Contract Formation Despite Additional Terms in Confirmation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over whether a contract for the sale of goods was formed, centering on whether the parties' communications—specifically, a contract form containing pre-printed arbitration clauses and handwritten modifications—constituted a final agreement or merely an offer or confirmation, with the court ultimately concluding that the contract was formed under the relevant commercial code provisions. The court reasoned that a contract is formed even if the acceptance or confirmation contains additional or different terms, provided the acceptance is not expressly conditioned on assent to those additional terms, and that the handwritten modifications superseded the pre-printed clauses, with the intent of the parties at the time of the exchange controlling the interpretation of the agreement.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Formation Despite Additional Terms in Confirmation: The court reasoned that a contract is formed even if the acceptance or confirmation contains additional or different terms, provided the acceptance is not expressly conditioned on assent to those additional terms, and that the handwritten modifications superseded the pre-printed clauses, with the intent of the parties at the time of the exchange controlling the interpretation of the agreement.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order to rule on the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
!""#$$% &'!#$$'
( )(* *+* (* +)
, - & &$ #$$'
!" # $% # !&#%"# !'"# ( )* +
#
(, ( ( -!#.//012 #!" , )
653226
* .)
27 8&#%"&9"6##: ;7
57 21<%2442# ="";'6! # ##%"> & '6! ? @ &&" & A ((( ( A ( ( ( ) ( ?A( )@ &$ (7 ##%#&= "&8 !#" <$ &# > & " 41'111 97 ; /1B " $&!<7
.7 (# ; >99 " '" &"#" &#" #% 50%!C2445.1&#!C244.D'&=>7 ! "0#C244.;'99# '6% #"? @6 D'"%# " ! &##6 9&% #!&&	! E!&# # ' %" ### '6! E7
07 50!2440'"C&"# ##7'%" 9# !#" <$ ; ## &# > & &" 5F!24402G<%244F&!#### .5'/0597
F7 # /!244F ( (H # ( # 9"DI(, ># #" ! ?6&$'@7
J7 52 "!C244J'"#"&# ";(, & ! ! 9 ## ' # # " '### .1<&"#!&K7
G7 5F < 244J ' %K" ; ' "!&# !#" <$ &# > %" ; '" # 50 %!C 2445 # 2G<%244F7
/7 # G &#!C 244/ ' %K" ; ' & ' !!# ";'";&& !!" " &## D &"# D # 8 !#" <$ 9# 'C<# ' " #"7
