Agreements, Promissory Notes, and Prevented Performance of Contractual Conditions Precedent
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered several actions concerning alleged breaches of various agreements and the validity of associated promissory notes, where the core issue revolved around whether contractual conditions precedent, specifically related to securing certain governmental authorizations, had been satisfied or excused. The reasoning emphasized that performance under a contract is excused when performance by the other party, or the occurrence of an event required for performance, is prevented by the other party's breach or repudiation, or when the condition itself is rendered impossible or illegal due to the other party's actions, ultimately concluding that the party seeking to enforce the agreements was prevented from satisfying its obligations due to the counterparty's conduct concerning the necessary regulatory approvals.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Agreements, Promissory Notes, and Prevented Performance of Contractual Conditions Precedent: The reasoning emphasized that performance under a contract is excused when performance by the other party, or the occurrence of an event required for performance, is prevented by the other party's breach or repudiation, or when the condition itself is rendered impossible or illegal due to the other party's actions, ultimately concluding that the party seeking to enforce the agreements was prevented from satisfying its obligations due to the counterparty's conduct concerning the necessary regulatory approvals.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision is cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.
Testo completo
#$%&$#$''( #&'&#$'')
* +!* , * ,+
- . / $ $'')
!!!!!!!!!!" #$% &" $'( ) ( %( # #$ *%(# # +(
(
,, * - " ($% # & ./" 0 1)
! "
- 3286 -
0+
89 !!!!!!!!!!" (( '(: % ;%) 8.<3" ()% 0 1) =(% # $> ( # ((& ?()(% @ A=* 48 (B 8..5" #( 0 = '%(% '(% (( # ()9
39 C ;%) 8..7" #%'% #$# # '(( # *-)#(%"
= %(% A(% ' *,, * - ?-'1 * @9 (( #% # ; %(% ;$% ' A:$( # $$ # $(1 #*-)#(% # 3/ (B 8..." /.52.C9
49 #( # 8< ;%) 3668" *% #%'% ) #$# # '(( '1 # * " #* #%'" # # :%%%" # # # ( # '9
59 # # *(( # #$#" * = # ) $%#D '1 # #;;%( $%# ((( # *% ?$%# ((" '&E("
:(-(%:" E$(:" #$(:" ($$(@9
