Contractual Pricing Mechanism Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought to recover damages for breach of a contract term related to the calculation of the selling price of an asset, asserting that the counterparty incorrectly applied a specific pricing mechanism based on flawed inputs and thereby overcharged them. The court reasoned that the contract unambiguously defined the inputs and method for the price calculation, and the evidence demonstrated that the counterparty strictly adhered to these agreed-upon contractual provisions, even if the result was financially unfavorable to the claimant; therefore, because the performance was in accordance with the contract's clear terms, there was no breach, and the claim for damages failed.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Pricing Mechanism Dispute: The court reasoned that the contract unambiguously defined the inputs and method for the price calculation, and the evidence demonstrated that the counterparty strictly adhered to these agreed-upon contractual provisions, even if the result was financially unfavorable to the claimant; therefore, because the performance was in accordance with the contract's clear terms, there was no breach, and the claim for damages failed.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision is cited in the final orders (order 8) for imposing the costs of the federal appeal.
Testo completo
"#$%%"#&&$ "'($"#&&'
!!
) !*) + )! +*
$, -. / 01 2 #&&'
3+*+ **)*+ )*4 $! !"#"$$%&"'()*%+,'+-., !"#
*%!
56666666666 )/0/1111111111 23!
!
6.47-6
3*
70 81111111111 9 :"6)!;< *"2%2= "!"% "%! *$$! ;> % )!*)!"2%"! !%!% ?1111111111 " @ !"# % A $)*" )"!)!*0
.0 .B$!.--.C33")!2>*A)!*3"*%* !"# *2 *"2%2 @ D*%"* "%"%%"* ))2%"> :"6)!;< D*%"*= )*! 33""%"* C*33"0 33% C33""%"* *"2%2 @ D*%"* %!*" !>"%2%2!2""2572$E!.---0
50 *"2%2CA%)))*!%2)!>CF"%C*>*%!%)!; C "%"%%"* )!2>*A !"%!2 D*%"* ! % 7,$".--. 2""* C33""%"* C*33" > 33% !2%!*%"3 7!G>"!.--70 %%2""*%%!23*!>*"!2%2*%%20
(0 !*!!"!7H2$E!.--.D*%"*$2@*"2%2!$)"! C>"$%%"*"!)!2>""*)*!C2.--5%"*! %!2 % *!%" C!2 * *! 2!20 2%2 )!2"2 & *> 2" "$)!%" 3!" !)) $%%"* % 3%!%"* !"%3%!20
,0 ! *!!"! 77 G>"! .--5 D*%"* !2 @ *"2%2 !>2 *)2!%"*!"%!2*!CF!"C2%%%!$"2572$E!.--.0 !>2""%))!I%!*2E"%!D!0,H505-0
