Prevailing Party Status and Fee Shifting for Related Claims
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant challenged the denial of attorney's fees, arguing that they were the prevailing party despite the trial court's fragmented decision structure, which did not explicitly declare them the outright winner, and that the lower court misinterpreted the fee-shifting statute by requiring the fee award to be solely attributable to the proven fee-generating claims rather than the entire case. The court reasoned that the prevailing party determination must look to the overall results achieved, finding the appellant prevailed on the central claims that formed the gravamen of the dispute, and the lower court erred in its restrictive application of the fee statute by not allowing fees for related work performed during the litigation of the ultimately dismissed claims.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeAI(ASSURANCE); DÉBUT ; INVALIDITÉ(INFIRMITÉ) ; INCAPACITÉ DE GAIN ; DROIT À LA PRESTATION D'ASSURANCE; RENTE(EN GÉNÉRAL) | LAI.29; LAI.28; LAI.4
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on the court costs of the appeal.
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs owed by the respondent.
Testo completo
&'(()&*++*,*, "&--.&*++-
"
" /" / /
*0 12 $ ) #$ *++-
$ 3333333333
44 / /" 5 /, ! " !" ''() #$%&
! " #$%
1,*++1
4 "
+2 3' 4444444444 5'16% 7 ) + .8 " '') 9:' ' " 6#9 #6';2 < " =' >"''"?'&'"')"6'+ 8-2
,2 ('"=)&',00,''')?'"?"''"?'&'"') '"';&'')"('%)'&$?1'&'"')"6'+ !!2
-2 ")''"+-@,00,?=='"?1'&'"')5'16% 7 A) "(" ('= ; ?'&'"') )' & & '&) B' + !/ ;?' (6' " 6 ) '% " ''"&"?'&'"')2
.2 " 6(C,00,;?'&'"')' &+ !/26"''")6"?'"6 '>:"&'(6'='(;?')'$99"? (6' + !D2 66 ;? 6('% "(" " 6' " ?1'&'"') ' &' )) =) + 80 ; ? $ ' "? '""''&6";"(""6' &'))6)2"'6(6"6;''6C))=''"? "6');1'66'()>6''2
/2 6)&' " 8 &(C ,00, ? A " 2 66 ; '&) B' + !/ (( )=:') $ 6'"A'+ !DC"%+ 8->"'''"=' ;?' (6'' 6 "'' "? 6 "'' ?'&'"')( $+ !/E'')) &)6('%='A&'+ !!2
D2 D ")(C ,00, '"';) ;?' "&' 6 (6)"'2
()"'6)''F3G6#9'6#99)6)"':)66 ,/A&',00-2>(').+8")(C,00,8,, A&',00-2):(6''"?6'""'()"'2 '"';;=="?=='6#9'';'&'" ' 6 ; ' )) '&' " ('% ):'% 6 ' 6#9''; " BB 3 GB "6' + 80 A;?$ A2"':'" ;'""+ 8+))')+ 6 2 "':'''C6#9';':''6)''2 " )''; " C ' " ))') " =C'"6'=''6H&''(2='(;(:)=
