Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/377/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/377/2007 Generato dall'IA

Termination Validity and Post-Dismissal Liability Management

Numero d'incarto ATAS/377/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case concerns an individual who signed their own termination letter in October 2002, despite not officially becoming an administrator of the company until December 17, 2002, and asserts that their subsequent actions, like managing outstanding social security contributions, were aimed at settling liabilities rather than earning income. The court needed to determine the relationship between the individual and the company at the time of termination and the nature of their post-termination involvement. The court reasoned that the individual's continued involvement, specifically managing bank accounts and paying bills after dismissal due to a work shortage, did not automatically negate the termination or establish an ongoing employment relationship, particularly as an ongoing criminal investigation for diverting social contributions suggested a complex legal standing.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Termination Validity and Post-Dismissal Liability Management: The court needed to determine the relationship between the individual and the company at the time of termination and the nature of their post-termination involvement. The court reasoned that the individual's continued involvement, specifically managing bank accounts and paying bills after dismissal due to a work shortage, did not automatically negate the termination or establish an ongoing employment relationship, particularly as an ongoing criminal investigation for diverting social contributions suggested a complex legal standing.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
cessazione d'impiego azione intesa alla dichiarazione di responsabilità gestione contabile contributo sociale reddito di un'attività lucrativa durata legale del lavoro

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for the allocation of costs in the dispositive orders.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

           &''()&*))+ &',,&*)),



# "!  #    "

-. /  0 12 *)), 



 !"  #





#

   $$ % $#&'#(() % #!"





            !"# $"" % 

   0.*,0  

 "

(1 1#2"34$ 50367"#"8 6( 92 .--(  ## : # ;:#1  ##  .< #& .--. '" 3 1 =   "#" " 2 >>#  +( "!& .--.  !#> >!#  "3#!#? :#?1 '# !!1  "## # !!  !## :   "#" 2 '#  2  6  # ;3#  0  (. ! .--( 9:; (@ "!& .--.1  3#  ## # 1 = # # !!  !## : 2 '#  2 1 1 % "## # !! #   "#" 2 '#  2   (@ "!& .--.  . >"2 .--A 3 2 '# #2 B C 2 1 =9:;<9.--A1,9#.--A># "#""#" 3"1

.1 /2!&.--(9:;.!.--D1"###:#" ; !##2'# 2  ;#3E$ 1

+1  A ! .--.  .( #& .--+  "## # !!  !## 2 '# 2 '# !!3)$ 1

A1 ;#""&"">" ; "0  ; !#2# (+92.--+  (. 92 .--D #  "#"  !" 3    FG!'   H % 9:;I#.--A1 ##&'# ###"#"3 6( I#.--D3  5036781

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



*++,-*.--/  0+*,0   .--+1 C0 #  3!#  J    : ;# ##   "#"1  !# #! 3 1 %  # "'!# : ;#""  "3   D ! .--+ B  &: #  3&6! '# 1%1.A9#.--+;#""'" >C33B## "#" "B4($B# 3!# ;>##  " !# !F 1/3#!&.--+ ;#""  "# 3 4 $  B  "#" B )F #  3&6!  >##1    #! 3 1% ##'"3;#""(/#&.--+! "#"#  "B#1

/1  ( 3#!& .--A   '""  >!" ;#""  : 1 = # % :    !3#  2# "" 3 2 "#"  !! # C "   "#"  ##  ## $* * *  3 #  3"   ( !  +( "!& .--(# (92+( "!&.--.1

@1     ; :M# 2# 3 ;>> #  ;!3 50367  8;""#"# 3#>>@3#!&.--A1 ""2 > ""#"21%92.--(1"## 2"'!#  !## 02'# 2 3" ###" 1 #  ###:; !## # (@ "!& .--.   #!  # 3 ( >1 J!&: B ; !## :   " "1=13#>":;;2#3C" ;#2#" 3>  #2 B :: ## :  # 3  3#  FG!'1

