License Renewal Denial Upheld Against Public Nuisance Claim
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioners challenged a decision that affirmed the denial of their license renewal, arguing that the administrative record lacked sufficient evidence for the finding that their operations created a public nuisance and that the agency improperly shifted the burden of proof, while the court reasoned that the agency's findings were supported by substantial evidence in the record, including expert testimony and documented complaints, and that the agency correctly applied the relevant statutes by requiring the petitioners to demonstrate continued compliance rather than assuming it after initial concerns were raised.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; License Renewal Denial Upheld Against Public Nuisance Claim: The petitioners challenged a decision that affirmed the denial of their license renewal, arguing that the administrative record lacked sufficient evidence for the finding that their operations created a public nuisance and that the agency improperly shifted the burden of proof, while the court reasoned that the agency's findings were supported by substantial evidence in the record, including expert testimony and documented complaints, and that the agency correctly applied the relevant statutes by requiring the petitioners to demonstrate continued compliance rather than assuming it after initial concerns were raised.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.
Testo completo
$%&'$('') *$+,,$('',
##*
*#! -!*! #!- -
+. -/ % ('',
*0000000000 ! "#
$
$
10000000000%$ #
$
#2- 3#!-4 &' $ ( $#)'*+,-
..
!"#
!'/)0!
! 5*
)3 . $ $ 4 ') " - 4 ! 5!
. ,6 " %7 . 8 $ 9 4::$ .# ;;;;;;;;;; !"# . , 4.< % ;;;;;;;;;;,-#.3
'3 . .# ;;;;;;;;;; $ :$ . - " % $ $$$$3 4 $ '' ') $ 4.< 4$ $ =$ =4 $$ . . $$ 4$ . : $ . :3 # $ $ )> ') $ # .# $ $ 4 = =$ ?@ $ $ .#$% $8A3
03 )* ') " % . .# 4B@$ 4 C=4 0) B ') $$ . $ = . $$ #.$$ -B3
>3 'D -B '' " % # .# ;;;;;;;;;; : . - $:$4 8. $= 4 !" :.$ 3
23 '+ C- '0 " % = # $ = 4 4$$ . 8 . $= " $ =4 .-$ E$ B: 4 .3 -$ 8 $ $ - F# 3"- . $4'+ :- '0. $8 ::$4::3
&3 )2 :- '0 % ;;;;;;;;;; = . .$ $ 4- " % $ .. = !E $ . $$ $ =$ 3
+3 '+ '0" %-$ . $$ @$ ::$4::. ,$$G"5!. ,6 78.$ ) '03
D3 0* '0$ $..8" % ..$ . .$ =4 $$ - $ $ = $ 3 $ @$ $ = -$ B ::$. :$ $-8$$8 H "3
