Usurious Interest Rate and Statutory Maximum Recovery on Secured Loan
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the proper application of interest rates to a secured loan, where the borrower asserted that the original agreement's usurious interest rate rendered the entire obligation void, while the lender sought to enforce the contractual interest rate or, alternatively, the statutory maximum. The court reasoned that while the initial contractual rate was usurious and thus unenforceable, the underlying debt remained valid and the lender was entitled to recover the principal plus interest at the statutory maximum rate, based on the principle that the court should not allow a borrower to escape liability for the principal amount merely because the lender sought an illegal rate of return.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Usurious Interest Rate and Statutory Maximum Recovery on Secured Loan: The court reasoned that while the initial contractual rate was usurious and thus unenforceable, the underlying debt remained valid and the lender was entitled to recover the principal plus interest at the statutory maximum rate, based on the principle that the court should not allow a borrower to escape liability for the principal amount merely because the lender sought an illegal rate of return.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for ordering the costs of the federal court procedure.
Applied to grant legal aid.
Testo completo
#$%&$#'( #)#('')
+
, -./" //" , / -"
$* 0 1 ('')
&2 1
34444444444
55- //" , "6/7-/3"-,- !"#$"$$ $%&&'(
!
" )"*+)
/ 5-
$. /0' 1111111111 ( 23& $+4- '&( '5 0 06 7 3&( 8 7& 05 $++, 9 & 0 $4 : '& 8& 0960; &0%<= 9:&9 &' &0 >?"%@+$+.).
". & "4 3& $++4 & &( 0 3& 9 $--= & 0 009;6 &0;3&&30 03&9#-= 0$#22&$++4.
%. 0(20#2&$-2&$++400&3&&0:'A& 0>B &6&3&&053C&) 5>D7 1111111111 11111111110&A&8(0'E&A&0&#)F$ 0(7&&&&3)'&&8; (&:&0::0&.
,. + 'E $++4 1111111111 0&A 0&A&8( 0 0& :& &3 &)(A(0%9F$ (0'&',)# (A 7' 0 & # 0&. 0&'& 0 :&0& &&0&'&'.
#. 1111111111 (&( ! E $++4 0&)A :& && 8;'0&'(&6&0'E& (0&A&0 & 0& %), :('5 ' &7 & & 0& ( ,)# 0 && '(0& '(0& 9 6& 0& G & (& 0 7 0 ;('A 0 & 0&5 & 0& #)F$ &'A 0;:& 'E& (& ( 0 7 && (& 0 && )
&&8.
4. $$3'E$++4;&((0( ( '&50'00 &0 ;)&3&0&( 8 &&( & :A 0 'G 6&&&7'0;:50.000'0 1111111111 :&A& (0&A( "$ 3'E $++4 9 ;&0;77&0;)&3&0&(C&) 5; D&0&8 8 &77&00& :&,)##)F$0'E&(& 0%9#.&'(83'(&07&&E 0'9 0 3&. ''0( 0; A 0. ; G(9;&(('G6&&&0'0(<23&$++!.
!. "43'E$++4?11111111110&A&8( &0& %), '& :('5 ' &7 & & 0& ( ,)# 0 && '(0& '(0& 9 6& B 0& G & (& 0 7 0 ;('A 0
*$,#$*-" )%*+)
& 0&5 & 0& #)F$ &'A 0;:& 'E& (& ( 0 7 && (& 0 &&)&&8.
<. 4 7(3& $++! ;( 0( ( 0 0'0 0 & 0 ;)&3&0&(30;E&0;.
+. 0(&&0$<7(3&$++!H1111111111;'&9&&& ( 0&'(0&;G (('0&3 03&0(8&377&.
$-. 0 $# 3& $++! 1111111111 ( 8 & 77& 0;&E&&( 'E& 0& :& 0E ,)# #)F$ 8 G0' 3(E :&8 (& A( 0; 8; & 0 &3'E$++4.F&;(03&0( 00'G6&&& 7&6&)A77'E&&3&A(.
$$. $#'&$++!?11111111118&(A'&3&;((0&A( 9 ;& 0 ; 0 8 0&A&8( 'I' 77& 8 75. ;( 3& 6 7& 0 7&90 0:A0'E60( '0'0( '(&. F& & 0 1111111111 0 ;E& 0 &' & &8;(&7&A(8;03& ':0EC .6 AD. &7(3&$++!3& & 88 J: '(A5 '& 03& 3 ;(0 7& 0.F( 3&3&0;29;.
