Statutory Interpretation of Prohibited Communications
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered multiple appeals concerning an earlier judgment that involved interpretation and application of various statutory provisions, including those related to limitations on the use of specific language in communications. The court's reasoning focused on applying established principles of statutory construction to determine the correct scope and meaning of the regulations in question, ultimately affirming or reversing various aspects of the lower court's rulings based on whether the original interpretation correctly captured the legislative intent regarding prohibited communications and associated procedural requirements.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Prohibited Communications: The court's reasoning focused on applying established principles of statutory construction to determine the correct scope and meaning of the regulations in question, ultimately affirming or reversing various aspects of the lower court's rulings based on whether the original interpretation correctly captured the legislative intent regarding prohibited communications and associated procedural requirements.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.
Testo completo
'()*('(++, '-(('(++-
$$!
$. /. ! $/! /.!
01 /2 ) 3 (++-
444444444444
$ /! .! !"#$ " !!%&
!"#$! %&
+(',+
! 5
#- .! //////////// &! & 0 0 01 !2 34 01 5 55 567!8%0!!0-
# ! ($$( && 2&& !0! !0 3 19!"!0!.!!%-
(- !010(:%($$(2!%;.-////////////2 !0! !0 1!2% 8 !8 !0 3 < 30 %= 1 ! 01 ! 01 0 3 0 1%3= 0 1&-
*- (> %9($$(.-////////////&!;31!2%81& 3!8!0340 !" !0?@%" 03!# !($$(!0&0!!03!%00&%9($$(%02- ))-+30;3!%0!8!03=&;01 !;0&%9 ($$(!)A2-##-+-
B- C0&%9($$(&30;.-////////////833!0 !8 !0 3! 22 3%! D 0 %! ! 0%0 0 3! ! 0 04 # 0&%9 ($$( %= 3 0 1+!0-
>- (*D!($$* =&;.-////////////333% 02-##B-+630E2-))-++3=&32-#>-+02!0337 D&02-#$-+02!0333!(#D!($$*333 %02-##B-+32-($-+02!033-
C- #)3%9($$*2!!2!;1&%%0%03= %%02-##B-+32-($-+02!80!2!33!!-
:- #> 9 ($$* & 133!! 0 .- //////////// %%0%03=-
,- (B9($$*1&133&;0&!!-
)- : %9($$*D&133!!01& 81 3 0122!!!0!+! !0!&!3 -
#$- ## %9 ($$* .- //////////// !9 0 !6 57;100&!!3&!& 8 &20! !038!&! 34 0%3=- !!2%&8!1 !3&30-
