Property Conveyance Set Aside Due to Constructive Trust
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant, claiming an interest in property acquired by the appellee, sued to set aside a conveyance, alleging that the conveyance was procured by the appellee's undue influence and that the property was subject to a constructive trust due to the appellant's prior contributions and the parties' confidential relationship, which the appellee breached by failing to secure the property in the appellant's name as promised. The court held that while the appellant failed to prove undue influence, the evidence supported the finding that the appellee held the property under a constructive trust because the appellant provided substantial consideration and labor for the acquisition and improvement of the property based on the appellee's express promise to convey an interest, and allowing the appellee to retain the property would result in unjust enrichment, despite the absence of a written agreement.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Conveyance Set Aside Due to Constructive Trust: The court held that while the appellant failed to prove undue influence, the evidence supported the finding that the appellee held the property under a constructive trust because the appellant provided substantial consideration and labor for the acquisition and improvement of the property based on the appellee's express promise to convey an interest, and allowing the appellee to retain the property would result in unjust enrichment, despite the absence of a written agreement.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision was cited in the final order regarding the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%&'#())* #+''#()),
-. --. - .
(/ 01 ! $) ()),
2222222222 !" ! "! # !"""$!%&'("& !!"
"!
33 --. .4-5 -6. "( )*!&+,-./01
!"
6-2,76
- 3
,8 9& ::::::::::!!""$1(,)4,"!!1(# ,))3"("(;;(&04<",))3""'&&$==" !>?"6 !"!"8
-8 # &(!" &@&" & /. A" ,))) @!( =" >" !"" & & $" B "!1 ,3 A1! ,)))8 ! & &!"B"">"@!((&"!1!&0-/A1!,)))8
/8 !!"("(&( !! ::::::::::'"""(& !"="(&&/.1!,)))&@ "(""&"!1& "" ! C==" (&D & -7 A1! -, =(1!! ,))) &@ "(&7.E&--=(1!!,5!,)))80,7!,))) "" !1!( "(&"!11 (!&&@ "(""" !1B "!&-7!,)))8
58 # ! !" & ,. ,))) & ! :::::::::: !&; & !&;! >&!1&="& !=@" ( !F"! & ( !"0! & G ' @% ("! >+;' !"'( -* <",))) !!::::::::::!;8
78 -3,)))! ::::::::::!(("&"("! "(!( &$!"!('!(1((>!&&=$( ! /65 !"!& !(567&@!">!1& !"" "! >+! "(!! " & ( &(;((!"1 1 &!""!6'8
48 ,3 "$! ,))) ! H:::::::::: (& "!"" &'( '@ 1" @!( & ,5 ,))) " '@ @1" "( ! ("" &( != &"%"&@$"; !""8("" $'@+" (""&( != !(%""B@(1("&,3A1!,)))""! !" 1 (!",))38
*8 -- "$! ,))) ! :::::::::: " I:::::::::: " &'( ' "" 1" (A!( B ' & 0>66 & ,/ "$! ,!"$! ,))) J 1" ("( & ! ! 1 & !(&! &!"&!=!!"!&"!8 "(&"!1B!" (""(1(B,..E&0/"$!,)))8
38 -- &($! ,))) ! :::::::::: !>"; &'( (&6'@1"1@!(B'! !"!!",)))8 ""(&@(""(!( !0"!"" "" 1"("( !!!G"&"!1&0-7!,)))8 !0"!""$"!