13 ..$'>C$'0-<. $$ @$ " % : $3 ..$$$$4 "
/01*/'2 !0/)0! . . ,4 .<$ :$.. $3.-$: 4BC$4 . , B0*C ,$:$3
)*3 '1 .$B '0 " % : # $ ::$4::8$ . =4F<.$F,I$ -$.-$.B$4F@ .$$ @# $3
))3 $)&:- '>$B.$. 4 !
. . ) '0 0) B '0 = .# ;;;;;;;;;; $$- DJ'+23!: 3
)'3 )& '>$ $: =4-$$ :: 4:: E$ : 3 4.= $$ - $ . : H $ -$ . $ . , % " 3 .=$4- C H $:$4 . $3
)03 E C $ $ : " % =4 -$ $ H :$ DJ'+23!: 3C- $$$. B3 $$ $J$ . $$$$ :$=.) :- '> $$ " . , % " $ C@$ . $:$4 3
)>3 '& '>- H$ $# " %4$$.B4 4::$4::F$8 . $ =$3
)23 +- '>" %:$- #.# ;;;;;;;;;;=4 4-$ . $ ..$ '> C$ '0 : $ ::$J::,) '0. ,G" $ =$$$$$ : 3 $$$:$ -$$: . '1 .$B '0 $ .# $$ -$ 8 @ 4 . 8 3 ::$. , - .-$.E$ I4-$ . . , 3 - -$ $ ::$: $ .-$ $- $ $3 $$ #.$ " % $ . E$ 8 4::$ 4:: . , I .# . $$ $:$ 4 . ,% " $$ '03 $$$ .8. : $3
)&3 $ '* - '> -< # .# . 4 4::$ -$ E$ $ . , 4# = 4-$ . " %3
/01*/'2 !>/)0! - .$ . . ) '0 0* - '> . - $. F$3
)+3 E C .# $ . " % =4 4-$ 8 $ H $:$4 :$ . $3 $ $$ .B $$ - $ . : B '03 $$ $ . $ $ - : HC=48:C- '>3 4<$. H4: $ . $ -$ !:- '> -$ $ . , % " 3 . $ -$ -< :$ $ $- =4 4$$ . 4F 3 .$8 .#$. . -'&- '>=4 -$ H $$ $ )0 :- '> F$$ B-3 $$ $ $ , $ - " % '0 #.=$ J . ,% " 3
)D3 '1 - '> % " :$ - # .# ;;;;;;;;;;=4$ $ $4 -::$$3
)13 >'>#!$ .=4F$$$ $ $$ =4-$$$.$" %3
'*3 EC $=8=4$$ :$=! -$$$ . . $$-#=44-$.$ $ $4 8:4'03
')3 )D '> . # .# =4 -$ -< # . .$ 4 '0 =4 4< -$ C .3 4::$ 4:: -$ . $ $ $ . . = F 4-$ . $ $ . . C=4 $B '03 . $$ . .B 4 4::$4::4 " %3
''3 . > '> .# $ - 4- C H . .$$$8 - .3. , . H . $ $$ B )0 :- '> = -$ . =4.B$ = ::$ :, 4 B - $ 3 . =$=4 $F: F8)J23!: 3$=4 $ : - $ $ . % ;;;;;;;;;; = $$ . =. .< 3)DC$. =4 :$.< '0 - $ $ - $ $$ : F3: $4 @ . ) C- 0* C'>$. . . $ $F$$ E$ B 4 0* C '> .$ $ :$ = $
/01*/'2 !2/)0! $ -$ $ . $ = 4: $ -$ )0 :- '>3
'03 ''C'>:$- #.#=44-$. - . . .$ -< '03 $ 4 : $ $ , $ $- :$ : $ = -$$$ $: F$ =$3
'>3 + C$ '> = # .# = ::$ 4:: $$ $ : $8" %'>C$'0=44-$. $$3:$ $ $ $-.-$. . K$ . $3 - . 4 : . - $ . F$ $$.$4: F)J23!: 3$. =$ % 3. $$ . 0*C'>$ : $ =48 .$ . - . $ .. $ 4 . ,4$ 3
'23 ))C$'>.#$$$$$. $$. $ $ 4 '0 $ = - .< . . . $ '>3
'&3 1 L$ '> = = ::$ 4:: -$ $ . " %$=44$$.$ 8 $ -B=. $$8.$ ) '03
'+3 $ '0 L$ '> $ - .$ " = # .# ;;;;;;;;;; = $ 8 .$ 'J11D'* : 3 $$ - )J22*D* : 3 . $$ . J !
8. . ) 0)B '03
'D3 1$B .# ;;;;;;;;;;$: 8=4 - $$$ $:84'0. $:=-$C8$ -=3 $ 4 '> -$ .< . >11+* : 3 : $8=4-$ H$$$'J11D'*: 3 =$ - H .$ $ - .$ "=4. $.3
