Marital Property Division Affirmation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought review of a decision related to the division of marital property, specifically challenging the characterization and distribution of certain assets accumulated during the marriage, including funds from the liquidation of a business interest. The court affirmed the lower court's findings, reasoning that the evidence supported the determination that the funds in question were indeed marital property subject to equitable division, despite claims they were acquired through separate, pre-marital efforts or gifts, and further concluding that the resulting property division was not clearly erroneous or an abuse of discretion under the relevant statutory framework for equitable distribution.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Marital Property Division Affirmation: The court affirmed the lower court's findings, reasoning that the evidence supported the determination that the funds in question were indeed marital property subject to equitable division, despite claims they were acquired through separate, pre-marital efforts or gifts, and further concluding that the resulting property division was not clearly erroneous or an abuse of discretion under the relevant statutory framework for equitable distribution.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of court costs (no specific reference to the opposing party being ordered to pay costs is present, but Art. 66 is cited for costs in general).
Applied for the allocation of attorney fees to the appellant.
Testo completo
"#$%$"&''& (")&*"&'')
(
+ ( +, ,(-, +, -
&. /0 / & &'')
1111111111 !"#$%&' # ()$$ (#*$$
#
-22 ,(-, 3+,4 ,5 (( $ $* +#,- # ./0123
!
7/4567
, 2 (
58 9#$ :::::::::: ;$72 # < 5,., ( $#$ %# #3$ $$ ( ! $ = ( 5,>- 1 5,,08 $$ # ( $# ( $# 1 ?$ 5,,0 # ! 3$ ($8
/8 # (# (*( ( $# ( !7$3$($ / (*&5,,- ( 1!# #$(! (!$3$($ $#(($# (!$#*$((#1! #* ##8# (# *($' ?$% (#$ ) # $& ( 3$ ($ 5@ #A 5,,-1566B8
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