*+,-./*,000 1-*++1 ''"&'9I69:'6(9(6 ('=""'&')'(6C2
!2 ' " ! &' ,00- ? '"';) 6 6&' &' ")'''"66()"'" 2
82 '"+-(',00->6';); ?&'>(') 66('%='+ ! ;?')''&)6('%='B' + !+;?'&'&')6"6'('"=C';$JK'92 & B' + !/2 % (( 6 ? 6' 9:?'")$99"&'2666('""' + !8 ?==' " )=:') ?# '") =''%(2 ? " 6 6('%='()"'L&'' + ! %==)6 =';?'&'6"&'2 + 8+?$'"?'";?' 6C'"?1'&'"')2
2 "'))(' 'C")+@,00-2 'C? ") $ ''; " 6#9'' '' ;? "(" " ")('$6'";"$&')''6C"&' '"?=='6#9'';'&'""'==2
' " -0 C ,00- )6" ;?$ &' 3' 4444444444)''6C"&'"6'+ 8+2 )6" 6 ")6( " 6#9'' " ?9M6' ' '"';) ;?6% >(""'()"''6"';?'6')"&'"+00N"" + !/2
+02 'C6)")$?"''"()"'(')""+8(' ,00.2
'"';);6='>")C"?'6')"&'"C$+ !/ ' &' ':( )"') ?(C " "' 6' # &' &)66()"'"%:F"6(C+ ,2B 66 ?'6') " " + !/2 B '&' " ;' '"'; ;;'?6&&?)"66()"' '"';) ;?' =='&( " "' ; ? 6 )&'&+ ! ;?;'?<$'2 66 ' =' ) " B' " 3' 4444444444 + !/";?'"(")")=:');?'?6&')"6'$ 6;;'&2
''"';)H6#9'""6'")(C,00,2 ='>)$+ 8+""?'6')"&'"C"=<('; '"66" 2'6C%("(6)9'"@$ : ?)' 6"' $ ?'&) " B'2 & "
*+,-./*,000 1.*++1 ?'" " '' + 8+ ' 6CC ' ; ?==' 6#9''; ' ")9) ;' =);2 ):( >6';) ;?' &' &') G:' '' ;? B' " "'==) '2 '''"%;6&'&' ")C'A;?+ 8+2
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
++2 ? ?)'66))""'C';"@(&;)2 6%1&C>'"))((';)""+8(',00. :")$A:"%A2
"
+% 7 ' :&' ?:'' A"''' 57 )) ("'=') '') "% + @ ,00- 'C " ' 52 + 2 72
H"-0(,00.6" 'C"('''=5'16% 7 )"?=='')"?2+2'"); B&' ))))&''"?2+-+" '':&'1 12
C7 F";''''C")> ('='&P
*+,-./*,000 1/*++1 1 =': 6 " "'6''= " ?H2 "'6''= "? A:( 6 ;)' ?') " 9 A:) ('=2 ?')"9A:)?)"$>1';"(L "'6''= # &' >6)( L ' 66 $ ;' '':' 5 F D , /E Q66 )' " "' "('''= .%( )"'' + + 62 ,.8 E GC9'" "' A"''' 6'&) ' + 8+ 62-+-272
1 ?')"9A:)&;';?'';6(# ;'C6&'>('5=2Q6662'262,/+72'66R ?6%">; "&'(H(6&'$?'"? 'A) 6 &'' " "' 6''; H) " '"? ='>""?)'"A: B M''')"'''A'"''2
1 '''''H"))2B?6' 66'' " 1' C 5=2 1F<' C "9"B9S'I&2+ +62+!8.-072&' 6"&;?'C"'%::))"?:'& 6 6''%( ; ); " ?' C&' ):'( A'"'; 5 F ++, -+-72 ('=(''"%;'")6';"?H" &'$'?>'"?A'"'';'='"6'+ @,00-")A$"A:'''';A:66) ))):'%()2
7 B >(' "?==' (6)E & ?H " " -0 ( ,00. 'A;?$>''):($&)'='=(')$?2+-+ "'?''2
