Tax Assessment Validity and Valuation Methodology Challenge
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought to overturn a decision regarding the validity of a tax assessment related to the valuation of property interests, specifically challenging the procedures and valuation methods used by the taxing authority. The court determined that the taxing authority's use of comparative sales of similar interests, which were legally equivalent to the interests being valued, was an appropriate and permissible methodology under relevant statutes for assessing the property's value, and that the statutory requirement to give notice of the assessment had been met, thereby affirming the original assessment and denying relief to the challenging party.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Tax Assessment Validity and Valuation Methodology Challenge: The court determined that the taxing authority's use of comparative sales of similar interests, which were legally equivalent to the interests being valued, was an appropriate and permissible methodology under relevant statutes for assessing the property's value, and that the statutory requirement to give notice of the assessment had been met, thereby affirming the original assessment and denying relief to the challenging party.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the imposition of court costs.
Testo completo
!"#$ $%%# &'( $%%#
)
* +*, ,-, *, -+
. / "
!0 $%%#
!"""# !$%&' %!%& #&"!!""(#&)&% "*&+ ,- . ,
!&%
// ( ,, % "&"# 0!12 $!&345 6466 67
-482-
1 ; # 6193 $!0# *; #$!#$%&&"!$%<(=="&!(%-"'""&# > ?@
%"% !$&&$%!*<&#%!&%#$%(%#-%&+%! %'"'%'"A"&%&+%!=#!%!-$&"%*"&#%-("*##=" (%&&"<%B!$&%6%!'*%6111@
!%%"% 64 $&*% 4::4 % ""; %A&& $!# "A!&" 0%! !A =#+"% ('&- *% %!"& %&#%"& $% !==% A!* "% =#+"% $%!'!;& !$%"! %= #" B "' "%<& %!$&+" A&"% &!+& %= *"& B ! $A "' (% #$"&%!+#&$"&"%<&B!#%#(#$%!"&@
%$$!%&#".!C&4::7 % $#""& +"%%A" $!#"A!&"(#$"!0"&B%!"&@
$% "% #" &%"&& % "A!&";# ="*%!0A"@
%'"#"%#A"! >,? '"#":'%"4::3 !"A# ; #""! (!&%!" %& &"<% #&"& "&%' ; !"& $%&";#D$%&"%+&!!A";&8!$0+"&%";&%$$!%&%"!!A"; !%&A!D&!!'%&#*%%'" %*%$$!%& % ;$!%&"&$!%(&";%!#&"; & % ;" '"& !" $%#"% ; #$+# & %'"A" #&"& $%#& $" 6122 & ('"& $ $E+# (%# &%'"% F;( 611G@;,FA#;&&"&!*F&"'F&"=""&$"$"&# &!&&%'"&!&&"'"&#@;% !;(! &%!'"& $%# ( &* !!%D +%!"; % * (&&"& %& !*F&"'""=="&B!'"$!%F&"="%"'""&#B6::H>&! "=="&#&0#?@;("!&#;&*!!%D($"=""& ;" !*%""& $%!!&" & %!# " $ ( D$%&" $%"""$""%@
&%(D$%&"#"0!> ? $%<D(%#& !"% && %"<% % ! %$$!%& & 1 #*% 4::5@ ; #">!%&+!$#"& $0+"&%&%+&!!A?!&$!#"A!&" *D&"!D&%%!&A+ A!%&+%!=#!%!-$&"%%!"& A!%&+%!=#!%!-&"*""&%#*&&DI&# &="*%!0A"$" 4:::@ " !& &"# ; (==&"! D A!D '%"& ; $ ""&% $"&#$%!="! &!&&"'"&##A<% ;&("% $!%&+%A %+!&&"!*!&$%!!A#'"&E&%#'"&# ;("
8679484::9 -782- (0 '"& ""&&"! % $ $0+"; & ! !% !" ;( &"'"&#*%%"&D"A"*B$"&$&$"%&@
, % * %$$!%& &"# ; ="*%!0A" ('"& $ %#$%"!%$"&#&%'"(%#@
$%#""!62=#'%"%4::9 ( "=" '==&6%'%"4::9 '%& %& &"<% !# F;(!% B (%# & %&"%# (==& $"= B #'&!$$!"&"!@