'(#)('($$* +*',+ ##- ## 0&%9 ($$* 1 33& - 3!% 0 3 1+%0! 9!"! !8 !0 2?! 0 2-#F>$$-+&!03!#D !($$(02-(*(-+3%!-
#(- 1&&!0&9!03!%00&%9($$(0&0!01%3 02-##*-+ &*%($$*!%02-))-+- !01 2!03302-#>-+&%&;-
3!0!8!0! !#D !($$*04 81 !G!01&&%B0&%9($$(-
#*- (( 0&%9 ($$* .- //////////// %! 5 3! 0 0&%3 0 ?@%" 01 ! ; 0&%9 ($$( 01 3&4 % 0 !!31+!0 &83 !<&;0E 0!0!22&3%<%!8-
#B- #( D ! ($$B &30 81! &! 3!9 01< & !8!03401 3401 .-
! $
#- 7!" !1"!!D0!!!67&&%0!2!&!!& 04 # H ($$* !9 0 ! 6- # - 7-
<0*$%($$B30 !90%!!!26!+34 7 &0122!!&01-#-!0&8 5 ! &&&& !!01-#*#0 !!" !+ +-
97I08!!!!90& E%!2! J
+2!"300!3!!201<-0!3!!201D"% 38&!1!&0?D"&%!2-1!&0? D"& 1&0 ; E+! 8 0 % K 0!3!!2 = ! E3&% K ! 33 ; 8! !!"! 6 I )C ()>L M33 &! 0 0! 0%!!!2 B4% &0!! #))# 3- (B, L N9?!0 0!D0!!!3! &!#),#3-*#*-7-
+F!&0?D"& 8!81!!83%=8 !93 !E%!62-M333-!-3-(>#7-!33O134 0E 8 0 ! %<% 3 ! ; 1! 01 !D& 3 !! 0 0! 3!!8 <& 0 ! 01 2!E 001&!0D" 5@!!!&0 !!!D!0!!-
'(#)('($$* +B',+ + ! !!! ! < 0&& - 5 1 3! 33!!0+!962-+IG! 90? 0 5?P!Q - #))# 3- #:, B*$7- ! 3 0 81!90!4""&&01"! 33!!4% 8 &8 0 1! 9 ! &"!% D!0!8 6 I ##( *#*7- %!2% !! 04 8 !0& 3!8 0 1< 0 ! ; ! 1E! 01 D!0!! 8!2!03!#H($$*0&D;0D"!!!!8 D"33&&&&"!4%&-
7 5E%!0122!%3&L 1<0 0*$%($$B !D81;E!!&"%; &!2!2%!&;1-#*# 0!1!!-
5D!0!!0%!!! 3&!81!0 0%!3!!0!-=!03381- >: 0 ! 2&0& 3! "&& 0 0! 0 ! + + & !" # D ! ($$* ?8 !! !9 0 8! ! !8 0 0%! 0 !- 0!3!! &" 2&0& 9!" ; "3 !E 0 ! %<% ! !ED8;&3!;4 0! %%!!0 - 1!!3&30;1E!"3&3!2&0& 8&"!" !&& 5-
51-#*#-# R!&9!0!9E3%3D" ! ! 3&L 4" %9 1"!! D!0!!%3&S-0&!0 #):#0!3!! !!&&%3&&3!&(!9&%%!JR!9 0%!!!2!!&300!0%!!!20 K!3& !S-
!!1!34%<%3!!38!0!!- 4" 01!3&! 3% D" 0 0&"" 01 0!3!! J 0! 3 ! ; !3&! !& ?!!8 &&"!8=&%!80%-D"0 3!3!!!%0 E ! 0 !- 0 < 0 *$ % ($$B !0&& 8 E 0 1- #*# - ( !! 3 0 3 3 01 !9E 0 0! 0%!!!2L ! !3&& R !9S %%!"!2! R!9S-1-#*#-( 3&!8 !9 0%!!!2 !!& R0 K ! 3& !S- 1 0! 8 &!% 0 !E 0%!!!2 4 01 D!0!!- !!1!3&!!&3%;08 %RS0!<8!2!&"%%!%01!!0&%!&-
'(#)('($$* +>',+ = 0 2!%& 3 !3&! ?!!8 &&"!8- & 0 E 3&3! 6.&%! 0 0 ! T . +#):$3->>B-78&"!#):$0!&E@&0 D!0!! ! ! 3& E! 3& ; 1- #*# - # !90%!!!2!0&3003 !E&!2- !9&!0!&; %3!&T !01 %%!!0U8! ! ; O 0 0&!! 0 0&3%- 1&! 3038!8%3%!"&&!38 !91&! 0&0%3&01!9!-&!& !08! %%!! 3&! 0 ! 9! %% ! 0 %3!!3!!46%3!!3!!E3U7-5.&%!0 0 !3->>:R0=4% !"& !01 %%!!3&!!&0%!!&&0&!0&!0 D!0!! 0%!!! 0!! !0&30 8 &3!%3&S-
