Intellectual Property Royalty Allocation Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged a ruling regarding the allocation of royalties for intellectual property, asserting that the trial court erred in interpreting the governing agreement concerning the percentage owed upon specific forms of exploitation. The appellate court reasoned that the contract language, when read in its entirety, clearly dictated a lower royalty rate for the disputed exploitation method than what the lower court had determined, necessitating a recalculation of the amounts due under the contract's unambiguous terms.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Intellectual Property Royalty Allocation Dispute: The appellate court reasoned that the contract language, when read in its entirety, clearly dictated a lower royalty rate for the disputed exploitation method than what the lower court had determined, necessitating a recalculation of the amounts due under the contract's unambiguous terms.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 1* for deciding on the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
!""#!#$$% !%%&!#$$'
( )(* *+* (* +)
%, -./ 01 #$$'
2 3333333333 ! !!"# "$"%
!
!
) *+* 4*5+) 674 &!"' $"($(")*+,-.) "!"&
(+/(
* 8)
*1 2" 3333333333 ! )"& . $ "&!& 4333333333356 $ * ) "+,,00*#"!+,,0$!6%! !&!& &""& "$ 7 ! $ 8"1 )! 9"!& & )"! ! )"& . $ "&!& :33333333335 $* 7&) " +,,+0, +,,+! .$ 5 +,,,
56 $* 7&) " +,,,0,!; +,,*1
+1 9 & 9! " "! * <! +,,0 6 977" ! $ 9" ="( . >""!!9! "$9"$"!&$?@81
01 5 9!!!!" $ 9A 9"!& & ! )"& %"!& $ 8 ! &$"! !""!" 7"". "! 7!" $" "8! $ 9! "4333333333356 1
-1 59B! "!$ 8"! $ 9"!& &&!&" "!+C7&) " +,,0 %"!& $9"&(8& ! ! $ D 1 *,E,,,1( ;&&7" $9 "8! !") 6 $B1 2$ 3333333333 &!& " "! 6 F $! "&(8& ! &8! ! $ D 1 *,E,,,1( ! ;&&7""" $9"8! !")6$B1
G1 $&""$*G!; +,,0 "!8)"$?@8="( . "> #!& $$ $9"$"!& !"7 % $ $ ". !")"!&9 &&$"!$;%"!&$9A !$9A&!%9"&!"! ) ";;%9" "! !"$!6! " 7" $ )8 $ $ ! % ! $ ! )" &!"! "! @;1 5 ""! ""! $ 7"!"7 $ ;! $ )" $ "$"!&$?@8!!&)"!! 7$9! "$ &$!"$9? " $ ! )"1 $&"" &""! %9 $ !" $&7""!") $ !")"!& $ $"!" $ 9! " 43333333333 56 $ ! !! $ " ) ("9"!& & "!;&&7"" $"$"!&$?@81
'1 " $& $ & 8"! $ *C !; +,,0 9"!& &$$& $"!" 8"! $ "$$"77"!& " ! 7"". ! & ! $ 7 ! $&7""!") $ 9B"!!"$"!$)!$4333333333356 0*#"!+,,01 &"& % &$ $"%"$!" "!! " 9 !$$!" H ! 5 1
C1 I!; +,,02J! 2 "! )!%"!&$$!" $ 2$ 3333333333 &"!& & %F! $ $! "" % $