79 #( # 3C )$B 3664" *% %(% $ 0 D'( '#' ?E$(:= ( '&E(=@ #( ' # *-)#(% ?-'1 @9 D'( ( ($$( 0 (B $(;$ #D" $B#(% '&E(=9 '(% # () %(( (1 # ()(% # *% # $> ( # ((&9
<9 ( 0 (( D'(" * # #%" 33 ) 3665" ' = A(% #$# # '(( # *%9
/9 # 35 $ 3665" *%" '%(% ' )(" ;$% ''(
0 (( #%" (( #% $'%$( ' $'%( %(9 *'' # ''(" ''$( ;( ) = *''%( # $%# # (E( :1$( ) # $%# (((9 ;" '%% =* *;;( # % # A(;(; $%#D ; # $'%( ''(9
C9 # 3. A 3665" *,, * - # ( # ?-'1 *;;@" = -((( # ' * " (&%
0 *% #% # 46 A ' '# ''( $%#D % 0 %(& ''(9
.9 # 38 A( 3665" *% D'=% 0 *;; =* )( (% # F%(B$( E'(F& %)( # %(( # (% ( #
2345323667
- 4286 -
'(% # ()9 %(( )=% 83 G( 3665H (I( ''( #*D'( '" )( 0 '%#" ) B)(9
869 # < )$B 3665" *;; *( %(% '1 # *% # *) ' > # $()( () 0 *''(" #*(((( # F%(B$( E'(F&9
889 # 8< )$B 3665" *% ;$% *;; =* %(( # *((( # ''( # F%(B$( E'(F&" =* ($((( #1 %'(9 '%% = $%# )( #%'(% :) ;;( B = '( J( 0 *: # # $B9 ( ;$% (( *''%( $%# # $%# # = )( '% #:( # (B $(;$ #D $':% # '(E: '&E(=" =* $B( = # )( BA()B = '( %# # ;;( B #%'(%9
839 # 38 ;%) 3667" *;; (&% 0 *% ($ #% 7 $ 3667 ' =* ''( %%$( % 0 $()( # ''(9 % #%" *''( ( #%% )B *(9 86 9 7 # *# '( :%% # #( # ? @9
849 #% ''( # 8 A 3667" * #%% *''( # *% )B" $(; = $:% ' ''" *)( ' $ #*(((( $%# ')( %(& ''(9
859 # 4 A 3667" *% *( #% 0 * " ((( #% #*)B(%9 D'=% = ''( %'#( D D: # ;$ H %(( $()%" B = ($(" # ( =* ')( J( #%% )B9 ;( # *) ' '#( # $& # ') ')( # 0 #% ''( $ ;#%" $ #( )B9 " ($ ''( %(B ' F%(B$( E'(F&" 5 $ 36679 " (( = '( %(( BA()B ( )( ' #* (B $(;$" ($( 0 = $%# # )( #:(=%9 1 " #:% #*)#(% #)( J( ) 0 $1 # ) #% $%# )% 0 '%#9
879 # 8/ A 3667" *;; %'# 0 *% =* )( %(% )( =*'1 *($ #% $'(" ( ) # '(" ''( ( #%% )B9 " $$ *)( ' (;( 0 (( D:" *)%( A(;% # #% ''( )B9
8<9 # 8 A( 3667" *% '1 # B ( # " ( 0 *( # #% ''( # 33
2345323667
- 5286 -
) 3665 ( ) # 0 * ' (( # #9 ;( ) = # ''( # 35 $ 3665" )( (1 $( D'=% = ;( ( ' $%# # )( %(% $ ''%%9 8< )$B 3665" )( '%% = $%# # F%(B$( E'(F& )( #%'(% :) ;;( B = '( J( 0 *: # # $B ( )( ;$% (( *''%( # $%# # " ($$( =* (( #:( # (B $(;$ #D $':% # '(E: '&E(=" = # )( BA()B9 " ''( %(( ( ($( $()%" $ %(( $()% ( ')( # J( #%% )B9 ( '" * ')(- #% $$ $ ;#%9
8/9 %' # 3 '($B 3667" * ''% = *% *)( '#( %%$( $%# ) ')( $(( # 9 '#(" '(I( =*)B" *''( %(( $ ;#%9 *($% $(( ' %=( ($ # #% # 33 ) 3665" (( =* ;( *( # '(( #* ;( #* ((( 0 (% )#(9
8C9 %'= # 85 (B 3667" ( )% = * ( = ''( *%(( ' )B9 " ' $(;" #% ''( #)( J( % ( # (% 0 * ' ) #%9 ;" ''% ) '#( ''( $%# A 3667" = ;( #( # B-;#% # *''%( # $%# # 9
