Supersedeas Bond Interest Accrual Date Post-Appeal
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves an appeal concerning the calculation of interest due on a judgment, specifically focusing on the date from which statutory interest should apply to portions of the award that were subject to an appeal bond. The court reasoned that while the general rule mandates interest from the date of the original judgment, when a supersedeas bond is posted, statutory interest accrues only from the date the judgment is affirmed or the appeal is otherwise resolved, because the bond ensures the judgment debtor is not unjustly enriched by withholding the funds during the appeal process, and therefore, interest on the amount covered by the bond should run from the date of affirmation, not the initial judgment date.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Supersedeas Bond Interest Accrual Date Post-Appeal: The court reasoned that while the general rule mandates interest from the date of the original judgment, when a supersedeas bond is posted, statutory interest accrues only from the date the judgment is affirmed or the appeal is otherwise resolved, because the bond ensures the judgment debtor is not unjustly enriched by withholding the funds during the appeal process, and therefore, interest on the amount covered by the bond should run from the date of affirmation, not the initial judgment date.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
"#$%&"$''( ")%)"$''&
* +,* * +
-. )
! #$ / $''&
! "#$ % # !$ &!$'$##( )
$#
* ) ++ % !1# # ,, + "#$ % !$ &!$'$#-. #!+ /
$
# ! + / + ""! "#$ % !$ &!$ '$# 0
! !
.4233.
0+
39 #!35,:$#% !(355;"#<+ =" ( > 3 "9 4 $ ?@9 !$! 11 ! A * ) # ++ ( 3 B$ 355; = ."#( C *$ D ## # !1#431!%# #477;@9
49 # #-E$ !"! ? %# 4774 !"F $ $! # G"# (# $$(%"#! %#=" ( >3"96@9
,9 3; 4774 *$ $$$! &F $ & "#$$ #$ ?6&67; 1#9 $ $$ #! &$$$ &#! # " $! $#% F $$ " 34 %G# 4773 "#! $ -& &!$ $ " 11 ! H$ " G $!IG$ #"#$$ G#"J H$# $"$$ 9 F" -!- & " $!J % $"#J#&#!"## $ "E$#G!!1 #I"#$$ G#"J$-"#!-$ "## $"# $A$#1#$ %#=" ( 33"9,@9
?9 # 45 %# $ 43 4774 !"F $ %"#$J#"# $ !"#$$ #$ &#!=" (>3"96@9
89 #$$#3#$:B$4774!"F$1 #!#%$! %##$##"#$ K$11$ # %#=" (> 3"9:@9
;9 # KJ$ ? "$G# 4774 -! F "#$ "# " 3: "$G#4774 # G"# (# $"#! %#!"F 9$ (#"#!%H"#1 $$!-&!" G!!1 $ & #$ "#$ &#. % $! #$ -I "#!%H !$ $ !KA #%9 1 F! I $! !- $G A I!" A 4,&:8,1#9$$##"$A $ !"#$$ #$ &#!9 1 #!A*$ !G $#$$"$ G#"J &#! $ % ## #! $ "$ G# "J A %# # "# &F.
!"=" (>3@9
69 ""I!$! $#K$!$#KJ$#$-# #$% !1 $ 144$G#4774=" (>33"98@9
:9 *$ % #! 4,&:8, 1#9 %# 8%G# 4774 # "$ G# "J %#$ "# &F.!" "#( * ++ L +++=" (>4@9
2345624778 .,233.
59 45 %G# 4774 *$ 1#! # G "# (# $ -I&# $"B$#1!## $(#-&#!"#!$ $ " $! $#% $ G!!1 $ & $! "# "#$ J 1 $ G$%#$"#$$ #$ 9 -!-&% $ $! #!$# $$% #!"#(* ++ L +++=" (6$33"98@9
379 3, !G# 4774 * ++ L +++ #$ $! A *$ $$ 4,&57: 1#9 ;8 %# 36 !G#4774=" (>,@9
339 &#!!$! !%11$,7%G#4774=" (>33"98@9
349 47!G#4774*$ % ! # G"# (# $ $$ $ & 1#! -I "% $ " "#!# $#1#$ !$ 1 KJ$ %## $&#!#%# $$ (#" $!$#% $ !$ $ &11 G!!1 &#$#$# $$ "!(#-I !$ $MJ! " F$ $INH"$N( %# #$ $11 !"#( *$ $% $G!!1 #"$$ "#$$ I % $!K-IAIMJ #$# $" ($"#$$ #$# $=" (8$ 33"98@9
3,9 : K% # 477, # G "# (# $ 1 $ "#$ 1 $ A &F.
