Settlement Agreement Validity: Fraud vs. Breach of Prior Disclosure Agreement
Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the validity of a settlement agreement where one party alleged the agreement was procured by fraud and misrepresentation concerning the true financial condition of the other party, and further argued that the agreement should be voided due to a breach of a prior agreement regarding full disclosure. The court reasoned that the specific provision in the settlement agreement stating that each party relied only on their own investigation and not on representations made by the other party barred the claim of fraud based on misrepresentation of finances, as this clause effectively disclaimed reliance on outside statements. However, the court found that the claim based on the breach of the prior agreement mandating full disclosure was not barred by the release language in the settlement, as the breach of a separate contractual obligation could still provide grounds for relief, thus reversing dismissal on that specific count.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Settlement Agreement Validity: Fraud vs. Breach of Prior Disclosure Agreement: The court reasoned that the specific provision in the settlement agreement stating that each party relied only on their own investigation and not on representations made by the other party barred the claim of fraud based on misrepresentation of finances, as this clause effectively disclaimed reliance on outside statements. However, the court found that the claim based on the breach of the prior agreement mandating full disclosure was not barred by the release language in the settlement, as the breach of a separate contractual obligation could still provide grounds for relief, thus reversing dismissal on that specific count.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAImposed costs for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%&'#%((& #$&'#%(()
*+ + + *+
, % ') %(()
- ........... ! " #
........... ! $ % "
&"
+/ -0 10 2 ' &&"(() * &+,-+./ '
!2 " 3+ + + + 4 5 &"& *& 0"*# * &-1)+ +,))./ '
!"
)3(
+ 3
45 "6# & 7 & 0"),,( 89 : 0" " 0 *" 9" & *" ! ; " < =>>>>>>>>>>> & < " =>>>>>>>>>>> " ! & (6 &488?5
)5 = : 22"+ 6# &*"! &! " 0 *" 9" & " ! *"&# *" & ! ; " *"!; @ *" 2 A *" : !* B "& " #5
15 6# & ; "& ; !2 & 2)7 ; 0"),,(&!&!&" C 22 " 0 !( ! 0"),,(* "B!& *"
-5 " 0 ! &! *"& " & && *"!; @ * &"*! & && !2 "*" & A" && ; " *"& A "& " # &&"(6 & 488?&)7 ; 0"),,(5
(5 = "" " .=== 4,6; "),,7 *"&& A * & " # *" " & -)C,(4 2"5 ), 2 ! & *"&& *"!; @D & " #& &!"E&@"& 26AC6 " ; "5 0" ":": " 0 ! "& *"&& *"!; @ " &*" C!&0 "A**"& & ; &! *" 2 A $ ; & B"! "& " # C; & * ! D & & " &! "*"F5 )7 ; 0" ),,( && -,7 2"5 +, & !* ! *"9 G = = 5