47 " 21 &#!C 244/ ' #K" ; '" !#" <$&&" 50!24402G<%244F7&"#DE " ## '6% %%# # % #" &%# L#!&"% &###D'"D###" #"
32/4435110 6.3226
!&# M 5F071F1 &$ (( ( ( ((( "% ' ! ### # & &## "<;" !L! "?!D&#(, I ! !C!# #L# ";'"!L!&%C# %!# ; !## 21 < ; (( ( ((( F112 @E7 "## D" D' & " "## ";(, ;$%7
217 25 %!C 244/ ' ! " ; ' " #'&#" #%&2440D' "& 5 "!C244/D' %#N# # '=&### % &&%&&=> ' !#"<$7
227 # .!2444'"#"" ! 7%8&&# "#" " ; ' G <% 5111 G < 5111 # 55 %!C 51117 6 #" .1 <% 5112 6 "## #" "& ' J%5112 C !##9 '& " <##; D ' # !" ; ## & % " !#" <$7 "#" #! ; !! # !#$ (3 D;#'9#%22%5112;'999" " ?6&$'A (@!!C<# !&"#7 " 2F!5115'A ('<#"7' C9" " ? A @ ' # !##97 '" ' & =#" "#!7 ' "=> '"# ' # 'A ( # "#" !!D" ; ' D "" % & & " 21 &#!C 244/ #% 8 !#" <$D9># ' 7L# 5/<%511. "#" ""C<##'99K" O7##9"#"%"& A D' # P9!'&# >D'%# "<;##" !#" <$ # !## & "7 ' C## %# #% && '# # '# !##%7
257 ##># 209"%511.' ";'" ! !C!# ' !## .5'/05 97 & # 8 !#" <$ &# > %" & &" 50 ! 2440 2G <% 244F &" # D ' %# " ; '" !## 0J'152975F7
2.7 5F 9"% 511. '" "& ; ' D' # & % ## !! # D' # 9 "9 #"L#;7
32/4435110 603226
207 25 ! 511. ' (( ( ?6&$ @ ! " '#"";'7 &$ <#9# ! !C!# # "#" " 2G <# 511.; 7 # 5J&#!C511.'8&D"D''%# D'%!C5115 9#D !&#%# !&"2F#C244/!##%"&' ## ' !#" <$ % ## ( ""7 <#" D '" %# %"C># >'9!#& !C!#&"" &' #D'%# & !!&# "&# &&# D # ; D !&# %# &" " ; !&##;D' %#%"&##79 &"" D !&# # '"=" &= " &&# &# %# "#" >>" ; '# '" & !## .5'/0597
2F7 # 50#C511.'"9#&&#!! !# &K D"#"#9"!L!<7
2J7 " F <% 5110 ' %" '&&# ; &# # "!%" "9#%&!! .5'4G5972F7
2G7 " &&# 54 <# 5110 ' <#" '&&# 9!"&'"229"%51107
2/7 ### "&&#'"&$ C " # 20&#!C51107 '&& 9#% '&#D '' "!#"&&$D'#%"#C"$ # !#"<$7 $99#D'#!"'&&&#"&% D' & ###" " ( '"&D7 '# &# D D' !D E## &$ "!## D ' %# &%# #" ' !C!# # !#" <$ D' "## C>" 9 &! #!& 6 "% 'L#"$ !#"<$D#6=#D (%#!&!#%" # !#"E7##&"D# L# "C# '7 # C !# D & !&C ### " '### "C#D'8# " "## P!# "#C % # ## D " D#####%&9#" ' !# !#"<$K#"#"" #"!&# (&!& ##"" 7'&&"> '7$% 9D C " %# !##" # &## '6! & !# 6 #N#
32/4435110 6F3226
'>!## " %!# <D'; G51 < D''#="D5.1< ' !#"<$7
247 "& 2.#C5110'#!"$%D'2<%244J ( 9" % ( (H # % (, ( ( Q # 	 "#" &
2 <%5115&(, (( 6 (7 7'#!" D& D # "## # ## & &D' '# " #!#; # 52 "!C244J&! 9# ## '7&&C#" & &" %# A !# #### & & (, (( 6 (7 7D ! !C!#D' %# " ; ' # 0 #C 244. # 5J < 244J7 >!# #D#;'8# ' !####" &'D'>!## " %!#&D'" '&&"#" '&#" #%&#"!#2G<%244F79 '#!" $ D &"## '# !# &# &D' ' &## '6% #"D'%!C5115D' 9# ! ### 20 9"% 511. # " "C# "D# &# # 5.&#!C511.7