!" $ & 1#! -& "% $ "#!$# #!% %$ %#=" (6@9
3?9 ,#477,&F.!" # G"# (# $& #!% KJ$ %#9 A #!% KJ$ %# ? "$G# 4774 $ A $ F.# %#$ & $!!- $G4,&:8,1#9"HG " $1##$ 677 1#9 "$ - = $ ?4&777 1#9 $$@9 &"" !J! -& J# $ $ # # A %$ -I F $ $"EN$A G!#$ 1%#I"#$ 4(" #F.# #$- % $% !$$=" (> 33"9;$6@9
389 #"#$&F.!"F$-*$ % $"# ! ##! #1$ 1## KJ$ ( # -IA HF "#!%HI!$ $#%9 &"" %# F"!-I$#$ O " $!$#% % $!K-IAIMJ#$# $ I% $ $! "#!#$# $ "#$$ I % $!$I% $"#P- $! I#"#"#$J =" (>33"95@9
3;9 #KJ$3#!G#477, # G"# (# $ - #% $#""#$!"#%###- !$ $$ -
2345624778 .?233. #-I $ $$ "#! $"$#1#$#! G#"J 1%#I!"FG!!1 ## #% $" G $!&%# #$ $# I $ $$ "#!%H%$ # G"!$$9!-$$$ # $ ! ! # # A $$# # #!% K-IA KJ$ # G $ # # $$$ ""$ #AI $ $$ "#!%H=" (>33@9
369 *$ !A&#!#$#$# $(3#K% #477?=" ( >8@9
3:9 # $ 48 %# 4778 &F.!" # G $ # 9 $ $ !" -& $ & "#$ $$! - &#!&!$ $" % $KJ$ %#$-&# $A $ ! "#$$ #$ ! "# #! # J &$# "#$ #! A !1# % ## "# !G $ "$ G# "J &#! 4,&:8, 1#9 " $!#E$ 8Q #! $ "$ G# "J9 &"" $ $-& ##$& $#$ "#!# "# KJ %# -& $ # # &#! &!$ $ " % $- " $!$#% &!$ $-$"# ##$-& "#!%H "#1 &!$ $ #! ! # "#! %# $ - "#$$!!$1 $G$"#$J"#$$ #$ "# "# #KJ9K$!-&!$ $A$#$-!1#% $! #$ $$ 11%#"$&#!9
359 44 K 4778 !1# ! - &#! $ ""! 9 &"" F"!-& #% $#$% "#$ #$- % $E$#$%###"$ G#"J # $ !"#$$ G#"J- #$# J "#&#! . %# $G #!-1 (##"#$$ % 1$# -"!- %# $E$##! $#"$ %$-& "#$ %# $ E$##$ $!9
479 # ! 6 "$G# 4778 &11 $ &#. % $! = .
"#( C @ ! A &""! #$ $ (# & % $! 3# K% #,7"$G#477,G!#$F& % $!377Q$ .