/00+/+,,- (0/( 2" 3333333333$9F! $"&$ 8"! $ !!%8& ! $"&!&4333333333356 1
I1 *-!; +,,09"!& &7 & &!"! $&""$" $*G!; +,,01B&% $98) !"8"?! *' !; +,,0 " " )"! &!& & %9 " " $9 " $ & 8"! $ $$! $"!" $ 77" "! 6 $&8 "!!"!" !! $ )" $"$"!&1 )"! " $! $. $"1 "! " " &!& $$& $ &! !!!!" )! ) ! $ !"!" 5( & "$ ! )"& .$4333333333356 ""% ;GI%9")"!7"!1 7"F# $9! !"!&&?"%2" 3333333333" )"!7" &%9 )$988!$ &$ .$ 8"! $ 77" "! $&;% &$ 1 "! $. $&"" "%"$)"!F! "$& &1
K1 $9 ;& B! $"" $ "& %" 9! ! *C !; +,,0 2" 3333333333 ! 2$ 3333333333 ! $&""& $ 7!" $ 8& ! ! 2" 3333333333 &!& & %"!& $ 8& ! "%1)"$ " 9&!"!$ & ";$ ". !$ &;"% ! ! $ .) 7" $ 9"7 % "&!& 43333333333
56 &!"! ""!& $ "! ! ""!"! $&@! $ ;" $ $!!!1
*,1 +,!; +,,0)" $8& !$9"!& &!&!& $"&$ 8"! $ L " ! $ & " "! "& !! 2$ 33333333331
1 #8!$*,); +,,0 ";$ ". ! & 7""!$"&!&4333333333356 1
*+1 $&"$ &!&) !7) $9"!& &$.); +,,0$!6 !" $%""! A&$"$"!&$?@81
*01 &" &!" $ *G $&; +,,0 9"!& & &!& &!"L"!"!%"&!&)"!&!")"!&0*#"!+,,0! %9" 9)"! M) & !! $ ". . !! $!1 $$ $9"$"!&9)"!""#")"&6 )" $"$"!& &$!"$ 9? " $ ! )" " $ ". $" ! " $ ". "$" ! 7"!")1 5 ""! &!"! "%! $< 6 !" $9!")"!& $ 9! " ! $$ !$"! 6 " !! $9;!" A $ ;"! &" $ ! ? ?$9"19 &7"!)" %9" ""!$"!" &" 6 9;!!" $ "$"!& $ ?@8 $. * <! +,,01 "8& $ ! $ "7 !" 7 " "
/00+/+,,- (-/( $$& ? .$9%")"! ! $&$". &#$""; $&;!$) !$"$"!&1
*-1 $&""$+,#)" +,,-" #!&9"!"7 & 9 & !"7%9 .)" %"!!&"0*#"!+,,0"&!"!$ &" "! 8"! $ "&(8& !19)"!$. ! " ) "&!& 43333333333 56 $ " "!" ?@8 * <!+,,019! !9 &)"! )& !""!"7"". $ "&!&F .)" &!& $"&8& !"%9"&!"!$ &"&1 5" "$ !! !""!"7"". 9 & )"! )& "!" $" "8! $ "&!& "" % ";""!& $9"7 $&"" "1
*G1 9"! &$"" $ $!" 9 & "! #!& $! $ +, 7&) " +,,-1B%9"9$&A&$9!")"!&"$9! " . 0*#"!+,,01!"$9! !%"$?@89"7 & $". "& $ "!!;"8!")"!"$" !" 8&& $ $ "! $ "N " )"! 77! " ! "$"%&%9"&$"! !""!"7"". $9! "1 7"")"! $"!!!".B"8& "!")"!! ") " $*C!; +,,0"$ !! $$$$ $"!" 8"! $ 1 !" % ! $ $< $ $& ? . $ 8"! $ &!& $ 6 " %" 88 "" ;""!&1 !69! "$9"$"!&$?@8$.* <!+,,0;"$"" !6 % " "! $& 6 "$"!& )"!" $ $)" $9"7 !" $! B !! $ "$"!& $ ?@8 & "$$* <!+,,0*,); +,,01
*'1 &"%$*G +,,-"!!&)" 7""6;"8!" $ "8 $ O"7 &9 &%9"$)"! ! ")"&!&1 $ " $$& $"!"%"!&$8& !!! )! !""!"7"". $"&!&1
*C1 & "! $ *0 ) " +,,- 9 & "!& $ "1 !"!%9")"! $ %"7""!$"&!&&!"! $"!" " % 6 " ;!" $ "$"!& $ ?@8 $9!!%$" ! ($#"!$"")"!$"!%9"77""!$" "% "$!! 8"! $ $$! $"!"1
*I1 "; $ & $& !" $ !" %" 9! ! *' #" +,,-L 9 & &"& %9 0* #"! +,,0 !! ?$"!&!&"%"$&!%B&!"!)"$1;" " $ & $ "% 9)"! F! &""& %96 7" $ 9& +,,0L"7"!! ) )!" 9 $1B"%&%9"&!"!
