Appeal Regarding Exclusion of Evidence of Settlement Negotiations and Prior Inconsistent Statements
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA plaintiff, appealing an adverse ruling, contended that the trial court erred in its interpretation and application of rules regarding the admissibility of evidence concerning settlement negotiations and prior inconsistent statements, specifically challenging the exclusion of certain testimony proffered to demonstrate bias and impeach a key witness. The appellate court reasoned that while evidence of prior inconsistent statements is generally admissible for impeachment purposes, the trial court's exclusion was justified because the proffered evidence related to settlement discussions which are protected from disclosure by a rule prohibiting the use of offers to compromise as evidence of liability; furthermore, the court determined that the error, if any, in excluding the testimony was harmless given the overwhelming evidence supporting the verdict reached by the jury.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal Regarding Exclusion of Evidence of Settlement Negotiations and Prior Inconsistent Statements: The appellate court reasoned that while evidence of prior inconsistent statements is generally admissible for impeachment purposes, the trial court's exclusion was justified because the proffered evidence related to settlement discussions which are protected from disclosure by a rule prohibiting the use of offers to compromise as evidence of liability; furthermore, the court determined that the error, if any, in excluding the testimony was harmless given the overwhelming evidence supporting the verdict reached by the jury.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the imposition of court costs for the appellant.
Testo completo
%&'%&(() "%))*%&((+
,"
- "#.- "! - !#
/ 0 &((+
12 &
34444444444 !"##$% $&'()')%" $
$
!33# "! 5-6# ##" #*$+,$%'-)'))./)0 ""!
!"# $
1'2)01
3#"
)3 4!5)+&40(6")++( 77777777778"1.9: )+4,/";"#/#<77777777773
'3 /" )+&+ $"= $ 5$= # =$ = / #>"!$=$="3
03 6")+&+>$?>@ #>$! *$/"3
%3 !$"#>$A)+&+6/")++(5" "!"$ """ ;>#"$ "#=$= 3
-3 ' 6" )++( '+ B/" )++' 9 /" ; $5$"$!!" CD77777777773
43 "#),6")++'$ #"#!"6$".#>1 E!=3
,3 ##')6/")++09#$#!##"$. # >1"/"#" /" ? $5" # ! # #"$ $B"$3
&3 $$!#"#)'6")++0# 7777777777?>"$# $!!""$ #$#./#"=$""/"$F
1 $ $!"!$!" " # =$ = $ $! *$/"G
1 $ "!"$ "#"$ "$$="$G
1 $"##"$H"!!!"3
7777777777 #> "" $ # /" #. !$" #>/")+&+6;>!$"#!")++(#>""? #-(I? "#!$"#6")++(3 !#"6$;;5" "#"."5"$#5$$$=$/" # !" # /#3 #. $ $ ;> $""$ $B"$!"#"#".#/""/3
+3 !## $!!""$ ./#)+$A)++0>BB"="$ H!"$"5""##"$#>3
2'&2'((% 102)01
)(3 #$#')$$5)++05"BB""B"# /$$#>##5B$!"$#>=#/$*=3"!; $B"$"$!"5/"?BB"$$ " =#B"#B$!"$.#> J JJ K #) $/!5)++00(6")++- /#>$5"$#>#"E!#>=#/$*=3
))3 "#)$/!5)++09L#"#!"6$".# >1"/"#"3
)'3 #""$ # )) B/" )++% $!!""$ # $ # ./ $$*#!##"$B/#>$"" =#B"#>B$!"$#>=#/$*=#)$/!5)++0 0(6")++-3
)03 $$$#)+6")++%>$BB"##"$$B"$ $= > ? BB = " #> = # /$*= $$ != 5" # $" # #". !"" #!$#6;>0(6")++-3
)%3 " # ) 6/" )++- " # $!!""$ >BB" # #"$ $B"$ # $ # ./ $ B"$ $ $! #>BB"$#>1"/"#"8"1.F :3
)-3 # $ $ # ) B/" )++- #"/""$ # #"$ $B"$#> $$!""#!$3
)43 $ $ # '& 6" )++- #"/""$ $ ; $59"/!#B$!"$"!" #>$5" #"E! #>= # /$*=3 #"/""$ #$ $$ $" #> $"".! # $ ? !"1! / # >$5"$ # #"E!"";#>=";"#>=#/$*=# !3 " = # ! $$ # ) 6" )++- 0(6")++43
),3 $!!""$ # )4 $A )++- > "B$! 9 # $$="$ # ! # ! $B"$ # '% 6" )++- 0(6")++43
)&3 $$#)/")++4#"/""$##"$$B"$ $ ; > /" "$! $ = "; . ;; !$" ! ;> >" !$"/ $" # B$!"$ $";36$;9/"$/=$!# . # & 6/" 0) 6" )++4 ;> $ "" #$!" /" /#B3 #"/""$/;>>/"$!
