Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/379/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/379/2006 Generato dall'IA

Cost Award Following Successful Appeal Based on Insufficient Findings

Numero d'incarto ATAS/379/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case concerns a dispute over liability for costs following the successful appeal of a prior determination, where the appellate court found the original decision flawed due to a lack of essential findings and the subsequent application of incorrect legal standards. The appellate court reasoned that since the appellant obtained substantially the relief sought, they were the prevailing party entitled to costs, even though the initial reversal did not completely grant every request, emphasizing that the appellate success was the primary factor in determining the cost award under the relevant procedural rules.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Cost Award Following Successful Appeal Based on Insufficient Findings: The appellate court reasoned that since the appellant obtained substantially the relief sought, they were the prevailing party entitled to costs, even though the initial reversal did not completely grant every request, emphasizing that the appellate success was the primary factor in determining the cost award under the relevant procedural rules.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
accollo delle spese anticipo delle spese condono delle spese procedurali riesame di una decisione precedente legittimazione a ricorrere decisione motivata

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision is cited in the final orders concerning the allocation of court costs.
Generato dall'IA
C/6608/2017
Appeal on Award of Costs After Partial Success on Monetary Claim
A/2291/2013
Appeal on Cost Allocation Following Partially Successful Claim and Expert Assessment
A/3637/2011
Rectification of Appellate Decision for Failure to Award Costs
C/16616/2022
Appeal Dismissed for Insufficient Grounds Regarding Cost Award Denial
A/1268/2009
Partial Success on Appeal: Award of Reduced Legal Costs

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the final orders concerning the allocation of court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



               $%&''$(&&) $*+'$(&&,

!!

- !.- /  -! /.

0 1 *  (+ 2 (&&, 

 "

 !" 

 #"

$   %   &  23"   '  (!" #!)*+(, #-.( */0- &1&1  -

#

$    &&                (, #--0*(*-   -

                ! "#

  -  

 3.

*6 " 78#  -5 ,#9" -++0(  "!9  ,"!:" !#   2,9!; # #   :< = >  ,"  2  !< "   (2?*-<"!*50/(# !" ( 2@7!*5@@(;!A2#!#"!2--,#9"*55.6

-6 )!33"!, !#!378#,"2!#2( "!9,"!:"!# " 2,"#8," !#!2< !","2< B," 3! 2 ,"2, C,#"!86

D6  78#  !< "( < 23!!#!3  *"  <9" -++0(  2#2 #"! E 33!  "!9 #   "  ! , " C2#!   ,"#8 < !","2< B6

.6  "!92!#",2!#!##! ,"2< B "2 ,"!#! !;" ##< !";!,"" "#"!8( !##"--,#9"*55.#*" <9"-++06

06 &A8!#"(!2#22#9!F

1 ;E!#"<!, " $   '  '      33!!2 G  $     %    '  #; ##,"##! 2,": ##"!:"E2<!#G$"6H*E06*0*" <9"-++0I

@6 #G"(!E#<2"2F

1 ;E,":   "!8(   #"<!2 , " E'J,!# !<"!#!"  :<='>(*"32<"!"D*7!#*550#*" # 9"*550 D*"*55@#; #!#! ,"2< B," 3!   #" <# "   ,#  !9" ,8 <"# ,":   $       &&                    ( " ;  #" <!#(  "

*  <9"-++0($"6.ED+D6/+I

1 ;E  #"<!2 , "          7;E D* 29"-++.#;E2#!#33!!2G  & $         %   $ &&     #;  ,#E2<!#(*" <9"-++0(G DHE/-D6@+I

/6 !332"# #"!! "A!#"#!  #2#2#"!C ,"#!6

    4.+554-++0 D  

H6 E9E 97#! 2!!,"#!(2#28"2G78"6

 !/.



*6 E"#6 -0    ! 322" "  !9" ,8   ,"2< B ," 3! (<!!("<!<##!<!!#2*/29"*55D=$>( #"2<!8"*"7<!"-+++(":8," 2"!< "6 ";  7 !# #,A "","##!  "#!G,"#8"="#6*--# *-D  !<! 1 >(  78  !  !< "  ,2##    E"#6 /D 6* !322"","2< B," 3! -07!*5H-=>(  !#G:< "!9# " !,!*" K#-++D(  !#( ,": ; E33!" !  2#2 #"! ="#6 *.- >( C2#" E 33!  ,"#8"92"2,"#!#! 2#"!2,"78!< ".