,1  (A 3#!& .--A ;"  "#" #     > 3 ; 1   '":;4$ 2# 3#3"!3J"3## 1"##3&:#" ;C0 !##1"##"'!#0 "&#    J I 3  "#" 3  C1  ##   2##"B2' :3"##2#B:# F 3 !  "!""1 !!  2#   '#   !3#&2#23!#>>#" #;C.--+  &# 3"2#"M#1

  33#   !M! # #> B ##  #  # !#" : ;" ; 3  :"  ># ; !## 3 E $  # E($   !  ; !#" FG!' ((92.--+1 # 3  ##" : ;#""  #" B '  !# 3 4$ # !&C  3!# 332#M# "#": #  1



*++,-*.--/  0A*,0   <1 .@#&.--A  FG!'H %!  ;"B ; >:;C!3## 3!##B:M#1

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

((1  " +(!.--D;  ""2&;33##9#"3 ;" # ((>"2.--D3 # 2#"1

(.1  " A9#.--/ ! "B;#"" ###  3## 3N  #3  (.(;@<D >1 @- 3 # C  !#" 96 " 92.--+BI#.--A1

(+1 $33# ;"9#"03 " .+I#.--/1

(A1 # (D3#!&.--/;"#### "#B  #1  ># 2 : ;# B ## : ;    "  # C 3## FG!'3 #3" #'1

(D1 "3 (-#&.--/;#!"#9# 1

(/1  !   & ";#!"2.-2!&.--/ 6'!# ;#&.--A :#:;3 ##&'#   FG!' H % 6(92.--D1

(@1 (A!.--@3### !3#31

;#!" "2N(-9.--D " ;  +(!.--D1



*++,-*.--/  0D*,0   ## :":#7 " M. K__________ n'était pas un employé de EASYMMOB et RBH SA avant de devenir son administrateur le 17 décembre 2002. Il a néanmoins signé ma lettre de licenciement en date du 29 octobre 2002.

En raison d'une baisse considérable du travail, la société a dû licencier la majorité de son personnel à fin 2002. Il n'y avait plus de travail non plus pour moi-même. Toutefois, M. H__________ a pu continuer de travailler pour la société, dès lors qu'il est ingénieur. Il est par ailleurs fondateur de la société et y a toujours travaillé contre rémunération.

Sur question de la Caisse, je précise que j'ai gardé la signature sur les comptes bancaires et que j'ai continué à m'occuper un peu du paiement des factures après mon départ fin 2002, car la société avait un grand arriéré de cotisations sociales et je tenais à ce que cet arriéré n'accroisse pas, voire puisse être réduit.

Mon intention n'était pas de gagner de l'argent, en gardant un pied dans la société, mais de régler le passif.

La procédure pénale pour détournement des cotisations sociales est toujours en cours."

(,1 $#' "B9'1

 #"

(1 >!"!# B ;#1 D/  1 ( #1  F1 ,   & #  O##: ###3"2BP#1D/ >" "3#'""  #  /#& .--- 5 8 : # #2 B   >" "  P0FG!' &'##P !#" P2&#" .D9(<,.5 81

$!3"#39'  P36#"#&1

.1  2#  ;#1 <D 1 (     2 ;#1 .D    3##  I!##F" 2#M###"B!:;#"">I# &> #:!&!#!### ## >>1

$;#1.D1.  #  ! ###;"##36 !!#Q;### ; >#!3# : 362!# 3##1$"O# ;#3&3 :  "  33# 3 ' # 3"2 3  # 3"  " # "#!#1

+1 #>#2:!!#F"B## ; !#"96 #"'!# 1 >#!# " ;  D92 .--D1



*++,-*.--/  0/*,0   ## " # 9 ;F #"  >  F 9'" 6  : ;33# ##0"#" ""2&1

 # " ##  "  ### : ;##" ;#  33 F&#" B 3  :;B   # :  ### !!" #  ;C# ;C# ;33#  ##!! "3#"M# '  3## B 2  #"M# #  #   ># :  ;33# 3  #& #"M# 3&  32" # : # #"M# '  3##  3 3 M# 3"2"  !J ; " >!# 5 H (.<.<- 1.1(81 ##C'2#"'!#:;##"  " ###3:M# ; !#"! ;>>5 H(+- +<(1 .1A81