8.9 #'= #(%" > 37 )$B 3667" * *( %;%% 0 #% ''(" =*0 $%$ # %'9
369 " #;;%( ( %(% ($ D '( ( :#% 0 A:9
,+
89 :) K:( A# # 33 )$B 8.58 ?@ %(% $#;% ( ((%" #1 8 G( 3664" B ( # " $'% # 7 A:" #( '%#( ( )-'%#(" 7 ''%( ( 8< A: ?(9 8 (9 ( 7< @9
( 0 K( # K%( # 8< A: " ' B ;%#% 3/ A) 3665 ? , 846 86<@" # :) #'(%" 84 ;%)"
#'( (( :( '$((( B ( # # %: 0 4 A: ((" " # K((( # K%( # )D A: 9
2345323667
- 7286 -
39 ;$%$( 0 K(9 7< 9 8 (9 E9 3 " B # % +( ( = # ((( '%) ' K(9 7< # ;%#% '( :%% # #( # # < (B 3666 ? @ = ( () 0 ;%#% K-)#(% # 8. A 8.7. ? @9
$'%( ' A: # #K'1 ( %(B9
49 ( (% ): 8 A) 3664" (+( # $#;( %:() ($$( # #( # *-)#(%9 '( # ) ($'" ( '' ''B 1: # #( ): $$( L ;( A#=$( #%($( ( '#( ( A: # ;# ''" ' ''% " *%(( # ;( %% 0 #( #%($( # #% ''( (: ? , 83. 5 #9 893H 8<. #9 8 H 47< #9 8 ( J( (%@9 = '%# (
0 #%;( # 1: (( (" ( # #*''( *''=( %) #1 A # (% ): ? , 88/ .4 #9 <BH 883 4<6 #9 5H 8..C M 4/ '9 48< #9 4B@9
59 %'% # ;$ ( #% '%) ' " '%( ( )B ?(9 <6 @9
79 *(% ): # %(# 0 *$B # BE # ?0 *D'( # '%)& ';@ '%# #*''("
= ( ? " " @ ( A=*9 *(9 73 9 8 " #% # $(1 #* ')( J( ((=% # 46 A ' ) #*''( '1 # * = #" 0 *D'( # #% #*#$( # '%#9 (( $ %: # '%# ( (% $$%#($( ): ? , 88/ .4 #9 <B" 883 4<6 #9 5H 8..C M N 4/ '9 48< #9 4B@" = :; = (( #% )%" # '1 48 #%$B 3663" ( $ 0 '%# #*''(9 *(9 86 9 8 # *# '( :%% # #( # # 88 '($B 3663 ? @" %#(% B # #%%:( # $'%( '%) 0 *(9 C8 " '%)( = *''( #( ( # ( J( $()%9 (;( ' 0 D: *( ' :%" * $'(( #% )B ' %' )"
) *)($( =*0 #%;( *''( ' )B ?(9 86 9 7 @9
*''( ( $& # #( '$((( #(( #* #% #* B( %D$ ' *((%" )( =* A: ( %)($( ?;9 , 837 838 #9 3 ( %;%@9 '('( # *% ' # #% ( '( ($$( B( #*%$ # '%# ( # #%E: # (BD" # #$ # #( #$((; L # #% '(1$( $B ( # ?M " -M$$(O
2345323667
- <286 -
M$$( P$ #:(P QB # :$ # P)E:E( )$ <9 R(B 3666" SE 3664" N 3 9 # (9 73"
) %;%H " ( #$((;" )9 O ( #$((; ( (I" 31$ %#(" 3663" '9 744 N 7949393H " (% # #( #$((;" )9 " '9 .4.@9 #" '%# #*''( )J( # )%(B (%J( = *''( #( D' $(; # #%# ) #% ( ?) '#( M " '9 (9" N 84 # (9 73@H 0 #%;("
( = # ; # * ''( $' ;$(% )( #%'I( #* A(" =*% ( ((% ( )%(B$( D$% = '(( #):9 D: ;$ '% ' *(9 86 9 8 %((" ' " *B:( # *% # B 0 *D%( # #;;%( #* ?(9 3C 9 8 ( 54 9 4 H T T"
- U(V ;E: # " O T ,,T 2M ?%#(9@"
R(E W#:;: # " (- 3665" '9 55@" ( '#( :$( 0 '% ' A'# (% 0 ' '%# #* ''( '%) # ( BE #*- ? ,
834 846 #9 4 ( %;%@9
'%# #* ''( '( ''( A#= =" #* '(" ;( *BA( # #% ( # *((% ( 0 '' #=" #*( '("
*''( $;( #%#" $'($( D'($( ?;9 , 88.