2,34)2-..5 6/2,76 ' ""1" "(&"!1&,..E !""'@&1 !"!&>!; (!!B,.K;8
)8 ,,-4A1!-...@!(("(> "(B1&!>"; & @I? " " ! &@ =$!+;8 # ! !" & !::::::::::"L::::::::::&-3A1!-...@%'&!> ("" !!" " &==(!" ;! =="( "!" !!&!8+ ""; !""1"("(&((&0 !!1( ! ! ' 1" ("( 1 (;" ! !1 & +>"!8 ""("" !>!; +>"!'B;"!8
,.8 ,*A1!-...!&::::::::::"9::::::::::&( !""& +>"! & @I? " " " &;"'( ("" &( != (10! !"(!"' +>"' & "%" & &! >!' "" + "";(""%!$("B""!&@=" & ""8
,,8 &"&,7!-...@!(&( (&&& !"" !0& @== " & @!61&"( M6 !0N O 1" B @$"" &@ !" ! &@ +&! "6"!"' & $; " & =$!+;8
,-8 !!! & ) -... (&P & @!6&" ! ::::::::::&'(' ""@1""(-7A1!,))) ! & &! $6!( & 4 A!8 @+ 1" & " &@&"B""( '"$; !"&& !' ""1"(&@$("!""8
,/8 # ! !" & ! H:::::::::: @""" & @ @!( ("" "( "" & "!1! &0 -7 ,))) ! &!( &("!( ! & =$!+; &@ +&! &!% "6"!"' " & $; >!'8 $" ! ! & "!1 $" &==8 "" ==!" !0" &@ ("" &( != ;!1 &==" $ !@""8
,58 5 ! -../ @!( ("( %( ! " & #!1 (& !(; ( M6 !0N #9O ! ! :::::::::: +>"! ' &;"'("!$ &@& ""'@=$!+;8 "& @%#9@(""&( !=@(""&(@!(& &=-..-"A" &!?"!&""="8 "!$ & @& "" 1 >! &( !1 """ !$&"( +>"!'B=$!+;'""B;G!@!( @"!F" & !"!" " & !" (&8 @$ &@(1" +>"!' """" & @(1" & "( & "!1 %;$ 1" "! ' ("" +>' ("" "$ 1 ! !&@"1"(B7.E&0,!A",)))"B,..E&0,!A"-...8
2,34)2-..5 652,76 ,78 5 A" -../ @ =!( @!( '@ &6!" &@1&"( !"1!( ! (!&&,!A1!/. "$!-...8
,48 ! &( & -4 <" -../ @ "!+( B @!( &6!" &@1&"( ! (!&&,!A1!/. "$!-...8@%!(( ! #9 !""" & &(!! ' @("" & "( & @!( ("" "$1! !&@"1"(B7.E&0,!A",)))"B,..E &0,!A"-...8
,*8 ! !!! & ,- "$! -../ @!( @" ( B "" &( &'" G"! "A! "( "" & "!18 !" " #9 ("" !1 B & ! J @1" $ '@ % +>"!'8 &&" & '@ 1 % !" "=="(!";&@$!1""!8
,38 4"$!-../!H::::::::::="1!B@ '@ !" !'!#9@1" !(&('@B(1" +>"!'" !>";' 1 =$!+; " =" ' @("" &( != @("" !!&;"B!"!&&& 8
,)8 * A1! -..5 ! :::::::::: !>"; !(&( B % ' ! " & #9 " ( &;" & "!$ &(;((!"= $! (";( &!" " =$!+;8 @% ;((! ("" ! "" @%!;'8#!$&@0"&@(1"!' 1"==!!' !$("'&!( !@!( @("" !="&@&!>"&@;(''8 &;'"@!( !(""&"!$&(;((!"=""$' 1" ""= % '! + ""; (1'( ! @!( '&("!"&""="8 "(&"!1%;$("" & ,..E ! "" ' @!( "!! " " &$" ="">!'@(1" !"&>!; (!!B,.K; '@"!1 !"6B6=%""' !;(&"!!&; 1$!"8 0 & A1! ,))) "1"( ! "" "" ="!"("(%;$! $6('8
