Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/384/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/384/2007 Generato dall'IA

Liability for Surgical Injuries Upheld on Appeal

Numero d'incarto ATAS/384/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party sought review of a lower court's decision regarding liability for injuries sustained during an operation, asserting that the evidence did not support the finding of fault against them. The court reasoned that the evidence presented sufficiently supported the lower court's determination of liability, as the record contained substantial evidence demonstrating the appellant's responsibility for the adverse outcome, thereby warranting affirmation of the judgment below.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; FIXATION DES COTISATIONS ; COTISATION AVS/AI/APG ; DÉCISION DE COTISATIONS ARRIÉRÉES ; DÉCISION DE COTISATIONS ; INTÉRÊT MORATOIRE ; DROIT CONSTITUTIONNEL À LA PROTECTION DE LA BONNE FOI ; PRINCIPE DE LA BONNE FOI ; PREUVE FACILITÉE | RAVS41bis

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
responsabilità dell'avvocato mezzi di prova medici risarcimento del danno alla persona dimostrazione di un danno irreparabile sindacato giurisdizionale decisione motivata

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the procedural costs of the federal court.
Generato dall'IA
A/2260/2004
Contributory Negligence Affirmation on Substantial Evidence Review
C/3722/2002
Appeal of Civil Liability Determination Upheld
A/1597/2005
Workplace Injury Liability Affirmation
C/27510/2018
Appellant v. Physician (Informed Consent and Causation in Medical Malpractice)
P/4250/2021
State v. [Accused Name] (Negligent Bodily Injury Appeal)

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the procedural costs of the federal court.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

           !"#$#"%&&' !!"($#"%&&'

!

  )!* !)+)!*  !!) + !*

,-  %  .& / %&&' 



    !"#$%  &&'

'&

((   (  (   ' ! ' )*+,"#$- 



                 

   0#.%0  

) ! 

"1 & 2 & !   '!  "3 2'4& #$$%  ((    (   (   5 02&6   7  8 9!  ' '  2&2& 5 02&6&&'7: '! 2&' ;2&!#$$"<#$$+1

#1 &&& &'!#/'4&#$$% '& <&&'!'' 2'' ' '!*=&  :&6>22 4 ' 6&? '!&*'&' &'4' ;&'! &2 ' 1&& &'  ':''!' '2@4A B$=&<&!2' 2&!'C1

B1 '!'4 :&&'2&!!2 '=&: ' ; ' :&!!'2&;< '%;4&#$$%1

,1 & && &  + ;4& #$$%  &&' ?!' ' ''8  22!  ;&'? '!&*'&' &&' ' && !&!1

+1 '3;4&#$$% ! '!&*'&' &&  8 ' ?4='  !2'  #/ '4& #$$% '   &!! <  &&'1 0   8 ' 22 '  &  / !4& #$$% ''' ; &  '!&*'&' &&!=<2@!1

%1 & 9 !   '!  + 8!;& & #$$/     &='!  22 '  ' 8 &! ? 2&'  '!&*' &' & &!! &  ' '  && !&! ?'&2&' '!&*'&' &&' ' &!!1D ='    6> ; & !'4   !2'  #- 2'4& #$$%  &' :   !' ' 2@4   B$ =&  '  2 '&  #- '4& #$$% '  :  2 '   !' ' 2&;  % ;4& #$$% '1 & !:' '!&*'!' ''&#-2'4&'%;4&1

/1   &&  3 8!;& & #$$/  &&' &2&  8 '    :  &>'''': '!&*'&' &2 '*'&;'''   &  &!8!&'      4 >' 1  ' :  !    ' 2& !:' !   :  & '  '!&*' &' &1

-1   &!2  "% & #$$/    '  &='  &&1  &22   2 '  22 4  ' 6&  ' '     2&'  &'&?&' ,"4 &6>'& 8!!&' 6& ?&;  '&; ;'5 02&6' (71&!86&<' #- 2'4& #$$% ' < :  & ' 8 ' 2&; & <  &&'  : !2'&' 89' ' && !&!!#$$"<#$$+1 6&



.,-,.#$$/  0B.%0   : ?!''  2' &  <  8     ?'4& ? '  &   !2'#-2'4&#$$%12& '9&& &

2 61E8 >&'''!2'' ' && !&!'!#- 2'4&#$$%@'?2'' '&' >!  :&& & #/'4&#$$%'?9' !1

31 2&6'&  ''!& '&<&&'#B&#$$/2&' ' !'! 8&!*=&:!' '>&!<=>&1

) + 

"1 8&!' < ?&'1 +%  1 " '1  )1"   & 4 '  & F' ' :''' 2&!;<G&'  +% : '&' ;< 8!!&&G&0;  '&; ;' #$!4&"3,%5 02&6 (71(2!'2&=>&G26 '  !'4 1

#1  8!!&&2&' >!!&& '& %'4& #$$$5 7'&!; >&"&=; &#$$B'22 4?261

B1 '&='!8& '! 2&!;2& 2&!'&&'&;4 5&'1+%<%$ 71

,1 9'&?&' #+ ( 2' 8 9'' '   2& ?!  ' '    !    ' '  ' !'4 '  '&' ' '2';&!1 '*'&2@! B$=& ;'8'&' 1

+1 ?&'  ," 4   ( 2&!; ' 2&  2' 9  &'  :  '!&*' &' & ' 1  ' '!&*' '  &:  2& '2@&' ' '2;&!B$=&<2'& '&2!& 2 '8'&' 2& 581,"4 1" '1     '   (71     ' !'& ' '  < :  8'& ' !'4  '  2    &   ' ' & 581  & &  ?88 8!!&& & '!&*'&' &'&!!&' & )1 ,$$,71  '  ?'& 2&' 2&  2& '  2@&  ' '  && !&! &!! 2&  ! '!& & 6  "& =; & :   '8 ?! ; 2&:'581&'1,"4 1"'4  (71