#$& % $!(3#$G#477,1$ &J#!& % $!;8Q9
439 # # : !G# 4778 $$$ "#!"#$ #$ # G !""!&#!$ "#$ ! "#1 #% #" $ %9
449 3; K% # 477; # 1#! # G - &""! % % $ +!!J - $ # # "#!# %# " $%# GG$!!$"#$$$"#! #$A-
2345624778 .8233. % $ !"! #$ & % $!9 #- # G & $#"#$ #AK$9
4,9 3# 1!% # 477; !1# 1#! &""! -&A $ ! & $ %## #!$#$ %$ #$ & % $! 377Q 3# K% # ,7 "$G# 477, " ;8Q 3# $G# ,3 !G#477,9"#! !- # G$# $A%##A# $ !$$"#$$ "J # $ &G J$ "# $$ #! $ #$1$#9
4?9 ;1!%# #477;!1# -! # G!! & 6"$G#4778$## #3#1!%# #477;#!A&""! 9$# !#!-!G$& " $!$#% &""! !$ $$!# #"#! %##$-&&% $"A%## "#$$ #$ A # " - &!%!$ #! !$ $ !KA #%$"#! %#9
489 37 1!%# # 477; # G ! A & $ # &""! -# - . % $ !"! "#$$ & % $! $ & N $ $ $# "# #"#!$# "#!$ "#!#9 4;9 # ## # 43 1!%# # 477; !1# 1 #! A &""! -& $ %###$& % $!377Q3#K% #,7"$G# 477,A% ##$3&?8?1#9$#$% ,:31#9 ( 1!%# #477;9
469 4? 477;$ #&""! 1#! # G! -& !$ $!J$N#J!!1 $!#E$"#!$"#!#9 "# $$$$$ J#"! $ $.H1 $!$$$$& " $!$#% A377Q36"$G#3?!G#4773A87Q6 3,K% #4774$A377Q(3?K% #4774-&"#$$ &#. % $!!"!47K $477,9
4:9 5K 477; # G -!$$!# $#A#$A !1#9
+
39 %,$G#477, 1 $=3(##!% @$$#!% J# 3#K% #4778=#!#%#$ " $ $&$#!% J# !$! 1 F! 3# %# 477? $ 3# K% # 477; R 477? 3677S@ $#'$ 1 $ G# " $ !J "#!%H
2345624778 .;233. "#1 =477?3;66@9+#"$!# " $% #-# $ &"" - $ E$# $#N! A (# "# " - #(J "" G $ % J# $ O 1 $ K# -$ !$# $$"# $= *34;3,; 9?G$#!1!#@9
I"("#!$ $ J#%#$"#!1# $ ! "#$$ #$ &""!#"$ G#"J #A $ %#"#!"$G#47749$$!- 1 $ !$# $ $ #! ! %$ I$#! % J# % # $A#$ $E$#F !#J#& # $9#O $ !$! 1 ! "# % " $ ."#( $ $! # %# $!# #3#K% #47789
49 I%#$#I$ "#!%AI#$96,93I$ $A IG#%$ I ! =+ $$ F # 1!!#$"#!#$ K# "#NM$ 35:? "935D+ /T 0 /./ / N$"1JN+0+ 35:,"93:4@9
,9 $ J"#$#&G J$ & $ $$ "#!%H%###"$ G#"J#$$"#$$ #$ % $#F.!"F$#$ 1 !"#KJ %#9
?9 @ F $# &#$9 44 9 3 "# (# "N# * "#$$ #$ - #$# J$"#$J! %#1#!$F#$9 34434,3?3$3?4 % 9+"# (# " $ !J #- & !"F $ 11 ! A $ $$ "#!%H $ -& "#!%H &$ #% N- !"F # $ A $ ! "#$$ #$ K $!"##!# J=#$934493 @9 #$ $ KJ "$ #1# "#$J & !"F H ##$$$"#$ $=#$934, @9#%N#-& "#!%H $ #% "# & !"F =MJ #$# $ % $!@ "#$J &$ $N -$ " " G ( # - $$ #$ "# 11$""# #$$"#!$$ A"#$$ #$ 9 & " G $! "#!# "#$J $! !- $G # =#$934? D *345??; 9893$#!1!#@9