-.8 ! &( ! " & * A" -..5 @ =!( &( "8#"B@ "%'!>";'1"("(=="(8 "!$&(;((!"=$!'"!6&'" !=&= & $==" 1" ("( (1& "1"( & "( ! "" ""="!"" $B " 8
-,8 !"&3 "$!-..5@!("!A"(!!"!""&( !6 &1" !$"&!"B""B @"!&@!"B,..E8
2,34)2-..5 672,76 --8 # 1 (& & #9 & -* "$! -..5 &! " & @("" ">+' " & @!( ! (& "!"" ("" !"'" ! $ B @% +>"!' & #9 ! ! ' @+ 1" & !"! ;;!1"8 !"0! !""" & !F"! =$!+; 1&" @("" ! @1 & (& "!"" '"B@ "(&"!1 1" G"!18
-/8 !( &-*"$!-..5@ !A"&!!8#9 1" %( @!( ! !>";' " +>"!'8 !!"" ;$"& %'@ ("" $&"!1! B " & "1"(& "(&0&A"-...'" 1&"(8 ! "! @ "( & "!1 B 7.E & "" "1"( A'@ & A" -... !""" & $((=! &@ &6!" &@1&"( & ,!A1! /. "$! -...8 !" $! & !"0! &1" G"! ! ! 1!!F"!=$!+;1&"8 !"0! =" &(=" @1&"( @1" ("( %( ' @; & "" >+''$""B"%&.E8 "B@(!"&("" +>' @!( @1" &!" B !"" B "! & /. "$!8
-58 -3 A1! -..7 @!( ("( !! " !&" ! !" & !H::::::::::&/A1!8#! !""==!" !!("(;!! ""1"(>("@("" &"""(;!("8#& @1" G ( & =8 @" & " ((" & &"B "( !=""8@("" $& A"=! != & !" ! =" ' "" !" !=( 1 +>"!'&!JC@%" & !1"=''@1 ! +>"!&!!(""!@(1"&@&&( !1 !(B&@"!$!>&(&&$D8
#! "" $ !!" & '@ !("" & !$&"( +>"!' ;!1 "! !"0! ("" ! 8 ! &= @("&" & ! ( !( &!$ %"" !" &@"(;!" & "" ="" & 1 ("" +>' (""!"("""!""1"(>(8 ('!"0! 1&" & & &1" G"! !8 @!( !"" & 8
-78 ""&("!"("("!B@"(-=(1!!-..7"" ("(;!&(BA;! ! !$&(8
2,34)2-..5 642,76
-
,8 ;1!@!;"A&!MO("(&=("""(&0 ,!<"-../ !$"&! (&7A; &" !(&""16 !(&"7 ("",4A;!M!"8,"8 !"74 O8
#"B@"&@("&,4A;! ! !$=(&(! -*A1!-..5M H,/.,.4O!& ;1& "(,/=(1!! & ""!"!!;" !""" !$"&! & (;! ! B "! A; ""! & @""" & @("&1%A;!8
-8 =!(" B @!"8 74 8 , "8 >8 - !$ F" " '&""" !(1B@!"874&=(&(!! !";((! & &!" & ! & 4 "$! -... M6 !0N O !"1 "" B =(&(! ! @!61&"( & ,) A ,)7) M6 !0N O8# (" !A;!&&@ 0"("$8
/8 " "!( 1;! ,! A1! -../ "!F" &=" & $! & " (; & & & @!61&"(8 &@ 0!"""=!(; !& "1;!A'@/,&($! -..-(;!& ! '&>;"&!0;&&!" (;" $!"'(""1;!!&!("&@("" & =" ' &" G"! !(( A!&'" ' & (' A!&' M H,-*54*&8,Q,-4,44O8
"0!& !(&!""=& "& @ '"B" &0"!(1;!8
58 ( (&=!"&( ( ! !("!!"!1$ 1!"&!"874 8
78 #@!"858,! @1&"(& !(""&"& "( & ; !(( !" & ; &!( ' !(" &@ """ B "( >+' " !1" &@ =!"( ;(" &@ & &@ &"8 @( - !( ' @1&"( " !( "( !1 &0 '@ " ! "! " ;!1"( ! ! B 1!! &!" % !"""!"&(!"8