BA'"''"('''&6)';?'" "('6''"'2#'"66;?2 /! " ' =)") 6' :)) " "' " ' 1 1 ) &': + A&' ,00- 9; '' 'C " ;' ' '; " "(' " '2 "'6'' ): =)") C': $ :6 '> " ' (H( ' '>A;$)6'$%&"'&((''" 2 ?''6)6"$?>':6)6'=)") ;):':&')) B2
B?2+-+2+ T')C'"'C>6(6A: '&' 6)E %: (C ?:'' A'"''(6)U2")'" + !+"'6''
*+,-./*,000 1D*++1 ''))(6))6'),'C)(('PT'C "('''='')6""'"('''=" L'6)&'U2
''?'6%(H(6''6;'"''2 %: "?'6)' 6( A: " "):: "? "'6'' P "' 6 ' $ '6)' ') 9''; )):';#)(';"(2A:"&6'6'''(" > ' " '2 " H " -0 ( ,00. '")) ; > " ?2 +-+ 2 , '' 6 " 6 6 "? 'C> " "' "('''=E ' '6)) T 'CU ((':'=' T'CU2?2+-+2, 6)'; 'C "('''= '') T" L ' 6)&'U2 ? "' ; )'( " '> "('''= %& "? A'"''2 ''?'6)'')6($"; (TU"'H;'='):(('("?''")(')2
# " ='() 6 '6)' 9''; )):';2 ) " &> 6)6' 53)(' " " ' V 3 1+ !062//.27;):'+ !0"')>M)" A'"'' '&' 6) >' 6)& $ ?2 +-+ 2 + 'C"('''='")6""6&'>)'=2 'C)'"')$ (6')V '"? ((''"W;' &' $ R " ")'' " ")6(2 ?)' 6"6;';(6(':))'6; 'C?)'&")"(6)"?'C'2)')&'";' (('' 6)' "&' C' (( ' " (6''6''%5(6''6''>6W72B3)('" " '62//!T"#%(&':) '"? ((''6)'')"(''))")'")'" A'"'' "('''& "'' '")6" ; )6'(6)U2
% + A&' ,000 )) (' C))=' "? :)) " (6)2 '' "& A'"'' "('''& 6)' " "' (( 52 /D 72 & ('' " (('' " 6)'))>6)()=='()53 + !62 .-072''')" A'"''?"6A('))(''6 F'6 F 2 &'6""'';''(6H9)):';; ) 6 " " =' (6) ('% "? ' A;$")&$((''"$A'"''"('''& 6)' B?2
*+,-./*,000 1!*++1 B'?"&''&?'6)'" "H"-0(,00. ( B (' ):( (('' " 6)'#(6'9) '1(H(''''2 ?('=(6))C&')6):'2
& " ;' 6)%" )' " B 66'' " =($ '':&'2
?)' " A: # 6 ' )) ) 6 'C =)")"H",!A&',00." ':&'"6) +- =)&' ,00. "'6'' '' 6( B " '): $ ' A: '' " ? " ?)' " &> 2
,2 ' :&' X:'' A"''' 5 E , 0/7 )) ("'=') '') "% + @ ,00- 'C " '2 =()( $ X' - ') - " "'6'' '' '"'&X)&':"'6""& (('' " ('% "X B "X )) (' "X==' 'C"''';5=2' /D72(6)" 'C")'')C'6A:" "X6%2
-2 '=)")6':))""'"'"DC ,0005 PB8-02+7)&':+A&',00-R" (C ("'='' " "(' " '2 "X6% "( =' ):' 6 "'6'' &': A;X -+ ")(C,00,):"6''6;A:"' X6$6"'")'("'=''""'"X)6)' $"")('"")'''':'5 F+,!.D!'"2++,+ 8-D '"2 +C E =2 ):( "'6'' '' 2 8, 2 + " ' =)")X1'&'"')726)'':6);>(') $('%""'6''"'X1'&'"')5'16% 7 "%:(5'16% 7&':A;X-+")(C,00,2
.2 A)"")'=():>&C52D EB 8-+2,07 8. " ' =)") X &'' &'& 5'16% BEB8-+2+07&':-+2+,20,2