$". <2&"--$11111111113'(0&&0;&(( 7&'( 0&A& 0 'E&A& 0& :&8 'E& (& 0&:. 0(( 8 & (& & E 0 3& 9 $--=0 &"43&$++48(0((&&&'&8;& & A&3' ;AA3 7& 0 ;(3& 0 (& 0(A((&3. F & E2&3 0 '(0& & (&&0'E&30&00"#'&'&&0 'E&&( 0 5A &&7 9 0& 9 %-= 65 0( &' . 0 'E& :&8 ' I:& 0 :A 0 & 0E & A(. ;3& 0 1111111111 ;( 3& & && & 0E 8 0 : 03& && &*0E*':. F (&'5 0 ': (& 0 '6&' "-- '. && (A' &'( 8; E(&'&' (& (3&&E8'&3& &03& ' 7&(&7&E. &(03&&E' 6&A&E0 7&' 0&'&&6&(& 9(3.
*$,#$*-" ),*+)
$%. F 0;8I('&8'(A0$$ 'E"--$6 0;&3&0&(0;(0'(A0"4=.(A'&0&8(0 8 ;( 3G& '' & 3& 8; &0;3&6'0(380&07'&'E&3& 0;(A&.
$,. $3'E"--$>1111111111'(0&&0; &'( 300&8;&(((&'03&9#-=3 0 &&03&(A''' G(0E 6' .F & 0&A :& 0 3(E '& 8 0 (& 9 &'& 0 '&( 8 ; 3& (A' :K 0 G' '&88&05 3&6 &8&(;' &00 &0:0& 7&.
$#. 200(&&0"#7(3&"--"; 7&6(0A(0;&3&0&(0 ;(9"<4=&3&0&(0"4=0&3&(0'(A5 C6( 9 4" =D 0 %% = 0 &3&( 0 ( C6( 9 %< = & $4 : '&D.
$4. 0;0&&0;( ; 00$"3&"--"( 200(&& 0'0(9E((7&& 0;800;0'& . &A( 8; :& 0 (3G 7&0$@,--7.8'&(&&304@---7.E '&. && 7&&5 ;(& 2 & 8 & &( 9 3& 9 ,- = & 3& (( E (. 9 &(03&0'(A&'(8 &((((3( A0'&5. 7&3(80 &J8(0( ;(& (2(8'(0&&&;0 :&'3& 0:&A&0> 0366'.
$!. 0(&& 0 $4 3& "--" ; 7( & 0 ;)
&3&0&(9;(&A(60;&3&0&(9",<= "<4= 0 2 0 0(&& 8& & 0 0 '8 9 AA. 0A&((7&'0('&(9"%=.
$<. & 0 $ '& "--" ;&(( 7& 9 ; 0 L0( E&M 7& 3& 8 ( ;(& '(&( 0&5(8&(&3& '&&3&(9#-= '&. ( 8 '(0& (3G& 0 3 &3&A&. '&&3(('&$%'&"--" 0&77&9 ''&& 0 F) ) ) ?) )/ F C&) 5N ''&& 0 D & 9 )& & 0 0('& & 003&I&0((''.
*$,#$*-" )#*+)
$+. & 0 $4 '& "--" 9 ;( ''&& 0 ( ( &0.
"-. #2&"--"1111111111''&8(90&''&&8; ;(&(&&' &E90 03&07& 8 &( 0 3& 0 7& 03& I (3( 0 0 (&& 7& 7& 0 3& & 0 ' &E 3 &3&( 7&' 8 & 77& 0 'E&A& 0& :&8 &3&0 ;AA3 A&3' 3' . 2& 0;&'A& ('A(&8'E& &8( "+ '& "--" 1111111111 8 (& 0(A((&3 &3 0 && &) :G& (& 3& A'( 9;6'0!E$++4.