&!"B!""&("!( !@!"8-38,! '& '@!( &!"B!"@"1&B5. !"8!"""0! ! 1&"( & 44 -2/E " &@ & ! 1&"( &
2,34)2-..5 6*2,76 7.E " &@ '!" ! 1&"( & 5.E 1!" & &%0(8
!' 1!" ! @!61&"( " &" &!" B & !"" " $(!&="(&%8!A;!&'"A!&'' " !; &@! " A; & ! &1" &0 ! $! ! & &" ' " ("$ "" ! & (& M H,--,73O8 1"$!!! !"&&( !@== % (& "!"" ! % !" & (" %"(!! " ! % !"'( ! "! &@$!1" !(( B " ==" M!"8 4) 8 - " *-$&!0;"!@!61&"(&,*A1!,)4,6 O8
&!&@(1"&@1&"("R>&(&"B !"! A;" ! @("" & "( " B &'! & ' ! " ! ' "1"( @!( " $ & "!1!8 "! &( (& """ ((" " ! &("!! ' "!1% " ! !$" %;! & @!( M H ,-7 -4, &8 5Q ,,7 ,/5 &8-Q,,5/,5&8/Q,.7,7O8
&!"=(&(!=% !! "!0!&@ !(!+ & !1 ! &$! !("& !1@ '""0! & !(&!&"!"18
S 0! ;((! !( &S1 (&% "!&"! A; &" !(!S$& !1B& ""&'!"= !' =&! !(" "?"'!"!8 "(;!&S(("&(= ! !(! 1! !$" &S 0 (& S" ! !;&(;"=!&S! !"&S% !"$" $ "8 !" ! =(!! 1! !$" B ! !" (& ' " ";% !"" " =" S$A" &S ("& !"( ' ! !" =& ! & % " 'S ! (;"&(!" "% !( ! !%('S "("(("$ &S0'&! "&"%" (& " S !(" & "" (& " ! " = ' &S% !""&<""1(M H,-7/7-&8/" !(=(!Q # -.., 8 ,.3Q H $( & ) 1! -..- /*)2.,O8
=!'S !(&! !"("$ !(&"!""A; " " &" "! " & =" ' S% (! (& "!"" " ;((!"&&"B !&! !" ! ""!& !"&='S"B&!!8 A! !&!& & &%"""=" ! ("'SBS !("&S "( &"!1 !(&&=M H,-7/7/&8/$2"!(=(! ,))7 855Q ,)33 87.5&8-O8
2,34)2-..5 632,76 ! ! ! """ B "( +>' ' 1" """ >+' !1'!1&"( &S!"858, &" "! 6 B !" & " ! !" &" 6 +>' ' ('1" B & &8 &0! & (' &S ("" +>' &= & & ==" B !&!>!; !S!61&"(&"& "(&; 'S!( !!" G>!=" !1&$1"(Q!& '"%;$&"G"!&("!($A"1"' $M H,.- ,47Q#-.., 8--5Q=8 H,-*-)3O8
# A! !& & "!$ "=! &!% 1" & !" !" &! B "( & "!1 M H ,-. ,,) Q 9 ,))4 -74 8 -,*O8 " "!$ "!" & "(;! & ==" +>' ! ' % !" +>"!' " ! (! '& S;" & !! ! S "( & "!1 'S " "$&S"!F!M#-... 8,4.Q H 8&,-!-..5 &"( B $" 43/2./O8 " " & &=="( "0! & !1B("$!S%"&&! "$A"1&S!( ==" !A"=!1&"(M"0! !"O8&!& S% & &!" % !"" & S! S(;" & &! &" G"! =!( ! & $!1" (& " B &(=" & ' !(" & &!" % !"" " G"! !( & 0! =!BS(;"(&"!""&!(M!!G"8 !("(&8-8-8-O8
! !"&S% !""""" !(&S""" +>'+"1!& &6"&"!$"=!&!%6"&"A!&' (! "" ! $ ==" ! ' S &""! "" & "( & "!1 "$ &S"!F! 1&"( M!!G" 8 !("( &8 -8-8/O8 ==" A! !& "!$ "=! &!% !"" S"!F" !0; ;((! "" & ; &!( & "( & "!1 1" &! B 1&"(&S!"858, 8% "B ! "&& J S"" & (& "!$ "=! &!%=""1"(1(!"('&S "&1$A"= 1!& "(&"!1 " !"'" 6!(!1 &&"&S%;(!"6!$"G"!%;(&S!( 'S!"G !"$ !("(M H,.-,47Q#-.., 8--5 18&8-$"!(=(!Q!!G"8 !("(&8-8-8/"!!G""(Q1! (;" H,-*-)3O8
