Enforceability of Unilateral Modification Clause
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed whether a contractual provision allowing for unilateral modification of material terms was enforceable, despite the apparent lack of mutual assent for the changes. The court reasoned that the clause, though one-sided, was explicitly agreed upon by both parties as part of the initial contract, which served as the mutual assent for the modification mechanism itself; therefore, the unilateral modification, made pursuant to the existing contractual language, was valid and binding on the parties.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforceability of Unilateral Modification Clause: The court reasoned that the clause, though one-sided, was explicitly agreed upon by both parties as part of the initial contract, which served as the mutual assent for the modification mechanism itself; therefore, the unilateral modification, made pursuant to the existing contractual language, was valid and binding on the parties.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAUsed to declare the appeal inadmissible due to the nature of the decision under review.
Cited for the allocation of court costs upon dismissal of the appeal.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'((& "%$)"'((*
+ ,-+ + ,
./ % ! #' 0 '((*
!" #
#
$$ %& &'( #!" )#*+*, -
! !
&0.1&
1,
/2 "#"!3""4 % "& % !# /15#0++6/75#0++72
02 /1'!30++6)"#" ! % 48)' 4!# ##" 9!:!# "'))!#9 )" ) $#" ;# <# !! %'#" 8'2 =" ># ## % #4# '# 9!:!# ##":= ) ?# :#= # ))'!#9 # % 3? 9:# ## %#)9#!#'" ! )4#=4!# 9!:!# "'))!#9)!### #'!))) !# 8 =%%'# ##" )@#)4#@# % ")##2
*2 " 1 "!30++6%44": )!#AB@#" ! %"'%C)")4#4!# 2
D2 %" 4!" ))# 6 @' 0++(2 ":" = !:" ## '# ) "## !) ) # #!) "@E )='# " " '4!##4 # ## ?F!:2)""' "3#"')"#" ! %#!#)"3!)## 4#=) )3 "## !#" # =% #3 0++6 %'# #@ ) #" 8244#3'=!# 4!#' % ## %!3? '# #@ "#" 3 = 4# )": ))#')#'%)'#E!)@#E#!2
62 " ))# 0D ' 0++( ) "!# %44 # %!)4!" " %2"#":"=%" "##3""4 %4!#!!)"!)8#' ") 0++*#)#4#'#0++6=%@#) )" %C)")4##=%?###)8 %<)" !!3#C#3# )8 %## #""!!## ## #' # 4 !! )8 G H 2 H%:# :#= %" "#" '" = 4I "## : !# =%)#"'###!!#%:# )#":!# %3 '! #2
)"!#@:"=!)## ##4!# ?#' # C)")4)"%"##) "!#"=! # ) 44# %!" 44#'!# %)## )!# %" = %'# % 4# "## % )@# )" )3#" 8#
./,*(.0++( &*.1& %::!##= '!)J)##)C!)2 ))#= )#":#@) "###8##' !#8 ) "!# @:" =% %))## ) E %& ?F!: ) ?:5# #"2
