Landlord Breach of Express Heating Covenant and Warranty of Habitability
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe plaintiff filed suit alleging that the defendant violated a lease agreement by failing to provide adequate heat, leading to frozen pipes and property damage, and that the defendant breached an implied warranty of habitability. The court determined that the lease agreement contained an express covenant requiring the landlord to maintain heat, and that the defendant's failure to do so constituted a material breach of that covenant, regardless of whether a separate implied warranty of habitability was breached, thus affirming the judgment for the plaintiff.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Landlord Breach of Express Heating Covenant and Warranty of Habitability: The court determined that the lease agreement contained an express covenant requiring the landlord to maintain heat, and that the defendant's failure to do so constituted a material breach of that covenant, regardless of whether a separate implied warranty of habitability was breached, thus affirming the judgment for the plaintiff.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
%&'()%*))* %+,-%*))+
.
/ 0/ 1 $ /1 $10
& 2 *))+
&3 14 5
6666666666 !" !#$ % &'( () # '# (##
$7701 1 $ 8/1 090 0 ##' (###' ( * +, - ./
!"# $
0 12340
70
37 !# 89999999999: # : ' 3 ;/# 3+<= (& . # >>##: # '#' ' ? 5 @: ## ) ' ( &A # ( 1= >'/# 1663 '#' 9999999999 B C ( ) # /#DD ?05 EF' ) # &#(#): )# (# #A - G ##) H C 7
17 A' &#/#' (& *' ( (# - DF# I9999999999 ( J9999999999 ( 3+,5 - 3++67 D. D$#) ( >> ;(&$# &' #>' (. 3+=< KF# - >#L: &D#F ># - #/#'7 #: # /#' ( (#>>' M:
(&D( )#' (&#(' (: # ) #': 'D# ' ## ( & & ( >7 (&D( A' #/#'
#/ - 366N: #: (. 15 /# 3++,: # & / # ( '(# ( /# - ?6N: # ( D. ( '7 /# ( M G O9999999999 H ># 9999999999: ) # >> (#/ #/#' K /##: $: #/#: #( DL - ?6N7
47 13 D 3++=: # (' ' (( ( # . ( &>># ( &0#/#(#' K#0 . L ( - &# (& (#0 7
<7 #'(## ( 3, ;# 1666: 9999999999:
'(# # ( &': ' (#F# #/ B D$# $#) $#> $* #7 8 '(#: ># ( DF /# : # #/#' ( - (#0;' #D: - (## ) # '/# ( $F '# - 36 MF: ## '/# #.7
?7 8 &A # >>' 1= >'/# 1663 ( ( & 9999999999: F: &' ' $ D$#) ('' / '# A #. #$' K># ## D$#)L: $* # '# D##': A'( (' # DF#7 '(# A #)' ) &$ ( >># # ' (# # A # #$# )( # '# #/#7 'F(: )' ) ># # &'# '#' A ' ''(: ): ( # ( /0 -: &' '# (&#/#(#' )& #/#' ( ': ( $F (: &# #) (&#$# ( / ( #.: '# /#FD7 (. ) # /# ( &'#
235+621661
0 42340
#D / D. ( ' ( #: ># ( $>> # #/# /# /$ # #/#' ( '7
