Appeal Regarding Disability Benefit Calculation Upheld
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed several appeals concerning the calculation of disability benefits where the appellant claimed entitlement to a higher rate based on specific conditions or earning capacity, but the evidence, including medical assessments and employment records, indicated that the established disability percentage and prior earnings supported the benefit level already awarded. The court reasoned that its review was limited to determining whether the administrative body's decision was based on a correct application of the law to the established facts, and in the absence of clear error or misapplication of the relevant statutes regarding the assessment of functional limitations and loss of earning capacity, the original determination of benefits must be upheld.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 93 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal Regarding Disability Benefit Calculation Upheld: The court reasoned that its review was limited to determining whether the administrative body's decision was based on a correct application of the law to the established facts, and in the absence of clear error or misapplication of the relevant statutes regarding the assessment of functional limitations and loss of earning capacity, the original determination of benefits must be upheld.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order (order 1) for declaring the appeal inadmissible.
Cited in the final order (order 2) for allocating court costs.
Testo completo
"##$%"#&&' "(#"#&&)
!!*
+ !,+ - +! -,
#% ./ #&&)
'0 1 2
3 45555555555 ! "!#!$$$$$$$$$$ !!
!
-66, - 7+!8,4,, ! % -. &'()*))"+),
!
/*0)1/
6,
)2 2 $$$$$$$$$$ . 3 )''4 55! %6 !.7- 5 .! !%8 % 69 :; %:8. 3+! )''(2 ;-;.! %!.%%..-.*'3+!)''(2
*2 ,1+!*11*! $$$$$$$$$$$%6.%6/;.-:%6;< %55!-.6=%65!-.:.>;2?*)@ ") ,5!!, A2
,2 !$$$$$$$$$$$%! !%*1-!*11,5!-. !. %6!.7-5.! !%8%69:;25. %6.!.:!+- !%6!%- !.;%-+-%6 !.%-B6= !%6;.-/ +%.5+%%55.%!2C -.% %55. % 65 ! + %.5 % 5!-D;.8-.:- +5!:.55+2 % 7..5! % . %6!:;.! ! %6.!. :!+ . %.5 % 6.:! % - +7! ! ! 5 > ! ! E 7. ! ! = = - = % = ! 8 !: ! 8 6.87!%. -%! %6 2A2%+!%-F- +!7..5!%.% &;-!.2
?2 *' -! *11, "! % 65 %-%. B 655 % 6!/+%. >/ !"G 6 A % !%! ;!: !- %6!:;.! % &;-!.%52
H2 ! !.7 !#%- $$$$$$$$$$$!:;.! *(+!*11, 5!- % + % ! $$$$$$$$$$$ B +! 8 %55. % 65 ! - + %.5 % 5!- D;.8 - ! + 5!:. 55+2 . % &;-!... !..2
42 ! $$$$$$$$$$$ % !+ -.% !.: >C#A !+. 8 6!:;.! 35 ! 6.!. :!+ 8 %!"! 6. .88+8%6+-86 .5. !%5!=.!!2
(2 ! $$$$$$$$$$$ % C# ! ! 5 !-!8! 8 65 !.%.7.-!%%!%6: ;!.@ 5!-.:.%;2?1,%6!% + F!