4 # D ! ($$$ && %! 9&&2! 01 "&& 0 %3&- !! 0 D!0!! 0%!!! 3&! 0 0! %% 6- >C 7- %!! 0 %%!! 0 3&!&&E3&%&22!%&6. #)):3-)B*$7-!!!&0 D!0!!103D%!&&%!!3 I!3 I - !300!!8!!%3<?&&"!88 & 3 0 0 2! %3& %!4 01 ! D8;0& ;%%!!0;D!0!!0%!!! 3&! 51-
5!10 !! 1!3&!0 0<0*$%($$B % 5 %! &"% %%!! 0 3&!=%3!?& !+%<%!!!!- 1%!2%3&&9 !&3&"!-
0 8! 3&40 &! 0 5 33!! 0 2%; !!" !-
1&! 0 D" = 3 ! && & 3 !9 2&0&0<0(:D !($$B0 !" !03& #* 2& ! ($$B 0!3!! !! 3% 5 0 !&" ; ! D" !! 0 1 0 1&! 0 E -
(- !2&0&3!"&&00!0!0C9 ($$$6 7& !"#D !($$*O0%9 %0!2!!00%!0!-01340% 2!&"!30!3!!0!2&0&F+%0!0#,
'(#)('($$* +C',+ %#))B+ .010F+%0!0(:D!#))>+ . !"D81*#0&%9($$(&"03!!38 D" 0 ! 1 3 ; 30 !0&! %0!2!!00!01&02!3&!;00&%!0 0&!!!!"!6 I#(:BC:!0-##(#*CC!0-#97-
*- E%01-#-(-9 .1+%0!!0 3!01!00%K+!01 %3!?"-
1-, .3& !8 0!03<30 81&!4% 3!8;!9!"! 0 ! 2&0& 0 ($ % #),# 1+!0 6 7- 1 340 ; 3! 8 1& ! 2! 0%0 33 3 81!!4%&2%&%; -&0!3!% &86-#7-!0 03&!048 0 %3!6-(7-1+ %0! ! 30 ?" H 0 ! 01!0 81 ! 3!0 6-*7-
51-) .0122!!!;1+%0!!1 0! 3 &! ! 1! 0 1& 3!9!!& 0 3& 0%001-,-
2!1-## .3&!83!0 0!0 3& ;1-,0!!0%0&!01&0&3!22 3@3%!D0%!8!!0%06-#7- 2!0 33 0 ! 0 0! ; 1!0%!& 0 ?@%" 0 0 !0 32! 1%3= 1+?@%" !2% 1& 3 &! 81! 0! !0!8 ; 1+%0! %% K 0 !0- 1& 0! 2! %%!! ; 1+ %0! 0 %! 8! ! 1!2%! 0& 3 1%3= 1+?@%"6-(7-
B- 134 && !2%& 3 (: % ($$( 8 !8 !03 !<30%=0%003-
1833!0(> %9($$(G3B0&%9($$( 88!013!0 !0-
!! 33!! 0 &"!! 3&!& 0! 3! 3 ! 30 223@#D !($$*-
'(#)('($$* +:',+ 1-, .3& !8 0 !03<30 0%0- 3!1! !030122!&! %%% 1! 8-
>- 08!3&403 !0&0!03!%01 030&%9($$(%02-))-+30;3!%3 !00%;0&%9($$(6)A2-##-+7-
01+%<%0!%!&%0&02!0332- #>-+&%&($D!($$*-&83!%0%! 133!!%%0%03=T3!V$*(#::>>T &; 01 % 0 2- ##)-+ ! 2- ))-+ 2- ($-+ 0 2! 0 33 ! 0 (# D! ($$*- 0! 2! 3 ! 22 < &%& 2%&% ; 1- *# - * 0 0!! 3 19!"!0!.!!%01&0!!($$#6<0 !9 0%!!!20(#%($$$ ')C'$$7-
'(#)('($$* +,',+
$ /! 5 .! $. /. ! $/! /.!
6 7 8 9& )0( .%
6
#- !8 9-
6
(- 10%3!%-
*- 4 133!! %%0% 0 3= 3! V $* (#::>> ; 01%02-##)-+-
B- 2% 3! 0 81 3 2% 3& < 0 0&! 0 *$ D 04 !2!! 3 3! %%0& 0& !9 2&0& 0 5?P!Q?28! C C$$B ! E%3!- 0&! 3 < 3"&- %&%! 0!J 7 !0!8 E%80&!!0&!9!!300&!! 8&L 97 E3 3 8 %!2 ! !% 3 ! 0%0 0&!!L 7 3 !" 0 3&- 5! %&%! ! 3 ! &&% &%&& 7 97 7 !+0 !92&0&033%!481! 0 0&! 9-%&%!0%!%= 0 3 8! D! !! 8 0&!! 8& 1 33 0 8&&E3&0!&6-#*(#$C#$,7- "22!4J &!0J =5 &!. 3!2%03&<!2!&E3!!!81;122!2&0& 0!3"22
'(#)('($$*