'13 ' -B '> .# $ = 8 - .< )J22*D*: .$ '0L$'>. $ -.$ "
0*3 2 -B '> 8 . . . ) '00*C'>$>41&)'*: 3
/01*/'2 !&/)0! 0)3 '0-B '>.#$..8$$ : $8 . $ $: $=4- $ . 4 '03
0'3 ..$ '+ C- '2 . $ 8 $$ 8 0J>)*>* : 3 .$ $ - $ )J22*D* : 3 'D $B '>3 C . $ 4 '0 $$ @ $ 0J>)*>* : 3 $$ 8 .< .$ . $ '> 52&D>*#&73 4< -$ J$ . $ . B ::$ .= % " -$ : 4::$ .# 8 .$ ) C$'>3
003 $)2:- '24 $ C$ $ $$. , B =$ =4 :$ ..$ 8 $$ . $$ . 4'03:$@$?..$ -4 A $ . =-$. -"$$ 3 $4 B .$3 ' '> 4 $ =4 . $ . .$$=4-$- =-$$ . '>3
0>3 . )2 - '2 C$ $$ $$$ = $ $ 4-$ . $ $ - $$ @ 3 .$:$-4::$4:: $ . " %-$. $$4-$ . =4B$4'>.=8=-$. 84::$ $8.$ ) '0C=40*C'>3 $$. $$ . 4-$ 8 +J121>* : 3 = >J2>13! : 3 -$ $ - 3 B$$ 0J>)*>* : 3 %E 4 $$ - =4-$.#$" %=$4 $$.= -$$:$-$=4$$ . ,= $$E$ :: $ =#! $. - .$3, . $$B$B. 4$ . ) '00* C'>3
023 .='&- '2 $$. $ $ ..- $$$$ H. $" %3 $@$ .$=44-$ H. $-$4 '> $ =4 $$ . , : H . )* '03 . .$$=4<-$ .. " %$8 : !#$$$, 4 !3
0&3 $)2C'2 B$. $. $ . 3
/01*/'2 !+/)0! $$ $==4$$.<. E$ .')$=4FB$$".)'3 $$$. -$ $C $ . = . , 3 $ -$- $$.". :3:: $4- C H ..$ " % = -$ $ -< 8 . : $ -$ . . 8 4$ $ $ 3 $$ '> 4$$ . $$ $ -$ $ .<3 $ $ '0 $$ $$ I 4-$ C : .# ::$ $ =4 -$ :$ @ - $ 4 : H.- $ $#$$"3 :$- $ :$4::$4::. . " % =4-$$$$=4-$.$-4$ 3
- =48 .$ 4::$ 4:: " % '0 -$ -< . .$ 4 # .# $3 $$.<. $-$$::$# $$ '03 :$ F$ . -$ $ : $ $-$) '03
0+3 )+C'2 B.." %3
0D3 B -$ + C$ '2 " % 8 4 -B$ 4..$ C$ 3:$- ='>C$ '0$$:$-$#$ 4<-$.J.. I$$.-$E$ ::$. 4$@3 ..= : $8 $-$E$ . ,4 ,=$.= -$$$ <4$$ . .$. '03 ." % - = ..$ -$ $ -< . $$ @$ 8 4 ::=. .#-@ C=4. $ $ '> 8= $-$$C H. $ = -$$ 3
013 $ 'DC$'24$ #" %3 $ =4 #$$ . $@ $ 4::$$ - $::$. $3($4$-$$::$8 . 8 - . '0 = $ $4=$$ . '>3. .$ ::$ - $ # . . 4 '> = $$ 8 0J>)*>* : 3 $$ )J)0D&* : 3 8 $$ B :$ B $. $$. 4'03 " % -$ 8 E$ 8 $ $$ $ 3 $ $$ $$. . '03
/01*/'2 !D/)0! >*3 0) C$ '2 $ $ . $ $ 4$. . 4'0.$$$$:$3 $ @$$.. . = . -$$$ <''$'03
>)3 $'1.$B '2" %$ B : $ $ B$ $ " $ '> C$'>3
>'3 )&$B '2% ;;;;;;;;;;= B=@$ :@ $ $$"4$$.3 . 4-$C:$. $$$ B $$$=4 -$- 3'2$B '>. =4$$F=- $C$3
>03 )D$B '2 -=" %-$$$:# $$=#!4<$$...3 4$$8C$$$ = . 4 '0 $$ 3
>>3 $ $$=#. $$'+$B '23$ =$@ 8C@ 3
! #*
)3 @- 4 @$C 57$:$$$, ) L$'0 B$ .2C@ $ . $ $ -!. $ 2 ..$ $ )& C@ 5 $3 ) $3 $2& 73
"$84$4$)&C@ . B: '+C- '>5 ()0*)*&7 @-.$)0:- .$$ $ @$. $$$ B$ @ 8 $ C@ $$ 4$$$ 4$-#C@ 3
'3 : $ 8 J $3 2& 3 ) $3 F3 > B $ K$$=$$$. -84 $32& : . $@ $ &$B '5!. ,6 7=$ $-8: 4 ! )D )11>5!. ,6 %73
".$. C@ 4.,$$B3
/01*/'2 !1/)0!
