !'(' '(B56'''$<"!''!! 7 U 99BB9U;B7$5$('!''' 5'9 'M ' 6 $ B $ $ BB 6 !' 6' ''"6'$('? *0FA&4130@4
B' !' $ (' !''' $ (' '(' $
6 !' '$ !! 6 !' 4 6 '& ' 6 B7''('6 !' ;B7, ('B7 " ('4 E' <! '(' '( < !5 6'$7! ' 7 ('!'''& 6'$'-'$5$7!& $<' $$ (' !'''& ' 6 G ( ' '' $ 6 !' $ 7'4
>4 7"& 7 '! $ ' , !!' $" 6' $ !''9&! ! I 5 : $)'& ' 8 .22*4 (! $ ' $" 8 .22.& $ , B ' ('9$9' '$( <'4
66 $$7 8, 5.22*4
F4 : $ &,7'$7 &B !'6 !' $)'& 5 : 4$ ', B6 !' )(4'' (6 !' & !"!$'' $ !'"& B' H '!' , 6 !' !!'4 ' '$ B7' G $ ' ! '$6 !' 4
$'' $7 $*0$!5.22.$" HB 6'!4
/*+01/.223 -+/+-
! - ,3 ,+ ! - +! -!,
78 9 : 47 #;' -
8
*4 (54
8
.4 ;4
34 'B $9'4
14 6 ! ' $ BW ( 6 ! H $ $' $ 32 ; $" '6'' ' !!$ $ '5 6$ $ & E)S'T) 6B' >& >221 & ' <!'4 $' H 94 !! ' $ ' L @ '$'B <! B $'' $' 5' ' $ $'' BM5@< B! '6''! ( '$!$ $'' M@ '9 $ 4E'!! ' ' ' ! ! @ 5@ @ '-$& '56$$ !'" BW' $($'(54!! '$ !' ! G $ (& B' ; '& '' B $'' B W( $ B<$' ?4*3.&*2>*2+@4
966'"L '$L #'- ' X 'Y
' 6 !$H '6'<'''BW,W66'6$ $ '966
/*+01/.223