(2 0, ! 0++( %" #@#" # ## "2 C)= = %# ) =% #'" : )" ?F!: # 44#" !3?? %!)'=%) "! )#!30++6 '4!##E; %'#" 8'4 )4# :# "'))!##!" )## )!# %) "#": ) ) !# )3 !?" %!)2 : = !:" 4# =% ) % 4!# )# # % C)" )4 "3 # ?F!: ):#!)24#'=)#!)))? "" )4!# %!#2 H !)J ??# 4!# 9)4#9 )#= # #?"=28:4'I )! %!3?E?=4=% 4#E4!#=#2
72 '#"E)%#!" ") 0(@0++(@# 2
%## # /75#0++( =# C)=">### %3"#:#2H )"# "'#: %>##)#?"=)=?#"!)"# ) 4!#:# "'))!#))#=2"44!"= ### %!3?##"=4# !### 4!###%### !)J)##2#!#& =% % ) "#J ) # & = # !)J # "#" )>#"?"#E%::## #2#":"%') '"#3 C)" )4 ! K # "# # #'" ?L M # 8: N ! %J # )"= :#=2
# C)=" ' ## !>! ' 4!# = "3#" )#!30++6#%#?'"@0++(2%#:"')3 '="#"'=%)#'4!#!= )F! # #J" & % "# C! & =%)8 )!# 4!#2"C!2
=# '="###!#"# !)JE ": ") =%%'#!?!#)?:")=%%#) )"' % 4!# ) = %'# ) 3# 4!!# )F!2
./,*(.0++( &D.1& ! )"## %#!" 4# != ) )# = ==%#)# 4!#)#>#)!)# !O ! 4!# '#># " E% C@ '# "3# &P % ! # )' =% ! '!30++6=4!# "3#")#!30++6 "@E2
H)##C)="=% "3#"4!#'# %3# %' % %# ) =% % ' 8 ) )!8 4 =% ! '!30++62
,2 D)#!30++(#)""'3#" #4 ":4 4!#2
00!0++742)3 4!#=# "#"# =#" #"!2 C)="=# )# 4!# # %C)" ## C:" ) )' )#) E 4!#2@#"=##@!#"?# =## HP4!# )"#))#" #))#"9)9 '##244##))#8!#)=# #">#)##=8' !##=)'##3""4 4!#2 #"! =" = 0/ )#)# E 4!# '# # )J ))# #'# 4!# )# E %"#: 4I )= J#"!#=2 #"! C)=" = ## 4!# # E ) 4# = :# ## # '# ! %# )#= # )!# "#!# :# K ) 3@#4 4! ) )#= # !:!# ! ":!#=### :###P )4###CJ)#)# %2
,
/2 :' 00'!3/,D/Q:#@ AP02+6B "#"! 4"###" 8/5#0++* 3# A HB !)" = @: # )" # # '&)" # =))"##L@:A#2/#2#6( B2
02 4!"!# E %#2 6( 2 / #2 ?2 1 H R# # = ### )"' E Q# 6( 4" " )# :"" # A P1*+2/B#'E4" " 06@ /,10 Q&?F!: 3:# # Q !#" Q'3#"A B2H!)"#)@: Q)8# "#32
./,*(.0++( &6.1& *2 #@#" #!) # # 4! = # '3 A#2 (+ 2/ B2
D2 #:)#)# '# #!3!#) %&?F!: 4 2
62 B!!#'!?" #'AS T?)#( '': )/@#0++*S/701/766TB4:# ! 4!# #!!# ' #4 ' )4#!# %#":# )#)# E #) %#R!###: 4!#A#2(+2/ B2
3B %#2 6, 2 0 4C #8 C= '# ") ! #' !?" #'2 !8 :"" '# E 4' %#":# )4 " # )!# # 44 ) ?"# !?" %!)2 ! # #!!# ) 3# %!" %)## )!# " !8 E )!## "# ) # 3 A#2 B )!' =4# )4 "4# 3 !?" #'A#23B ! = ?F!: : " A#2 B # )!## C " %="C)")4A#2 B2
#C)## %)')4#!# %#":# )4 # " E ## !?" #' K !#'!?" #' '#>#!'= # #!# !! " ) %"## !?"2 ## # )!# %"'# %# )## = %# ))# ' %& ?F!:2 =# ))E%#26,2/ #* %C)! "! E %#2 6, 2 0 A: 4" " # ' 4" " Q&?F!: 3:# # Q !#" Q'3#" 0@#/,1+$$/,1+(/7P42E)) % #K $//0*,1 2////07/#D++ 203P /,,,U/0)2(6 2/#"4"B2