2'&2'((% 1%2)01
;"B""$ ;" $ # B$!"$ #>#" # " B !" =! ; $B"$ " "$!"5 / $ #""/"#/>$!"$?=$3#"/""$ B" # $"H # > # >$" #$!" / >$5"$ #> #"E! # "1 E B"3 #"/""$ /" 9 ; " $" ! # $"".! # $ >1 "/"#" " # # = ! # $""$ $B"$3
)+3 # $ $ # )+ 6" )++4 #"/""$ # #"$ $B"$$;9""/!#B$!"$ 0( 6" )++4 !" ;> >/" ! ! $5 #"E! $!3/;>>/"$6#B"H! " !M! # / # /" # * #!"""B !" ;> $ "" #$!" /" # #$!" $" # "/" " / B3 #"/""$ "! /$" #$ ? 9 $"5"" #>$5"#"E!#"/"$!"5/$#!" "# # = "; $$ #>$# 4( 6$ #>"#!" 6$".$ #>!$"B/#>#" $#$"3
'(3 $!!""$#&$A)++4> "B$!9;>/" $#"#!"6$".##!H"!#4(6$$"# )6")++4'+$A)++43
')3 " # ) 6" )++, 9 /" ;" #>"#1 $"". ? >@ 3
''3 . ) ! )++& > /" ? ,- I $6$ . # !M! !$*3
'03 # # )( B/" '((( 9 #$ $# #!# # "$ . # >1"/"#" /" ? >$$" #> #>"/"#"?'-I3
'%3 $"#)+!"'(((#?> 7777777777"" !#" " "B" ; 9 " ! $ "/" "$#>BB"$!#"=/*N#B$!"$#6!5 = 3H$;"". #"#$"#/# !$/! $/ #5$ ; # ! # 6$ "$#>O#.!"!$;"=#"""#/"# $B"$3 /#;".#!#"#!#"?> # "#B$!"##!##$""#/"? -(I3
2'&2'((% 1-2)01
'-3 0$A'(((9#$"?B"$!! 77777777773
'43 0(!5'((($"/"P77777777773
',3 #$!#"#)&!"'(()#7777777777?>"$ #> !#"$#>O#.!*! ";"# $"; ;" N" 5" # B$"$ # 6!5 = # """;##$ $";36$;$/$;" B"= $";#"!""$#"#/""!?6$ !" $" '(I3 !#" $ ; >"/" H 6;>? "$H"="5# !".#";>$$/"H"=#> ;>HLQ"/"3
'&3 "#))6"'(()9>$/""#/"?-(I "$#$5.!#!"$#.$/"?043-I3
'+3 . )) $A '(() L # "#!" 6$". # # $ #="R @? #-(I3
0(3 $ "B" !#" # )4 6" '(() # 7777777777 # ? > !#" H$ /$" / " # >"/ "! ; $ *! $#.! # 6!5 >" ==/ " !" #>/"= "/" # -( I3 #$ $ ? ; H #>"/"#9$"!$#"B"#&(?-(IB"B?$$ #)&!"'(()3
0)3 #$#%!5'(()# 7777777777#"$$=5" "? $= "#=$= #9"$!" " >5 #>! B/ #> "#"/ !$ $# " B"#$$"#!";"3
0'3 $ $ # !M! 6$ # 7777777777 7777777777 =!#"$$=5""?J#=$= #"" /$?JBB/6$"$ #>$!"#"="/#>$$="H8$!$$#!: "/ # "5" " /$; #". $="$ # ! $H3 !#" >$ / #>=! B/ #> "#"/!$3
003 , 6/" '((' 9 $ !$* $/" #> / $#/"#>!$*/$*H#>"/"?,(I?"# )B/"'(('3