G@ # 1 $# " $ & $! !- $G A & K $ %#$ &#$9 34? KJ$ %# "$ "## # -& "#$ "#$$ #$ &!"F!G $## "$!# $ $!=#$944G 9 3 36 !G# 355, # G# "J R*S@9 # #-# $$ 1 (###!&!"F!G $#&$$# G$ & #$ & " $ &$# " !#$ 9 $$ " G $! ""
2345624778 .6233. $$1 -& "#!%H &$ # #% "# &!"F !G $# = *345?:: 9,9893$,9894@9
@+&#$94493*#$9,A8 $"" G"#J $#1#$"#$$ #$ - #$# J9 . %$E$# $ $#1!#! A & $ $$ "#!%H &!"F G!!1 # =#$9 ,@ $ $"#!%H$#1#=#$9?@#O $ " $"($"!=#$98@9
89 &"(K#&$#!1#"#! %#44$G#4774 "#!%H!$ $!KA#%"##" -&% $!$! # % $G!!1 $& .#$& % $!9"## %$- $ ! "#$$ #$ &F.!"F - "$ # J % $ E$# $#1!#! # "$ G# "J # KJ %# 1 F! N 11# : " $ 1 KJ$ $! !- $G&#$934? 9
!1#F!$!KJ$ %#% #$4,&:8,1#9 %# 8%G# 4774 # "$ G# "J %#$ "# #9 # & " $! $#% "#!$! "# &""! !1##!!A*$ G#"J# #$ $$ $$ -& % $ "#!G$ %#! F!$ KJ$ %#-&G$3,!G#47749
;9 H !$# # $&$#!1#"#! %# "#!%H!$ $!KA#%= *3,4?73 9494@9 $#$ $ 1$ !$# # - &%# # $ A #$ & % $! "#!%H"#1 9&"#(&#$94; 9 3 " $ =#$9 45 @ &"" -$ "# J A # $ F "#$$ & % $!9
+K# "#!J $#F"#$J% #"#!%H #% & "#!%H $ $ "# $ 1 "#$ -9 # #% & "#!%H 1$ $# & # $ #$ A "#$$ "#!%H "#1 - # " G "#$J % # "#!%H A G "#$$ #% 9 #%&MJ#$# $# $A"#$$ & % $! & K $ - & K $#% ! - & K !$! 11 ! A "#!%H "#1 #O &$#'# $A"#$$ & $ $$ "#!%H "#$ # "#$J % # "#!%H "#1 &$# K $ 1%# = * "G ! ,7 K% # 477?3527, 98#!! C+ +477?"9864@9
#%N #% 11$ % & "#!%H # "#$J % # "#!%H " G $ "#$$ %#!
2345624778 .:233. % #A#G9$$ NH"$N( ""#$ $#KJ %#
1 F# $$ & $! !- $G $$ "$ $ !!$ =+ 2*/ +U$#V+N J#N$3555 #$934?>,@9
$ (#"#!%H"#1 G J$ # F $#$ !$# $ %"#!J $#$## $A#$& % $!%#$"# # " #$ A#$EJ#F (" #=J 1!!# A &"" & "#K$ # "#!%H "#1 % #% %$ $ % $! 35 !G# 3568 356; 3?4 $ 477@9 $ #&#$94?93"#K$- ##"A&#$94;93 1!!# -!-$$#!J$$ "#G$ ## !G$# $F"#$$ "#!%H"#1 $!G$# $ A #$ &#. % $!9 " # G 1!!# # H & $#"#!$#&#$94;93-#% FW " $ 1!!# 35 K 3585 # &#. % $! =#$9 45 @ X "" G "# J "# 1 F# # $ A #$ "#!%H"#1 % -$&#$945 A&F &#$9?: 94 = * "G !41!%# #477;34?27? 9?9?94@9
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
2345624778 .5233. &"( & 1 F! &%#$# # $ A #$ 3# K% # 477, "# ! 6 "$G# 4778 $ G "#( &$#! 1# "#! %##$-&A$.A"#!%H&!$ $##% - # &""! 9 !- &$ A K$ $ $# - !1# % #! 4,&:8, 1#9 %# 8%G# 4774 # "$ G#"J%#$"##9
69 %- "#!( % $$$#-&#%N&$A$#$- !1##!!#$ $$ "#$$ #$ %#!A& $ $$ G#"J#%#$&#$9,*"##% &#$944 93*#-$#1#$ $ #" $#KJ$F!$ #9