-6 & E"#6-- $= <#"<!8",!*"7<!"-+++>( !< "(,"##!  "#!;!"#"!8 #,"#82  3 "2#C"#6*--(*-D(*.*#*.- I"#6DG0$E,,!;# ," 8! ##G#"32""=6*>6 "); 7 !#(,"##!   "#!G,"#8" "", G!332"#","##!  "#!(8#2  < !"  !9" ,8 C!## 2<##   #  !< "( #  ,"##!    "#!( 8#2  < !"  !9" ,8 C!## 2<## # ! "!8=36"#6-.$>6 " ( 7 #G,"##!  "#!#GE< !"!9",8C!##  #    !   "!8  !#2"L#    #  !< " = $*-H-D+I $*-5...>6

D6 A,:(78,"!:"!# " 2,"#8," !#!2 < !","2< B"6#,"#!# #(A,"#(  "!8(  -- ,#9" *55.( A#" ,"#  *"  <9" -++0( # G ;78#!< "#<C2# !"6

&    # ," !#(  ,"##!  ;! ,#  "!8 ,"  " #  H*E03"6*06   !#   G   C12,  .+E00/3"6@+ =H*E03"6*0F->6

< !" 2,"##"!:"E2:<#G.DE+-/3"6D+=DHE/-D3"6@+M .ED+D3"6/+>( ! 9! ;E  !# G   C1 7 !#   ##  -*E0*D3"6@0 =.DE+-/3"6D+F->6

    4.+554-++0 .  

23!!#!<(E# ";! !#G" ## *5E+.D3"650=.+E00/3"6@+1-*E0*D3"6@0>6

.6 3 "2# G  7"!,"( ,!  7 " 2#"!# , "  ,"#8 7;E  #  #"3"#   ,"##!    "#!    "(   7 !# !< "2 9223!!!"  ## ,"##!   " !# G  !#2"L#  ,# !" "   ##  1!6  !#2"L#  # 2  #C !! 28   E"#6 *-  E "  "  ,"2< B ," 3!  <!!( "<!<# # !<!!#2  *H <"! *5H. = ->     #C "28#!"( ! !1! # ,2"!" = $   ,9!2  D@4+-  *H 7!# -++D>

06 2 #","N(," 2"2##8"#!#="#6/D6-# H5'6* !"," 2"!!#"#!<*-,#9"*5H0>6



OOO



    4.+554-++0 0  

!  /.3  !.- /  -! /.

 456   7  8   9# :,( /;

*6 <!#  $     %    '   G #"32""(   ,# !" ( *5E+.D3"650G$     &&               3<"   ( !! ;  !#2"L#  ,# !"     !2"#(:*" <9"-++07;E ##"3"#6

-6 AB ##;9 !6

D6 !#;," 2"#8"#!#6

.6 3 "  ,"#!   ;E ,<# 3 "" " "  #"  ,"2# ""L#   2!  D+ 7 " :   #!3!#!  ," ,! " 2 "2  "!9 322"  "( &)P!Q") 3;! @( @++.   (  #" ! C,!"6  2!  ,# L#" ,"  826  2 !"  !# F > !!;" C## ; 2!!   " "# 2!" 9#!"  ! # ,   2!! ##;2I9>C, ", "; #!3!#!, < !""## #"2!! I>, "#"!8#"  ","2##6&!2 !"   #!# ,  #" ! 22# 22"2   ##" > 9> # > !1(  "!9322"", "",#""#!:""" ";E! <"2""!""<962 !"" "#! " " B  ,"<( ;! " # 7 !#( !! ;  2!!  ##;2 # E< ,,  ;2#2C,2!2" "#="#6*D-(*+@#*+H>6

 8"33!:"  "2!#F       !$$ ?"!& ? 

 ,! 3 ","2#""L## #!3!2C,"#!!!;AGA33!322" " !,"8"33

    4.+554-++0