"$. (3&0$4 'E"--"; 20E &0>111111111104 'E"--"8&'(8 ;( 0 ( 0 ;( (& 8&' 'I' 8; $++4 8; (& E03&9#-=0&3&(&3(A5.; & '&0&0 0;8I'(A0'O &)&(&&3(9' I:'0%-=0; 0&67 '&7 8 3& 7& 0 P& 7'& & 0 &A 3 7&. F 77& &3&( 3& 0 & '& 0 &&08;& &(03&0'(A(&'I'&7(& 60"4=.
/ ,-
$. &A3&;A&&20&&&CD(('0&7&(&&(05 $Q"--% &E0&. 7'('9;. %.%00& &&&&&0&3;(3&A0 (& 003 ''&&0'&50 & ' ('& 7(0( '& 0;77& &E 0 & & &8 & '&5 0;)&3&0&( '' C7. . #4 D. ' (0 &E0(&&(E& R00; 5.
". & 7(0( & A(( 0 0& 0 & 0 4 E "--- C D ( 3&A $ 23& "--% 8& R( 0 '0&7&&0&7(0(;)&3&0&(C D05A' C D; &E; 50582A0&
*$,#$*-" )4*+)
; 9 0 &0(& '0&7&& 0 0& 0 ;( 0 7& (&900('&00(&&&&A&C ?$"!,4!&0. $$"$%<4&0.$ES7.(A'0& &&&&.<".$ D. 0& &&(A05&(0&.
3. F ;. <# . " . E & 0 & 7(0( ;)3&& 3&3 0 "- 0('E $+,4 C FD 8 ; &8 3& 0 ;. 4+ ; 0 0& & 6 ( & 0 7& 0 '&7 &38(&&8&.F;&&7& 96&A0(&0& I &' & 2A 'E 3& 8 (( 0;&E3&. 6&A 7' ( (A& @ 0@ E 8 0 ' 9 2&0&& 0'&&&3 0 0('& @E2 0 &&A 8& & '& 0 0 @& 9 & &&'( 0 ( 0 6 A&7 7'( 9 . 0 & 7& 307'&'6&780@6&A0@ A& 0@'0& (&&(8@8&7&0'&568I& 0@ 0(&& 05 8 0 '&5 77& '&7( 0(030(&&&&83(8@0(3 0@77.
;&(&'0&0$'&"--"0;&((8 )& ;(& 0;0 3 0(&& 0 ; 0 $4 3& "--" 8; 0'0&&&&' &&'&;&0;0;&3&0&(. '&3(0(0 '3&(0(8&; '(&(.F &0(A''&7&38(. &0(& 0 (A 0 %- 2 C. 4+ <, . $ FD. (8 & 3&0&0(8&2(3E97'.
,. F ;. , . $ ;&3&0&( 0&'&& 0 &( 0 A& ('( ' 0 A 0( 8& ( 0; & 9 ( :G&8 ' 3 0; &7&'&( A(& 0; '0& 0; &0.0&90('&( ;."<.$ 8&0& 8 ;( 0& 9 ;& &3&0 9 ,- '&. &5 &3&0&(044"*%='&0'&0( &3&0&(0#-='&80 &3&0&(0,-= '&3006&5'&(00& &&.
#. 2A 0 & 0;6'& 0 '&5 E2&3 'G0 3&0( 0''0 300(&0&& 0' 9 0& && ' 0 2A' 3E 0& &&A&6. '(0& ( & 3 E & & &&A&6 &' 7& ;E2 0; (0 0(&( & E3& 700 ' (A'&0(& & 6 &'( ;& (( (E& & & 0 0& C'5D &
*$,#$*-" )!*+)
0& & 0 6 '(0& & & 0 ;6 E& '&3(CF"--- .$#,(7.G&(D.
4. F;."<." ;(3&0;&3&0&(303&8 ;( &(&6T;&3&(8& &E'I0 0& 5;6(&(30'0(0 &' 0; && (8&&E( 0 ':( 0 3& ' ( 3 8;& & E&&3&0&(.3&3&0&(0('& && 0; 5 0&&8;(E3;&9(' 0 ;(3& 0 & &3 28; '' 0 ( 0 0(&& C $++$ A%%"S ? E&(0"<7(3&"---D.
