Sanctions Upheld for Violation of Court Order
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant sought review of a decision concerning the imposition of sanctions following an order for sanctions that was allegedly violated. The reviewing court affirmed the decision, reasoning that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in imposing sanctions because the record supported a finding that the appellant knowingly violated a clear, unambiguous court order, and the imposed sanctions were reasonably related to the violation and necessary to ensure compliance with court mandates.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Sanctions Upheld for Violation of Court Order: The reviewing court affirmed the decision, reasoning that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in imposing sanctions because the record supported a finding that the appellant knowingly violated a clear, unambiguous court order, and the imposed sanctions were reasonably related to the violation and necessary to ensure compliance with court mandates.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
"#$$$"$%%& "'('"$%%)
*+ **+ * +
, # ! -. $%%)
! "#$ %&'! ($'$ ( ' "# $ )) *! +% ,"-! ./"-$'"#
'
)) 0 ++ !" '#$ 123!('456!7577 78
!
;597:;
* /
7< ! $ 7263! '%' ## ="$>'= ( $'$* + <+0$%'?4404::<;(!(&" '%"46&&."#"<+'?"'%72,%7226 - $ ' " @ "'! 0 ( $'$ # " '%<
5< 5: >$% 722A! "$($ "#" " ('' (B " 0>> '"0;%"'$C;(B0 D<
8< ((' "'$ " 7A # 722A! ! " (- " &@! "@'-$ #('' 1"# "/ ">> " '' @!'.'$#,"@"''''(B$'(' "#$-'"@@&<?('$''"'%<
4< 0"0'@0$''"$$"72E'A('#.722A!-" $&.''"F"$(('?0 73('#.722A< (.1/(#'0(-0$('/'%'$? #;'#( % "#' $"' " # G "' % " '#( ? '< + ('$ # "$%(($ "%' (#'' " '% ""%"#"#'@"("'<'$'$#'$## ">>'$ " &-< (.'$ "0#$' " $'' $'$ $%-$C(B4>4 D<
6< "(('"'$"8'.722A!-"F"-$ -! %@' # (B 0' " @ "'! "#' &H ('' ''"@%"$.'"@'&%"#('#'' -0'.'$'$!"'-0$$''#'$(#& '".'@'#(-(>>'"'%/(&1-($.< $-!"('("0('$"'%##''1" >I"<''"-$'%'$0>>''''('!?#;
'#(<("'$'$($$-"B-##$"0%' ($'$#(B'#'$($!('$"'%"0$(' J'>/$-0'$#'C(B5A>4 D<
A< K,%722K! !#$""0"#'"+ ! " ((' >< "-$ - %@';' # (B (#B '&(>#'('"0#('!%'$'$($"$?$'" ('$'#1"#$-'!-0($;'&>$#;
'.'%'$'$''$!-0%'$'$($"$?"'&( >#' 0. " @#' $ '$! @'& ' ' 0. #(B' " #$- '! - 0$%' (B "B '%' 0$'' >' ( . "' " 0'$'#! 0#$'