7 % 4::9 (%# =!%# !$$!"&"! B && #""! %;#%& $%#*&%&"&&"!(==&$"=@
$%#""!""&%!$$!"&"!5'%"4::9 ( %=#%&"&&"! (==& $"= & %#%'# =! @ " !"#%# ;(" %!%&"& !"% - !&&%$$!%&(D$%&" 0!-;(#&&&#(%# #&"&#!%"!$&"*'(D%"(&"'"&#%&"'$&#B$"&$ &; <!% $%#'""!='!%*B(%#;&B(""&"A=! $%#&"&$A%#%&"&=="&$!%E&%$%"!"#%&"!@
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
;& B ! #&& &# (%# !&& "$!% ( $" $"&# &%'" !"A;$%!*<A!!&$%#A# ;(C*"%"; !$#%&"!A!%!"&&!$#%&"!A!A+ ;!%&+%!$"% "<% %$" ; &! !'& !""&& A!D " !& ' "$!"* ;("" $&$"(A!"%"$!%&%+%B&! ;(#$%!'#A&A%!"=="&#B!&%"% ;(%!&%
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
2 2 ; !" A'!" % M!%A"&"! F"""% >? #&# !"="# & "&"&# < 6% !C& 4::7 %"* &! % !" !$!# 5 FA !& $%#"& & '"-$%#"& 5 $$#& & 69FA%>%&L6&L%&59 ?@
"&BM&"!M#&"!69FA% $% %"*=##% 42F'"%4::3> /67:6:9? % !"A'!"!$&# 67=#'%"% "$!"&"!&%"&!"%%A&$%&&& %"*&!%!" "#A% % B &%!" FA &"&"% M&&& M#&"! !'DFA%@
%"*#&""!$#&&$!%FA%M$<@
8679484::9 -582- M"&%F&#&$&"!&%#""!"&"A"%!%&%'*>%&L59 L 6 &L +L 6 & %&L 9: !" =##% % $%&" A##% %!"& %!"9!&!*%4:::N ?@
M'%&M%&L53L6&L #""!&#""!%!$$!"&"!!& D#&!"%!%;M==&$"=&&%"*#B!$$!"&"!!%!%#&#%&"%#@
!M%&L55L6 !"=##%4:#*%619G%$%!#% ""&%&"'> ?&$$"*$!%%$@
M"!'"&<!%%#=#%%D%&L55&59 @
M%;E&'"&B$!%"&$"&%&%'"&%#"&#B%;#%"% %$%!'""!&&$"&$%&&"!$#""% M%&L59 @
!$& & M#&%!"& !D"&# "& M==& $"= D &% % $%!'""! M%&L 59 $%""$ $$"* %&%"& M==& $"=M$$";&$&$%!A"B%@
($%<F%"$% $!"*""&#%&"%%(==&$"=%!%(&$ *!%!#B!"&"!;("D"& $%&""% "%!&&!&B ="&D$&"!;"F&"="&&&%@
M&!%"&# %!% "" M %;E& %&"&&"! M==& $"= !"& $%!#% B $# "&#%E& $%#& D"% " !&"= ='% MD#&"! "#"& #""! !& $ $!" ; D ;" $'& E&% "'!;#$!%!&"%!&"!!&%"%> 6116$L54:?@
$!% ="% FA =! % M#&& ="& & ;M" %#& !"% ==&%!A"'&"A&"!$$#&"%@
="&;#""!=!$!%"'*&M"&#%E&$*"=="&$B F&"="%!D#&"!"#"&@
M$%!#&B$#"&#%E&$%# $%#'""!%M""&"A =!$'&E&%$%"!"#%&"!@
M"=&$&;M=&!&@
(($< #""!( $$%"%%&(%#%$!% D$%&"$%"""$""%!&%"$%&!&%'%$%!*&$%"!%"@
(" $$%)& ==&"'& ; #""! ""&" ( #&# $%" % *%$$!%&#"&%"&& #'&"!$"&#&%'"%#"
8679484::9 -982- &$!%%"&!-B&"&%-E&%;"="#"=&&%%!#%*#% "&%&"!"%@
$%#'""! % (" "&"A $%#&& $ $!% (%# A%# %&"&=="&$!%E&%$%"!$&($<@
(A"&(%#"$!&(=!%&"!*""<%=="&$!%="%=B #'& %*!%& $%&&"! %"* =##% %&"# / 4G78:546!&!*%4::5>!"L7L4?; " (%# '"& %!% =="& $!% !'%"% %# "$!%&& "&#%E&(#&"&$"$#%"$%%&%"&(==&$"=@
& & %!%& ($< ;" ! (""; -E "$!(*""!*""%@
(!!"&!!"#%%;("$!%!%=="&$!%="%= %&%"&(==&$"=@
" & (& $ " =%"& !% %"% ;( $" ="% = %*!%&$%&&"!;""%"&-#+#&-"C&!#@
%&%"&(==&$"=&!F&"="#@
%!%&$%!#;&%F&#L
8679484::9 -282-
-+3 +*, ,-, *, -+
45212 6 722 2 89 !#$ -:
12
6L #%%!%%'*L
12
6L %F&&L
4L "&;$%!#%&A%&"&L
7L =!% $%&" ;M $'& =!%% %!% !&% $%#& %%E& #" 7: F!% < !&"="&"! $% $" %!# %# %"* =##% % ,+O"P%+!=;" 9 9::3 &%!" D$"%L #" $& E&% $%!!A#L #!"% !"&Q ? "";% D&&;#""!%!%&#"%!*&"%"&$#""! &&;#@ *? D$!% $!% ; !&"= " &" $!'!"% % && &% #""!@ ? $!%&% "A&% ! ! %$%#&&L ," #!"% !&"& $ &%!" ##& ##%# ! &&% ? *? & ? "- %"*=##%%$!%%$&%%&"<%%%!%;M" '%#%%"%%'*L#!"%%!%&"!%!%!0 $%' ;" %!& F!"& "" ; #""! &&;# & M'!$$ ;#&#D$#"#%!%&>%&L674 6:9&6:G?L A%=="<% $%#"& "// R%", R
!$"!=!%$%#&%%E&&!&"="#D$%&""";MBM=="=##% %!"$%A%==
8679484::9