Restrictive Covenant Enforcement Despite Neighborhood Change
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA litigant appealed a decision regarding the enforcement of a contractual covenant restricting the use of property, arguing that the restrictive covenant, which barred construction or maintenance of any building or structure except for a single-family dwelling, was unenforceable because the character of the neighborhood had changed and the covenant no longer served its intended purpose. The court reasoned that while changes in the surrounding area existed, the property owner failed to demonstrate that the covenant was obsolete or that enforcing it would cause undue hardship, concluding that the restrictive covenant remained valid and enforceable due to the continued residential character of the properties governed by similar restrictions, thus affirming the lower court's injunction preventing the unauthorized construction.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Restrictive Covenant Enforcement Despite Neighborhood Change: The court reasoned that while changes in the surrounding area existed, the property owner failed to demonstrate that the covenant was obsolete or that enforcing it would cause undue hardship, concluding that the restrictive covenant remained valid and enforceable due to the continued residential character of the properties governed by similar restrictions, thus affirming the lower court's injunction preventing the unauthorized construction.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on the allocation of court costs.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the assessment of legal fees for the respondent.
Cited in order 1 to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
!""#!"$$% &!%'#!"$$%
(&
) &*) &+ ) + *
# , "$$%
-. / 0
1111111111
2! & ) ! * * ! " ! #$ %
3*&
& '()&
#, -" ........../ ! 0 #)1#/ 22! 34 " 5 ( 66 7&34 8, 22 " 9 3:"4 " ; 3! <: = " " 3 3&3!/ > "?< &"!3", " 3:9:!3 !! 3 = "< 9 3:>, ?! '# ?! = )* ! 3 @1#'/ 3 :< 3 ,
', "! " 1* ''/ ? 3" 2 ! >? ! 3 ;! 3 ?! '', "! 33 " #) 0 '1/ 2 3! "A ! 3 0>? 1# "! ; '',
1, <! 3 / ........../ !" / 3! !" <</ "!! #) "! ; '' B
C 3&3! " <: " 4 != ;: <: D " 3 " ; 3! <: E > 0? 2 " 3 #))*/ " ! 33; " 3 <> = "!0% / 4,
3:9:!3 <> % F*G 9 3:"4 % F*G,
/ !! 3; " 33 !" <> <H % 3:9:!3/ > !3< ; "<2, 3:9:!3 9 3:"4 22 "3;,
?3! " #)@1 " ! > " 3! ; % :< #)@$ % =! <> " 4 ! <!, #)@$ % #))*/ 3 = 3 3! ",
" =/ 0 & I << J-K,
34 ! " 3:9:!3/ 3 " " 3" 0 =/ > 3> !! "?= "A ! " 3:9:!3 3 / 3 "! "! !/ !! C % = L,