9855595::6 ;897:; " #&! '.'$ % 0'' "0 '&B #%.< #$" ''$ 0#1'&(& " -"( ? "'! $(&#' ' ' L"B# " ,#.< '$ (' " " ? > '$ " @-0'.'$"(@'''>'<#&$'' >>'$('-#'.'<0@#''0(#'$'' (.''(@$%">>'$?%<>/$''#'$? 75:M! 0/' $'' #(B'< ! #$" '#$ -0 - ' @ "'! '' # &@ %' $'$ (< @ '' '. # #$$ ( ((' ? 0$'' '$< '' ("' ? $' '&B " '.'< '#$ -'%""$>'0$''((."#G0$ (%' ( 0@! 0( >$-##'! #& " @ "'"''.!&@##.>$"'<,@$ -! " '%'$ "('$! 0/I' (' '#' (#''' " ('' "$(#' ' ('! &@ " ##. >$ "' @#' (#' >$-'! ('$ " '%'(.?('#('?("#'C(B48>4 D<
3< + . " (('! + ! ( " 5K ,% 722K! >#$ 0$-0'#'-"(>"('$/'"0"'! $'' # " #'' % ('$ " '% #(''< 0 @@$ ? '' #'' L% ( '% '%'$ ((($! '##' % 0" " 0;%"'$ ? - ( " $'$ "$<
K< 0 #("'@"0.%'(>-0'"$$" 87 E' 2 '. 722K! ( '(< ((' " 5%#. 722K! /(' " ' "0.%' (> " 0 C D'(% ? -0$$''(' '%" '$#-#!#J#?'#(('!"=$#'' (&1- .%$= ' ! .'' @" #'%' ' >>'! ' ,-0? ="(''=< 0$ %' >>' " =(' "0(( >' '( "$>' ( ''" %/ "0>>'$ ' "0'# - (#''' "0( (' " '(=< ! #$"; " ' "0'$@' (> C D! "-$ - 0$ >>' " $- "0"' $($'$ " @ "' 1' 'N$ "(#'#(('"@#'$'$!=('$=" " '#(! - @ "' $'' ''#' '.! % '& '$! $(&#' &- ' " " " ' '< '' '&! 0'.'$ " @ ' $- #.@- #(J&' 0$ " '% (' #('. % 1'&# " '% ("'>! #J#?'#(('C(2!>6 D<
9855595::6 ;497:; 2< "$"7,7222!0 ?0$"@$"0%"'$" K:O%'"'?''B"B7,%722A<
7:< ('! + ! ( "$ " 74 %#. 5:::! '#$ - 0$ $''?#J#!-'$-"0"'!"0/'%'$ " ">>$' ' " 0"'! ? "' -0 ( '% '#'('P-0''%'$'/@."''' ,$ ' (#''' " $ # "0% 8056:>< -! #($?@"405::><$.0"'!'(' "@"0""56O<'"0%"'$>#?'/"$'$ $<+01','$"#'$('''?0'$@'$"7:OC(BA8! >4 D<
77< 0$ $'$ # ? /(' " "% " #$" " + < !($')Q&@!"(('"'$ " 73 % 5::5< ' $'$ $%-$ ## (' " ('' R " " @ "'! " ' '! " $@B " @ @&! " ""-"""##.($ @&< ' $'$ "@'-$ R @'&! " #.@ ' $@B $("1' " ? "'< #$" '#$ - 0 (%' /@ " ('' -0 / '%'$ (' $'' ( (' " &@!(''#''$$!'?('#(C(BA6!>4 D<
75< +'?''%0$!+ !("$"A('#.5::5! ('$'/"0%"'$?8:O'$"#'$('''?0'$@'$" 7AOC(BA4>4 D<
78< 0 !"""$%'('"#",5::5! '@$ ! ($' &@ '&($"- ' #$" '''"0$! -"-$!"(('#$""4,'5::5!- 0$''"'$"(''$''''!-001%'#">'" ''! - 0$'' " @ 0%' ( '.#' &@$ "( 5::: # - 0/ "0 '%'$ $"' ' $%'#' (. C( 5! > 8 D< -' " % 0$'' " '$ " ('' 0$'' @.#' #$$!$("($@'%<$@#'"-$-01%'. "'(''0/#-<
74< ' #' %$ "! ) ! " % #$"$@ C+D!"-$-("0('&B"@0$'' ( .#' /@.! -0 722K! 0$ (('' ( ('(@$#-0'#'!0/"0'%'$#.' ( ''#' /< "B ($ -- -' (($#'< ""-$-001%'('#"('
9855595::6 ;697:; "(''!-0''"'.'$''("("/!-0$ (',$?0(">#'?(#'-0(%'' /&(,<
76< )'">#'!0 "$"$"#''0$?%'@ "0.%'(>?0"-#N'"'@'? ('$$""'%"A:OCK:O""#''#(('"/ &(,D!(B($""0"(''!"#($@0>>'' (' '#' # (#''' "0' (' -" 0%B$< $'$%$-0$"%'$%'('".' (@$! @ "$(#' - (' ' "$(#' " &@< '$'$'?''"(>%@."0%"0" ("'$@B!"0#(1$"$('"(''(("0";