B'?4!# 3#)!#:"" )4#!# )4 %!3# ) E %&?F!:2 & ) #V? !# !3## )#?F!:44#4!!# ) ! 8# %#":# = %'# 3# "4 E Q#26, 2 0 #2 E 2 # Q: ! )!### E Q" Q )#):8 ###?= !##E)4#!?" #' ? #'#" #' )"4= #" )## )4C##A42E)) % #K $///07D#D++2 # "4"P /,,1 U *, )2 00/ 2 /3P /,,+ U , )2 6( 2/B2
./,*(.0++( &(.1& (2 B!##4!# 3=)4#!#)4 :"" Q)#!##)4#!#)4 Q&?F!: Q# )# Q# '# ) ## A $ /+1 /((B2 <## "=Q#!>!!)#)"# ###"#= C ! # = 4!# )4 4' Q?3# ":!#Q)## )!# Q"!?" #'# "4 )#=)" !#: ###8# )# A $ /// 07D 2 0 # D++ 2 03P /,,+ U , )2 6( 2/P' $/+1/(6 20#"4"P># $ D#30++/ /*,.+/B2
3B )4#!# )4 %&?F!: 4# # ?= 4!# )4 = ":# !)8# "@E= )423# )4#!## )!##E%" ##4 !>!: !"#=C" )"" !!#2 %&?F!:4E##=! J:)!###E" % )#C):8 ## #?=)!### )'>#E')!##4 )4 : A ! )"'#' # " )## %&?F!:; V/,,0UD(D)2*/,B2
B # E ' )# ># #" 3@#4 )4 #!# 44"# 4!# # %"2 )# #'4!#! # "%")8 "@E 4!# 3 !)8# A#?"= )#=B )4 = "# ) E #' %!) A )2 # U D(6 )2*/,B2
B ! #) # #!!# ># )"4=!# #" E !" %)## )!#P #>#" # "=#2#' )3@#4)) %!"' 4!# %"## "!= ! # '# ## )!## E & %:!# ?!?" #':""2
4#) "# #C#%V:!#'# # ' %"2'# %C! #! =# 8' ) % !8 % # 4!# )4 ! %#"" # & ## # # !# ?:" & # ":!# 4"=#" % %'# ) "#" ?F!: A !" ?F!: !!#P 42 $ )3" /D(.,7 *5#/,,1 2/3.33P /,,/)2///B2
3 4" " )"" ' ># =Q 4# # ) !"# )"4= Q#&E& 3## Q)##
./,*(.0++( &7.1& )!#244#)=! ! "!" !8:"" ))#' "!= # )42 !"# )## !)!###) Q'#:!!" #)Q)## )!# Q)844#)E") CC: Q#26,2* 24# =Q J # )33#" '"" =Q )4#!# ' ))#' Q 3@#4 )4 # !" 44#'!# # 3##!# Q)## )!# Q)8 A #' C! !?" #'S T *0B2
"#Q##" #'#":!# =# ' 4"=##!"3##!#Q)## )!#2 34 : Q!" #!# ) Q)## )!# Q" & )8 # : =# A *DB2
%)8# = #= )8 "@E 4!# ' '# :#= !)## # C)")4#2 !)## ""!#)) %###3 "# %'=4!#=#Q#) )3EQ")#')#2####)## ))"!# ! # "#!# ) Q3## Q )# #'2 # 44# !## = )!# Q" # !)3#8 44%#)4!#=#2 )# # % ) ))# ""!# # '!33 = # 4!#'#8#!# )3#" %!)2=%"#" ))"))!#:"" )4#!#)4%!3 ) E %&?F!:2 # ! # '# ## )!## E %" %:!# ? !?" #' :"" = % ) "#" )'"%2H4!)# !?" %!))# 44#>##""2
72 ' =)"8 #!)## Q!3 #4 # ## = = ) # ## ) ! )#3 Q!"8#!#)## )!#2## @#"# "#:4!"2
./,*(.0++( &1.1&
2 ,1 ,-+ + ,
!
345 .. 6 7 8 9 #&' :
5 .
/2 "'32
! 5
02 @##2
*2 #=)" #:##2
D2 4! )# =Q )'# 4! # )"# ># " *+ @ 8 #4# )8 3 4" " AH?WL?4=((++D B)' !#8 # )34!"!#C#210 4" " 34" " /7 @ 0++6 A $BP !"! # = !#4 # !J )'#)#:# # ! #P # ># " 3 4" " ) ' )# ) ' "#= C # %#2 D0 $2 )"# ># # )8 ) #'="!!!J )' '#>#@#E%'2 :448 " #K $$ XH X
)4! )"# >###4"C)##H"## Q##E Q"!):44
./,*(.0++(