0'(0*11, /,0)1/
! 865!-.:.%;2?1?!5 : !- %6! !"! +:. %" ! 8 ! -82 ! +:. ;2 4?' + !7"- % !"! % - !- - 5 !-!8! 8 6! + !+!86 !"6.;%6!-5%!.2C !%!!6! !7"-%- !-6 !.%- 5!::!+2!! %%.7.-& %!75!.8 !;!: !8-3! ! .2C6!:;.! 6 -.;% %.8 !!!!7%- !-%!"!2
I2 ! %. % ' -7! *11, 6 !5. % !%! ;!: J % !- %6!:;.! -5 8 !:- -.%= 7 % % ! ;!: % 6!:;.! 6:%;2?*)6. !- 2
'2 ! %. % )1 -7! *11, 6 .:- !5. ! ;!:%!-% &;-!.2
)12 ?7!*11,#!$$$$$$$$$$ "!%655 B %=%.2
))2 !%.! %4+-7!*11,6 -!5 6: % 6!:;.! -5 8 ! ;!: % !- %6 .+ B 5!-. :. 6 7 8 -5 ;:8 %! .! ! + &- <- % 65!-. :. 86 .+.- =.!! 6!+ % -"! %.!- % !2 ! 6 !+. 86 6!! !! B 6!:;.! . 35. ! .!. :!+ 8 . ! .8 % 6 + - .:-%5!=.!!2
)*2 !%.! %(+-7!*11,6 .:-- !5 6: % &;-!.2 6 ! ! -5 %.3B +8. % %. % )1 -7! *11, B +! 8 !:- -.%= 7 !..% &;-! - .-.! B % -! -.% ! ;!: ! 6!/+%.86 -!% B%: .%8% !-%%.!!-- -! .%:/;.! 8 !."+5!.8. .6. !- %-!K65!! %6% ! .:! .. >5 ;% . - % %. (H@!.+:%6.+7!%. 1, !" !!@!.!%-%A2
0'(0*11, /?0)1/
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
)?2 +.B !!6 % !.+%'5.+!!*11? !3%!!26=%6%.!%.8 !655%!%65PQ/B/%!6.!.:!+ !7!.!/65!-.:.%2!"+ 8!$$$$$$$$$$$%55.%65!! + %.5 % 5!- D;.8 - .:- + 5!:. 55+ 8 .. 5!-. ! #%- $$$$$$$$$$$2 55 .. !+. 8 %55. B -! +!7. % !5!- % 65 / + = 555 %55. B !+!!!.! ! !!. !%6+ ! / 5 ! B !7 % 6- % 2 6!. -. 6 .:- !.5.!. B 6+ % ! $$$$$$$$$$$ 8 6.!. :!+ !7 !.! 8- .8 % 6 + - % 5! =.!! B 6 :.2 6!. -. - ! ! 8 !- %6!:;.! % &;-!. + F! !;!: ! 7 % ;55! ?1? % 6!% 8 !! : %
0'(0*11, /H0)1/
- 8;R3%6:!-!865 !. 6!! %.7. -2 5 !+. 8 C# 6!:;.! 6. -.;% %.8 ! !! !7 % - !-%!"!8..5!-. !58656 %6!7..5.8%67!5!-%6!:;.! +%6F!!. ! &;-!.2
)H2 !. 8 % )I -! *11? "! % 65 . 67 % % . ! 65!-. :. !72 %- 8 6555!%65!:.55+= 886!+!.% %55 ! ! + ! 8 5!:. % B 5 - !.;726!: !!%8!$$$$$$$$$$$ !. +! 3- =-. 52 8 %!! %6 : !- !"+ 86 ! %="- . %6. !-! 86 ! !"- .-2 !% B 6 % %!!!!%6!%!!865%6= . 86 7 +. 86 !"!- 7-;.-8%! !.%- %6 8 %7..58 &;-!. &;;.! !" 7..58 !- %68.!! % %6 % :%-+-%6!:%-.!2!! !"+!85!%-%-% 6#C%.7.-.:"!%:8.!8 .! H14'!87 !5-*11*B % ('2!!+83! !%% !75.%.!%! .:86!+%.%.3B..%-.B !%!;!: 5!% &;-!.%65%.-77B%6 2B %55.! !" 8 %!! :!%! 9 -F- 6 !8-%6.2
)42 !$$$$$$$$$$$ .%!! .%!.7! !-.% %%-!*11?BN%& !=%.+ -.B !7% !. !.% .!-O2 ! !!!86=-!:8-.+%!7 %6.+%6/-!.B:;;& %--7! !.%-=--7! .!!!7%6!:%: %!% !!/-86!7 %! +%6.87!@+%5 .!!+7! % !- 5.!! - = % 7 . !@ !!+ !7 +/!5 - ! 73+ %.5 2 -.% 5 . %6 -.! ! +!7 % *11* 7 8 % !5!- !. !+- ;:.2 C6!:%!7%.+ - .+-Q= 8!