45-0-4/66/ 7.4567 ( )(#$ (3%#& #* ((###%$) C* ##%$) +C$ $)$ ( 3$$( (!#(( D6B ( $3$ ( ;($*$ $# ( *#3* ( # 717?' ( #$ $# *$ ? (! #$ $# $ $# ( #&(!)$$&<8 ( ' $ (? (*3$ ## $ )$ # ( ( !$$ ( 3$ !& ( ?#* $# #?$#!I%# # 3 $$)!$* (#8 ##' 23 )# *& * (# +%?*$$3$% $#(!3##8' ($ !#$% )) ( !$ $# ( ) 1 $ ( 3$ ! $* * 1 D6B8 3 ) $ ( 3$ #$ !'(($# # 3$%*$3(#&$$ 8
D8 ($$# ( /@ #A /66/ ! *$ # &?$ (! $2#$#((5#A 5,,@.6 *&/6658 ($$# ?#1J#8
08 ($$#(5@ *&/66/! *$# &?$(! (*$7 (25# #&/665&(! '(!$3$($ (>6B8
>8 # # ( 55 # #& /66/ # # 1 !# #$ (! $28 ?2 1 !' $ ( 9 # ) $ *# $3 #$#?$)$! (3$(($?? ' # 8
-8 #3$(>J3$/66.! # J (#8 23 )K9 9 #?$*#$#%#&( 9 (# ) !??$(('($$#8($$#(/@#A /66/# #+ $2 # $#( .6 *& /665 ($$# (# #8 !' $( 9 #*2 #?$*K9 9 $!+ $# ( ! ( #$# %#& )$ #* !%$ (!' $* $7($$$$8
@8 *$ $&(5#A /66.8
,8 ($ ( #* $# # ( $ ! ( ( .?3$ /66D8 ! #?$* ) *$2 ($$# * (?$$ $3 $ & $?$ *($' (#$ ) $ 1 !' $( 9 ($$#(3$$#((#$ 1 3$ ( $#(#$#%#&( 9 8# ) 1$# )!#$?$'#$#%#&(*#M! 3 ( ($?? $$ ! $ *# $38 # $ # $ $(( 3$8
!$(!($$ ($() $($ 1$ $# #** $2( 9 8
45-0-4/66/ 7D4567
568 #$ ( 9 5/?3$/66D$(*( (*# $3 $##)#$#%#&( 9 ! (#$# (+C$ (##%8
558 #$ ( 5, * /66D 9 #( ( ?N# $3 O $ )!$ (3$ ! C 1 ($$# %#& * #2% ( ' P )!' # #$ $*$ ( ($?? $$ 8 $($))! $* $#(!$ ( 3$ '$)$ ($??$$ # #)!$ # ( 3$ $# ( !#( ( 56B8 ) +C$ #(##)! $ +C$ # 8 # ) # #??$ (! ($? *#+ # 32 )!$ $$ $ (!$(( *$ $(!$ $##$ &$)*#(1)#$!J# (* #*($'#$(# ? %%3 $ 3$ $* $ ( #( !3$ +C$ $) #$( )!$ $ $#+C$)CQ!' $8
5/8 #$(/,*/66D# $($)$ (#$#8 #($$ $?$ (+C$ +C# C (5.*/66/ # ) & $$) $ %3 $ ($ (! $ * $( # * $#* $&3 $3$ #?$#) )!#$ 8 $?$ $ #?$*($%((/@J3$/66D8
5.8 $&(#(#!($ $#( C??( &$* C#$ $ ( $(#(5,*/66D8 ($ $#$ ( ( D *$ /66D8 #$# #?$* ) *% )!$($)$ !' $ ( *#$ ( #3*& /665 $ $ 1 ! ( # +C$) *% %* *3$ ## $8 $ $((!#((D6B$%$?$)7$ #*#$#C(D6B8 $ ?& ( #3#$ $$ ?#C ) D6 1 06B # .6 1 D6B*$! #$&8 #* (#'$% ( (#* # ((# $($))!3# $#(! ( $ #&&* (?3#& )!$$$$ #&&) $ ( 3$#$ *$/66/)! 5,,@ /6658
!$(!($ %(1J%8
, - (
5< #$%3#$!#%$ $#J($$$;< *#($?$ $ $ (2 5#A /66. $& #(#$; 85 8<8
F (.6*/66D( $&(*$$ $?;$72 < # (!#??$$ (! 85 8#$( ) K3$ 3$# $#(! 85.5( # $ $#%3#$7 78
45-0-4/66/ 704567 &<R# (# ) #$#$ $ $&(' *# $?$3 O
7 ?$%(($#$ $?(!F 8($#$ $?(!J%* )$! #$ (C#J% #*# $?8! #$ (C# J% ! ( 1 '7$ ) ( * #M ($#$ $? + 3#$ '* #M$# 1) $#$ $%$; R,>/,0ST $ ( (#$ (*$$ $? D2* ($ $# 5,,5 8 /D@ S "&C$( (#$ J($$$$3$5,@58.5. 8<8
