Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/482/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/482/2005 Generato dall'IA

Market Price Date for Contract Damages

Numero d'incarto ATAS/482/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute centered on the appropriate method for calculating damages in a breach of contract case involving the sale of goods, specifically regarding whether the calculation should utilize the date the contract was made or the date of delivery as the benchmark for determining market value. The court reasoned that when a breach of contract for the sale of goods occurs and the non-breaching party seeks damages based on the difference between the contract price and the market price at the time of delivery, this aligns with the general principle that damages should compensate for the loss at the time and place of delivery, which is where the injury from the breach is felt. Therefore, the court affirmed the use of the market price at the time of delivery, rather than the contract formation date, for calculating damages.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Market Price Date for Contract Damages: The court reasoned that when a breach of contract for the sale of goods occurs and the non-breaching party seeks damages based on the difference between the contract price and the market price at the time of delivery, this aligns with the general principle that damages should compensate for the loss at the time and place of delivery, which is where the injury from the breach is felt. Therefore, the court affirmed the use of the market price at the time of delivery, rather than the contract formation date, for calculating damages.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
calcolo del danno valore di corso compravendita valore litigioso contratto differenziale violazione positiva del contratto

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the proceedings (costs to be paid by the appellant).

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

   

                

 

         

  



 !!!!!!!!!!  !"!#

"#!

"  # $ % !$#%#&""!  %#%./ '"#( )*+!%,"!-







&'()* +,( -.&/()- //,, )0/ 1$  -2'/3

  4   0   '!$/%%"$1%#0 %$23.-456%'!7%8 '!""/'%"$$!"%#9:%$.%#/$23.-'"!$!/$;1"! 9:"#!$&$.<<<<<<<<<< ."#%=>:/#%#.'"%'!'!"'! =#?

 :!/ :# "''"/ 9 ## $/%%"  /-# @"%! "==!# $ '!",7. $ #/?

:$#$A"@.,!0 %!1#/:"''"%#%"$:!/?

'!"!!%!$00"@.,!0 &$.<<<<<<<<<<%#!1#/!"!?

$!/'"$0=/@!%!0A %%="!./!%,$/>: :@%#",!@#%"91"#!?

: $# $ ) @!% 0A   '!#% "# /#/ "@">/ 9  $% $ ".'!#%"'!"$'!#%?

:9:%$:$% !%,"#!"B/9:!/$/%'"!'!"$%! !#%=%#./$%'$/#%/$"#!<<<<<<<<<<?

: $# $ 0) @!% 0A   !"!#  '!"$%#  ####%" /#,% '! " ./$%#!%##?

!%,#!.%$%#####%"9%:%@%##9$/#!.%!?

'!"!!%!$(.%0A %%="!./!%,$/>:@%# /  $/%%" $ '%"   $"# :!/ @%# /#/ %="!./ '! "!!%! $ .C.1"!?



      

"="!./.#9:!#DA;D;$"%=/$/!!'!#%-//!$$!"%#$ !"%$("#",!06 8 #!/@%-!!1@%!0;# ''%,  :'7  :!! '#  1>:9 :@"% $ " '!/@% 9 :#"!%#/ $ !"! !"%$/!!  $/%%" "  $/%%" ! "''"%#%" "#! >  !"!/#/="!./?

$/%%"$"%#C#!"#%=%/9:!/#"..%>/9:#"!%#/$!"!?  ;   : :'7   %  /  $/%%" '"#/!%!.# 9  !/'" # 9 :%#!#%"".'/.#%!"!$"/'!!%,$/?

 $  "$%#%"  :%#%./ !%# $E /.##!  '!"'"%#%" 9 :###%" $ !%,?

 '$#  $  .! "F  $/%%" "!!'"$ G "%" $  !"!##%$"#%7!#%=#%" %B%$:$"!#9%#$ "##!>!"!#$@",1#D

 

.    4 -          *

))()

560(70&()8,/90/)0()(/)0,:)3;<+=

,70*

D /!!"!!@,D

70(*

0D "#9%$>:/$/%%"$'%"$$!"%#9 :%$.%#/$23.-D

;D %#>!"!#$@",1##>:%:#'!H/.".#D

D B$!3D

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

"'%"="!.$'!/#!!C##"#%=%/G'!#%'!-!==