476 #9 8B ( %;%H ) %:$( , 'B% # C (B 3664" 873268" #9 4@9 #% ( '( = ''( A#= - ' D$'" #( # *% 0 ( #*)#(% -" - (( %:$( *BA( # '%# #*''(9 *((% )B$( #* ''( #) # ' # ; ( '( # ''( A#=" =# B $J$ $()( # ) #% '( ''$( '( (=% ' *''(9 # (% 0 A:" ''( A#= (( %:$( *BA( # (: #( 0 +( ?;9 , 837 587 9 #9 3H , 'B% #
8. )$B 3665" <<5264H ' '%# #* ''( O X - "
((::(# $ (( - Y(: P 837 584" O T ,,T 2 T ?%#(9@" R( E(;: # P)E:'D" (- 3668" '9 8.@9
<9 ((% #$(() ( A# ( % ' '' :%% # B ; '%#" #%( B # *(9 5 # * ((( ;%#% ? (9@ = # *(9 . (9 *(#( # ;$$ D; = (( * # :( # '%# $$# 0 - #*%)( # ( ' *)B(% ) # '%# = ( ' J( #%
0 ($'" =* ')( * # $'( P (I( ( : ($( '# ? , 836 58/ #9 7@9
2345323667
- /286 -
;$$ D; ( ;$ '(1 # #% # A( 'EB% ' *(9 3. 9 8 (9 ( %% =* ( '%) ' '%# # 1: # ;$ :" = (( : ( $(%$( A(;%9 A'#" ;$ '%# ( % # $ ) # ) # #( ' #%$( # '%# ;$%$( '' # *%:(% # (($(" = ' :( *''( # #( $(%H (( D: ;$ ()( # ' (#( ) 'EB( # ;$$ D;9 & ;$$ D; $( = (( ''( # 1: # '%# A(; ' (%J( #: # '((" #)( ; ( $'= # $1 (B %( # #( $(% () # $1 #$B *1 D (BD ? , 846 8C4 #9 79598" 83C 853 #9 3@9 *D1 # ;$$ '( %# ( # 1: # $'($( $'% A(B"
( # ( = ( ((E% ? , 837 8/6 #9 4@9
)( ; # '' = # '%# A#( #$(()"
')( J( D$% ( A:%" ''" = ''( A#= 0 '' #= *((% #$(() $'%(( *( '% '%B$( #* $1 = " ;$ #* #%9 (( $" #% #%($ *BA( # ((( = '( J( #%;%% A( ' ) # 9 )E" # $ L #% * %(% #" ((( * ' #*BA(" ( A:$( ;# '( ' J( '% ? , 837 585 #9 8" 88. B 4< #9 8B ( %;% (%@9 (;" A'# # B ;%#% # " '%# A#( #$(() '( J( %(#" ' # $(; #*%$ # '%#" 0 =( %(( #*J( A:% = D1# *BA( # ((("
*(-0-# ''( A#= )% ' #%" = (( =( ( %(($( % 0 *BA( ( # (: = * '( ' #* %(( # ;( $$" ( 0 #( = *#$(( ( D'$% 0 A( # ( # '%# $ ? , 833 4< #9 3 ( %;%@9
/9 *" *:( # #%($ *( 0 A( (( = * #%% *''( ;$% ' *% )B9
$$ %(% ''% E;; 7 -#" *(9 86 9 8 ( 7 "
*''( #( ( # ( J( $()%9 (" (;( ' 0 D: # ;$" * $'(( 0 *% #% )B ' %' )" *)(( =*0 #%;(" *''( #%% )B9
''( # 35 $ 3665" *% (% #% $'%$( ' $'%( %(" $ %:$( ;( ) = *''%( # $%# # (E( ) # $%# (((9 ;$% * =* *;;( # % # A(;(; $%#D ; # $'%(
2345323667
- C286 -
''(9 #( # 38 A( 3665" D'=% =* ( %)% ' F%(B$( E'(F& 83 G( 3665 ( =* )( 0 '%# ''( #*D'( (I( '" = B)(9 8< )$B 3665" *% %'# 0 *($%" = *)( (%" J( (A # *((( # ''( # F%(B$( E'(F& =* ($((( #1 = 'B9 '%% = $%# # ( )( #%'(% :) ;;( B = '( J( 0 *: # # $B ( = #1 " *)%( = #:( # (B $(;$ #D '% ' $%# # %(( D(" '= # )( BA()B9 # 38 ;%) 3667" *($% $'( ($ #% ( ; =* $() ''(" ;( # =" - ( #%% )B9 ) # '( # *%" *($% " ' #% ''( # 8 A 3667" #%% *''( )B9 4 A 3667" ($ 0 * ''( # F%(B$( E'(F& #(% # $ 36679