03 " 4 $3 1 3 ) @- . $ $- )' .$B )1D2 5 . , 7 . $ .-$ : . $ . C$$$C .$-$. -$ . $ $ . :$=:. $4@$3
4.,-:$=$ =$ @ # .# < 4$$ = % ;;;;;;;;;; -B$ . $. . $. 3
.$$=4$.: $.. $ -B8: - $ $32&$ 3
>3 B$. $8 $ ..$$B$ .$$:. =$$3 $@ . $ .$ . $ 4$ =48 $$ . C = B $ $ ..$ . " % '> C$'0$$=$$. $. $$@3
23 ".. B$=$- $" %$ -B$$:# $ I#!=$=4 $C. -3
7 " C . $$ B : $ . $ $$ $: . $ I C$B . C I $ L$ =M J@$ J $ 8 .$ $:$ $ .$ . :$$IJ-$ .F, .$$ 3 $J$B=!$::$-$.=$$ 3 ::$ = $ $ $ .F, ., =J.. 5 ()''0)13 > $ : M " $ $ $ $: .3 D+& $ C . $MN $$ $:>,3O+*>.3)20M NPQ/GR S$@- :F S$@ F$.:@ ', 3 0>) .3 )'073 = $:$ $ -$ . . 5$$$$ @$ 7$ .$. :$ =J$ $$ . = . $$.$@$$. =J . $ 5:3 ( ))* 0+ 3 07 H . J $ @F$ .$ JB .@:$ 5 ( .B))- '2 '>/*2 3>3)73
= .$ . JB$ $ $. $ = J # $ $ $$$ . .$ . = - .$# . -$ 8 $$ $ $ @ J$ $ J $ I .$ E$ $$$ @ . $$FB$8@ .$. -
/01*/'2 !)*/)0! B $$$-$:$J$::8 FB$J-$J$$ -==- B8 - $$5 ())11>3>BM))+)0'3>M))0B '1D 3 'M - $ : J @$C -3.3'>1 $30273
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
$ = $$$8. . $ =44$.$ ::$. , . ! $ . - $ . $ 3 .. K$ = '>C$'0$ : . " %'1 .$B '0 = .. $ 4::$ 4:: . , 4 F3 = $$$ 8$ @$ . $$$ 4 B$$-4$
/01*/'2 !))/)0! -4 $ . $#!<$$$= : . - :$ '>. F3
&3 , =4='>C$'0-$$-B$ $: # $ . =$ - 4$ 8 C$ $$ = $$$$.$. 3
.. = 4 B$ . .# % $ 4 ! B@$ . 4B ..$ "3 4 $303) %.!$!. .=$$. "$ $4 . 5 ()'&'&D30B$ : 73
4B@$ .< . 4 $3 &) %M $$ $ . $ 4B@$ 4 4 . F @ -$ 3 $ = C = . $- $$ ::$-B. ,4!$4$8$$ ! 5 %)1D*.3)&)M)1D).3&)73
. -$E$ .<84-$. .$5 $31*3) 4 4 !'+C)112T %$ -@ $ :$73 $# $ E$ $ . . F4 $3'&3) 4,-82U. 5 $31*3' %73 : 4 $ .$ 4 $ 4 . . . 5V7F4 $@@ . . $3
+3 4., $ B =4<$ .< . $ . = . $$8 $$ ::$. ,4$3 I $ $ = ..$ " % $ $ : 4$ 8 C$ $$ = $ . 3 "4@$. . 4'> $4$.. $$- 8:4'0 =4-$L$ 8= $::4::3 B$4'>$ 4:: -$ $. ,% " 3 $ = $ . . '> % " . .4 . ,4: 4-$ B 3 %@ $ $ F$ $ . . , $$ = . $$ - $ . 4 B$$=FW$ 3 4$$ =4 $ . = 4E$ . , # . B$ 4 '> .$ $ $. = $ . ::$. ,=:$$.BC'>3
$ $ J . , J $ ! . ,- $::J::8F$4$. $.:
/01*/'2 !)'/)0! F " % F3 :$ = $ 4-$ 8 $. H: $4::$. $F4$. $ $ I ::$ $ " % = B: C84. 5 ( .B 2 C$ '> N ')/*>73 ::$ $ =$ J $ =$#$ 4::$J @$$ 9 - $ J $3 & % .$ J.$ J$ : $3
, .. $$ # $ 4=$$ . :$ . . # . '>3 $ = ! . .$ .B $ $ : 8 . . . . :=. .$8 B3 " $ :@ $ . 4::$ $6
(''%%X% >2>31*5)*#7Y+3)+&64
(''+%X% 2&D3>*5Y%3+7'6+'
* 6 83&)&6+'
.$$$$- 8C . $5'J11D3'*$)J22*3D*7 L84,-8%3+7'+' 96. $4 =4 ::$- $#. '0'>3
D3 $E$ C$$ ..$: $$=4 $.$0J>)*>*: 3
.. $ . . # $ J 8 % " "" : JB$ F$ $$$ $$. J !B@$ .<8B3
/01*/'2 !)0/)0!
# - *5 *#! -!*! #!- -
:;9 < = >6 7,( ?
9
)3 -B3
9
'3 C$$3
03 $=. $@ $$3
>3 : . $ =4 .-$ : $ . $ E$ 0* C , $:$ . . B : "FSW F:= & &> $ #. 3 .$ E$ . @3 $6 7 = #$$= $ B$ $. $$=M B7 #. . = $: $ .- $$ $ M 7 . $ @$ . $$3 " $$ . $ $ $$ 7 B7 $ 7 ! B: . .$ $, =4 - -B3 $ < . - = $ C$ = $$= $ 4-.. =$#. $5 $3)0')*&$)*D73 @ :: $6 Z % $ !C $6 % G %%
.: . $ E$$$:#. $=484::: $.B=. @ ::
/01*/'2