Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/442/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/442/2006 Generato dall'IA

Statute of Limitations for Breach of Contract for Sale of Goods: Accrual Date for Revocation of Acceptance Claims

Numero d'incarto ATAS/442/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case involves a dispute regarding the application of a statute of limitations to claims arising from a contract for the sale of goods, where the seller alleges the buyers wrongfully revoked acceptance of the goods, and the buyers argue the limitations period began when the goods were delivered due to an alleged breach upon delivery. The court reasoned that under the relevant statute, the limitations period for breach of contract for sale of goods generally begins when the cause of action accrues, which, for a breach that is not an explicit warranty breach, occurs when the breach itself occurs, not when the aggrieved party discovers the breach or subsequently revokes acceptance; therefore, the court analyzed the specific timing of the alleged breaches, including the initial delivery and the subsequent events, to determine if the action was commenced within the statutory timeframe, ultimately concluding that the claims related to the initial delivery were time-barred, while other claims might not be, depending on when those specific breaches occurred.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Statute of Limitations for Breach of Contract for Sale of Goods: Accrual Date for Revocation of Acceptance Claims: The court reasoned that under the relevant statute, the limitations period for breach of contract for sale of goods generally begins when the cause of action accrues, which, for a breach that is not an explicit warranty breach, occurs when the breach itself occurs, not when the aggrieved party discovers the breach or subsequently revokes acceptance; therefore, the court analyzed the specific timing of the alleged breaches, including the initial delivery and the subsequent events, to determine if the action was commenced within the statutory timeframe, ultimately concluding that the claims related to the initial delivery were time-barred, while other claims might not be, depending on when those specific breaches occurred.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
compravendita termine di prescrizione fondamento dell'azione contratto di organizzazione annullamento del contratto operazione di pensione

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the Appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the provision of legal aid for the Respondent.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               #$%&'#%(() #%#%(()

++

, + ,   ,+  

- . /  $$  %(()



  !"!

!"0000000000 

#

$$     %     $  $    !78!  &$      $'   $   & $           ( )*!$#+,-./0#123(1411   .

$$     %     $   $ $$   $  $   5         (!##16(0#(1442  

                 !"

  496  

 1 

1<  =,"# ! 13 87* 4;;3(  1->" ?") ! ) ! 0"> #  07  !* ! !" ( 7   4 =#1:64(#! (744=*1:@@("7!#! 4-=1:..<

4<  ?88 13 ! =,"# 07#7(  ) ! 0"> #  !7  0#,0"#7!*!07*A08B0?! 70C!#",<

-<  =,"# ! !*( !* !78#8  -1 " 4;;3(  7#7 #"  )!71;*4;;30C7#!0#,<

6<  )!7#7!0#"!###!07*A( 0#07###!78!0#!""B "## ! *  ! 0# B !#  ",( # #  4-=1:..#-1"4;;3<

@< $D,#!!"!(7#77#)B&*!07*A"7!#  ", 0> !  $$     %     $  $    D$      $'   $   D $            E  F &7*#(  -1"4;;3(G'<-46&3.1<-@<

3< # G  !"!(  &# *77 B& 0>!  "0# ! 07*A 0> !  $$    %     $   $  $$   $  $  5         E HF(#B&*"7!#",&7*#G'<434&;6.<2@<

2< !"##7#7#"C0#!#!6"4;;3<=!# !B7B&G!78#!&)*#!!7"0#(I##! ##)<

.< &)!&)=#!!78C7(7#7,!7G=,<

 + 

1< &#<4@!87!7)0,!07*A08( *(**##*!#7!12!7")1::-E'F(#7*, 1=*4;;;(>,07!!!*<B=## 0!D!0##!#G0#,E#<144#14- ! *+ F(

    914.:94;;3 -96  

=,!!!*"07##!&#<2-<1!87!7 07*A 08 ! 4@ = 1:.4 EF( # G >*  ) #!!01J#4;;-(!#(0>B&88  7#7#"E#<164 F(C7#!&880#,)! 7! 70##!7#"70=,!!*<

4< $&#<44'E*#*,!01=*4;;;F( ! !*(  0## ! # B !#  ", # 0#,7 8"7"# C#<144(14-(161#164 /#<-G@ '&00B# 0,"##G#87E<1F<?B=#(0##! #G0#,0!G!887#0##!#(,"#7 ! * ! ) 0, C## 7*#"#  ""# ! !*( #  0##!#(,"#7!*!)0,C##7*#"# ""#!!",E8<#<46'F<(=# G  0## ! # # G &* ! ) 0, C##  ""# !   ! ",  #7I# !  ""# ! !* E ' 14.  4-;/ '14:666F<

D0>(=,!0">#!70#,0"#7!* !07*AB!#",0!"!<!#0## #( !D 0#(  ! ",(  4- = 1:..( !D# 0#  -1" 4;;3( !#GB=,"#!!*#!*C7#<

-< $  !"# 0!#(  0## B 0!#  ", 0  #!-46&3.18<-@(#!BB0!"   # ! 434&;6.8<2@(  #7I# A# !7=G 7#7 7 0  ### ! 07*A !78!<   !#GC+70"##!134&-6;8<2;E-46&3.18<-@K4F( #!B&!#"##!1-1&;468<6;E434&;6.8<2@K4F(!#B D#  !"! B !#  !78#* G  C+70  "## ! -1&-138<-;E134&-6;<2;+1-1&;46<6;F<

6< 8"7"# G  =0!( !0  = !7#"# 0  0#, =B&""#!#8#!0##!#!!"(=# !*7)778!##0##!#G!#7I#"0# "##!+< #7I##7#C"""7,&#<14 !&!07*A08*(**##*!#7 ! 1. * 1:.6 E 4F    #C 7,"#(  + # 07 E '0)7-39;4!1.=#4;;-F

@<  7""#   0L(  07! 7## ,## E#< 2- < 4  # .:H<1!07!!"##*!140#")1:.@F<

MMM

    914.:94;;3 696  

+   1  + ,   ,+  



23454   6  744 4  8" $)% 9

1< *#  $$     %     $  $      D$        $ '   $   D $            E  F G #87( ! "0#! (""!-1&-138<-;G $$    %     $   $ $$   $  $   5          E HF  8* ! !"  (  B ! #7I# "0#   ! !7#(!>-1"4;;3=B&""#!#8#<

4< DA!"##B!)<

-< #B07!#,##<

6< 8"  0# !  B& 0*# 8"  #  07# I# !  !7 ! -; = !>  #8# 0 0 ""!7 !7  ) 87!7 ! ( $?NO?8B 3( 3;;6   (  # C"0<  !7  0# I# 0,7<  "7" !# K F !B C#"# B !7  # !7 )#   # 0 !  !7##B7/)FC00B"#8#"0*!"!## #!7/F0#,#!07##<$"7"  ## 0  # 77"# 7"77  ## F )F # F +!(  )87!7!00#"#>B& !*!7*)<"7"!"#"A ! 0*( B # =#(  B  !7 ##B7 # &*00 ! B7#7C07!7#E#<1-4(1;3#1;.F<  ,88>  7!#K         '' P$ P 08"!07#I###87C0#BDGD8887!7 !0,88

    914.:94;;3