57 (' ( 14 /# 1663: 9999999999: '(#0# ( & : #': D ( &A #: ) &' '# - /# - 366N ( #/#' ( ': # #(' ( #/#' '(# $>>0#/: - (## )&# # # - ( (# ## K/ #.L )&# &# - ( ( $F7
,7 ( ( (#/## ( '( # ># ( & (
11 P 1663 ) &' ( /# - #0 )#' ( $>>0#/ G #( 'F H7 # ('# )# / &# - ': # # '#' $Q I9999999999 3++6 &'./: ># '#': - ,3R666 >727 8 & ## F/# ( # ( : # ) # '( &' . &# - ':
) $>>0#/ G #( 'F H: : ) - #: - <5R+5+ >72 K4R534 >7 A 34L7 ' ( # ( F# )# / . &# - ' ) &#/#' A#F#D F( ( F# #>'# - <6N: # ( &( ( 44:=N7 # (. (' # - ## ( > ( # > ( 7
=7 D 1663: ( A (#F#) >>' 9999999999: (#F: # ( $F# ( #F# &':
# '/#( &A# (& (# # (& /# > (& ' ( # * ( &. #>A7 8# - A: # D''>##' (& F# # / (& &. #>A:
)#: '(#: '' '#' / .7
+7 ( 43 D 1661: S '(# #(#)' ) &>># (#) ( >># &#'' &/# ' # &#/#'
># ( (#: ( )& /# ;#># &# (& 7
367 ('## ( 5 ('D 1663: & >#' A (&#/#(#' ( &#'' ( 44:=N : '): ;' (( ( # 7
337 1? ;/# 1661: &' . ( ## ( 80 K#0 . 8L ('## ( & : A (&#/#(#' 7 >## /# : &F# ( / (&#/#(: )&# (/# S ' D ( 31 #: /# #/ ( /# #D ( D$ # ( 34. #7 & # 'F / $* $'#) : )&# (# # '#' $Q I9999999999 3++67 #('# >> )&# * /#
235+621661
0 <2340
# ( D / )&# /# '#' / &' 3++, ( &#/#' ( : #) (### ( A (&#/#' - ?6N # - (7 # - A (&#/#(#' ( ?3:<=N: ' D (& / (&#/#( ( <3R=6, >7 ,? ' (& / $* $'#) ( =5R35< >7 ,6 ': (. - &# (& (#0 (&#/#(#'7
317 ( 4 /# 1661: (#/## ( '( # >#: - ) (# '' / ># #: A #)' ) D A (&#/#(#' ( &' /# '' ' #>#' $#>> ### : &'/ - 4+:=+N: ( ) # (/#
31 #7
347 '/# ( 1+ /# 1661: & ; ( - >## ( ('## )': F /' &' # ( ># '## (#>>' ( 7
3<7 >A ( 35 # 1661 (' - 8: &' (# - & # ( (A '(#A: & ( 9999999999: (#F:
' 5 , >'/# 1661: & ( 99999999997 # '(# A #)' /# >' # $* #> ###' # &$* # '#: # * '' ( # $* #> / /#F D /# K ( , ;/# 1661L7 ( #(#)' ) &' ( ' ( # &'# '#' ( # ('D ( &' : F' F# # /# '(# K ( 35 # 1661L7
3?7 '# '# ( 4 ;# 1661: #' ( #: #># A (&#/#( )&# /# /' ( '# ''(7 ' >> ) / $* $'#) & ( A (&#/#(#' (# '#' - ( $F # )&# /# '' ' - / (&#/#( D7 /# (. (&F / (&#(' ( ( =3R?=< >7 ( ('(# #7 8 D (& / $* $'#) #F' ( +1R6=3 >7: A (&#/#( &'/# ( - ?<:5N7
357 /#' - ('#: 9999999999 /': D ( &/# ( 9999999999: ) &' ( ' ( &' &'# '#'
># 1663 FE - &F# # ): > (&'' #(#) FF/# ': # /# (&( )&# '# ' ## ( # 7
235+621661
0 ?2340
3,7 8 # ( 4 1664 ( 9999999999: &' ( ' ( &' & '#': / '# ' (& (* ' - &>>:
( )&# /# ) & #(. (# ( &#''7
3=7 /#' - ('# #D ( ' #' ( /# ( ## ) $#A ( &#/#' '#' '(#: 9999999999 : # ( , /# 166<: ) &#/#' ( $>>0#/ G #( 'F H /# S /#F' - =6N F( ( >># (#)7
$0
37 L # F/# &F## ;(### KL '' (#>#' ##':
(. 3 P 1664: #D ( # K7 3 7 L7
S ( 46 166<: (: #D (###> K#0 . L ' (&>># #' ( &7 3 7 : #(' ) 8 /# '' '' /## ( &7 343 ( ## F/# 0 07
DL T ( ) # # # #D ( ': A #> #/ B