#''.$'-<''>$'$($$-''("'% $'' " (#' -0 ($" " # ' '(< "-$-@"0$$'''%#' '.! $'' 0'' "0 ! (' "0 '&B ' S&' #'< '#$ - "$(#' '' ".' (@$ (%' J' %@$! 0$ (%' %& '% ('("'"@($"!#J#'>'>I' ?&@"(''0#(J&'%#..#'"'%?('#(< +#$"!'' -#.'=#/'$$=- "'@ ($$"'!>>'$722K!'(''.$!.-0(/ ( "0 ('&B '' " @ ? 0%< ,@$ - 0$ (' '% / & ( , % "#' " K:O #! ( ' #(' " >'@.'$ ' " ( $ / &@#' " (' C(7K!>6 D<
7A< + '' .! "% " $"('' (> " 0 ! "$$ -0$''"'$"0$0$''#$$< ($"$?#(" @'-0'($5::4&"(C4K0624<;D' -0 ' ( .' 5::4 0 -J' '' " "'%'$$@B'$($''%?"47!3&&."#" C630::K<;D! '' #(' "0 '/ "0(' " 36O! "0 "#' " "#' " 5:O ' "0 $"' (($#' " 5:O C530375<;D! - "'?"@$"0%"'$"48OC(72!>6 D<
73< "$"7#5::6!0 $"'''B$,-0? 0$?-'"'%>>'7#5::6<
7K< "6%5::6#($'$53%5::6!0$>#$(('? ''"$>'%-001%'#'>"%"$ '1'''B$''"'$0%'(#'$%$< ?-0''B'?J'%$<
9855595::6 ;A97:; 72< "$"5A,'5::6!0 >#$"$"7#5::6< %$ - "$ " 7 , 7222! %' $'$ >"$ '#' ((' " " 5 %#. 722K - ' ? 0$(- ? 0(''" '% " ' $#- # " # G 0$ 0%' ? '%('#('.%1'&#"'%("'>" "'"0'.'$"@!">'@.'$'"0#-"$'< ((' " ' " % '@ "0.%' (> #(!0 '-('$$""'%'"@ "0$0'.#'#$$"("$''!.- "@'''$#J#!''##0$''"'$"0$<B% (-+ ?0$"@$"0%"'$"56O"B 7,%5:::!('$(''?8:O("$"A('#.5::5! -"$#'.;>"$"(("$"$%<
5:< "78('#.5::6!0$','$'''"$< "#"$($.#'0"'"#$"'''! < >' % -0 >' % 0' '% "( "$ ' " 0 !-$''"'$'"#$''#'&@$!-('$" '%''&$-!-0$%'"('$"'%( ; .' ? ' "0 ($" "0.%' (> "' -0 $'' # ((>" - (#B ; &@$! - '' #'#'>"$%'>!->'-+ ' "' ? ' "0%"'$ " 8:O 5::5 ' ,'> $% ( 0 "/'"#('"<
57< %'$ ? (! 0 ! " $( " 77 '. 5::6! ,'"<
55< ''!("74%#.5::6!#'(' @'-#$";" ! !0%'I- ('#'''!-0"('(""#$"' -0 0%' ($"$ ? /# " ' - % (.' " % (%'J'$#'#"'<
58< ""0-J'0''"'"5A,%5::A< ''! $'$ '"-'$"'$#< /(-$-0%' '"(5K'.722A!--00%'I((#B>! #&'%"/'@$''''#'@"!-0(#B ($'"$#.722A!%"('!-'#$$ ''#' 0$'' " (''< #$" "-$ -0'#'! " #&%'(''&B<>>"0'&%$ ' "0 '.'$ #('' " @ P '' ( " (@B " $''P0'&$%"#B$%.'>".'T'%@( "0 ('&B " @< #$" "# % "-$ ? 0 -
9855595::6 ;397:; ('' (' '&$-#' '%< ("' '$ >' -0 0@'?-"0(.'$ !-0(%'=',''-- &=#-0%'%'-0'?0$&< '#$-" !-(''(' '% / & ( ,! $'' =/@$$=< "' . N' '0'#<$#$#0(-00%('' - -- #'! 0 ( >> ( (($ ''< '#$ - 0 (' >>'%#' 1 " $$ 0$ ( " (#'! ' '#' ? 0$&! "0 (' " 0#(' " $! "0' (' " >' - 0$ ' '$"/'>< '("0('&B"@!"-$-0 $''#(."($%-"0%$'$!$''($$- .'"#$"!%0S@"0$!$''"@@("'#((.<
54< ('1'$?0/(#"B>(B-J'! $'$@"$?,@<
*
7< @%U@',"CD$'$#">$'''$!"B 7E'5::8! .'"!#($"6,@! "' ($"' ' %;($"'! 6 (($' ' 7A ,@ C'< 7 '<'6A D<
+'?U'"U$'"7A,@!( .>$"$ 53,%5::4C )78:7:AD!" @%"('$!78>$%! "('''@'(#''' .'" " $@ ? ' ,@ ''! ! " U''' " U$'"%/,@<
5< >#$#' ? 0'< 6A < 7 '< &< 5 ! . ' " N' ' - " ''' ($% ? U'<6A">$"$('@$$""'"" A'.5:::C D-''%?>$"$U;%"'$ "72,7262C D<