(# # *''( - = '( J( ;$% ' -" )( # ' J( (' ;$(9 *% #( ( D' # ''( $(; # #%#" $ ;;( = * $' '= *% *( ' #*# ) # * ' = *''( ( ;;$$( $()%9 *" )( *($ #% ;D% 7 $ 3667 ' *;;" *% )( D'=% ' = *%(( ' #*# ) # $%# # H ($( ;;( = # %(( BA()B ( )( ' #* (B $(;$ #D ( = #:(=% ' $%# " $ #* ;;( B9 = $$" (( $()( ''+( ;;( :# # *(9 86 ( # A'# & ()"
$J$ ( $ # ($((" # #% $'( ' *($%" ''( $%# = B ' (( #% (:9 ;;("
# '1 $%# ((( # $& # ') '$((( # ;# # :$(" $ $()( (( = (" $J$ * '( '; #%# # ''( $%#D $'( $()(9 " *"
*''( # ( %(( ;;$$( $()% ( *($% ')( (( ' #% $ ;#% ;( #*(((( $%# %(&( :$( # *%9
C9 '#(" *''( #( %:$( ( # 9 "
:1$(" (( # ''( ( = # B%=("
*% * ' # #% = %(% $'( 7 $ 36679 D'= $( =* *( ' #*# ) #%" $ ;( $( # '(( # *-)#(% =* (# %$ ( * : * ( '(I( # $ # %#'(( '; (9
(" ;( # (( ; # '(( -(# = * '%(# 0 # '((9 '#(" (( =J( $'( *''+( ' J( ;;( :# # *(9 86 9 8 9 (;" ' = ) ' J(
2345323667
- .286 -
(%" ( ; (& 0 *% #% )B ; =* ' %'9 " # # 38 ;%) 3667" *($% *( B% 0 #$# ( =* $() ''( - = #$( %(( ;;$$( $()% - ' (; D D: # *(9 86 " $ (( ((( #%;( # # ''(9 1 " *($% ')( ' (( ?#%;( # @ #% *''( )B"
;( #*) ''=% '%# '%) 0 *(9 86 9 7 9
.9 ) # = '%1#" )( # (( =" #* '(" *''( # *% %(( ;;$$( $()% ( =* *( ' 0 (( )B ( ="
#*( '(" #%;( # " *&( ' %(% % ( ;$%$( 0 *( 86 9 7 " ( ' # *''( )B9 " *''( # ( ?#( ;( '( %( B%=(@ #( J( #%% )B9 )# ' %=( # ( # 0 * ; =* # ) #% ''( '1 *J( '% (( $()( # *% = ''( $%# =* ; #( # 4 A 3667" ( '1 *($ #% $'( ' * 9 ;;(" *($% *&( ' D$% #( ''(" B # % ( # (: ;#" $J$ ' %$ # '%#" %:# 0 A'# # B ;%#% # 9 ;" & #*A( = # = '" ; ''( $%# '#( '1 #%"
((( D1 # ;$$ 'EB%" '= *($% * ' D$% 0 A *''( ( $'%$( ?#( ;( '( '1@ ;#9
869 (" = B(( : # " #( 0 # #%'9
2345323667
- 86286 -
,+0 +!* , * ,+
123 4 5 67 /)$ ,8 3
89 % )B9
3
39 *#$( # #%(9
49 #% ''( # 8 A 36679
59 ) # 0 * ; =* (( 0 ) (( *''( # ( ( = ''( $%# '#( A 36679
79 #$ *($% 0 ) ( #$(% # 766 ;9 0 (( # #%'9
<9 ;$ '( # =K ')( ;$ ( '%( J( # #% # 46 A #1 (;( ' ' $$#% #% B ;%#% # " EWPE;= <" <665 " ( D$'9 #% '( J( ':%9 $%$ #( O @ #= D($( = #% ( #% B( ( ' # #% ((=%H B@ D' ' = $(; ($ ') #$# (( ( #%H @ '( :( # '%((9 $%$ (( ' ( %%$( %$%% (( @ B@ ( @ -#" B ;%#% # ' ' ( $(1 =K #) #% )B9 $%$ # $( $& # ')" = ( A(" = #% ((=% ( K)'' # = %(% D'%#% ( ?(9 843" 86< ( 86C @9
:;;1 %#(
- S Z
%(-A( O ,%#%=
' ;$ # '%( J( ( (;% D '( =K0 K;; ;%#% # ' :;;
2345323667