7U #$ ( C# J% 3 )#$ )!$ #$ ) # *#+ ) $& #3$ '*$ ;?8 T #8 $ 8 8 /05<8 $ V !2 (# ') (3$ *F*#3$ 1!#$#(!#$ J # 3$# $#((#$ #$ $) # F ( #$(! ?$' ( ( ! $# ( J% K # P # $ $#$ ( #$ $ $ J$($ $#8
7 #$ $# $ $# $ F ( 8 K ! $ $ $# ( 7$ & ;?8 7RN#$ & ( C (KCW$Q3#85,,585-@# D.6<8#3$ (3)! $&(#$ 2%%(!%$3 $$2* #) #) ( ! $# $ # %$* J$($) ; R 55/.5.<8 *$? * $$(2#)#$( #$)( !F ( 3$ 1$!'$ (!J$($ $#)$?# $#($5 #A /66. (J1 (# J% $ $ $$ ) J% # %$2* 8
< K'*$(!#??$#* S3!F ( (.6*/66D$ J)!1#'$ $%* 13$?$#?#*$ 1! 85.5 ( #$!$ $ 8
K J$($ $# (*$$ $3 $ )! $ ( (#*$ $$(#$8+$()#! 8 0- ( #$ ?( $ % ( (#$ ( #$ 7 7 3$% 5 J3$ /66. C) # $ $ $& ( )$ $ $) # ( (#*$ ( #$8 ($#$ $#%?(#&$% #1%# # # $'(#$#*F* #$ # $'J)1 $123 ($3#$$# #(# 8 ! $$##(1!'$%##$?()%$ %3#$ K8
K#! 85.585 G#$ &$ ( $&'* #J% # $3$ S 2% #*& !#%$ $# J$($ $# #* H8 # ( $# ( 5,-5 ($#$ $#
45-0-4/66/ 7>4567 # $ $# #* $/$&#$ OG $& (*$$ $? $ $ # #((#$ (*$$ $?( #M#$3#$ H8
# $ $#!$ 2 #*F*$$)#$#($$8 2%(!$ $#* J%((%%(!($#$ $## #O ($ #$ 1 $ $# $ C$ #$) ##%$)#+ * $)(#*8 J%(3 $$#$ $* ( ' $(#$8 (#F (.6*/66D#$() ' (! 85.58/ $$ (#(! $&' # ( (#$ (*$$ $?S $ $ G $&H # $%$?$ G $&H8 ! 8 5.5 8 / $ ) $& (*$$ $? $ $ G( #M #$ 3#$ H8 ! ($ ) $* ( # $' (*$$ $? 23 (! J$($ $#8 $$ !$ $# $ * 1 ( # ) * GH (#$ F )$?$% $* (! $$( *$8
+ ( #?$* $ $# C$ #$) ##%$)8 ( 3' #$ ;9*#$ ( ( #$ E 9 75,-6800D8<)%$ 5,-6 ($ 'P ( J$($ $# $3$ '$ 3 1 ! 8 5.5 8 5 $& (*$$ $? $(( ( #3#$ ' $?8 $& $ ( $ 1 * #$ E #$(! #$$#(# L)$ 3$ 1 #V ( # # ($$# ( ( * 8 ! $ ( ) $# ) ** #$ % $# # ) $&! $ 3(# (#* (! $& $#8 $ 3$( ) $ #$$#$(3$ &$ # $#(#*#$ $# $$2 ;#*#$ $# $ $ ' L<8 K# 9*#$ ( ( #$ 8 00- G( + 2* 3$% #$ (! #$$#$$(# *$ $ ($(# $ # ( J$($ $# (*$$ $3 ($ $ $(( ) $# #* H8
2 5 J3$ /666 *$ &?$ (! % ( #* 8 $$ (3 J$($ $# (*$$ $3 $ ( (#$ # ; 8 0> <8 #3 *$ $ ( #$$# ( # $ '* ??$*;9 5,,-8,D.6<8# $ $#$ ( J$($ $#!(J*$ *$$ R$ R 8 3#$ ( #($ $# )$ $ *FC %$ )) ((#?$#* * $2(!#$J) 1(3#1#$$#(#1J$($ $#(*$$ $3$ K!#8
45-0-4/66/ 7-4567 K$ !# (3$ $3 !$ $# ( ( # F ( .6 * /66D # * K *$ %* # #$$# ( # $ + #*$ C $7*F* $ $# $ $#8 !*$? * & 3$%$ 8
3 ( )$ 2( $# ( K $ $# ( #?#*1 # $ $#%3#$8
! $# ( J% + $ $& ?((#F (/-J3$/66D( #$%3#$(# 5. ?3$ /66D ($#$ $# $ #$ * K ( $% 1 #$ J% $ $ ( ! ( ! $# ( #3' 8
/8 #?#** 1 ! $ . $ . ( ($#$ $# $ #$ $ #($ 3 ! 3$% ( #$ ( (3 #$$# # ( # # *$ (!#??$ $& # ( #$ $ $) # # $# * $2(U7$3$($ ;?8 $0><8K#* #J% ((!2 $$ &$8