&$ " & & % " !"0! %;$ &S ==!" & 1"( 1 & !"! &! " & !("(;!" & ! & "!1 & >' " !( =" &S !$&"( +>"!' &S "( " &S &!( !"" " &S"!!"0! !(""!"""(""8 !M,O&
2,34)2-..5 6)2,76 =="! !>!'&S !&=S("&"! ! (!(&!$M-O&S !"&S"(;!"&"" =""&1M/O&S("" +>'!"((1" $ ">(! "'!'""("S(>"$(!"& ! &!("&=" +>'M !=" !!"!(&&O=M5O &S(>&"!""$"!""!=!%!0;&S!" " &!& !(>$"" &( "& "1""&==!"& !!( !!"!=="&"!$"=!&!% M#-... 8,77&8-Q!!G"8 !("(&8-8-8/=O8
0 ! 'S S$ & !("" ! "' &;" & "!$ "=! &!% ==" ! A"=! &!" B & !""&S!$BS% !" +>"!&&!!; &%&S&'!BS&"!"M"A;&";O"& '!!(& &!! +>''6(;!&(;" % !"0! "( 6& 6 !""" & !"! &!8 S;" ! &S("$! & 0! $A"1 " " & """ +>' S!( " %!! "1"( ! !>( & "!1 ;!( &!'S!"M=8!!G"8 !("(&8-8-858"!!G""(O8
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
!(( A! !& %; !( =" &S !$&"( +>"!' &S "( " &S &!( !"" & "! !"0!8 !'S "!$ &( != ; "!$ "=! &!%"'S !F"!("B6""
2,34)2-..5 6,.2,76 ==" " &"" & +&! &!% +>;0 &S !$&"( +>"!'="&S"("&S&!( !""M H ,/./73 H $(&/.1$!-..54/.2./O8
48 S 0 &! "" & 0 (& =! ! ! H::::::::::(&"!""&S!('& ("+"%( @!( B && & (& ! !" & ' & 0>66 &% ! !" & @I? " " ' &% ! !" &@% M +>"!'"!>";'Ob
S&"!" &"( #9 ! '@ !( & % ! &% (&&" ("!>";" (" +>"!8 &!! " !" &;" & "!$ & @& "" 1 >! &( !1 "" !( "!$ &(;((!"= $! (";( &!""=$!+;8
@% +>"!'&5!-../!"'@""" +>"!'1" A"=(B "(""&"!1&!"!" (!& B 7.E &!" "! (!&8 @" ! $ & "( & "!1 !!$!( !"! !! !"&"" +>"!'&@I? " "&,*A1!-...'1"&;"'(( &&( !=(10! &&!&=$!+;'@("("!+(!"&@1&"(";8
@>! " "!$ &( != $ " !( " "" '@"!$&@& ""1>!&( !18
@% & ! !" & #9 !" & 1! '@ @%" & & +>"!' & "!$ & !"( !$& & "" =" ' " A"=! & " & 1 (&6A!&' &@ "(&"!16&B&&"=%( !#98
@% !>";' & * A1! -..5 @("" !(1(( ! "" @%!;'8#!$&@0"&@(1"!' #9 ==!!' !$("'&!( !@!(@("" !=" &@ & !>" &@ ;( ''8 &;'"@!( !(""&"!$&(;((!"=""$' 1" ""= % '! + ""; (1'( ! @!( '&("!"&""="8
! !"&@%	"&("(=&"!("&"""1& &! !" &(!" "" (& & S!( & $ $ $A"1" ' $A"1"8 ! !&! ! (""=="(&1!%" !&(!" " ( ! S!( " " ' & S0 M= != ! +"0 ! +> " +>"!'O8!"&<""1(8! !"! ""