B0 *"2%2 C2%% ) &"%%2 %% *$$ D*%"* )! *!!"! 7-32>!"! .--5 " !2 *$$%"* 3*!$ *!%" D!0 7--0J 3!"$"$!0
H0 ! *!!"! .H 32>!"! .--5 D*%"* *> 3*" !2$2 @ *"2%2C>"$%%"*"!C2.--509CAG*%"%D!0,-0J 3!"!))0
+0 E*!!*%!"E%"*2%22%E"%.5>!".--53"F%$*%% K@D!0(+LH--066@)A!5-G*!0 2*$)%2%22%E"!E "! 9.--.!"%!2)! "*$)%"* 9%!*" @ ! *$)% % 3"% & "! !*2 *!!)* "! E!% 9$*"2%"*!"%"*0
'0 !*!!"!,$".--5D*%"*3*!$$%*$$2*"2%2)A! $*%%%&!*!%%!>2*$)%*!%.$".--50
4.5++4.--5 6547-6 7-0 !*!!"!7,G"%.--5D*%"*!2*>*$$%"*@ *"2%20$*%%*33!C2>"%*!*!>2*$)%*!% 77G"%.--5@D!0('L,.505-0
770 !";! *$$%"* !2 @ *"2%2 % ( *K% .--5 % 2$%!%2%%!$*!%0
7.0 B *%*E! .--5 ! !2&""%"* D*%"* C33" )*!"% % 3""%:"6)!;C=*%"3"2*$$$%)A!M-5..5'5H@ *"2%2)*!$*%%D!0('L,.505->"%2!N%@,O;7'*K%.--5 %D!0.,-0663!"0*"2%23"%*))*"%"*%..*%*E!.--50
750 7- 2$E! .--5 D*%"* "" !"E 2 C !&N% $">2 23""%"> C*))*"%"*0 %! %! *$% )!*"% E*!! *%"%"* *$$$% )A! !>2 *$)% C$)*A!""&">!*$$%"*0
7(0 >"%2@2%!$"!23!C%)$"3%20
4.5++4.--5 6(47-6
!+*
70 *" >*" ! C*!"%"* G"""! :P . -,= 2%2 $*"3"2 % "%"%2 ; 7! *K% .--5 !"E %* ! *"0 *3*!$2$%@C!%0,B07"%0E !"E*I%"%"& *%%%"* !%"> @ )!2>*A )!*3"* *))*% "%"%%"* )!2>*A$)*A!%A%!*"%A*$)!"">*!""&CF )!2%%"* !)*E""%20 2)*2 >% G!""%"* *$)2%% $%""!>E0
.0 *" 322! ! )!2>*A )!*3"* >"" !>">% % ">""%2 ., G" 7'+. : 6 9 +570(-= "%"% !2"$ C! *E"%*"!!"2:!%0.07=0
9* C!%0 77 0 7 %*% $)*A! *)% !"2 *$" @ C! *E"%*"! *"% N%! 33""2 @ "%"%%"* )!2>*A "!"% !"%!)!2>*A)!*3"*09"C$)*A!*3*!$ ) @ * *E"%"* C%*!"%2 %* !>" *$$ C33""! "F $*" @ "%"%%"* )!2>*A0 CF)"!%"* 2" C$)*A! &" C ) *E%$)2!2 @ %% "G*%"* % *2 @ C"%"%%"* ))2%">)*!33""%"*:!%0770,=0C33""%"**!">33% !2%!*%"3:!%07705=0
C!%0507C*!*!!*"%C"%"%%"*))2%">$%";! )!2>*A )!*3"* :"6)!;< C*!*P 9 +570(5(= )!2>*"% *! & C$)*A! *"% >!! @ C"%"%%"* ))2%"> *%"%"* )*!C$E!"2*$"@*">33%;$*$%*Q"!"% K N%! 33""2 @ "%"%%"* )!2>*A0 %F C"%2!N% $*!%*"! *!!)* @ " &C))"& #E"%$% C"%"%%"* ))2%"> !%!)"$%*%"%"*:!%050.C*!*=0
50 F%!$C!%0H507#&%*2"%!"E&"*I% !";! "% %* *%%%"* *))*% "%"%%"* )!2>*A$)*A!%A%!*"%0
C ) "%"%2 )!*2! C*))*"%"* )!2E !*! %!"E0G!")!)!2"2*%!&""%"%%"*)!2>*A " C"%"%%"* ))2%"> )*>"% ! C*))*"%"* @ )*!"% !*>!$%*%"%"*)!C$)*A!)!2""*"$"E@ G$%: D77,',P 7''77('=0 !"E2)%"" *I%!"!%$%C*))*"%"*3"%)!2E"%! *$$$% )A!0
