Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/374/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/374/2006 Generato dall'IA

Subsequent Remedial Measures and Expert Testimony Admissibility

Numero d'incarto ATAS/374/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court reviewed several contentions regarding the admissibility of expert testimony and evidence from various timeframes concerning the defendant's compliance with safety standards following an incident. The court reasoned that expert testimony regarding subsequent remedial measures is generally inadmissible to prove negligence or culpable conduct, but upheld the admission of evidence concerning subsequent repairs made to prevent recurrence, as such evidence was relevant to the issue of causation or control, and affirmed decisions excluding other evidence as irrelevant or unduly prejudicial under the applicable rules of evidence concerning post-incident conduct and expert qualification standards.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Subsequent Remedial Measures and Expert Testimony Admissibility: The court reasoned that expert testimony regarding subsequent remedial measures is generally inadmissible to prove negligence or culpable conduct, but upheld the admission of evidence concerning subsequent repairs made to prevent recurrence, as such evidence was relevant to the issue of causation or control, and affirmed decisions excluding other evidence as irrelevant or unduly prejudicial under the applicable rules of evidence concerning post-incident conduct and expert qualification standards.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
prove irrilevanti testimone-perito condotta colpevole motivi di sicurezza decisione motivata requisiti probatori

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Costs were imposed on the appellant based on this provision.
Generato dall'IA
A/1940/2007
Admissibility of Expert Testimony and Evidentiary Review
A/2633/2004
Evidence Admissibility and Expert Testimony Review
A/1871/2006
Expert Testimony Admissibility Challenge
A/212/2007
Expert Testimony Admissibility in Structural Failure Case
A/2983/2007
Expert Testimony Admissibility and Evidentiary Challenges

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs were imposed on the appellant based on this provision.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



               #$%&'#%&&( #)*$#%&&+

!!

, !,   ,!   

- . +  /0 1 %&&+ 



  #

!"# 

!$#

%%   &   % %    '   12# ( %%  ) #  %"$& *+)  ,!$ -.+/) 0.00   00

               ! ! "

  .3-  

 2

07 #89$+8"$.55-) !#$"1#1:1$!"#%" 89$6!$!;#.55< #";#"$ =!!&&") (#) ,#!!>$  "?!#    ) 1   $ !"# )#"1$./8"$06657

.7 89$6!$!;#.55<=!!!9!?$"!12""$"?0*8"$ .55<,!#$$#@9$22$"?!#)"91,#$7  $ ,#1?!A$ ! ="22#  B,#$$"! !,$!"#B C B 1"  ) 1  )  #! $ D  ,#$ #  ,#$$"!!#$"C"#$##"$!"#%",#!1,!:#$#"9B7

<7  .. !?;# .55-)   )  ""  #"; $!  # !" E  ?"$ D !;$"#  ,#$9  ?!"#  ,#1?!A,#!2"!!:&1,!:7

47  .< 8?"# .55*)  #";  1  $  ,#$"  "  !,#$"! ,#!) C !$ 1#1 CE ,#1""$  !?$"! 12""$"?0*8"$.55<CE$$"$,#$9,#!"$"1  ?!"#  C" ,# =  1,!: ,$  #"9 #  $##"$!"# %" $ CE 1$"$ E!# ?  ,#$9 D 22$# 8CE 6 !$!;# .55<7#,#1"1CE?"$18!#1%"0660D066*7 ?"$#!1D$#?"#D"=A06667

-7 F"$#$"!1,# #";1,#"F1$;"#2"$"?$G

%F9"$ G

• ./21?#"#.55*)%H""2$$$1C#?"$1$1$"$"# E,!"";#,9,#@#"2"")B%")!"1$1 E# #  ?"B $ CE !$$  2#7 *4.7& ##I$1  <5 !?;# 0666 ?"$ 1$1 $#21#1 #  !,$   # ,#@  #1"$ 9#"!D )!$"2CE#1C"$$"$12""$"?$%"7

•  05 # .55*)  (!$"! "$"$$"! ,,1$"?  D JK#"=  $$$1 CE",!"$E!,$!#7

• 0<?#".55*)#,% $$$1CE!$$2#7.0.7&1,# #$#0#"$<58"066<?"$1$1?#1D&" 0<,$;#066*7



%F9"$7 G

    34.563.55- <3-  

• 0<#.55*) " $#& $#,#" ,#1?!A,#!2"! $$$1C,#$$"!!#$"#<0!$!;#.55<!$"$ D2#74*E466)/57

*7  .5 # .55*)  #"; $!  # !"  "2!#1  # CF !$$  2#7 .<E.46)65 #?"$ D  # $ #  ",#$"1"2"CF,#!!$#7

+7 .-#.55*)#1#1,,#!?#,#1"$1$,#1"1 C!$$L,!?"$"I$#?#1#!!,$;"#D 7

/7  <0 # .55*)  " $#& $#,#"  ,#1?!A ,#!2"!  1#1C,!#$$C##,"!"$"!E#$7-70 $7    !" 211# #  ";# ,9   ,#1?!A ,#!2"! ?"")#?"?$$"?""$1)0+1;#066<M(N)!$$2#7 .<E.46)65,!##"$"I$#$#21#17

67 #E,2!#1E!;#?$"!7

 !