2,34)2-..5 6,,2,76 " "%; ( !A! !&"(6&"+ ('&!""!$! 1! !$"8
"!'"!"&! !"""!0 !>&% ("$ ! ("&@I? " "A1!-..." !""! +>"!'"!>";'8
! ! "! !(" (& !"0!" & (& "!"" & @!( ! ' =& !!" " & "!B!""!'"&! !"b =="S;" & S1 & (& "!"" &" ! !" " " " 1"'	'"=!"&S&& ("8
1 & &;" ( + & ! S%" &S !$&"( +>"!' &S "( " &S &!( ==" !"" ! &""! 'S==!"&1"(1&!"!&!"&!("(;!! ! &"!1S" %;$& !"&!!"8
"! '@ (& @ =!" !" &;" & "!$ "=! &!%8 "= =$!+; 1(!( " != &(!( "!$"=!&!% ! +>"!&!" '@ + &@%! !( (1" & !"0! (1& ! A! !&&" !"&S !(!!"0!1&"&"!$ "=!&!%8!!"""'@!("!"0!8
!1" '@!(! "=="1" ! !& %6M& &!"!0!'(O'=&" !" &(=1!$'!S%;$"(&S! !&S"1"( !=8 @!(& @" ="(""& !"!(!1($!& &!!"8
!!!"0!"!"B !(&"!$"=!&!% !"" &@ ==" ! ! >!' &@ ! &= S("&" ! ! ( !( &!$ M,O8 #! " & "!$ $! (";( " ("( !" &;"'( ! (&8 "!$"!"=! "(&"!1&!!"& !('" ! !"&>!; &"&! " !("& &''@1(!"$(!"" G"! ""(8 !" (!& " ! "! & 1 & @!( & !" !"0! & ==" ! ! >!' " G"! " !("$8
!1>S !F" B"!&! !"(&%=;!"&! ' !!" $!" !" &S"(;!" & "" =""&1M-OG@" $'@11'' & ""&!"!"8!!";!&(&$!"1="
2,34)2-..5 6,-2,76 1@ !F" $" !"!$(8 "(;" "! ! !(& !'!&"!(;0!"1"8 "" & A R; & "( &S! ! $"( & !" "R> '"&'S(&"&="=!"&""!'SS ( ( "" !! & ""18 !"0! " & G"! &(!(! 8
S%" &S ("" +>' !"( !'" "(" S(> " $(!" & ! & !(" & =" +>' M/O !" G"!&!>!&( !1 !&! !""("" &!("A"= &&"& "(&"!18
= !" &""! S%" &S (> & "!"" !"'( =!(" % !0; & S!" &( " & "1" " & ==!" & ! !( ! !"! ==" & "!$ "=! &!%M5O & ! J 6 @ ! % A "( & 0!(! +>"! +>;8 !"!!"1 $ $! & "!"" ' @" ! &@(!! ("" & "( " !"(&"(;"("&!'(&@1" & 1(!"$"B !$0""!H::::::::::8&!& @+&!"0!&"""=&;!'@!(@ ( ( "'(""==!"8
!F" & ' "!$ +>' ="" 1 (1(!"("'&S "&1$A"=%"""1! & "( & "!1 & !!"8 "!! + &S&""! !"0!%;$&S==!"&1"(& !"1&!"!&!" &!((!!& !&"!18 "!$ +>' !("( ! S"(!( S"!F"6 B ; "! & "" & "( & "!1 "$&&!B1&"(&S!"85 8
!"!""""' G>"!!"&@%!! != & & & $==" &1!" G"! ! &(!" & =%" & "" "(8
1 """ "' "( & "!1 %;$ & ,..E &" G"! !" ! "" ' @!( "!! " "&$"="">!'@(1" !"&>!; (!!B,.K;"'@"!1 !"6B6=%""' !;(& "!!&;1$!"8
*8 !" B %! @1&"( ' &(8 #@;" &@ !( +" &< "!! !!"1"(!"1 !&&&@&"" '>& "!"B%!!"1"(!"1"%&S1&"( &"G"!&("!(!!"B(">&;((!& !&!1
2,34)2-..5 6,/2,76 M !!!"@1&"("@ "&@!61&"(6 T/..)O8