4.5++4.--5 6,47-6 (0 2""* %*!"%2 $""%!%"> 322! )*!%% *$%"* @ )A!*$$C!%*%F2%2)!>*")*!"%)*!%%% *%3*")23*!"$"2@G$%F2%*"! C!%0+-0.#0.*"322!!)*!"%)*!%%%3""% 77>!"7++':69.+707P060 *$$%"!7''' )07..B#0(,=0
% $N$ 2""* )2 3*! %*!"%2 $""%!%"> %*!";!"%&"%%%C*$)"$%%R# !*"%)E"@*3"2)! *322!%"*))"%"*!*"%322! $"&"%%%)23""%">$%>!%!*"%322!S%!$%"% *% 2""* *% )%"E C !*! $""%!%"3 )!; C %*!"%2 322! * C !*! !*"% $""%!%"3 : *)0 "%0 )07..HP 0 %T E! 9#E%!"E U*V! 7''' )0B.7=0 ! %*!"%2 $""%!%"> 322! S % )! F%"* %*!"%2 $""%!%"> %* !";! "% 6 " 3% %! %!"EF 322!F%%!%*!"%2**!"%"*"2)%C$""%!%"* 322!%%&C%%%C*$)"$%%R#!*"%)E" @*3"2)! *322!%"*:!%070.%0E%*"322!! )!*2!$""%!%">.-2$E!7'B+[ 697H.0-.7]=0
!"E %* ! *" %%% !";! "% %*%C*$)"$%%R#!*"%)E")%*&" )!2; )!**! $">2 23""%"> )"& %%% 3* *$%"*)"$%%"$"2@G$%F2%*"!0 %%*%"* %C"!*2&3"%&$%";!&"*%*!*!% G!%33%">$%G*!""!*C!%0H'%&C" &"%2)*!>!*))*"%"*@)*!"%%%%!3*: D7-' ,7=0
,0 C); !"E 2 %"% )*! 2%E" &C &"%2 C$)*A! *)% !"2 23! >"% *E"%*"!$% N%! 33""2 @ ")!2>*A)!*3"*&"!%CG$"2%2*%%2)! !"!;*!&2""*C33""%"*%%!23*!3"!C*EG% C!*!0
*>"%)!"!C$%%!&2*$)%D*%"*)*!%%! *% F%0 33% " !*!% C$E )"; )!*"% )! $! & 23! % $!2 2E"%!" C $*%% D!0('L,.505-*!!)*%F*%"%"*$)*A2)*!C2.--.0 *%! "$) )">"%2 2E"%!" "6" CA% !2" " F *$$%"*D*%"*"@ !"E2!"%$)N#! D*%"* C! % *%"! )!*2! !*>!$% 3" C*E%"!!*"!*"%: 0,)%$E!7'',=0
4.5++4.--5 6B47-6 &" *! 3!" )*!"% " *% C*33" ))*!%2 )! 2E"%!*!&)*!"%E*%"%: 7'H(5.=0"%2!N%%3!")! 23!*%)!"!)!2>@C!%050.C*!*!!*"% C"%"%%"*))2%">$%";!)!2>*A)!*3"*)!2"%2%@ C!%0H#05(%B*"%"*C33""%"*!$"@C$)*A!*! 2""*C33""%"*.5$"7''B0
*! %* $*%"3 " A " C$%%! $ % )!**! $">223""%">C*))*"%"**$$$%)A!0
B0 &"*!3!"%2)C!%0H50.)!2"& %**">%)!2>*"!)!*2!"$)!)"%)!"")!%"%0 C!%0 +'W 0 7 *" ! )!*2! $""%!%"> 7. )%$E! 7'+, : P ,7-=)!2>*"%&%@"&)!*2!%!%"%)*!)!%"0 *%3*"2E*!%2$*$%)>%N%!$"@#!)!%" &" "% $";! %2$2!"! * %2$*" 2;!%20 33% "" & !"E 322! ! C $" )*"E""%2 "$"%! !%"%2 !*! %2$2!"! * "%!G%2 @ 2;! % )!"") 22! )!*2!)!2>)*!%*%E!#!*": D7.B7,7 *"0(E=0
G!")!)!2"2&C!*!>*2@C2#!"%N%!"$"2@ !*! )!2%% !%;! 2;!%2 * %2$2!"%20 3"% &C !*!*"%2)*!>#;33"%))!"*!"@"@" *32!! % !%;!0 *! 3%6" &C 22$% S !"%"&E S CG*% EG%">$%)!%<)!%"*!2*"%>*"!%$2)!*2!& E"$N$ )*>"% %!!!*$)%%C%%%"*& C* )*>"% !"*E$% F"! C & * !*! 2%"% 2)*!> #;:!%"&97''+)07'(=0!"%")*!%%! *%"%"*)!2>*A)!*3"*)*"%>*"!")!*;% %2$2!"! *"% N%! %!#2 F$"% * $% *$)*!%$% 2E"%! *%"%"* )!*2! G"""! $" 2$% * *$)*!%$%>%)!*;: D7.(.+,=0