.8 J (($ ?#*%'# 3&; 80>X>6( <8
D8 #$?( $%((#$ (#$(># #& /666 ; O K @.685< 3$% 5 J3$ /66. V ( #*&*#($?$ $#((#*$(#$8(U2 (* # ?#$%$($#$ $#3$%J)U.5(*&/66/ %($$#)J%(#$U1( #$( $# *#($?$ $# ( (#$ # ( U # $ 1 ( ( *$ ( ($$# $ $%$ ; R 5/- D>- #$(8 5 5/5 @.> #$(85&S?8%* ($#$ $# $ #$ 8@/85(#$?( U7$3$($ <8 $ $% #) '*$ 1 *$2 ( ($#$ $# ( #$ U7$3$($ ;$72 < ( # 2%* ;$72 <3$%J)U.5(*&/66/8
08 ' * ( ! 8 D !$3$($ ($*$ $# ( $ ( %$ * * # ( #% ( )$ (! $ 1 C+$)#* #3 (!$?$*$ #%$ (!*($#(! $( 8 K# ! 8 /@ 8 5 ! (#$ 1 $2 !$ $3$(1>>/4.B*#$1(*$7 !$ $3$(106B*#$ # 1 ) ( !$ $3$( 1 D6 B *#$S ( $& ! (!2 ! 8 /@ 8 5&$ ( (*$7 !$ $3$(1D6B*#$8
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
(! *C%* $*# (#$ F 3#$ (! ( (!#$ (#)($7$$ (%$8 #) $ $#($?? (! ( $C%* 3$$#8
>8 &$) $#!28 ?? ($$#(/@#A /66/ ?#8 #$$ # (#$ 1 $2 &(!$3$($ (566B8! (#3#$(#$ 1&$) $#($ $#(3$$#* $#C # *$8 ! 8 !' $( 9 ?$'7 7(%(!$$ ( 3$( # (?N#%#&1>6B8 ?$ 9 $($?? ( $( $) 3#$ *F* J# $) !' $ $ (J1 #3*&/665(!*3$## $ ) $)! ( (# $ P (%( )!!*$# (# )!$$ $$ #&& ) $ ( 3$ #$ *$ /66/ )! 5,,@ /6658$ # %$#!# #$(! $2 #$ >> /4.B # % 9 #$ >6B $ + >/4.B8 ( 7*F* ($ )!$ ($??$$ (! $* $ ( 3$156B2 )!?#C &$)!$*#$&$ J 8 ?$
45-0-4/66/ 7,4567 $ ? ) ##) ! %(* ( 3$ ( (' ( *($# #$ +C$ ##%#)!$$ ( 3$ (3$ F ?$' 1 *#$ -6B8 $# ( # #3$ *% '$ $# #** $ ?#$ 7(3 $&8
#(($()$2()!! ( ( # # $# ( $7$ $ ( %$ # *$# 5,,@7/665 /66/?# $#$ $#( $1#A /66/ ! #*/66/8
#) 3$$# ?? ! 1 # 8 #$( $# (#$ %* F '1?# $#$ !+ (($$# (# #8
#$##(*$($$#(! (5@ *&/66/ ! $3$ 1 ( ($$# ( $2 # $#( # $.6 *&/6658
-8 # )$#& $ %$((#$ 1((; R5560-S 8@0 8/ 8? K# $#3! 8>, S R(/@*/66/D@-465< )$ # ?$' !2 1 /U666 ?8 3 $$ !$ $# )$ $8
YYY
45-0-4/66/ 7564567
-( 2 ( +, ,(-, +, -
6/7 8 9 3! #:& -;
7
58 #3&8
7
/8 !(* 8
.8 #) ($$# ( ! ( 5@ *& /66/ $3$ ! 1 ( ($$# ( $2 # $#( # $ .6 *&/6658
D8 #(*! 1+# $(*$ (/!666?8
08 ?#* $ ( )! 3 ?#* # # F ( ($ ( .6 J# (2 # $?$ $# $ #( ( $& ?( ( KCW$QC#?)$ > >66D #$ '*$8 ($ F ##%8 **#$ (#$ O < $($) ' * )($$## ($#& $$ (($$# )S &< '# # ) *# $? $ $* #3#$ (*( ($$#S < # $% # ( # 8 K$ **#$ # $ #$ * * # < &< < $7( $&?((# * $2#)!$ (3($3&8**#$(#* $##*#+ ( 3 )$ # J#$ $$ ) ($$# ) !3# ( ) '($# ; 85./56> 56@<8 %??$O $( O $$ &&#$
#$#?#*( F # $?$' $$$)!1!??$?( (#$%??
45-0-4/66/