/2 " X2 D ' ' ): '' ; 6'""'>6')&"?2 2-':(6 ;?' & "('' )'" 9C' 52 +- 7 B' (' ( ?' (6 " & " ?'&'"') (')'%"''"'>")'"''(6 B'2
*+,-./*,000 18*++1 ?6% ?==' 6#9''; " (( % '&'"6)2B?""&"?'&'"') ;?'&'"='>2
B?2. ?'&'"')"'(''"6')":'6)() 6(":");')"?'$)69#'; (6&"?'='('):)'"?("'"?'"2
B?2,82+ ?)"'$'%?''&'"$DD ,*-N('$"('1?''&'"$/0N('$; " ?' '&'" $ .0 N ('E " 6)'C ?) 6 "?6%?2,82+C' 6)""('1?''&'"$.0N ('2
B ?2 , 2 + "' $ " ?2 ,8 6" '6M$"$6'";?)6)'6') " :' "C " .0 6 (' 52 7 $ 6' " ; ' 6))(#'6')"&'".06('6" )'6'C52C72
?>' "? '6') " :' "C 52 , 2 + 2 7 "' H "(' ; ?' $ ) :( C'') '( ')&'C ;? == &'(C "C( 6') " :' " ?) " ( =='(( :& 6 A'=' ?' "? 52 , 72 ' ':'( C' 6 H '")) (( '&( C'') ( ; % '( )&) " ('% ; ? 6' 6)&' ; 6';( 9:( C ?'&'" " &' 6)&''C 5 F ++ +0, '"2.)=)EB+ 628+'"2+72
?HB+ 6280")A$') 'C=)")"A:) ;?' ?>'' 6 " ('= " &' A'6" "6' ?) &': " + D02 ' ' 66) ; '% ")(' 6 ")'(' 6) " "> &' 6)& $ ?2 , 2 + C'')6"==)(';('"?'$)2 5B+ 628+2'"2,)=)72
?:' " ?66)'' " 6& ' = 66 ; ' ?"(''' A: =" 66)'' '' " 6& =' 6 '&':' >; ' "'& 6)" "?==' &' ; ' =' 6) ":) " &'(C 6)6") ; "? ( 6C' 6' 6 ("'=' 66)'' ' 6= "?"('' "? 6& 566)'' ''6) " 6&E Q' S:&=9 ' " BI'&'9: 62 ,+, Y ./0E QZI*G[ S:&=9 "
*+,-./*,000 1 *++1 S:96=: " " , )"2 62 - Y +++ 62 ++! Y -,0E #:' "&S:96=: , )"2 62 ,!.E =2 ' F +,, .D '"2.+,,,,-'"2-+,0C,, '"2,C++ -..'"2- )=)72 ('% " 6)" &' 6 "' "?H " ?2, 2, 25B,00+Y+062,8'"2.C7A'6" " ?(6' " ?2 . 2 ) A &C 5 F +,. . '"2.C+,,+D,'"2+"?H')72
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
*+,-./*,000 1+0*++1 'C")'&";?''"';;?$&' C " ?(% (( " "' ' '"% ; ?'6') " &'""+ 8+))6&;)6?'""'';?C' 2 '""&"?'&'"')"'H='>)+ 8+2 #')"6'+ !!'"'$"'''%" ?'&'"')2 1'"&&':"%66'" >"''2 ]]]]]]
*+,-./*,000 1++*++1
/ " 4 " /" / /
617 8 9 5% '(* :;
7
+2 )&C2
$ 7
,2 ?"(2
-2 );")''"? "+-@,00,2
.2 ' ; "' $ "'' '% " ?1'&'"') "%66'">"''2
/2 &'? $"")''"'")2
D2 ';6)":'
!2 =( 6' " ;? 6& =( 6) H " ")' " -0 A "% '='' 6 6' ((") ") 'C =)") " B9S'I9=;' D D00. ' >(6'2 ")' 6 H 6:)2 ()(' "'P 7 '"'; >(;")''")'C''6"")'' ;)E C7 >6 6 ; ('= ' '( 6&' "(" ")''E 7 6 ': " 6)2 B' ()(' ' 6 ' ))( )()) 7 C7 7 '1" 'C=)")"66('%;?' "&")'&C2()('"('(# " 6& ;' A' '' ; ")'' ;) ?&66 " ;))>6)"')52+-,+0D+0872 :=='P )'"P ' B CB
6'=("6)H'=')>6''';?$?=='=)") "'6:==
*+,-./*,000