0%3 # $ # '4 /" '((' # 7777777777 ? >"$ # > !#" $ $/ B$" ; > # # "
2'&2'((% 142)01
>"==/#"!$"#6"'(()F$"5">"BB 3"!;>"#/">"$"5?> 3
0-3 $" # 4 !5 '((' >BB" !# > "$#> =#/"$";"$?>"";>? $!#"77777777773
043 # # ), !5 '((' > $ ? > $ " #A! $! H$ ; " ? H" "/" "/?)((I#""#$B3
0,3 !M! 6$ 7777777777 =! $ " # > #A!$!H";;"$"/"?# -(I$B"$#>"#1"B"!".$/>$!"$""$"3
0&3 $" # '- !5 '((' >BB" "$= 7777777777 " # /" # " B$" # "/"#3
0+3 $"L>BB" ),$$5'(('7777777777 $# ; " $" BB"/! BB /" $""$ " ? $#""$ ; 6!5 $" / B # ;$" >O#.! *! "; #$ $BB" >==/" # BL$ "!$ $/$; #"!""$ # " B$"$ !" "" # 6!53$/B$""!;"#/"#"" #-(I3
%(3 #""$ # '4 B/" '((0 > B #!# # "$ # >$;>"/"#/>H""!$""$ #5$ >" # ? $ # !" ;> "/" # >HL $""$ " " B"! H"="53 > / ? $$ ; >1"/"#" /" " = ! $B"$;>"$#"$$;>>HL" "/"3
%)3 "=#))!'((0 B$!$!$ $!#$$$""$$/"$"?#""$#!# ?/$"$"#>"="##$"3
%'3 "=#'4!'((0>BB" #?> $"#$#$">"/"?"$#>""+/"'((03
%03 "= # )- /" '((0 >BB" "/" ? $/ > ? " $ $ #$" ? " "#"; " !"" $
2'&2'((% 1,2)01
$$""$ " "!" #" )+ !" '((0 B" # $!!$"/"$3
%%3 "=#),/"'((0>$#$"?>BB" /;"/"#$#H".!#!#'(((>" "$ #> ==/"$ # $ # 3 6$ ; $ "/" $B"$ $/" M "! !"3 B" #!# ? ; $ #$" $" ? $/ $!" /" 6"#"; # > "!;"!/"="=3
%-3 "=#&!"'((0>BB" !"#""$ "!"?>#")(6"'((0B"#!$"/$$$""$3
%43 #"$$=),6"'((0#!##>3
%,3 "=#),6"'((0>$!$$$""$3
$ #>5$# / ; >"/"#" #/" M H!" / # >")4#$"B#"=##$"#$" #4$$5'(((8"1. :
>=" # >"/" $B"$ $ >" ', $ >"/" !=.3 >/"$ # >"/"#" $ > #/" B" $ ! $# !"H3 / ; >" "$ ;" /"!$!#"/##$"?;"" #!"$$#?$!"$#/$"#!$"# 6"'(('3"H$>M$!!";"$" $!">BB" ##4!5'(('F!M!"/" $# /$$" /" ? )(( I #" " # $ B #")((I#$"/" 5"#")++&$",(I3/ " ; / $5 # ". !#" 5" 7777777777>"!";"$;#>"">*/" #>3$H";;!M!#"/"/$""$ " $! # $""$ / H"= $ 6!5 = >""#/""#-(I#$#0-I"3# # >"/" !=. >"" # /" #/" M $ " $!#$!5Q "$""$#5$$"H # -( I3 B" / ; ="$ # #$" " " !"##!"$#=#>"/"#"/H"#/3