 2&! &:=& 2&'' & 48!!&& 5 02&6 H 7 8 & : ?4 >'   2@&  '!&*' &' & &  ' '  (' !2'' 8'1  '!&*'' :' 2& 4'  2&  8 ' :  !4 '& 4' '  '!&*'  &   2 '  88!&! ;'> ' ' 2&! !' 2& ;!  &! &1 6 & 



.,-,.#$$/  0,.%0   !4'& '!&*'&' &' !2'' 82&: ' '  ?' 2 !'! 2@! < '21  ?' 2 '& &  2&  2   48 &!&2&62 '!&*'&' &581 H #,=; & "33#    "33# 2> "// ' I H   %   "33#I H   ## =; & "33$71

 &&'   :  2&!6 :    !' '    ?26 8! < &!& '!&*'&' &&' ' !#$$"<#$$,&' :!  &"32'4&#$$%&'8 &!1

':'  '!&*'&' &&!!& 2 ' '&; %;4&#$$%12&  2& ' ;& '*'& ; 1

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

5 H "#,  ,$#  1 #4 "#"  %  1 B471 ?'& '! 22&'   !:  ?4  2&; 5  ;& 4 2&!2!&'I H  24 !#&#$$$ B-/.33I 1"71(?@=':&:?'& '! 2&6<9 6' 8 ' 0 '88'=&  :&!&;   K '&; ;' ?!)!  !   &&  ' '   ' &!&;; & ''2&'': ' &' ; <?22 ' 2&  2' '' 8  '&2 5 H""3 3, 1,4.I""+"#I H 24 !#;& #$$BLB#$.$#718   2&  2   4 8  :   ' 2&!>&  &'  '& ?'' '   '@5&'1+1B '1I H"#%"$, 1,47& 22&'& ?; 0<0; ?'& 6&@1& '<2&'' 48  ! '  ?&'1 , '1 ' 92&!' &! < ?&'1 3 '1 (  =& 2& &  ?  & ' :  ' '=& ;4 5 H "#/  B%  1B"#%B-/ 1BI  #$$$MN"#%21##B7?  '&'   '?4' &''2&''2&2&<'&2&?  '&!'& ' ' &&;'>!:? &&'  88 2&'1



.,-,.#$$/  0+.%0     '@ 2'    9 >&  ?'& '! :?  8& 9 2&  & :?    8 ' '  '&2 2  8  :?   !> ' ' 2!  0 1 5 H "#3  B-"  1 /1" '  4& &!8!&  '!71

D 6&2&  2 & 4''?2&':& ?!'4 ':  !2'  8&  ' '& 88' ;' '!  #- 2'4& #$$% ' 4  !'! ) ! <  &&'1 ?'& 2&' ?;   ?!''  2'#/'4&#$$%2>!4' ;&''!  :''&!!; '*'&2@! 'B$=&<&!2'  && &&)''2&44:!2'#/'4&!'! &! <  &&' ' :  :?    ' & '  !   2 ' <  &&'  B$ =& 6 &!2'   && &1        8 !  2&  2!>' ! 2'?2&!; &;&6>&4 8 1

&!:'&&&2&' ' :!  & 22 ' +8!;& &#$$/&' 89!  "32'4&#$$%8 9' ' ' 2&&8 &!' :!  &22 '  * '   2&'' &  '!&*' &' & &!! 2& !2'  #/ '4&#$$%&!*:!2'2&2&' '1



OOO

!  0+  *  )!* !)+)!*  !!) + !*



!  1-

"1 !&&&&;41

! 1

#1 ?'2&' '1

B1   !   & 22 '   + 8!;& & #$$/ 2&'' &  '!&*' &' & &!! 2& !2'  3 ;4& #$$%  * :  ' !2'1



.,-,.#$$/  0%.%0   ,1 8 &  !   & 22 '   + 8!;& & #$$/ &' ; 9 ' '  2&    :?9 !    "3 2'4& #$$%  * :  !2'#%'4&#$$%1

+1  ':2&!&'>&' '1

%1 8&  2&'    :G 2;' 8&& && '&  2&!' &&*'   !   B$ =& 6  ' 8 '  2&6  & 4 8!!& 5()P Q&)8: %%$$,  72&; &&' 6&& ' 24 8&!'9&'1-# 8!!&& & 48!!&"/ =  #$$+ 5 H7I  ! &  &&  '  :&    ' 8 ' @2&;'2&'& >'&&&'' &I  ' *'& &!  & 4 8!!& 2& ;  2'  2& ;  !'& : 9  '   ?&'1 ,#  H1  2&!' &&*' '  2 6  2   &&' ;:!@2&; ;'*'&= '<?; 1  >&88 6&  &! 'J           ER S 44     



2 8&2&!'&&*''' 8 !92&'   :G<G88 8!!& & 2&>&88





.,-,.#$$/