/00+/+,,- (G/( !&)$?@8 ." "!"$&;!<!+,,01 " !!)"!; ! "%$" 9)"! &!& ! "!&1 B % 9! "$"!" $ 2" 3333333333 $" ! ($#"!$"%9")"!& "! 8"! $ 7"$7" $" %"!&$8& !1 " &!& "F# " $ $" ! ($#"! %" " )"! " $ 7" &" 1 "8 "! % $"!"$956 7""!$# $"!%9"7"! !!?!"% $"!"1!")" ! "!! $& ?B"8& ?@81
*K1 " !77" &)" ! !"!&&?"%)9 & *'!; +,,0 $%9)"!" !"7 &%9"7"!PQ? !!! "R ! %9" $)"! F! $"& 8"! $ " ;" 8& !%"&$"&!&1 !%"&!&&!"!" "! 8"! $ "A)"! "%%"& !$!")"!& %?@89&!"!6F$)& "7" 1
+,1 9 & "!&$"!&!&8 $&6#8 1
+*1 &8&$ !" ! "!!%$;"$ !"$ "!"( .1
/00+/+,,- ('/(
* +)
*1 " 8)" 9 8"!" #$""" => &!& $"7"& ! "!"!& $.* <!+,,0 ";!$ "&$G #8$! &"$!!)"( &"$!G&!!*'#8 = !1*!1 !G' >1
9&!" $ #8 A! " &!& & "; 7&$& $ F! $ +C #)" +,,- = D *0, *,'> $ " 8)" $!& *0 7&) " +,,- $""!" ! "!" 8! !!! ";!$ "$"&8 6 ! " #8 !"!" $ 9!!! $ 9&!" $ )B #8 1
"; ! $ " !! "! "% !! !!!" !")6"7&$& 9 (?@8 ;"8!" !9"$"!&$9");""!&$+G#"*KI+="( . > ""%96"!!". $?@8$); *KI0= !1G' >15&!!""&!;" #8 $$9.1
+1 " !" 8&& $ $ "! $ " $ ' !; +,,, = >! &)"8 * #)" +,,09"%69 (?@8 ;"8!" !69"$"!&$9");""!&7$& 8!"B = !1* 1* >1
! #!& $ 7 ! $&" &8B ! ); = !1 G' 6 ', L !1-K"&+$"8)"!". $?@8>1
01>59 !1I1* 9 &$ "!69"$"!&$?@8!!9" ! " !"! "1 ! &!& " " %" 9! !"6 !$! )"!%"? ? 6B !")"!&6" != !1*,1* >1 "%""6! !"!? ? 6 !")"!& 6 " ! 6 &! ! !")"!&6! !"! ! &!& !"!"= !1*,1 + >1
;> ! $ 9 !10* 1 0 !1 9! $ "! 6 9"$"!& $ &$!"$9? " $! )" %"7"B!$&""% $ 9A S)!"7 "$& ;!S%"!&$9"& $ ; $9 8 $" "8! $ 9! " $ $&!! $9 !""!"7"". 69! "1
/00+/+,,- (C/( 5 # " $ ! )" %" #"! $9 "!!" 7" ;6$9A 9$ "!69"$"!& %;"% ""& 7 ! ! " " !" $ $&"" $ 9A 6 "7 (" $ ". $&! "!1 ! " 77!$&! "! ;""$9$""!" 9"$"!&$ ?@8 &8!!" !". $9"$"!& $ &$!" $ 9? " $! )"= D*+0+0->1 !&8 $"B"!&! "! &" ! $ "!69"$"!&$ &$!"$9? " $! )"!$ "!6 9"$"!&$?@81!$" .88&& % %"! $ "!$"8! "$")"$$! !""!"$9! "9&.) 6+,T! &!& B U!"7 $&""$ 9A = " " 5 V ,*(K+8-W*'>1