/ # ! > $ ""! ? >"$ # #""$ ""=" /$" ? >" "B" B" # $! >""$ $!! $ ? !#" H "## $
2'&2'((% 1&2)01
#!""#/"$B"$35"#""! $?>$$"#>#>"/"#"5#>H!""!#%(I3
%&3 $"#''6"'((0#R @#?>BB" $!="#>>$ "$$>$$""$B$! !P77777777773
%+3 #""$$$""$#)(#!5'((0> $B"!#""$ #'4B/"'((03
BB"/;>"/"#>"#$"=>"#?># #>$;>"/"#5>"B"!"; ">!M "9#/"$""$"/6!5 = 3 >BB"/";>!$B"$/"#6? " ; > >/" $ " / # /" # * #!"""B $ $ # "$ # !" !; # !$"/"$3 >BB" ##" ; # "/" # ; $$ $ ; >"B$!"$? =#>1"/"#"">H"" ""#$6>$$""$3
-(3 "= # + 6/" '((% > B$! $ $ #""$ $$""$ . # "5 $ # $" 8"1.F :3
" $"$ B$! # $ $$""$ !$"/ # ),6"'((0H$?"!M!=!;H#/$ #!!3
-)3 =".# $B 2'&2'((%3
-'3 # !!$" $ L )& B/" '((% > $6#$/$*5?=!#/$ # #""$ $$""$ # )( #!5 '((03 BB" $ >""$# $"#;>"!$!$S#""$/" # ;" " #""B3 " " / ; > #!$" $;$" $" /" # 53 B" " $" ;>.!$B"$">*/"#>""#=" ; $#""$ #>""$ # " , & >" #$ "3
-03 "=#%!'((%$!"$"$3
2'&2'((% 1+2)01
!#"
)3 $"=/$">$=""$6#"""8:!$#"B""" #.)$A'((0 "5$#$"$!$# - 6= #$ "# /"1"# - )4 6= 83)3-4 :3
'3 "?>"$#>"$#)46= "5B# ', 6/" '((% 8 P )0( )(4: # $" =/$" #$ )0 B/" '((% #"$""$ "$" = ! "5 $#$"#"=?$"6="" #>#>"$#$/H6=3
03 $B$!! ? 93 -4 3 ) 3 3 ' "5 $ # $" $N " "; # $"$ / ? >" -4 # $" B# " = # #$" # $"#4$$5'(((8"1. :;" $"/?$"B# 91"/"#"8"1. :#)-6")+-+
%3 $" B# " = # #$" # $" # 4 $$5 '((( 8 : /"= ) 6/" '((0 N !$#"B""$#$!5#"$""$=##$!"# $"3 !" $" # /$" ; #$" 9"; #$" M ?!".#""$;.="5$ /"= !$! $S B" 6"#";! #!" $ $#"
8 P)0('0( $"#3)3)G00- $"#3)3'G P)'+%$"#3)3'G P )', %4, $"#3 ) )'4 )04 $"#3 %5 B:3 .= # $# ; ? 9"; / #. 6$ # $ /"=8 P)),+0$"#345))'04($"#3%G J )++&T0, 30)4$"#305:3 >";#$#>.3
-3 6 # B$! #" =H $ /5 ? B$! 834( :3
43 $$#$"/#>?#>"/"#" ! $##>/"$#"/"#"3
,3 $ >3 '& 3 ) > #$" ? ". >" "/"# ? 44'20I!$"?#!"1>""/"#?-(I!$"$? ;#>""/"#?%(I!$"G#"5> #>.>3'&3)5" ##!"1>""/"#? %(I!$"3
>"/"#"##"$""$#"!""$#"#=" ! ! $ # $= # ;" #> " ?
