Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/489/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/489/2006 Generato dall'IA

Retroactivity of Statutes Over Prior Judicial Determination

Numero d'incarto ATAS/489/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute centered on a claim involving a prior judicial determination regarding the application of an earlier statute to a set of facts that arose between 1962 and 1966. The initial ruling, based on a 1961 statute, found that certain actions were not actionable, and subsequent legislation in 1964 and 1966 did not retroactively change this finding for the intervening period. The court reasoned that the legislature did not clearly intend for the later statutes to apply retroactively to supersede the effect of the prior ruling concerning the conduct that occurred prior to the new laws' enactment, thus affirming the prior judgment's effect on the period in question.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Retroactivity of Statutes Over Prior Judicial Determination: The initial ruling, based on a 1961 statute, found that certain actions were not actionable, and subsequent legislation in 1964 and 1966 did not retroactively change this finding for the intervening period. The court reasoned that the legislature did not clearly intend for the later statutes to apply retroactively to supersede the effect of the prior ruling concerning the conduct that occurred prior to the new laws' enactment, thus affirming the prior judgment's effect on the period in question.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
applicazione delle leggi retroattività della legge condotta precedente effetti della sentenza termini di prescrizione accertamento giudiziale di diritti

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the costs of the proceedings concerning the appellant.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



               !"#$#!%##& '!"$(!%##)

'

 '* *'*  *    

+, &  %" , %##) 



 !"#$   !%$&$% & '()*'$"$&(%+&$,&" )"%$



&

''     + ((  *  !" &#$ -./!%&012!3133   34





            

   *152*  



5067651662  *452*  

  - .      "$%$  "#" " %&& "+8"&$"&"34&91666:

 +;; & " +*8"&$ <*%= >  ? + #  9$$; "+"#*&"+8"&$"=3&91663!%"$"12@81661:

+$"$%$"#""$8""&A&"&"30@8 1662!B108&%+ :

"&&="=3@81662!%"$"17 81662:

'"&"%$8-"%"C <(?( <*%=>  ;"&?! %$&$ %  !  ;#$  14 @ 1662 %%& A && "$!&A&&&D"$"+ "1781662 &%%%9&!9"#&A+&"*&8"$! %=&&#%$#&:

;"&&##&8$D"$"17816628&% $&$&;$&D++8&%$&$%&A%$""$8:

+$$&$&""""&&%%&!%+&#$"" :

 % "$ " 7 8#9 1662! +   &&$ D  ;"& +$&& % $ % +$8& " +8"&$ A D   %$"$!  #&; D  ;"& +8&%$&$&$,$"%$""$8""&A&:

 %  " "$ "  #E# "&! +   "$$ +%%& ;#$ %;"&9@&8""$"&&&%$&$:

+$;#$&"$%%&"+ "78#9 1662!  & A  & &! 9"#&! A  &&& D  "$"$8""&A&"1781662&;"$!D+@&" +%%&";"&:

 % "$ " 31 "$#9 1662! +&#$    @& "  & A  ;#& "  "$ &&D$!  ,& D  "& F %&& +$&& %   & D+ +- 8& "=  %  "+F#   "$ "  17 81662$&&;"$:

%"37@8166G!&##D$ 9"$ %E&H"+89#%%&"+&#$&"#"$"+&% " ; " 8 + 8& +&& " "  8 "$ "+& " &&=A%&"3@816628##&A;"&:



5067651662  *052*   &$&&"%$A&"&&I-%&I=:

+&#$;#$ 9"$.;$8166GD++8&@#%%$ "&;8"$"&A;"&:

&7#166GAD+&#$&"#$A&;A ;"&  "$ " & &= " 17 8 1662 8 "& " 8 " "&:

+&#$!"$&"1/#166G!%&$":

&##D$338166G 9"$%"&& "+  J((( !*8!D,=8";"&!A&& "=! && F &# " D  & & #  9$$; "+ & &="+8"&$";""%$8-"=3@81662:

&%%$ 9"$!""+#%,#&! ""#"A;"&;#&"D%$=":

+  !   " $% ;;#&8 "  ;"&! A +& "  "$%%&"78#91662:

  / .,8K,&@"<?$&$#";$ &&&$!"=3H&1664! 9&"!#%$ " 2@,!"&%$"&&8*%$"&!2%%$&&3G@, <&L3&L&2G ?:

&AK&"K$&"3G@,!% 9;$"$ 1/@81660< '34636G?!" ,8"%&$!34;$8! "%&&&,&%#&&& 9&" " $,   A & @, &&! ! " K&&& " K$& " 8F@,:

+F&#"+&L2.";$"$%&,$$""&" "G&91666< ?!D&$%%$%%E&&I$%  "$   "$  %%& & 8  &$E& ", "+E& %&$,$ A  D+&$#";$:

+ +!  & & &  "$ "$&  9@& +%%&";"&&"$"1781662"+&#$!"$% D*;&&=#&"&A"#""$8"&"&:

+%%&D"&F%&&"+*8"&$+&%&I$ %"$"&&:



5067651662  *252*   &+"=&$E&","%&&"&&& "$!"&D"&E&"$$89:

L

  '0  '* *'*  *    



12/-/,, 3  4// /  56 7)% 8

3L $89L

1L &D%$"&,&&L

4L ;#  %& "  DK %8& ;#  &  %$& E& "  "$ " 46 @ "=  &;& % % ##"$ "$  9 ;$"$ " ! (IMNI;D G! G660   !  & F#%L  "$  %& E& %,$L  #$# "&> ? "D F&#&D"$&"$9&&%""$ &&D$: 9? F% % D #&;  &# %8 "#" && & "$: ? %&  ,&   "  %$&&L (  #$#  && %  & $$#& $#$$  && ? 9? & ? *"!  9;$"$"%%&#&=DK "8"$89L#$#"#&#- " %8! D & @&!  D  "$ &&D$ & K8%% " D$&$F%$"$&<&L341!36G&367?L  ,;;=  %$"&         OP J -      

%;#"%$&E&&&;$F%&%,;;





5067651662