!@(1"&@1&"(!1&"!1'@1& !!"$"! %!U" @"1"( '@ " !$" ""&! & !0 %(" (1"&!&!(& """ ""&@""('$!(& !>( & "!1 " !( !1 '@ !" $"! @ @("" 1&M!"-38- O8
#" &("!" ! ! & !1 ! !" %"" "&&&!"B!"'&="(1" !1A'@"&&('"&('!&!"B !"M H,-)---Q H 4*.2.,&-=(1!!-../O8
"!&A! !& !("(@(&("!" ! ! !@(,)))&!"'!!"!"("( $&! !&! "1"(& "((""&"((""""!& !8
#@;" & !1 1&"( !!" & &! '@ " J !!"("1"( !=,)))("" +( &&$==" !!&/S...=! +(&V=@8! 1&"(,)))@(01&B/4@...=!8M/@...%,-O8
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
2,34)2-..5 6,52,76 "& 1!&S !("&=="&="!!!1&S1& " " & S$ & !" & !"8 = " !(&!B&(&";$ (!!B-7E8S&"!"&""1! $!01" &(&" (!(8 " A; " "= !"" $""! !(" B & S&"!" M H ,-4 *7Q # -..- 8*.O8
S!! " " & @"1"( (;0! & $""" ! """' & !(=(! " ' 1" !("&! = =="" &"1"( "!( (""1&"!& !&",))3B1! /@7.*=!8 !M 'G"!"!"!&!,))3"$ /Q T,.6571&'="5O8 !$!""&!&("" " &S >!! & "!1 & '!" >! " &!( >$&&! =(!!B+&"! !M5,)>!,))3Q== =(&(! & """' >==! ( & !>( & "!1O "" &" G"! !"(B/@4*5=!8M/@7.*%5,)25.O'&!&55@.3/=!8 ("( ! @( ,))) ! $ & @& & ! % ! "(;! & "!1! M= 1!0!Q ,))3 W ,))) W O !1&"(,)))"&55@/4,=!8M55@.3/%-/)52-/*)O8
#@;" & &(&" B !"! B "" & !!G" & -/ "$! -...M H $( ,2..O !$=(&(!&'('@ @+1" &!"!$"""&,.E!&""B& "1"((;0!& &!&@"1"( "!( (""1'!1!" "!& !&""&!1!!;!&&!;(1"&S"1"( ' !1! "" "(;! &" 1! 'S $! ;="= & "1"("(;0!" !"""S"!& """&& "( >& & !( ' 1" =="! & "!1% !& " &" (1"! """' !;(8
'@"G&@>+ ">0J@!""$"""&-7E ! !(""%&$"'!"A"=(@ 0"" '!11&"(@(01!"B//S-*,=!8""(;0!"=(!! !1&"(8
@ ! "" 1 !1 1&"( M[/4@... P //@-*,]2/4@...%,..O$"&!"&;!(&@1&"(&*4E==" ! !""!@"!& !""&@!61&"(8
!!!(10&0!=&("&"G"!!A"(8
2,34)2-..5 6,72,76
3 . -. --. - .
!
70898 : ;88 8 4" $&( .<=
98
,8 (!!!!1$8
! 98
-8 !A""8
/8 "' !(&!";!""8
58 =! !" & '@ 1" =!! !! "! !(" !!G" & &( & /. A! &0 "=" ! !&( &!( !$ =(&(! & ! #>XV!>=' 4 4..5 "! % !8 &( " G"! !;(8 (! &"N O &'! %""'&(!!"&(!$"!" &&( ""'(Q $O % ! ! ' "= " 1! &&! "" "! &(Q O !"! ;"! & ! !(""8 # (! "" "! ((" ((!( ""! O $O " O 6& !$=(&(!&! !! "!!"0!!!!'@ &1!&(!!!!1$8(!&!!"!!+ & !1 ' !" A" ' &( ""'( " @1 & '("(% (&(!!"M!"8,/-,.4",.3O8 ;!==!N !(&"N !! # $# !("!6A!"N 9!I 99
=!& !("!!G"""=(% !"'@B@===(&(! &! !;!==
2,34)2-..5