!! $ 9 & %" &"" "(F ! $ ! )" !! % "&S!! )!"!"$9A S!%" &!$"!6 $ "$"!& $ ?@8 7" $ ! $ & "$ $ $"77"!& $ 9! "!$)" $ !& " !!")"!& "&$ ! "%"!"$9B"! !;$$ "!$%9" ! &8!!" 9"$"!& $ &$!" $ 9? " $ ! )"%B! !"!&8 "$ $ $A!$ "! = *KKIW08I>1 ! !"" )"&$9 &$"!$9 )" &$"&!&%" $""!"&? ?!6;!" $ "$"!& 7" $ "!" )" "&!& $! & "$ &"%!$"77""1
"!!" ! )? $"77& ! % "& ! )! $ "!" ""; 6 $9 A %"!! $&7""!")! 9! " " $ 7 ! $ ("L " "! $9 !!)"!6&$ "1)$F%$9! "!" $9B"! " %9 ! "& "! $ &""!" $ ! ! ! $&7""!")! !! " ) "&!& = D *+0 +0->1 $9! 9"!& &! "" &!$ $"$"!&$?@81
>5 # " $ 9! !" !& " $ 9 8 $" "8! %" ! $&! "! 9!7U$8 !" %9 !"0*"&0!! %")"6;!! $; ";#!"7=5*KKC W *,*80"$1G$>1 !"" %9"98"!$$&! " %! ";""!&77!")$9$" "8!$9"7 $$&""$9 ! " " )"! $ $ ! ! "! B"!! $ !! ! "1 &!;" 9&!$ $ )" $ $&"" 7!" $ " ! .! = *KK'/*KKC W-* 8 ++C ! "$1 *; ! +L 5*KKC W*,*80"$1G>1B!"6 ""% J! ";7&$& $ !; $" $9$""! !" " $"! B 8 = !1 C*' 6 C*'; > $9 )"
/00+/+,,- (I/( $&! "!$9 !"0*"&0 = *KK'/*KKCW-*8 ++'"$1*;! &7& >1 ; $"$9$""! !" $ "!B !!"!F! B%9""!&" $$&! " .!! ;""!&%9"B !"$"&!&= D*++ +C0"$10L D $+- +,,- 0/,0>1
-1 9." &!$9B! "!$8"! $ = >% ! &!"!!$$&"""!"8""&8& !)"8! !") 6$B$"&!&4333333333356 !!"!" $9 !"$*,E,,,7 1 &!! "!"& $ "! =71 B ". 1 *, ">1 . +, !; +,,0 " 9&!"! 8& ! " ! $ & "& =71 ". 1 *-$ ">1
5 !$&"")"!&!& "$ $&7""!")!!")"!& $"&!&0*#"!+,,0$!%" $6$ " # $! )"! O !! ?$" ! &!& "%"$&1 U " #%96 7" #"! +,,01 ) "& " ! ? ?& 6 !! 9 $ & "&!&1 ! ! $ 7"! % ;" " )"! &!& $ &$"%9!%9 .)" ! )&)!" %;" F! &""&A! &)"$9" 7"$9&+,,01 9! "$7 ! $&7""!")$9! "%9"9!" "!?@8 $. * <! +,,01 "8 "! %9" $)"! 7" $" $ )" ;&&7"" $"$"!&$?@8!!"!%9"9!!". !7 & B"! !"$"""!!"&$"!! .9)" "$ ;?$$" ! $#"!$" $"!"%"!&$9"&8& ! 1
9"!"& $"!" $%"!&$8& !77"! ) " $ "! B "$"!& $ O ! ! $ & "& $ "&!&1 &%!9!%9)9) ! $7""!%9" $ 7!" ;6$9A 1
9"&8& !$956 $"B8$)" $7"B $&""% "&!&!F! &6 $ A !% B ""! 6 !! " "7 "$& ;! $&"" $9 !10*10!1 1 77!" &!$9 !1I1* % "&$"&!&6 ;""!&""!&!!$ "!" " 9;"8!" $ !"" 6 8!" $ "&!&1 ! "" !")!"!" ;6$"$9$""! !"$9 "&!& A =: H! X 5?Y"X "? ")! ?! ;"8!" ?! Q/D Z7 !( ((2" 1 - $ !1 I >1 5" 9" "!" %"!& $9"& 8& ! ! 6 $9B $ "! B "$"!& $ ?@8 "!. 9! !!7" $&""7 % %9" 98"! $ $&! " .!! ;""!& & " $