0'(0*11, /40)1/
! ..% % 65 / !! ! 6. !+ 86 . !- /;.-:8 % !.7- / - .:- ! % ! 5-2 = !-. 6+ 8 ! % !- % &;-!..%8.2
)(2 H+!*11?6 - 2
)I2 ! !!! % )' +! *11? ! S$$$$$$$$$$$ % !+ +!! %6 ;-:%6;< /B6%.!.! !% %. % !5 % ! ;!: % !- % &;-!. !:;.! 2 ": 8 !!% &;-! % 65 ! + &%!- + + -! >-! -! % 69 :;A86 !;!:%5!% -35.2
)'2 "..--8.:!%.B3:!2
!-,
)2 :+!6!:3%!>A..-%5.. %")!J*11, !7%!- .% 83:% !.%+/ !.%8 .R3: !>!2)2!H4 A2
CB6%6.%)43:! ! !75.%.! *( 3+! *11? > L ),1 )14A !% :+ % . ),5.+!! % !! !: !- !7 %!%.:!!B!3:!% 6%6.%+=3:!2
*2 !7 % ! 8 -- ! !+ B 5.%.! % )' 3 )'H' ! 6!/+%.>/ !" @52!2)2!H42)2;2*A2 C- . !3:!%%6 "%.72
,2 5.%.! ! ! :..! % %! % ! % 47!*111> A!.+:!)!3+!*11,!T. -%5 % -7! % % %- % 6!/ +%.2 ! % Q!2 ) 2 ) % % 5.%.! % 47! *111 ! ! :..! % %! % ! > A
0'(0*11, /(0)1/
6 8B6!/+%.>!2)B*47*IB(1AB-8 %.!:= !.-B >!2)2) A2
?2 !7 % . 8 !! !3. - >!2 41 2) A!+75!-2
H2 5!-.- B 6!2 I 2 ) !. +% -. %6 +%.--%!=-!%!.% 8.! %!B!.7!! .%:B6-.!!B+:!%!B 5+!! 6: %! . %.!-. 5 % %!. %6+. !772 -7! % -! % !.% +:7 5:!---!-.%-!%6!%! !5 !-%-&=!2
42 +! % 6!2 ), !. %! = -! -.% .! !- % 5!-. :. 386B 6M: % *1 !.+2 -! -.% !%. 5!-.- B % %+ %! ! B :! Q5!-. :. /-F-2 3! !%% !75.%.!%!%-58%!B % -! -.% Q.% = - .:- !- %Q %! B . 8 ! . = &- <- %Q5!-. :. - 8 Q= .! -.% + .8 % 5!-.2 ! Q5!-. :. Q %! B . 5 8Q = % . %.8 85.2 Q8%.85.!Q%!B .Q5!-.:.%.!-!.+"! .! 8 Q!/+%. % !%! ;!: -! -.% % %! % Q!2 ), > L % )* 2 *11) ,HH01)%2)@C*11) 2(H%2,@ L)11?)+2!.5.!A2
(2 .:!%+% ! !83! !%8 6 8 .:- % %- % 6!/+%. 8 % . ! !"+ % 5 P % % 6 !. % -.% P ! 8 !"! %.8 % . 8 % %!8%F!!;. !3:%!!> L %)*2*11) ,HH01)%2) L)*,)1,%2,%),'%2,))) )II%2*7A2
I2 6 "6!.-. 586555!%6 5!-. :.2 C := % +! 6 = % .!%.8!55%!%65Q/ B/%! 6.!. :!+ !7 !.! 5!-. :.%-"!B+!!%!=-!-.%2
0'(0*11, /I0)1/
!! +8 6!!F !% ! L % % )* 7! *11) > 22A8+%- !;!: !6!/+%.%5! % !- % !..% &;-! %6 5 55! % !.7-2
6 8 B 8 55 %! % 55! 65 .! = + &- <- % 65!-. :. ! 86 - ! % 5=! % =: .+"! B ! %6 %.85.!5!-.:.B. %!2