517 "&D J "!C5110#9#%D'#!"'%#& &&#"&%99# ### "#D''%#&& # "D# &# 5. &#!C 511.7 & %D" &"!&# # '#!" &"!&# D &# L# #!&7
527 &D J<%511F'#!"<# #"9"#;!"! "&7
557 .2<%511F#"&"#"D(, '%# &&%"### "$# 8&D"&D'%#& D !C!# #!# '6% #"7 ! "D#" '#!" 209"%511.###" #'#"9""&& 8>!# "%&&" "&D7
5.7 ("#"> ";<>7
* +)
27 >%R>#< ?@"#"! 9"###" $ 2P#511. C# !&" F<> # &" # # %6&" # F &&"# # 2J <> ?#7 2 #7#FJ @7
32/4435110 6J3226
(#;R# R"# 2J<>& C9" " 5G<%5110? A2.121J@ >% &#"2.9"% &###>#&!### C# "> ; # <> ## R### R"# %8<>7
57 9!"!# ; '#7 FJ 7 2 #7 =7 0 C # N# # D ### &"% ; R#7FJ #%;9" "R6! 2/!2440 ? @7
## '6! #% &"%K# %!# ' !#" <$ &# > 6 D ="" # <% 2442 6 % 8&"!#;9" "'6! 2.<2422? @7
'># C ' 9##% ' !#" <$ #7JG &D#C "#!&"##7
.7 #<#" 9!# "&#&"##%C?#7FJ# J1 @7
07 #>&#'C>#&'" ## !#"<$ D # "#" %" & '#!" & &" 50 ! 2440 2F<%244F %!# & !L! &" !#" <$ '6% #" '!#### 0J'152975F7
F7 (&D#&"C %D# &#&&C '&$7 ! S !#" #> # "#" %" %# 2<%244J %# && '&&D &# 9" "'! 2.<2422? @7 & # " &&#D ! ### #&##66"#" &$'#"%> 7
## &###'#7/572&!$&= &# D &#!#" #&&&C8&## # 8 " 98" %# #" %>7 #%8 &"&# '#7 5F ? #7 .5 &<#@ #9 ; ### &## P!# #=" # &"!# !#" !! 8!& ' &#D#&&&C; &## "<;%" %# '#" %> ?AA 2442 &7 5JJ@7 %= H(? (6H!!##4 #7/5@ !SD# ###&&$2<%511.% ##&&C $ D'###"###&$#"%>#D C!L! ###&# &## "#"!#7
32/4435110 6G3226
D# # &## # #!& %L# ##9 & !&# "% # &# # %# ' ! S &&&&C;### # ">!## # <& #"?H(&7#7#4 #7/5@7
J7 '#7 5F 7 2 &"%# D &## P!# #=" %# L# ##"T###&#L#8>"D'#"""## C9# !### ## 997 ## &## "! #!# &&C !#$ '6! ?#7 2 "# % '#75 @7
D'C># ##!!#D "<;"#" >" & '#7 5F 7 2 9# D & ">!## '#70G72 (D"##<D;&&C&>;###& " &## '6! P!#%"? A25J5.T 5112MH2F/&72J2 7J@7
### &##'#70G72 (&&D#!& # ' "# '"%&" ? A254221 7 2@7 ( && >"" # ' !## &# " " 9!!# &" 9 =<>" #D##"< '#&&" D# 9 ; # D' # # " # D #9# %L# !&##C? A25G0J4 75#L##"@7#& > % "% " & ##" < ' !## # # &" ; "% ' " #" 9 9! D # "%# 9# %8 %8 !K &%&#C ;&&"#< D 99"#? A25G 0J4 75#"9"@7
&& '&&D# ; ### &## D 6 # "#" " & " 9! % 9# 'C<# ' # "7 &$ & #!& & # " # " 9! ' !## &# ! "&"## &##"& "!&###"D'8 # "# "%&" ? A254221 72@7 O#"'"&# " "98# "98%C!9# " %## &#"&' !###8&! %#" %## # #&#C 7 "9# " !&# D# 9 = " " ? A 254 221 7 2 25J50 70C255.J4 7.@7
G7 '&$'#!"%";'" !#"<$ 5F!2440 2G<%244F7 '#9#'C<# ' "9!