/00+/+,,- (K/( "&!& "& =71 D $ +0 !; +,,* I'/,* 6 ! ">1
9 ! !! )" B & ;""!& $9"&8& !""")%7 ! $9! "0*#"!+,,0! &%! ! $ ! )" " % " 9! " "! ?@8 $& ! F! ! ! 6 *,, T1 "! "" " ? %% "!!" $9&$ $"!" " " 6 9! " $9"$"!& $ &$!" $ 9? " $ ! )" B% " 9 "!$ "!9 !10*10!1 1
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
! !"! %9" "8 "! % $"!" $9 56 B"8"! ! !?!"%1 9")"! &!)!&$!! ! $&7""!")! 6 9!")"!&$"&!&" "!! ""&$"!!$& ? . $ ! "! 6 !(6 % &!"! 7 "!& 6 " 1 J!""% & "$$* <!+,,0*C!; +,,0"9! ";$977" %7 ! $9! "&!"!77!")!$&7""!")1 )?$.$&@!$ %F! )"!6 $"!"$8& !$
56 !")& !" $ !")"!& $ "&!& ! $ ?!! ) ";; ! )& "7"; 7 ! $&7""!") $ 9! "1 9#!%!! !6 " %9";!!!) ";$ "7 !"&!$; ! $"! "$ F1 77!8 &$&&8!"$9"!"&" &!$".$ $" ! !"". !$9"!"7 & !$!$ *-!; +,,0""%$&?8$8! ; ! $
/00+/+,,- (*,/( " ! $ $") ! "!& %9 !" 7 B"!"! " $ 9"!"& %! 6 9 &"!" # "$"% $ $ 8 1 ! 8$9B&!"$$") "!!$ "8 "!& & $ "! ! ;"8!" = !1 +C 1 * > &!! &%)"!"$$)" !$ !"" !88 ;""!&$ 9 !1CI 1
9.%!"96F! B"&$ O ";$ & $! %96 ! $ *I !; +,,0 ! $ ) ";; ! )& "7"; 7 ! $&7""!") $ 9! "L "! $9 !!)"!6&$ "19"!% !$ "! B"$"!&$?@86! $*I!; +,,01
! %" ;!"! !"! 8" $ ) "$"!&6!"! $$&= !1'*!18 L !1IKV10 >1
/00+/+,,- (/( +)8 )(* *+* (* +)
-292 : ;22 2 < 0=# +
92
*1 & );L
92
+1 9$! !"!L
01 $&""$!! L
-1 "!! %2" 3333333333$ "!B"$"!&$?@8$. *I!; +,,0L
G1 )"! "!$?@86 $ $&""L
'1 $ 9"!"& 6 A ! "$"!& $ *EG,, 7 1 6 !"! $ !""!"67 "!$&L
C1 &;! !"$!!! ! " "L
I1 7 !" $ %9 )! 7 ! &! F! $ $&" $ 0, # $. !"7"!" " $& $ & "; 7&$& $ 5?Y"X ?7%" ' ',,- ! " B" 1 $&" ! F! 8&1 &" $"!N > "$"% B!!%$&"" !$&" ;!" "!$$&"" !!%&L ;> B % !"7 " !" )" $$ !! ! $&""L > ! "8! $ &!!1 5" &" !"! ! " &&! && & !! > ;> ! > "($ ";7&$& $ ! !". %9" $) $& " );1&" $ !" A $ ) %" ! #"! "" % $&"" !!%& ! 9) $ %&!&B&$"& != !1*0+*,'!*,I>1 8 77" N &"$!N :"$ 2 " " 7 $ &! F! ! !"7"& B !" "" %9 5 &! "! $9 !!69&" 8 77
/00+/+,,-