'2 6!!F 8 !.5"! !! 65 55! .:- %Q 5!-.:.5!-%6!.7-8%!7% - !-2 L %- 6= %6 % . ! %.8N-F-Q%+Q+.!!8Q5!-.:.!- ;!!: 8Q .. 6. 8 % !7 &;8O2 55 . 86 !! % % Q= ! 8Q==.!!Q .!.. !!- %Q5!-.:.!7 &;8.+"! !..2
6= !.!!+.B86 + %.!-!6= %6.!=!!7%6!%! &;8 .58%65 >!7 % !. !8A &- <- % 65!-. :.2 + 5 . 8 !7 &;8 6. ! 86 !" 65!-. :. 86 ..- ;:8 -8 6. !. + %: % !.7-2 6= ! + .:- = 8. 8 6 .! + !+8. ! % ;- + + ! .8 - !" - ! % 6.+ ;&8 &;8 % 65 >- %6.!. % %.+! % ! ! -: - - ! %55. % ! ! !A2 -F- 5 B ! % 6!: % 565 !..%!7%- !->:!% "!A! !+ !26+%6= !..5!-. ! %-.%!2 56= !5!-.86 !"!+ - % % 5 6- : %6 !. %. !+ +!7 !5%!%!. +.!!- .. !5 !+ &;;.! 8 B !- -.%-=2
+ % %.! L %- 8 % . % -! K = = .! ! 6 .! %6.. / =!F-- - ! ! 5!! ! 5 7 M:/!7 &;8.+"! !.. !65255-. 86.%!!%!%;5!-BQ= .!%+
0'(0*11, /'0)1/
8Q 5 7 M: 7 !--2 -! + -! %.8 ! !! !7 % - !-> L %)*2*11),HH01)%2*A2 5 L 3:. 7 8 . % ;.! &;-! 8 +F!-.B-!-.%-!%.8 ! !! !7 % - !- % 652 6= ! + %6! 5!-.8!..% &;-! +F!.% ! ;!: % :!+ !7 % - !- %. %-- % 6M: % 2
)12 6!!+!86 B5-F- 8 2 6 5 673 %6 ..2 6& % B ! !- !!-8!26%-! - 86 %J .:- 5! N%O % 9 86 7 ! - !%;- +2!6= !%.+8.%8.8 %! . .8 % ! % 6!: % 586 "2 -!B 8 ! S ! B T!2 !T ! ! .+% 8 !.%6 255%!%55!%8B %.+ . !65%>-%6.!.%%.+! %55.%!!/ !A2 !7%.%6+ 8 !- ! !7 5.%.! % ! % 7 - -% % !. 86 35 %" ! %6%-!!!!-!%!.% 2
))2 + 5 % !+! 6: % 6!:;.! 8 ! L$$$$$$$$$$$ ! 86 ;.! 7!"+ 55 &;-!. + ! !.+.! ! !.2 6 % = 8 6!:;.! 5 ! !. %!B!!-==:%6. %.. . !3! !%2
0'(0*11, /)10)1/
PAR CES MOTIFS, LE TRIBUNAL CANTONAL DES ASSURANCES SOCIALES :
9:3 ; < 7= >?# -@
3
)2 .!!!!+7@
3
*2 6%-@
,2 8 . % &;-!. %6!:;.! + ! 2 $$$$$$$$$$%+F! !;!:B!%-!-.%@
?2 %. % !5 % ! ;!: % &;-!. % 6!:;.! @
H2 8 !.%!:!@
42 5!- ! % 8Q + 5!-! !! ! !. !!F % %. % ,1 3! %" 5 ! !--%. %!. !7 5.%.! % ! C;UR!;58 4 411? ! =- !2 %. F! !:.2 -.-! % G A %8! =- 8Q %. !! %.! 7! % %. 8.@ 7A = ! ! 8 -5 - +! %-%! !%.@A !!:!%! !.2C-.-! ! ..- .-.!. ! A 7A A /% !75.%.!%! !! !!-"!!!!8Q %+!%.!!!!+72-.-!%!!-!!-& % !+ 8 ! 3 8 %. 8. Q+ % 8..= .%.!!>!2),*)14)1IA2
:!55"!G !.%G LL V!C V
5!-% !.!!F5.= !8QBQ555.%.! %! !:!55
0'(0*11,