0/ ?< " > ? !=!! 22 3 3 :> 2 > 3:9:!3 !! 3/ " 3 9 3:"4 ? <<=!, A "? 3 = : > " ; 3! > D! 3 3:9:!3 ,
(''$('+ & 1()&
" !; 3 3/ % " > 3:9:!3 3=,
6 = 0<M ! > 3 = % = " 3! " "/ ? 0 =<; 0>?% 3!/ 0? ! 3N " 22 "= " !" <> :M 3/ >? " ;!!2 L,
+, "! " $ 0= '1/ ! >? 3" :</ 3 ?! '1/ > @' ! " "< 9 3:>,
F, ?! 2 ! 33 '* 0= '1,
O, ........../ !" " / <!! J-K/ ? " % " $ ; '1 B
C ?A > 0? 2 34 " 3 ! > ! 32 D! > % ?P"4 / 0 34 " , 3 " " I H< > ; = < << 3! P"4 3! % > 0? ;=! :M 3, 3 2 9 " 2 ! " "< 9 3:> > "= 3 >, J " > ! 32 3>? ?9 P"4 :M 3 " ?A ,
- 33 % " 3<= ! " 3 % > ! 3 "A % ! 3 "A / ?&%&" 9 ! > 0/ = " &0, - !2! % A3! 3 Q 0? ! % = << % 33" % 2 >> < " "? "< 9 3:> "?;" " "? 3:9:!3 0 3 > ? " 3 < 3 3 I ;!!2>, :M - .......... > 0? = 4 ! = 2 0 3 > !" 3 ?=! <2 3 , "! > 3 4 ;/ 0 3 !< < >? 3 "=< A " <9 > > 3 = 22 2=; L,
@, 6 2" " !"/ / 3 "! 33 " '1 0= '+/ 3! 33 " "A ! 3 3 ?! '1/ #*+/ 33 " 3<= "? ! " &0 % 9 ! > 0 > ="/ 3 ?! '+/ % @1 !, ? 3
(''$('+ & +()&
<<!! % ?!! " !9 " 3 ;"< 32 2 > "= < 3 " 3<= " ; " ! " 3:9:!3,
$, ?! 0! ) 2!= '+ " "! 33, 33 > " 3:9:!3 = "< 9 3:> 3 < 3:9> " = 33; E > !" / 3 ! > " :>/ >?! "! >? 22 3 "! " 0 =/ "A ! " 3:9:!3 "3;, ?! 3! > ;"< 32 3 ;/ 33! 3 !" " ; " ! " 3:9:!3/ ? 3 ?22 3!/ ; >?22, !3" 2 % << " .......... > 33 % 2 >> < " "? "< 9 3:>/ 0 > & 22 "? 39: 2 3 " " " " ;!,
), ;= " 'O = '+/ < >? " " 3 " ! " "< 9 3:>/ " / !<" 33 " ?!<! " , 6?< " ; 2! / 4= > 22! 3 I ! = > 3 !" 34 ! " 3:9:!3 <" !< " 0!, 33 2 >? !! 3!= >?34 3!" "? "?= % A / !!=!,
+*&
#4 8 <= ?< 0" 78 !! "2! !/ "4 # R '1/ ; " 7, # , 8,
I " 1* '+/ 3"/ ; " 2 7&34 8 ! "?22 ! " ?, # , / "! > 6 = !! !! = " ?, #1# " <= & &,
(''$('+ & F()&
;8 J " > ; " !/ A 2 = B
& 2< 3 " "32 " ?I, / "32 "? 0< 3 >! ?! " : 0<!/ 2, ?! " : 0<! ?!" % A& > " Q "32 9 = A3! Q 33 % > < 7 J )O ')F E 533/ ! " " " 2/ +4 !"/ #))#/ 3, '+$ E K;:"/ " 0" 3=! / #)$# 3, 1#1 ,8,
& ?! " : 0<! = > >? > 3 9 > ; 3= A 72, 533/ 3, , 3, 'F#8, / 33D ?34 "A > "=/ I 3=/ % ? "? 0! 3 = " " 3> I! " "? 2A " " ?! " 0< 6/ N ! " 0",
& I "!! , 6/ ? 3 33 " & ; 72, &JS ;/ ": " 6:TM/ =, / #))#/ 3, #@$/ +1*8, = 3 " = >? ; " 4< <!! "?< = / 3 34 > !> " ? ;= !< 0"> 7 J ##' 1#18, 2 / "4 > "! 3> " ?I " = % ?A "? 0" > 2 "3 # R '1 "!0%/ " 0< / > 0< 33!/ !! !<4 !,
8 6 A "?22 3! E = ?I " " 1* '+ 0>?% A/ !< % =!2 2 ! % ?, #1# " ?,
6 0" " = 3!/ >? " " 3 " , 9 " 33 > ?, F@ " 2!"! 3 <!! " " " & &/ ! =< # 0= '1/ :> ; " / > > " " " , "3 !< 2!"! ;< % <3 A " I / A 0> % !3 % 4= "= "
(''$('+ & O()&
, ? 3 !3" % ?A< 3! 3 2!"! > !< <= !! 6,
6 ?, #1# , # / C !; " ;A 3 3 0< = 3! E 4< ;/ ?</ 0" 3! L, " ! " #)@#/ "3 !! 3!! 3 ! '/ ;! B C ; " 2 ! 3 " " " 2 " Q 3!= L,