0 >#F ( (# ##> ( &S7 : (# ##> (& ;F )'# &#' ( $ ;F': #>7 &#' ( $ ;F' &'( - A0# ) ( U (# ##> * /# A ' U # - )# ##F# K T +5 1+? V W : '# ( (# (###>: <. '(##: 3++3: 7 1<= V %D$#(: (# ;(### #/' #: 3+=3
7 434 7L7
0 R#' ( $ ;F' / )# )&# # ) * ) #D /# A# K>7 W : 7 #7 7 1?3L7 : # " & . (A ) (/#: S /#: - &# (& #;' /## ( (# ##) S' (
235+621661
0 52340
# (& >#A ( ( &'# ( ;F 8:
@ ###' ( # ## ;#(##7
0 # ### # S ('' 7 8: & # ## ( 0# D K>7 0TX# D:
($ ( 8$Y#Q: /7 : 3++3: 7 3,=: <46L7 /# ( / )& #D (# .F F'' (&F# / : ##. ) ') ( &# D/# 'F# ;#(#) K T 331 434L7 #> ##: (. ) #(' #) ( &S ( /# - # &A# (& ;#(## )# ># ( # 3 P 1664 (';-: ( ;F ##: ## ) ;F ':
'' 'F#. '7
L 8 A# (&>># ' V / &S ( ( 46 166< # ;)&- A#: # 'F - /'#># >#' - &7 343 ( # &##7
8 ;#(## (###/ '#: )& # ( (# ## ( #7 * # ( ) &7 ?, ( # >'(' # F'' ( (# ( # 0 0:
' /#F 3 ;/# 1664: $) ## #D ( : )# # #) ( (# ( #7 (# ## 'F >'(' D#F - F #A ( # S #:
#A ;) - ' # - ./ (#/ ## ( 7 & ## ' ( - &A#F ' # >'(' ) 'F# F/# '' 87
8 &7 343 7 3 : G # 'D# ( #DA ;F #/# ' V .F D: &F##: ;#(## ' H7 ( '# ( 3+,3: (# ## ## '' '' #' 1: #D' # B G #D (###> ##' ( (# (###> ( U # '/# H7
## &# . S ## ) # (##7 .F (&# '# ;F ( ('FF (& (# ## B (# # - # '# #': $##):
''F#) *'#) ( 7 ;F (/ # ### ( A # ( #7 : ( S ( 46 166<: #('' ) A ( &7 343 7 1 ## ( (& #DA
235+621661
0 ,2340
( (# (###> V # # '' G #D H #F#># G #D H7 : &7 343 7 1 '# ) #D (###> ##' G ( U # '/# H7 & (# ) '# ( #A (###> ./ (& ;#(##7 ## &# '# #' - ( ) G H (# S )#>#':F#: (&# #('#'7
* ( >#' # '# $##) ''F#)7 ' ( /A ' # K!'# ( ( # Z ! 0 3+,6: 7 ??< 7L ) 'F# 3+,6 (# ': A @' ( ;#(## #/# ' A# '/ - &7 343 7 3 : #D (###> #(' ( ( /# A'#>7 #D '# (#' - #' Z # (& : ## ( : [ )# /# - " ( ('## ( (' 7 &'# ( )# ) # F'': # ) #D &'# / (' ( ' (&#D#7 '# '/#( ) # ## '# (/# D#: # ( ## ##. K ## ##: A [L7 8 !'# ( ( #: 7 ??,: G ( *. /#F': : # (& ## '##' ( ## '' ('#(': # ( ;#(## (###/ (## #(' (: ) ' # ' H7
. 3 ;/# 1666: '' # D''># (& F'' ( '7 ## (/ ;#(## (###/ '# ( (# K7 ?5 L7 /: ## ( ## ( '# '' A ' '>>#' K! 3++,: 7 +<46L7 ###' ( ;#(## & ( ;# '' # : # T # T 7 /# ( (## )# # S$' 'F#: )) ' (: ( ># ' #. (& #: ;) - ('/ - ## ( : - ;#(## (###/ '#: 8 &7
8# & (/# #/ &# '# ( ( S ( 46 166<: 8: # 'F ## ( '#: * # $' #0S # ###7 & #> '' D /#' 'F#7
/ ( )# '.(: '# ( 8 ## ( > - ## F/#7
235+621661
0 =2340
&'# ( ;F * # '' ' #D >'(': ( S ( 1, ;/# 166<: ( # F/# ( ':
34 >'/# 166<: (# ## ## 8 ( #'F - # ;F ##: : ( & ( &'# ( /A 7
17 >' - &# 4 #' 4 ( (# ## ##: #(# / &' /#F ( # ( (/ ## ( '' # (&>># #D ( #: # #) # #. (R 8 K>7 # ?5 L7 8 ' ;F ( (& . ## 'D#7
