Copyright Statutory Damages Based on Infringing Copies
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involved a challenge to the application of a statutory damage provision concerning alleged copyright infringement, where the plaintiff sought statutory damages for multiple infringing copies, and the court had to determine the applicable measure for calculating those damages. The court reasoned that the relevant statute defines a "work" for the purposes of statutory damages as an "individual title or edition," and concluded that the evidence supported a finding that each independently created infringing copy constituted a separate "work" for the purpose of the calculation, thereby affirming the judgment that awarded statutory damages based on the number of infringing copies rather than the number of titles involved.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Copyright Statutory Damages Based on Infringing Copies: The court reasoned that the relevant statute defines a "work" for the purposes of statutory damages as an "individual title or edition," and concluded that the evidence supported a finding that each independently created infringing copy constituted a separate "work" for the purpose of the calculation, thereby affirming the judgment that awarded statutory damages based on the number of infringing copies rather than the number of titles involved.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProvision cited for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.
Testo completo
"#$%&"#$$& "'(#"#$$%
) *) ! + )! +!*
!, - .
#/ #$$% !"###$%""#& ! & "#& !''&$#!#"## " "'& ( ( !##'&'#" $7& ")'#*&)+!#)"',--.!./001 2
2 !#&&3.!)"'3043!3.0/ 53
5 !#66"7'&.8!)"'76!4//3
! 90%89
%0/84%0//4 9-%89
0*
3: &;+'3,<�//4!-=6*& &#*)&#=&#' )&""$ #<"& ! $ ! 3>44! ' "#& !$3>43!&#$'0-$*&3>>0!$'' )&$#$?&&#'?#''$(#)"&'#'#"#"08 ;#0//3:
0: ("6#77&-;+')&$#'$! &#*)&#=&#'"&"$ )&'+ )& "#'#$ <"#& )&$<"@ )&"7#" ?# )& 6 $)"A&'&#+:
-: ;+'#<"&'<$7##'#70;#0//4'$'$', ;# 0//4 &#* $ )"& ? #9# )&"= "'' B '&7$&&:
,: &#* $ "##'$ & " #'#''#" )&$<"@ )&= ? <#' "'#$! )# #'&)$ #'#''#" $7&)&#'#"#?&"''<"#&?# &'&#+!"#''&0-$*&3>>0'0;#0//4:
4: &"&'#<'#+'#" &#*$$$')&'+#<'C C &'&<#$&<##77$&'$'*#'77##$)&= 5 :(""&&#&&#&3-&0//8!"'' )&''#" )&$<"@ D$=< B -D3,- 7&: ,/! "' # 7' $#& " 3D8E. 7&: 0/ "&&)"' B D<"#& B ' &#+! #'$&F' 0 ;# 0//4 ")&#:
(" "&&#& ( ( 38 7$<&#&0//8!)&''#"?#)'&#+'3DE>47&:!")&' "''&G00"'"*&0/// (( (:
"&&#&0E;<#&0//8!2 ##?$?& #)"#' D )&''#" #*& )+ 0D,0>7&: ./! &)&$'' )$&#" D77##'#"3&"'"*&0//3-3$*&0//-:
<"#&'#"$"''##B3D,847&:0/H-D3,-7&:,/93D8E.7&:0/I J3DE>47&:J0D,0>7&:./!"#'B4D8>/7&:
"#& C (""&&#& ( ( E' .)'*&0//4!)&''#"?#)'&#+)&$7&"'
%0/84%0//4 9,%89 3D0>8 7&: E/ ' 0D00- 7&: 44! #'$&F' 0 ;# 0//4 ")&#: "'' B )&'+&"'##B-D40/:04:
&#* $ &?# (( ( ( ! ")' ##<# "'#'#" (9 &: &$' ? #9# )"& &) &$#$ #& #77#')"&F'&"#B:
8: "' "' $'$ '&# B & ' 4 # 0//8: ;&##'#" # ##?$ ?DB $7' D"*&<'#" D## 3> # 0//8! &&F' &#'&&''*:
E: D*D"*;'#"$#7#A$!$'$+&$B;+&:
+*
3: D&':04"#7$$&&#*&)+)&$<"@)&"7#"! <##!&<#<''#<##'$3E$*&3>>-HI!'&$<#+& 3&;<#&0///!&=+)&"$&#<"&:"&?";"#'"' )K"&&)&''#""&'#B)&'+&H&':300'30- " #<#9 I! ;+##<"&")$''D&':E-:3"#7$$&& )&$<"@ )&"7#" 04 ;# 3>.0 HI! "#' B =< &#* '"&"#)#3&"L'0//-!"#'!)&=?D77#&# $'$'&#H&':3,0 I!A$'&D"77#)&'+&* $ &$)&'#'#"$'&#$)&;+#<"&:
0: ("D&':00H"<'&<#+&)#3&;<#&0///I! #<"&! )&''#" "&'# ?# &' &#+ "' )&'+$ "7"&$' A&':300!30-!3,3'3,0 M&':-B4 D))#?' )&"+#"''B'&7$&&H:3I:"&6?";"#'!)&''#" "&'#B)&'+&"&&)"B#77$&'&)&''#""&'#!+'$ <"#& #*& )+ A#'' $<'' "' #<"&! ' )&''#""&'#!+'$<"#&#*&)+A#''$<'' "'"#"&#+H7:&':0,I:"&!";"' B )&''#" "&'# ' B D<"#& #*& )+ A#'' "' "#" &#+ #'$&F' "' #<"& H 30. 0-/M 30>,,,I:
K)=! ;+ )&#=& #' "&"$ )&'+ )& "#'#$ )&''#" "&'# ?# &' &#+ )& &: ' )&'#'"'!K)&'!&#+!0-$*&3>>0!K'&)&' 0;#0//4!'B?;+'#<"&'<A$'"#&:
%0/84%0//4 94%89 -: (" "' )&"#'! )&''#" ?# )' &#+ )& & ' 4D8>/ 7&: '# ? ?# )& & ' -40/7&:04:
##!&"#'B"A9$)"A"''0D.,47&:H4D8>/7&:C0I' &"#'B"A9$)""''3DE8/7&:3/H-D40/7&:04C0I! "&'?D'&?#"#'&"''3D/.,7&:>/:
" & #)" '&"# ")' )&$<"@ #77$&'! )&'+7#''#=&'&")')&"##)#7#'#":
,: "7"&$' B ;&#)&! )# ;"& $'&#' )"& )&'+ ;?D"''&7&')&''#""&'#"&!";"#' #<"&$*$$7###&'')&''#"&"#'B#'$&F'")'"#&& "''9#: #'$&F'"'$'A##$+"D&':30 D"&"&)&$<"@)&"7#"<##!&<#<''#<##'$ 3. <&# 3>., H 0I " " 'A &$+'#&! # #9# ' )$&#& H ")*#$-8%/03.;#'0//-I
4: $"' & )&G! )&"$& $'' +&'#' H&': E- : 0 ' .>2:3"#&)&"$&##'&'#<30)'*&3>.4I
%0/84%0//4 98%89 ! + *0 *) ! + )! +!*
123 4 5 67 .%# +8
3: <#' ( ( B '&7$&&! ")' !"3D/.,7&:>/B ( ( 7<& "#& ! ## ? #'$&F' ")'"#& "#$&'! = 0 ;# 0//4 ;?D"''&7&':
0: D@"''?*"#:
-: #'?)&"$&'+&'#':
,: 7"& )&'# ?D )<' 7"&& &"& "'& )&$' &&F' $# -/ ;"& = "'#7#'#" )& )# &"$ &$ &#* 7$$& &! (6N#O&6"7?# 8! 8//, ! '&"# A)#&: $# )' F'& )&""+$: $"#& "#' C I ##?& A'' ? $##" &"&' $#& "*'#& # ' ) $##"''?$M*IA)"&)"&?"'#7#'#)"<"#&&'' '&$##"MI)"&'&#+'&""&)&$'':(#$"#& "'#' ) '&"# $$' $$&$ " ''& I *I ' I #9! &#*7$$&&)"&&)'&&'#=&&&"&?D# <&$&&#&&<*:$"#&&"&'#"&"&"@ )&<! ?# &"' ;"#'! ## ? $##" ''?$ ' D<")) ?$'$A)$#$&"&'H&':3-0!3/8'3/.I:
+&77#=& &$#'C 	"# 1 "&#P ")#"7"&)&$'&&F''"'#7#$A)&'###?KBK77#7$$& &"#)&+&77
'&!<""###"!)&)*#'#"#)"#'#7# D<#"77##:
%0/84%0//4