?34 I 33 > ", 4< "?3! 3 0< " "!<< "? "3 B " 3 % 3! !/ :>/ !!<> 9! > " , 0< "= 3 3 " A " , / " I " 1* '+/ "!! > A " ?, #1# , ' 3 " 3 3 "? ;A " " " 2 E 3!! C ; L <2 C ; L, / ?, #1# , ' 3! > ; " 2 ! C " Q 3!= L, ? " > ! " A " 2 4= "? 0", ?3! ! 3 % " > C L " I >2!/< / "? "! !,
9 " 2 ! 3 3! :> !!<>, ! " =A 3!3 7-! " " U - & #)@*/ 3, FF+ ,8 > !< #)@* " !/ A N! " 0" = 3! A 3!= % ?, #1# , # / ; " 2 "!3" " 3= A!2, ; ! "! % 3 ! U "? / " / V > = % D " "! " "!3 , ?! 3" 3 > > 3 <!!/ 3 > ; ?! = "! " 3! "?;, ! !=" > 3! "= ;/ " 3 34 7 3 3/ A3V8, 6 -! " " / 3, FF@/ C " 94 =<!/ / "? 3!! " !! "!"!/ " 0" " = " "!3"/ > !3 3! L,
(''$('+ & @()&
4 # 0= '/ !! ;!!2 "? <!! " 3!, "= 0" " = 3! " " 7, FO 8, =/ " " 3! !! A3! !22 ! 7- #))@/ 3, )+1*8, ! " 0" ? " 3 0 !! / 3 J 3 J , = 3 " " > 3I:! !</ >> ! 3 "/ " 2 3! 4 "? / 0> % "!= % " / % 0" " = 3!/ 6 ?,
6 ? "= = ?3! " " I " 1* '+/ 6/ !< " 3!/ 9 3 :! & I , ? 2 3 !! ; =! 3 !<,
= " > 3!4"/ ! " 6 33 " 2 % <=,
?! " 0< 9 3 !! ! 3 ; 2!"!/ " I " '@ 0= '+/ " <= "3!/ #1 2!= '+/ "3 3 6 " !< % 0< / / " ? " ?! " =A ,
', 2!"! 3 <!! " " " " O ; ' 7 8 ! =< # 0= '1 D "2 " ; "3 !< " " " ? ", 33; "?34/ "! < " " 'F '1,
1, 0! 3 "= 0" 3! =; 7, FO " ?< 0" " '' = ; #)+# U U ' *F E , $O " 2!"! ?& " " #$ #))+ U - U 6 $1',#*8,
+, > < 3 ; " ! " 3:9:!3 = "< 9 3:> 3 @1#' > ? ! "= 3" :< 3 3 ?! '+,
F, ?, F " ?" 3 " ? ;< " " " & 6 3! > ! " "< 9 3:> = " " "4 9 3:> 3 :</ 33
(''$('+ & $()&
!"/ 3>! 3 3:9:!3 2 ! 3! " :!3,
A " ?, 1' -/ 3 ! A 'F % 1# "= I 22/ 333! ! >, ?22! " I "! ! " !:" 2>, ?22!/ ?"!> 4 ! > " 3 !A ! 3!"> ,
6 !" / 22 ;!!2> "? ! " 3:9:!3 3< 3" 0 =/ C > 3> !! "?= "A ! " 3:9:!3 3 / 3 "! "! !L, !" " ? !/ > % / 3 ?! " = " 3 " " I H< 9 ; = < << 3! P"4 3!/ > "? " 2 ! " "< 9 3:>, 33 "4 " 3<= " !,
> = 3; "? 33 !"/ > "! ? > 3 <A 3 2 ?;0 "? !" 2!/ > 33 2" " A 3/ >? 3 "! 3 A3 !/ >? !! !; 3 " " 7 48/ > "3 " A !" 2 > " ?A3 ; =! 7 J #'' #O* ", # !2, E J 3;! " #) 0= '8,
J " > 33 " !" ; % 3 " = " " >? D, =:/ !" / " 3! J-K <</ "!=! = !" !A/ "!! , ?9 "4 3 " ?! " , ; " ! 2A "4 % "A 3 ; " ! " 3:9:!3 = "< 9 3:> > ? ! "= 3" :< 3 ?! '+,
(''$('+ & )()&
+&*3 &*) &+ ) + *
56 7 8 95 -:" +
6
#, S ,
6
', ?" ,
1, > ? ! "= 3" :< 3 ?! '+ "A ! 3 " 3:9:!3 = "< 9 3:>,
+, > 3!" <,
F, 2 3 " >W 3= 2 3! I " "! " 1* 0 "4 2 3 3 "! "! ; 2!"! " / 6:TM:2> O/ O+ / A 3, "! 3 I 3<!, ! " B 8 "> A > "! "! ; 3 " "! >!E ;8 A3 3 > 2 3= " " "!E 8 3 < " 3!, 6 ! 3 !! ! !! 8 ;8 8 &"/ ; 2!"! " 3 3 4 >W "= "! =;, ! " 9 " 3=/ > 0/ > "! >! W=33 " > !! A3!"! 7, #1'/ #*O #*$ 8,
<224 B !" B
-& X Y
3 2 " 3! I 2! A 3 >W% W22 2!"! " 3 <22
(''$('+