32/4435110 6/3226
### &# L# "!" D'8 # ' "# ' "%7
%!# !#"<$&' " '6% #"'"###% #D " % 6!'"##&"7 # ' "## &""7
%= " 21&#!C244/ ' #K#;'" !#"<$&!L!&" ##9#%#<#9 "% &" " '#!" &#C 9 ### &##%"7
/7 # '&& ; ### T %D &"C!# "9# D#" "$ (, D '# & &&#" &% D' %# &###" " (7##&L# "C# " #! D '#!" # P &"C!# # ' !C!# !#"<$%# "!###7
D' & ; &!$ % !& 6 "> #!!# ## 9# ( (H # ( D##"(, ( ( Q( #;'8## ># !! & # 6 D# D#" "$ '#!" &# #%# %#L# !& '#!#97% !L! &C$! D#" "C# #7
47 #>!##9#%D"#&# %!# ' !#"<$K#2G<%244F7
@ 8#! R#75F75 # ! ###&# &";!&# !!#S'### ' 9#!&# &D&$&!# #7( # ! ###N# R#&C&D&"&"%# " &&# & > " # "#!#7 #8# # #D ; R #7 0G 7 5 ( &&C !#$ R6! 7 " ##" & ## &# "> # " &"!&# ? A224 0.. 7 . # L# #"T A &C" 51.310 49"%511F@7
C@# &$& #D''&& " ' #K# !#"<$#D'! %!C5115 "=> '"##% %# A 7 K ## D " &&# R "## "= D '#!" F <% 5110 " 9! ! #
32/4435110 643226
### !#" <$ %" 2440 # 244F7 D# % 20 9"% 511. &# L# "" !! " K# #!& " &# ! %# ! S " D'DD'#&"#"&#"D "!#" 6 7
@ (R># " D A <>" & !#9 #=# ; "#" ## R !##9DRR># R " &"!&#D>9D'&#L#&>"&%#" &# & !L!#!&? A2222.F@7 "!!&& ;; # %!# &##7
%#K&D!# ##S#$ &##8# "<; !!# &!# D # !!# # # U R># &## &" D U ; # #" ; # R =>!# #!!&8!&!> R& C""9 R# %% %97
%= D '# &!# &## "" & D<#9### &## '#6&&# $> "> # 6 #$ &## <## ; !C!#'&&N#D'&$&7(' $D">#% # " &"!&#C D&!##6&" "6 &# 9 ; &&# RC># # R # "C# &# D' % D " !! ; $ R## S K &!# # S # R ### # &#C RL# !& ? A25G0/0@7'9 # "D'#!!# S !#" <$ "" '6% #" # "#" %" 6 #;D## (""#"#"!&"%"##9 ' !#" <$ 6 # 2F #C 244/ D !#9 ### # &&#D "!!";7
D# &# "&# " &"!&#&###9#%# ''DD'#&"#"&#"7
9!"!#;<& !#$ &"!&# " "&# !!>?#7F5 (@#8>"&D " &"!&# F # &#" ?#7 /5 7 2 (@ D R##" " "&# F ; !&# 9# !!>C7 R# & " DR " "9#%#& "? 2442&72.J@7
'&$ ## D " ### '#!" "#" F<%5110#D';## # " &"!&# D6D ' & "#" #!& & &# >>" 5. &#!C 511. 6 "##
32/4435110 6213226
>!# "&" D' # !!" ; $ %!# !#" <$ & ' ? 2G <% 244F@ $ !&# ## (""%"##9 P&' ?2F#C244/@7
47 #DC##> % !#";## "&7
32/4435110 6223226
( A( ( (( (( (I
/0121 3 411 1 56 '# +7
21
27 "%C
21
57 R !## " '#!" F<%#54<#51107
.7 ! R#!" ; % # !#" 2'111 97 ; ## "&7
07 9! &# DR &%# 9! # &"# L# " .1 < $ #9# & & !! " " C 9" " (=VW=9D J J110 # 8!&7 " &# L# &>"7 !"! #I @ D 8#!#D "# "C##& " ##D"T C@ 8& & D !#9 #! &% ! ## # "T @ &# ># &"##7 ( !"! ## & # ""!# "!"" ## @ C@ # @ 6 C9" " &&#!#$DR % "%C7!"! !#!K &% D # <# D " ##D" # R%&& D"#"8&" "#?#72.521J#21/@7 >99$ " #I AA H( H >99$6<#I #=
&9! &"#L###9"8&#DR;R999" " #"&CD&>99
32/4435110