75 & &!&!&" B*"& & - ),,756" & " A!ACD !2& C 0";& C 4( ),,7 ""E&" &" "&&05
?5 C0 C 06& ! 2 B! !&!#" !D6#"5
+ *
45 C"&5)( 2! !"" 0"*# *"!; @*" 2 ; "; ;&& ; &! 4? ! 0"4881HGI &"!; #" 4"6; "),,, "9#*" ! " ; "5 "A 6 & & * J " "*"&& "& D*"&#"H"&54))&4)1 ; $ I 6# ; " *!&& C"&5?154 2! !"" *"!; @ *" 2 )( 6 48+) HI & D 9; " 0
3-)(43),,( 13(
& " * 4" K&),,1 & *"9AC22 " !&!&" H"&54-) I B!&" C 22 *"&#"0 ! "!*"& & !&" !*"6# ; "5
)5 = C"&5))GH ;&"; #" * 4"6; "),,,I ; " *"&& "& A "& " # & *"&#! 2 " ! & B"&54)) 4)1 4-4&4-) L"&51D( GC A& *" # &&D&"2!""H54I5 ":A 6 & *"&& "& D*"&#" ""* D 22!"&"*"&& "& # &! ; " 0" *# B && !;& & & ; " & *"&& "& # &! ; " 0"*#B &&!;& & & " #H25"&5)-GI5 " 6 & D *"&& "& & D C; " 0" *# B && & " # &!"E& & ; " H G 4)+ )1,L G4)8---I5
J*9 6# *" 9" & " ! *"&# *" & ! *"&& "& A "& " # *" "5 & *"& & & J *"& " # ( 6 & 488? J&" *"& )7 ; 0"),,( &DA6# & ; "& ;B!& "5
15 = & *" & *"&& A * & " # *" "& -)C,(42"5),2"5& AA *" "& -,72"5+, &!"E&@& !6D!&!!*" & && *"!; @ !2 "5 " &D B$!* && )4C,)(2"57, H-)C,(42"5),M)I&$ &D $D && ),12"5-,H-,72"5+,M)I "&AJ& "A &D B$!* && ),C+))2"5 ),5
-5 2 " ! & D 6" *" * 6 " !&" & * " *"&# 6AC & &"2"& *"&& "& " 6 & ; "!0!!2 " &&*"&& " &D &!"E& *& "" && $ 5 &!"E& &!&B !# C"&54) C " "*"!; @*" 2 ; "; ;&& ; &! 4+ ;" 48+- H )I &B "!# & " $ & *!" " H G *0 !173,) 4+6 &),,1I
(5 A "2" !* J"&5?15)*"! A & ;&*"!; "*" ! " * "* & *" * #"& &5J"&5 +8' 5 4 " *" ! " &"& ; 4) *& 0" 48+( H I *"!; & A& D A *" ! " & #"& & * " *"& 5 &2 !0 " & ! & *;& E&" D :"# *"& A # & 9"&! !" " &! # !#9"&!5 22& A " 02! !" " J * 0 &! &" #"& &! " "
3-)(43),,( -3(
&! !" " &"6&! D !#9" & *" * #!!" *" ! " *"!; * " & &0": " H G4)74(4 5-0I5
" 02! !" "!# &"!AJ @ 2 " 22!" &" J *"& & & &! *" 2" *" ! "D:"# J*"& A # &*"!#9"&! 9"&! !" " J"&5+(5)&5 2! !""J"$; &"; ;& H =I H& & "&5 74 &5 2! !" " *"& #!!" " [ ; #" * 4"6; "),,1]& J&"*"& " & B !* J"&5 +( 5 ) &5 2 = [& & "&5 74 &5 # ] " &A J"! " &9" !; !6& J & !*D*"& # & & "H"& A=),,)*574I5
" 0 ! 9" A J &" !* 6& 2 * J*9 J&& & "6& 2 ";:AC & ! * & J ! &5 = * ; &! A 0 "& & &" & " 0 D 0" ! ": A & !&! !; &! J!& & 2 " ! D 0 #& " #" & ; & & * 0 J " ""E& J J"&5?(5J! &"2 B! J ""D(,,2"5
NNN
3-)(43),,( (3(
* 3 *+ + + *+
60-7- 8 9-- - :" ')% ;
45 ; & .=== D&"2!"" *& < "=>>>>>>>>>>> ),C+))2"5),DG = = 2;" < =>>>>>>>>>>> A &!"E& *& " !"& 9)7 ; 0"),,(6AC & &"2"&5
)5 J@ &&A 0 5
15 < =>>>>>>>>>>>* & C! & (,,2"5
-5 2 " *"& AC *;& 2 " " " " &" *"!& ""E& ! 1, 6 " 9 & 2 & *" * " ! "! " 0 2! !" " =:O P": 2A 7 7,,- &" B * "5 ! *& E&" *" #!5 ! " & M I A" B& & A ! " "& ! " 0& " & * ! &&A!L0IB* "* "A & 2 & * ; " "&& &" ! LI* "&" #&" "*"!&&5= ! " & & * &" !! & ! !"! &&" I 0I & I $ " 02! !" "* ""*&"" & 9""" "AC ;" !"" "";05 ! " " " & " " @ *"; A " & 6 & A ! &&A! & C; A!&!B*! !" "&H"&541) 4,7&4,+I5 #"22 " "! &M "" = 0=
* 2 " *"!&""E&& & 2 !B*"& AJDJ22 2! !" " *"#"22
3-)(43),,(