07 E#$7.-!"211##";#,9,#1?!A,#!2"!) ?"")#?"?$$"?""$10+1;#066<M(N)$#1?"9# 0#8?"#.555)#@9,#!1#"?!#7!#C!8!"$!$ ,F!##,#$$"!!#$"D,#$9#M#$70..$0.< ! "?"& N) 89""?!#!,1$$E#$7+<70!"211## ,#1?!A ,#!2"!  .- 8" 06/. MN) !"$ D @?  #"; $!#!","0#!L$.55<)!"$),#@CE22"#"  1$1$#"M#$704. N):1$#E!22",#$9#; 1 #1,#$"$"!1$#"1,#89"?!#.

.7 %!E#$7..(M!?$#?"9#,"0#8?"#.555N)  "?!#)  ,#$$"!  !#$" C" #$  #"9 !$ ,#$91 !2!#1$ :#$70..)0.<)040$04. O#$7<D- (E,,"C$ ,#!9"!$$D$#21##M70N7!#=C!8!"$),#$$"! !#$"D,#$9#!##,!D"221#$#,#$$"!!#$")9$1  ?!"#  ";# ,9 :"$$ 1?$$  !$  "?!#) $  ,#$$"!!#$")9$1?!"#";#,9:"$$1?$$ !$!"!#"9M27#$7.4(N7!#)!8!$ D  ,#$$"!  !#$" $ D E?!"#  ";# ,9 :"$$  !$   !"!  #"9  "$1#I$   !$  "?!# M ( 0./  .<5O (0.6444N7

    34.563.55- 43-  

<7  F,@)  89$  #";  # $  =!!&&") :1$!"#%"),#1?!"$C##!,D,#$# ,#$$"!!#$"!:&1,!:C",$#"97

 %!) E ,#$)  !?$"! 12""$"?  0* 8"$ .55<  #) =!!!91 ,#  89$ ,#1"$1) "" C) E$# ,#$) # 1#$"!  "!,#$"!,#!,#?$ #";1)"$,#$9 !"$I$#!,#"!,#$9,#!"$"1?!"#,#1?!AC",# =  :&1,!: ,$  #1  #"9 !"$  ./ 8"$ 0665  6 !$!;#.55<7

%!  !$ ,#!"$)  ,#$$"! C" ,$  #"9 ,# 7  $  2#7 4*E466)/5 $" C  C" ,#   $7 ""7 !"$D!:&1,!!$$ 2#7.<E.46)65M2#74*E466)/5&G.N7

"!;#D "$#& $#,#",#1?!A,#!2"!?##  !$$ "#$$ D  #)  ,,"$"!  E#$7 - 7 0 $7  ( & C ,#1?!"$ C E#1 ,$ :"9#  ,"$  ,@   ,#$$"!  !#$" !#CE" C"$$ 12""$"?$  %" & @ !# C  #$!"""1D"=A)(#),","#17

47 !2!#1$ D  8#",#) ,"  8!# 1$#"$ ,!#  ,#$9 8CE!$$#2#$,#$$"!!#$"!#)!8!"$ "?!#1;112"""#$$,#$$"!#!"$D"$1#I$!,$!"## !$$&"7 "$1#I$!$1$:""19!E#$70. E!#!#,#1?!A,#!2"!?"")#?"?$$"?""$1  0/ ?#" 06/4 M .N ! !  $: #19$"#) " "&" $ ,1#"# M (!,;"1<*35.0/8"$.55<N

-7  1!$  # ,#>)  ,#!1# 1$$ 9#$"$ M#$7 +< 7 .  $ /670!"#,#!1#""$#$"?0.,$;#06/-N7



    34.563.55- -3-  

!  2  !,   ,!   



34565   7  855 5  9" /+% :

07 ?"$  " $#& $#,#"  ,#1?!A ,#!2"! D ?##)  !,$  7  )  !  2#7 .<E.46)65 "#$$ D   7

.7 ?"$ "$#& $#,#",#1?!A,#!2"!D?##),   !$$)  "$1#I$ !,$!"#    !"1#$) @  6 !$!;#.55<8CE!$$#2#$7

<7 FA!$$C;!"7

47 ?"$    D !"C# D  " $#& $#,#"  ,#1?!A,#!2"!!!#!1,"$7

-7 "$C,#!1#$9#$"$7

*7 2!#  ,#$"   CE ,?$ 2!## #!# !$#  ,#1$ ##I$   1"  <5 8!# @  !$"2"$"! ,# ," #!1 #1  #"; 211#  #) %=H"P#=!2C" *) *554   )  $#!" :,"#7  1"  ,$ I$# ,#!!917  1!"# !"$ G N ""C# :$$ C 1""!  #!#$ 1"# !;$"#  " $ ,   1""!$$C1O;N:,!#,!#C!$"2"$",!?!"##$$ $#1""!ON,!#$#"9$#!!#,#1$$7%"1!"#  !$"$ ,  $#!" 11$ 11#1 ! $$# N ;N $ N "&)  #";211##,!##,$##$"@###!#CE" ?#1##"##?;71!"##!#$"!#!#!A  ,#?) C" #!$ 8!"$) "" C  1""! $$C1 $ E?!,,  C1$1:,1"1#!#$M#$70<.)05*$05/N7  9#22"@#G  #1"$G   A% 1#"  

!,"!2!#,#1$##I$$!$"2"1:,#$"""CFDF22"211# #!",#9#22

    34.563.55-