47 # >'(' # F'' ( (# ( # ( 5 D 1666 K#0 . L ' /#F 3 ;/# 1664: " ( D (#>## ( (# ( &0#/#(#'7 (& . ( ># 'F# (# ## /#F ;)& 43 ('D 1661: 'F( ## ) ;F ( # & - ( #('# (#>## ( (# ( &' ( ># '# - ( ('# ( ('## ##F# K T 31, <5,:
#(7 3: 313 4=5: #(7 3D V >7 'F (# ## ##: 7 =1 7 3 L7 ' ##F ') A#' - #. ( (# ## ( # >'(' &0#/#(#' ( 3+ ;# 3+?+ K#0 . L ( .F /#F ;)& 43 ('D 16617
<7 ' ' ( > ('# # ' #: ' /D:
/ ( # 5+ : =< # ( # >'(' &0 /## /#/ ( 16 ('D 3+<5 K#0 . 8L7
?7 8 &7 < 7 3 : &#/#(#' (### ( #' ( F#:
'' ( F (': )# ' (& # - '
$*#) / (& #>##' F'#: (& (# (& #(7
(# - ('#' &7 1= 7 3 )# (# ) &' (# - &# #/#( - <6N #7
&0#/#(#': # #D ( >#A ># '(#A ('# ;#(#) A ((' &>># ( &0#/#(#' A '(# #: A A # ( '## A'# A A #)' (&D/# '' - >> K7 5+ 7 1 ,1D# V 8 3++, 7 43=L7
235+621661
0 +2340
( ( &'/# ( &#/#(#': E$ ( '(# # - ;F &' ( ' - #(#) ( ) ) #/#' &' # D ( /#7 : (' '(# # '' # ('# ) /A : #D: A#F ( &' K T 31? 153 #(7 < V 33? 34< #(7 1 V 33< 43< #(7 4 V 36? 3?L7 (# >'(' >#A # # #. (& '# * ( /: ## ( #D '## ( / & #) #. ( '( (###/7
8 ## : F# (& ;F '# #D /: )# #F#>#: &F# ( '( ( : ) ;F ( # (# A# D;#/ * ( /: ) )& # /: # ('#( # #. - (# ## ( ;F (# ##F#A7 8&# / ' ( '(#A (##: # #)#( &>># '# &D ( '# D# #(#) # ) # >( $. '(# K T ( 43 ;# 3++, V 8 3++, 7 43+L7
R . ;# ( : R(### : ( ( '( (###/: ( ># A # - '(# #(' (: # '/. '#7 ) ( A # 'D# ( '## : D (RD/# >(# (R#/#F# .: ## )R # # ( (#: ) A D# - ( ' /#: ;F # ' # F )R #(# ( ( ( D#0>(' K T 31? 4?4 #(7 4D2DD V 311 353 #(7 3 '>'L7
)# / D (& '(#: # ('# ) # ##F#A # # ># &D; (& '( >#': ) >( ( A : )&# 'F #('# # A #': )&# # '' 'D# # # ( (# K.L: ) (# # ( A '(# # # ) # ( '(# # D# #/' K T 311 356 '>'L7
>#: )R# '# ( 'D# '(# #: ;F (# # ( ># ): RA '#: '(# # F'' #: ( (: - ( # # # ( # ( ># )# R# - (#7 ##: ;# ( ( ( #( A # ># '## )R- R '## (
235+621661
0 362340
R# #' ( /# '(# ( ># K T 31? 4?4 #(7 4D2 '>' V 3++? 7 << V 3+== 7 ?6< #(7 1L7
57 & .: (# # # /# '(#A: () # ) >> ( D. # (#)7 >#: ( U # #> #F#>##/ #' ( /# K>7 ( 9999999999 ( 43 D 1661 # ( 9999999999 ( , /# 166<L: # /# (&' ( ( #('# )# #/7
,7 & ' ) A ># ( DF # ( >># #7 & ' )&# /# ( # - # 7 &F# ( ( ('# ) #/#' # A - ) A: ## ) # ) # # '(7
=7 ( &## ( (#: & ) &' '# - /# - 366N ) $>>0#/ G #( 'F H7 & >(' ># &A # ( 9999999999: ) #: ( ( 1= >'/# 1663: ) ## D$#) ) #.:
># / : ## ) ( ( $F: - '/#7 # (. &#/#' ( )& #(. # #D / &$ ( : (# (/ /# ( /# ( / K A ##L ( >' K( ( L7 ) ># ( $>> # #/# # #/#'
( ' A D. ( ' ( #: )& &# #) ( ( $F ): ( # ( /: &# #) #/#(#'
##7 8 /# D# #/': * ( (# /#7 / D ( '(# # (. S #'7 ': #D ( ' & # ( & ': ( )&# * # (&( ) &#/#' ( $>>0#/ G #( 'F H # ( ' - &' ( ' ( 7 /#: : (&' # ( 9999999999: )# #: ( ( 3, ;# 1666: &#/#' ( - ?6N7 >>: ># ) (# #/#' ( & " #D A#F#D #> '/)' 9999999999: # * #: 'F( - ;# ( '#':