#$ "#!% $-#-I $ $$ "#!%H$#1!#! "#$$ #$ A% $ $$ "#!%H$$# (#"#$$ $ E$##$ $!#O#$ $$ $! #"### " $ "#$$ I % $! "# #% %$ =#$9 , 9 4 *@9 &NH"$N( O &H " #$ $$ "#$$ "# #% %$ "#$$ I % $! I $ $$ "#!%H "%$ E$# #! $=#$9,9,*@9
"$ $# "#! -&!$$ ! - $#1#$ & "#$ "#$$ #$ A % $ $$ "#!%H . A % # K $ %#!.#"#KJ$F!$ ##$ $$ "#$$ #$ $ E$# "#!!! & 1 $ KJ$ 1 F$ "#$J % # & #!% %$ # 11$ "$# F %## % $$9""#$ $A&#! $ A & $ $$ "#!%H & $$# "#!# 1 $ #!% KJ$ %# =+ / % # $ %# $ $ $$ "#!%H#!%H"#1 3555"95?3@9
&"($$!%$ $!&$"##! !" -&""!&!"! 1 $ KJ$ %# #!% %$ #11$"$# F %#9
L$$ ! - !1# &!$ $ " # $ #!# A & $ $$ G# "J # #$ $$ "#$$ #$ #! H #A%##A%A& $ $$ G#"J #$$4,&:8,1#9
:9 % $#$#N#-$ $!#E$#$ #9
$ (#"#!%H"#1 $ - $!#E$#$ # $ "# !G $# # A 11!# $$ - "#!% $ %$&$#!% J# &$# &# =% # *3353,3@9# #A!1$ " $ #!J$ #$" -
2345624778 .37233. $F& $!#E$#$ #$8Q=#$937?93 D3,7?3? *3353,8 9?338,6 9:@9#- $"#$$ G#"J & $!#E$ #$ # $ B A "#$ # $ O "#$$ % $ F J G $ -& $#"$ &#! #! # $ ! # 1#!$ A &#$937494 D $"$! #-&%#$ $#!J # $$ " $ =&## $ "#-& $ $$ "#!%H$% !$ "#N #""#$$#% @$ $ ! # -$ $ $ # " $ = * 335 3,3 9?@9
&"( !1# % #! 4,&:8, 1#9 %# 8%G# 4774 # "$ G# "J %#$ "# # "#( *$ G# "J #! $ + 9 3, !G# 4774 # *$ G# "J # #$ $! $$4,&57:1#9;8%#36!G#47749$$!-KJ$ %# $ $#! 1# 44 $G# 4774 F!$$ % #$ 8 %G# 4774 # "$ G# "J %#$ "# # !1# " $ A $$ $ $$ $ ! # -$ $ $ # " $ #$ - &F!$ $#1#$ "#$$ G# "J !$ $ F J G A $$ $9 !1 $ % !1# G$ #$ $$ "#$$ G# "J 3, !G# 4774 $ $#%"#!-$E $$ "$# - &% $" F!$! KJ$ %#9 !- H # A %## $!#E$#$ ##$#8Q(8%G#4774
59 %- "#!(G 1!# 9$#%!-% #$!1##!J $ !A"!###!$ # "#$$ -& %# A &""! 9 # G$$ J $!3&7771#9 ##!A$ $#"#$ "$ A1# $!"=#$9:5/9, @9
2345624778 .33233.
1 +0 +,* * +
!
234 -- 5 6 7 8 #9$ :
4 -
39 !##%G9
! 4
49 I$9
,9 * ) ++ A %## A * ++ L +++#"$%#$ $$4,&:8,1#9" $!#E$A8Q& (8%G#47749
?9 !1#A%##A# $!3I8771#9A $ $#!"9
89 1# "#$ -I "%$ 1## ## $# "#!$ ##E$ ! ,7 K# ( $ 1 $ "#( # G 1!!# =+NZ V#N1- ;;77? @"#% ##$ (## $ "G 1#!$F#$9:4 1!!## # G1!!#36 K 4778 = *@D ! # ## $ -# $ 1 $ H"#%$"#$# J$###$$ #D $ E$# #! # G 1!!# "# % "$ "# % !$# - F $ &#$9 ?4 *9 "#!$ ##E$ $ " ( " ##$ %-!H"#% %$E$#K $A&% 9 J#11 (# "#! $ U# + U #!$ #.K# $C N "" )
" 1#"#!$##E$$$ 1 !F"#$ -IAI11 1!!# # "#J#11
2345624778