#>  C3# #  !  !#6 ;0FG!' 3  :   "  ###   3  ##" #  FG!'#B623; 1 0###>! ; " ### :#!3 FG!' ;#1,D1(#1 #!!#9#  # ;"B; !#"5#1 ,(1.#1 81

   FG!' # " 3  "  ###  ;##" #5 9' 8#">9# "#   ;&   #  # B ; !#"  FG!'1  : ;##" # 33" B ##    ! B C! 3   ##: #  #B  !#" FG!' "9B"3   ;"## 3 ""   # #  ;#1 <D 1 (    2;#1.D  ;C'###3##: # ;  "#  ; "2 3"  # "" 5 H (.<  ((- 1(1(8133## 6B ;C!:#  ####'5 H(./A-(1 1.&*81

A1  ' 2  "2  "   3  ##" 9  ; !## # #  3"  B  "2 ; " #"  > : # "2#  ># 2C   2C !J  32 3#&    B  33"# 9 : >>"# 5 H (.@  A/<  1.#">"81 ##93 #3BP#1D+1(  : 3: "# "33#>!!#3" >#!B"2P"P "2&":!!#  ># 2C !3##  #2  2C !J  32 :  32# M# 3 # 32#1 C #!  ;1 .  ## 3# ;3#"'!#2 " "33# >!!#3">:;#!>#!#"#: #>#2M#!3##&5 "#81



*++,-*.--/  0@*,0   D1  ;36 ;   "2#  3#!& .--A :  # "##  ! # ; !## 3  "#" # :;   O# #" B '   #    3!# 3   !3J #  "## "'!# !##12# 6 ##: >#2C #"#" "2#3#"!#B " ;# ; !#" FG!' 6 92 .--+1  ":#  J   ; !## :   # ; "2 3"  #  ;36 !3  # :  !   ###  3##  I!# 3N # "'!# > "1 # C  #  # B ; !#"  FG!' ## :#  "#" #F" 3 ; 3 "#" >:;#!"1 # 3# 6 C' 3"#3" 2C! ##:#1

/1 #BC!"### 3## I!#3N;# 3"##333#1

;#1.D1.  3: #  ! ###;"## 36!!#Q;### ; >#!3 #  :  36  2!#   3##1 $  " O# ; # 3& 3 :  # 3" 3"2#  "  33# 3 ' 0# "#!#1

;2# ; !##:;#!"2#  #  !   ### B 3#  !!# Q  "  33#  ;  +(!.--D# 2C"#1 !###:#;# N  ( 9 .--D  "    +- 9  C3"  A 9# .--D1 ;#!" J#    "  ###  A 9# .--/  2# ; !## :;  '   " ;  3"2 3  3# 3"#"1 $ 3"##;#3":#33#1

@1 ## #M#9#"1

,1  # 3 # &  #  !  B ;#!" 3  :M# "3"  !  ;&'#  ## ; #! :; "##  & > :;3N3## ##### ! "#:0 !### ## >>1

#"' ###>B2:93 "#  & >" "    & >  ;"  # "3   &"  >! ;3#  ; 1  !3# 6  :  >!  # 3  :# 3">:  9#  ! # ; !##  ;"1    >#   3  3#"!# B ;  :  "#  33#  #2 3  "#"  !# 3 > C  : ;"###2 0##"'' '2C#& >5M#3&"  H  A "!&.--/ +.@*-D 1+81



*++,-*.--/  0,*,0  

   "  "!  #    "



 2 3-

(1 "2&1

 3

.1 9##1

+1 #:3" #'##1

A1 >!  3#   :P 32# >!  #  3"# M#   "  +- 9 6  #># 36  & >" " 5$FRSF>://--A  832 !#6  # 3&>!"!#C#1,. >" " &>" " (@ 9 .--D 5 H8T  !"!   #  :   !#> # !J 32#3#'# # ! #T # M#  "  & >" " 3 2 3#  3 2 "#: C  #  ;#1 A.  H1  3"# M# #  36  3  #2:"!!!J 32 2#M#9#B;21  '>>6  " #7        %  $ J     





 3>!  3"# M###>"C3##$"## P##B P"!3'>>



*++,-*.--/