!. 7'(' 9 ;. "! . $ ;&3&0&( 0 ( 8& ;6T& 0;&3&( &3 (3( 7& 0 ;' I:' 0;' & 36 :E&. 36 :E& 0 ( 3& 0 '(A 0 ;&3&( 0 '(A ;(0& 0 7 C. "! . " D. 30;."!E&.$ 8(;6&3&( &3 8;9 ' & E& ('(( 9 ; &02&;&3&0&( (3(;.<." .F;&936:E&0;.#.$ ;&3&0&( 7&6( ;. "! &3&(. & 70 0('& &3 0 ;&3&( &3 0 E& (9; &02&0;' &'036 :E& 0A( 0;&3&0&( 0; 5 :0& 0 77(0060'&0;&3&(8&.
6'0;."!E&." &;(6&''0;6' 0 0& 9 &3&( &3 9 ' ' ;& ;(& & 0 ( ;&3&0&( (3( 6&3' && &E 6 3&3&(&3.
<. ;3&(9%<=6H1111111111;( 9'(A794"=. &0((8;&&( 20;:& 9 6 &3&( &3 9 ' &. 3& 05 0;(3 &3&0&( ( (' : 0 &3&( 8 ; 7& ; .
+. ;A&; 50;(3 '&&0A(0 &(03&0 0&3&(&3. (A0&; (8)& ( & &( 0 3& 0 ((0 7& 0 7&. F05&&A&603&&' 0&'&&7& & 6 &3&( (A5 0 :A 9 8 A. 0 0 '(0& 8& 6'&( ; ( 8&. F 1111111111 &( 0 3&
*$,#$*-" )<*+)
0 7& & 9 (3. 7& E 0 &5 0 0&>1111111111&'(8 &(03&0(& 0#-=0&3&((0&3& &E0 &&.
3&0'(0&)&0; &7&I&0(('' (77& (3 &(03&:(&80;(. 77 && ; ( 8 &5 ; (0( 9 3 6' '(0& 0 8(. ; 77( (0 0(&( 0 & &&A&6 &' & '5. & 05 R 9 (&&'(0& &3 E02& 0.F E 0 '(0&6 7&A 0 0& & ; 05 &E 0 &( 0 3& 0 0A( 0;&3&0&(.
3& 8;& R EE 8 0A( 0;&3&0&( 0 &0,-=30&9 &0'O '&6C'(A&3&( 7&D;6(8;9%<=&3&( &3(3'A'(9#-=. 7&& I6 8 0A&&(9;&3&0&(&0;&377&''&' 3&0&90'0' 7&( (&(8 8 0A&&(9;&3&0&(0"-=3&7'& 7& ('&CF$++! .<-&0.$ES $+<, .+#SF $*"--- . "!D. 0 ; 0 A& ;&3&( &30(290"%=. 7&0'O 08;9 0A(0;&3&0&(0<!=&I&0((''(77& 0&.
$-. 308& (50&;358;&&00&&' 5. 3&0503G9;&&'( &&' ('&7& 0 7& (3 &( 0 3& (&0 0 6 '(0&8 J:0 (096'' 0)& 0(0 & 7&.
8 8 8
*$,#$*-" )+*+)
-5 " -./" //" , / -"
9
$. (3E&2( /'11111111110(&&0 $43&"--"0;77&0;)&3&0&(.
9
". ;0' &'S
%. 0(&&0$43&"--"0;77&0;)&3&0&(S
,. 3& 9 ; && ' ('& 0 0 &0(S
#. &8;&; T0;(''&(0;&0'&(S
!. 7' & 0 8@ 3 7' ( I 0 0(& 0 %- 2 05 &7&& & ''0( 0( &E 7(0( 0 F:U&K:78& 4 4--, & 6' &. 0(& I A(. '('& 0& N D &0&8 6' 8@ 0(&& 0(& E& & 0 0(&& 8(S ED 6 8 '&7 & &' 3& 0'0 0(&&SD &A0 (.F&'('& & & ((' ('(( D ED D &)0 &E7(0(0 '&58@& 030(&3E.'('&0'&'G 0 3 8& 2& && 8 0(&& 8( @3 0 8((6 (0&(C.$%"$-4$-<D.
A77&5N (&0N VW X /G /
(&)2&N?/
(I''&8( &7&&6 &&&8@9@77&7(0( 0& A77
*$,#$*-"