!"E322!!2$%!))2&C"A"3"! "332! %! C )!% %"* *%"%2 )! $" 3!" )!*2!@#!C)!%"&""%)!2;!%2*$";!%2$2!"! C!%0+,0.%0*"322!!C!6>""%!>">% : 9X9+5707-YP30%$%!%0B7%0*"322!!)!%" 22! ! *" [ 6 9 +5-07P >"! )" 7!G>"! .--5]= % C%! )!% !*"% F 2) * C!%0 +, 0 . %03 9 :%$% !%0 B7 %0 = !*"% &" C))!2" * !"%;! 2>*))2 G% C*%"* 2) @ )!%" "% $%"!:!%"&9.--.)0B7=0
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
H0 C);"*>"%2%!$"!)!$"!""23!"> 2;!%2 * %2$2!"%2 G%"3"% F)%"* )!"") !%"%2 )!*2!)"3"%"2))>%N%!*%!*A2@$!0
0 >C%%"%23! >%)!*; ""&C *! )!*2!G"""!2;!%2**$)*!%$%*"%N%!*%%20 33% " 2"2 !233""! @ "%"%%"* )!2>*A &" $2 D*%"* @ C33""! C*33" *3*!$2$% F ")*"%"* 20 C )! "!G$"*2"%F$%")*$$%"*&""*%2%2!2)! D*%"*0 > "332!% 22$% !"E 2 % 3*2 *$)%%G!")!)!2"%2@"!2$!2$*$%@%"%! 3!")!*2!0
*!3"F!$*%% !"E%*!*"%% "$"% 2%E" )! !;$% *" C %%0 3!" )!*2! &" )>%N%!$"@#!)!%"*$)!%C2$*$%C!!N%2% 2E*!:!%07!;$%!3!"2$*$%%"$"%2)!*2! $""%!%">P ,7-0-5= !;22!C2$*$%C!!N%2CF;) D!07-L---066:!%0.07!;$%)!2"%2=0 !"E*$!;*! 23!@)A!2$*$%D!07L---0660
E0%@F$"!&%"*2)0 !"E*%%&D*%"* " $%"! )*! 3"! >*"! !20 !) " C"%
4.5++4.--5 6+47-6 )%)C33"!*$)F">3"%*!*"%%%!>" !&"C)2)2!&"%*!$$%2"! !0*"%"*"!*%!*A2"$"%22)@ $!0
4.5++4.--5 6'47-6
! +*3 !*) + )! +*
7-8 9 : ;< 0(# +=
8
70 2! !>E $ 2)*2 7- 2$E! .--5 )! D*%"* "%"%%"*))2%">"!"2*%!811111111119 P
8
.0 C$%P
50 *$811111111119 @)A!@D*%"*"%"%%"*))2%"> $*%%D!0('L,.505->"%2!N%@,O;7'*K%.--5D!0.,-0663!" *%%"F%)*!"%P
(0 !** $">2 23""%"> C*))*"%"* *$$$% )A! M-5..5'H5@*!!$*%%$%"*2P
,0 *$23!@2$*$%D!07L---066P
B0 2E*%$!%*%%!*)$)*"*P
H0 "%&)!*2!%!%"%P
+0 3*!$ )!%" &C )>% 3*!$! !*! *%! )!2% !!N% 2" 5- G*! ; *%"3"%"* )! )" !*$$2 !2 !"E 322! ! 9#Z"T!#*3&" B B--( %!*" F$)"!0 2" )% N%! )!**20 $2$*"! *"%< = ""&! F%$%&2""*!*!%2"!*E%"!"%)2""* %%&2P E= F)*! )*! & $*%"3 " %"$ )*>*"! $! %% %! 2""*P = )*!%! "%! * * !)!2%%0 9" $2$*"! *%"% ) %!*" 22$% 2$2!2 * %%! = E= % = "6 !"E322!!)*!!)%!!$%";!!!*!&C" >!2!!"!!>E0$2$*"!!*!$%"*!*!$*A 4.5++4.--5 67-47-6 )!> &" !*% G*"% "" & 2""* %%&2 % C>*)) &2%2F)2"2!*!%:!%075.7-B%7-+=0
!33";!< !2"%< "DD U!"9 U
*)"*3*!$)!2%!!N%%*%"3"2F)!%"""&C@C33"322! !*")!!33
4.5++4.--5