8< ' '$ %@ 7 ,% 5::8! 'N' " #">' $@'% '##' " "' " 0;%"'$< (' " % '#(!'((((.B@""'%@##'G >' ,"-#' "$'#' ' ("' ' ,@ " >"((!((($!0$''">'$$? "' "$'#' " "$ ((' '@ C ) 752 4
9855595::6 ;K97:; "<7<5P7A2"<7P86A"<7'J''$D<#G "$"0 "($"?$%""@$"0%"'$"'"' " 7 # 5::6! (( " "' ''#( ##"' 0/# " .;>"$""$?#B"%"('$@C )78: 885 "< 5<5 ' 5<8D< - ($" ' ? "$>' " B@ '' '! % "' 0((- $% "B , " '$ %@C ) 773 28 "< A.P 775 8A: "< 4P 722KV83(<87A"<8.D<
4< . " $ '' - ! ','$ " ># ' "$ $@/($%(U'<A: '%.<
6< /'#"0'<K ! 0%"'$'"#'"('$ "@! ($#$ (#' " @ "$! - $' "0 ''' ? '$ (&1-#'!(%'"0>#'$@$'!"0#""0 "'<
1"($-,("!'"U%"'$!" "'"!''$#-'#$"P' $- $#- .,'% " U('$ >' -U #('"U$%C )77:536"<4P7:65:3"<5D<-U " U'%'$ " U$! "$ $#- >' "$>'! 1 " >" "$ "U" #$"! " # G (#''' "U$% ('$ " '% " U'$$ " " '%'$ .#' /@.C )776788"<5P7:676K"<7D<
+ 0'< 73 ! '/ "0%"'$ " .$$> " ' .' #">''.!''!"0>>"#"!$%$(0%!? % @#'$ $"' $-! ((#$< %' $@#' ( "0' ('' ". "$ %' "0 "$ '$ >! - 0$'' " >' "$'#' #"> '.#' ( '< ' &@#' #('' " ' (( ? > "@$ "0%"'$! ' " "' ? '! (' #'% $% 0'<73 < ' (' J' $%$ #' " #">' ."0$''"'$!#-;''$#J#!# - $- ('$ " @ ' . &@#' #('' C )78:842"<8<6P778536"<7P775835"<5.'82: "<7.D<('"%'&@#'0'("'"'J''&$ #('>''-0($''##'""$'" '' '$@'?0$(-""$'@ C )78: 867"<8<6<5P7568A2"<5'$>$P775835"<5.'82: "<7.D<
9855595::6 ;297:; A< %'U""$'#"$'"U C' "U ' 'B "U%"'$D (' J' $/#$ ( % " $%< - U'< 73 U((-! >' - '/ "U%"'$ ' . #">''.!(B"$'<
U(B! ,' 5::5! ' "-$ -0 (' -0'%'$$'''&$-#'(.<("'@$-0$'' "(''$''''!-00%'($%$"(5:::'-001%' #">'"''<+''.!'#(."($" ? $% U'<73 < +01 ,' ("' % '@ "0.%'(>>>'$!-"$#'$-!#J#0$''"'$ "0$'!!'$#J#!$-('$"@' . &@#'! #('' (-0 ' (( -0 (' "$# ''""#'"K:O'%'/&(,< ("'! -(#B.%' $'$#($'$"0'@'(!'0 ($'$""<('>'.-0#$'?- #N' " '@ ' ' - 0>>' " '" "$,? #-$ " 0$ ? ="(''=<B!0'('-'''" !-"-'722K!-0(%'%('"$' ( "0''$< %"' " %$> ( " '@ '( 0$ ('$#'!"$#!'%(B"/&('<
$@"/"$'-($B"'!'('#'"#' %1$ ? 0 > - " #'' L% .%' (> ".$ " '@ '( - (#''' " >@ ( ('$ " 0$ ; '' $ ; ? % " & "'('<
9855595::6 ;7:97:;
/ + *+ **+ * +
!
01232 4 522 2 67 -)$ + 8
32
7< $%.<
! 32
5< 0"#'('#'""$'<
8< %?0 (''#($#'<
4< "# U'#$ ? % ' ## " 7U::: ><! ? '' " ('('?>'"$(<
6< ># (' " -U (%' ># ' ($' J' " "$ " 8: , "B '>' ( ( ##"$ "$ . >$"$ " ! +&WH&>- A! A::4 ! ' /#(< "$ (' J' (@$< #$# "'R D "- /'#'-"$'"$.''(""$ ''-$P .D /( ( - #'> '# (% "#" '' ' "$P D (' @' " ($''< + #$# '' ( ' $$#' $#$$ '' D .D ' D ;"! .>$"$"(('#'B-U "%"$%.<#$#"#'#1 " (%! - ' ,'! - "$ ''-$ ' U%(( " -$'$/($"$'C'<785!7:A'7:KD< @>>B ($"' )) V+ V
(>#"($'J'''>$/('-U?U>>>$"$ "(@>>
9855595::6