(&( ( #( A # ># (#.: '## #.: )R- R '## ( R# #' ( /# '(# #7
/# ') (&D/ ) & - D (# ) & #('' ) /# #' ( /# ( 366N ( ># ( $>>0#/ G #( 'F H: ) # (
235+621661
0 332340
( #/#' )&# >> >>#/ M ( >#: - A ( ?6N7
+7 8 &7 1= 7 1 : &'/# ( &#/#(#': / ( /# ) &#/#( D# AX &#/#' )& #D ( ( #: . A'# '/ ( ( '( # (& ## ')##D' ( $' ( /#: ' / )&# # D# &# &'# #/#(7
/ #/#(#' ('# ## D ( (# # ) &' D / &# - ': ( &'/# ( # #/ ;)& ( # ( (# - 7 $#>> / (&#/#(: # * # ( '>': ;# (: - )& DA ( # ( ##)7 #D##' ## ) &' & #: . / ( &# - ': #/#' #/ / S #D ( ( # K T
315 ,5 #(7 4D2 DDL7 ('# / ( ##) ( # D ((#' K T 31< 414 #(7 4D2DD V 8 3+++: 7 3=1L7 D '$' '(# ># ( S$ - ( &#/#(: A # ### #' $(# : - &EF: - ##': - 'F# ( # ( '; A (& #7 &* ># # (& ' ( ('(# (## $ ( > #('#: # # /# @ ( '( - '/# FD ( >> ( > / (&#/#(: ( &D ( # ( 7 ;# ( &( ( ('(# FD '# - 1?N K T 315 ,= #(7 ?L7
&F# ( ( F# )# / . &# - '7
'# ) ;# ( ' ( #D >'(': A# ( (# - : ## ) (#>## '/ / ;)& ( ('## )# ( ') (# - # )# ('# ' # ( / K T 31= 3,< #(7 < V ## ('/ ' ( (# ( : #D - # ( / &7 1= 7 1 'F B 8 1664 \ 33 7 44 #(7 47373 V S T7 ( 4 >'/# 1664: 5,6263: (#' - D## # >>##L7
&: (P #/#' - DF# I9999999999 (&$ - ># P 3++67 & ># #'(# ( #0S '#' ( ># ( 7 &
235+621661
0 312340
)& 3++, ) D. ( ' ( ' # A (&#/#'7 >>: 15 /# 3++,: # & / # ( '(# #/#': ;)& A' - 366N: - ?6N7 ( ('# ( (& ' K7 1+ L: # * (. # ( ( #('# &' 3++= ' ( '>' # ( /: ( - &' (&/ ( (# - 7
8 #. >#F (#: X )&#(' (: 3++? 3++5: #/ =5R1,5 >7 ,5R=+1 >7: # * ( =3R?=< >7: )# (: . '## - &#( ( &#(# # ( #A - # K( 3++5 - 3++=L - =1R?46 >7 3++=7
# (&#/#( &'./ ) - # - <&?4? >7: # - ?<R<16 >7 K>7 )S # ( # 3++=: 88 3++=: D#) G 5605< HL7 # ((#' # (& $# ( /# ( <6 $: # (& (' $D((# #>'# - * ( # 3++= K<3:+ $L: (# S ' - ?,&66? >7 ;#># # ( '( - '(# ( ( 1?N: &( ( & 7 # (&#/#( ('# #/#' - 366N &'./ ## - <1&,?< >7
(#>>' / $* $'#) / #/#(#' # . #/#(#' (# - A (&# #' ( F# ( <=:1N: )# / (# - ) ( 7
T ## ( ) (&#/#(#' ) '(' & # ) ('## # (# S ' ( ( #(' )# '.(7
'): (# S # (#7
235+621661
0 342340
1 $ 07 0/ 1 $ /1 $10
1: ; < 8= &'* $
:
37 ' /D7
:
17 ( # ( #('7
47 # ) !# 89999999999 (# - ) ( : (. 1, /# 3++=7
<7 ( &##' - / ( =66 >7: - # ( ## # - ># (' 7
?7 > # ( )R / > ' S ( ('# ( 46 ; (. #>## # (' (' #D >'(' ( : 8$Y#Q$>)# 5: 566< : # A #7 ('# S F'7 '# (# B L #(#) A ) ('## ('# D# # ( ('## )'V DL A ) #> # # /# (( ('##V L #F ( '7 8# '# # # '' ''' L DL L #0(: #D >'(' ( #. )R# (/ (' #/D7 '# ( # * ( /: )# ;#: ## ) ('## )' R/ ( ) '' A '(#' K7 341: 365 36= L7
F>>#. B '#( B
!#0# O # ]
'#0;# B #
# > ( ' S #>#' A # ## )R- R>># >'(' ( # F>>
235+621661