2'&2'((% 1)(2)01
*"; $ ! $/ #> "B"!" $=" #> !#" $ #>"#83%3) :3
$ >/"$ # >"/"#" / # /" ; >"/"# $" $5"HL>"/";>$"$5!##". H"$/#!##"$$!#>""$ ;""5 # ! # /" 8/ #>"/"#: $! / ;>" $" $5" >" >" "/"# 8/ "/"#"G 3'&3' :3 $"B##"#""$$!!" >/"$ # >"/"#" $!! $ ;" >/" #>"/" / #>M "/"# 83 '& 3 0 :3 B$# #"$""$= $"B##"3',',5" 3
$ >3 ', $ / >"/"#" #> >HL #>"/""/#>3-3) $BB$!"$# "/" $ ? 5" # ; ! >" !M #>$!" /H 5" 8! $# "B";G 3 ):3 /H 5"#/"#!=$#>"/"# !=>#"$#B83':3
/ # >3 ',5" 3 ) >"/"#" # ;" >H ; "! "/" "/ $ / $ >3'&3' 3>"$$?/H 5" #>3-3) >"/"#"B"H$>3', $"/"3 "B##!""/#>"/""/ # >$!"! # /H 5" #= #>"/"#"#>. #"#$>BB##H"/" ;"$8! $#!"H#>/"$#>"/"#":3
$ /$" " #$" M $"# $!! $ HL "/" ? " ! $ ? ! " " $/" #>H!" ; B" >#!M!"$>">""#3$ ";;"$##$"M 5#""$ ;>>#/$6;>!$!$S>#!"""$"#""$ $;$#!>/"$;>"H "/" "/ >" /" 5$ " B" ; B$ $5$" $ 5"!#$"#$""=#=#> /"!5$#8 P)'-)-($"#3'G)),)+%$"#3 05B":3
&3 >. $ H"; ; #" !". #!# # "$.#>1"/"#"$#>6$"$ $;$/!#>#>"/"#"3"! ";#$"M$! $#!"H3
2'&2'((% 1))2)01
;"$# $"H#! $##9/"$#9"/"#"8! $#= #/$! $#!"H:#$/#.$;; ; $" !$# # "" $ 9 #$" ? #9"/"#"
+ ""$#! $#=#$!"$#/3
>="###"!""$#"#/"# ="# $"$/"!""#/;#".5B"" # ! # #"$ # >1"/"#" # )++0 ? )++43 $BB$B$!!?$ "$5" =# B"#B$!"$/"?$5"#"E!#>=#/$*=$B"$ ;""$!"5/$"?3=!>$"$ #>BB#=";##=#/$*=3
$>#6!"/"##$!"* $H H! B"H >* $ " / # /$" /$ /"#$!"##$!"$"3
B";$B"$#>"# $"".H>$;> #$$##!##"$ $"!#?$ #"!#/"?)((I>$3 !#" " # $ 7777777777 #>" "! "#/"#"?-(I#$B"$3
$ * 5B"" # ! # #"$ " >=" E # #!""#/"#$B"$#>=#/$*=3
$$ # 7777777777 BB"! # $" L ), $$5 '((' >BB" ; " $" /" $""$"?$#""$;6!5$"/3
"!""$ $ $ ? B" $!"5 / $B"$ #>= # /$*=3
$#$H$B"$?)((I / "" "#="3
+53 ""$ # ! $# !"H $" "/" $B"$ ? ,(I !=.?0(I3
$B$!! ? ;" #" 8$"#3 +: $ #$" M $ 5#/"#9"/"#9=#/$*=?,(I3"!; $ "" # Q !=. # -(I3 !M! 9$ #!" ""?BBQ !=.8?0(I:#=#)-I
2'&2'((% 1)'2)01
8$" -(I H )-I: #9"/"#" ; $ 5$" "BB" $ $/" #$"?#"$#9"/"#"3
+3 > #. $ ? "$ ; > 6 #!# # "$ # $3"$$*?#;"B $#!$"B#>$#$#>H$B"$#?$# ;>#$N1!M! $""3
)(3 /#;".#$6#""$""="$B"! ;>"" "#>H!"! $##>/"$#>"/"#" "5?$3
2'&2'((% 1)02)01
7 !"#3 "#.- "! - !#
8 9 : 5$ ;+& !
9
)3 $/53
9
'3 63
03 ";"/B$!$$M##"#0( 6$ #. $"B""$ " $!!# # "5 B# # U"C $B;"44((% $"H!"3#" M $$=3 !!$" #$"F : "#"; H! ;9 #""$ $ #" $5" " # #""$ ;G 5: H$ $ ;!$"B$"!$/$"#!##""$G:$ "=#$$#$3"!!$"$"$" ! ! $ : 5: : "1# "5 B# # $ !". $ ;9" #/ # "/53!!$"#$!"$$!$*#/;" $ 6$" !!$" >" >=" # ". $"$ # $3 $ =!6$"!!$"#""$;9/$#; H#"$83)0')(4)(&:3
=BB".F =F " @" @
$"$B$!#M$"B"H""";9?9BB"B## $"=BB
2'&2'((%