Commercial Damage and Interest Calculation Appeals
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed multiple consolidated appeals concerning the proper calculation of damages and interest in commercial disputes, particularly regarding claims arising from breaches of contract and related financial obligations, involving various transactions occurring between the mid-1990s and the early 2000s. The reasoning consistently centered on applying established legal principles for calculating pre-judgment and post-judgment interest, rejecting arguments to use different or inflated interest rates, and affirming the lower courts' factual findings regarding the underlying contract amounts and breach dates, thereby upholding the damage awards and interest calculations as legally sound under the relevant statutes and agreements.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Commercial Damage and Interest Calculation Appeals: The reasoning consistently centered on applying established legal principles for calculating pre-judgment and post-judgment interest, rejecting arguments to use different or inflated interest rates, and affirming the lower courts' factual findings regarding the underlying contract amounts and breach dates, thereby upholding the damage awards and interest calculations as legally sound under the relevant statutes and agreements.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision is cited in the final order regarding the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
!!
" !#"$ %$&$ "!$% &%#
%'() *
!
!
"# $%&'!('') %* !&' +,) -!../0$+,++ .
3,143
$ +#
+5 $'+67,$'8!$!!%9%!$! 8'': % -!! % * &&& ! %9% ; #< %-=+6625
,5 >&%9?!+66/$8'':@'!'!3-!!->% 9!A 5%9!B%%::!':'*,000$ * % # -- C9 +666$ 9!'' *! D %* &!! -*! % %@ (& % A $ E ! F 5 # 9!''$ 9(! %9%&!' - G --'&!::!'%!3-!!5
.5 %'%,.&,00+$*% #!:'H9!''9I!% -!!% #*::!&&'%!!'&'&8&!% J5,+9K265K2$-'!!-!!DH!!--'%%%'&8 +66/H:'*,00+5'&!!=!'-9!''->%'%!% %9%&!!%9"-('''!'=!'-%'%,7?! ,00+$ !:' +/ !8 ,00+5 !! %' ! !' :$ :! % 5
75 %,6=*,00,$9"-(''$!*% #$ '!8!8'-!!:H9!!!% $9:&! C &!! %?&! -D 9'*! H J5 ,,9,265K2$ ! -! % -% !!:%%':-%&8&!5-8!'%9%&%% & !! -! -> % '%! % %9%&!! !! '*'5
25 ,2 :'* ,00,$ 9!'' %'-' %&% % & % !!!' % &!!H!!$*C!*!'!!&&-8*!@5 --! * 8! &!! C&! % !3 -!!5@-!C9->*'!'@% #$9'!!!*' )9!&H&-!%'8!,00,!8!CC&%!5 '(! !* % !! :> :!85
/5 %+,&,00,%'H9"-(''$%! !'-$-!*&!&'%-8%E !'! ('' % F $ ! ! 9!'' % %'&G$ --! C9 *! ::!' !3-!! - %@ !$ (L H C 9 - C ** ! : : H 8(! :&5 *C!!!-'%9!''$C99!&H&-! %%9 !!5
1+2021,00, 3.143 K5 %''&!%,&,00,$!:'7=,00,$'%!% %9%&!! % 9"- ('' =!' %&% % &5 %''C9!''*!&&*!(*%%*%9:&$ -*! % * % A -%! !3 -!!) 'C$8:-*!I!!5
45 .=!,00,$9!''!=!'->% &&! % &!> #1 1 # ;=%9G 8 ! % <$--!CC!%8:%*!I!-' %!@!5@-'C99*!*!'%'8''%9@-! :>&!!!5#!!-'9*!-%9&'! %!C%>')%&!'C9*!D%A '!!'!'%%&!'!GC%H8!C%'-! (&! % % !3-!!5 # 9!''$ &!! % J5 ,,953'&'@-'!(%-!%:-: C9%?&-&!5@-'*''!>(%!* %!C'-'HA $'!!&&!!!! %9!$-'!!-%7008G,0!G>&%::'!!- % 7000 -( !!5 %> * - C &- !! ! !& =!%%*&8&&-%!*''5--C9 *'-%!@*&!!%9%%J5.,0053-&!C99 --:!'% #5
65 '-%/-!&8,00,$9"-('':&C%>& %9?! +66/$ ! @'!' !3-!! -> % 9! A 5 %9 !B ::!' & % :'* ,000$ ! -- C9 +666 9!'' *! D %* &!! -*! % (& % A ) %> '!' *!' H -'! =!:!: % ! &!! !G' %- C9 !*! - E 5 ! $-!!%!'%+6:'*,000$*D&%&+666%@ &!! % J5 7,253$ -*! 9 % E ! 9! % F 5 9!'' @-C! C &!! '!! *' &-!8H 9#9--! M%&!'!GC N5 -'! ! C 9!'(!' % *&! ::!' - &!' ! E !F -'!!!!&&%J5,4970053 %! !&! %* %'% J5 ,K953 $ -'!! 27 &!' % J5 20053!!%:G5&'%-8%E $%! $%%'H9"-(''%!%2*,000$ --'C9!''*!'!'-'!H%'&G%*% # -> % A O --!! &-'! ! @! 8!%%%-!!%%'*--&!%!!!% 9!5 !&&!%@(!GC!%:&!$ %'!:'C&&!%G'()*!'!''C%'%' %9!!8 % %&!' !GC !3-!!$ % -! %9
1+2021,00, 37143 &P % J5 20053 - &5 +6 & ,000$ % %' %! $*% #-!C&&' -'!! % : % -'!!$ % !''-G$ % :@ !$ C 9!!%:!-%%%%!H%'%:G%J5 200535%! '!!-%!-'%&!!-GC& %-?!+66/%'&-!&!!&&C-%!H% &8&!%9'*!:H%!(%C-%!H% ( - !* :5 =!:!: 9! -%! -* * % #5
+05 +2*&8,000$!H!(!%%% #$CI! '!'%&%'*&-'!!%9"-('')--!%9CI!% ,K & ,00+ '*'' C %! -'% % ,6 *&8 +66/ 4 :'* ,00+$%&!!-&&!!%J5.7+.653*!'!'*' &-! # % !$ -*! % E ! % F 5 9!-!$!,4*,000!2:'*,00+$&&%J56+K053 *! '!' *' '(&! ! &-! # --!! H 9!''$ &-!%*% #5!!!'%&!!-D9'*! HJ57.9.065359"-(''%>C!G'&!! C9 !G! ::!! !3-!!$ *! % 8(! % (&!5 # 8 : ! I! !$ % & O *!$ - * - % 8(! (! %&! M ((&! %&%! # N C9 %*! ! 9"- ('' ! % !! :! * -!8 %9!Q &%:!$ * -- % -!! '5 9"- ('' ! =! % 5
++5 ->*C9--!&-!%%% #$ 8%' -'%'H9%!%-!5!!!'**'8(! % ($ --! C && C9 *! -D % A 9'!!C%%&!'-:5*'%*%&!H -'%$C!'!'&&C'H9!&'5
+,5 G%-!-!'%5%*'('$C ''&! -!! '!! % 9!! ! % -> % % ! -$!!C%8$%-!%!3->5
$ !&#
+5 %%*-'8&!C(*9(!=%% ,,*&8+67+; ,02<'!'&%:'-%+7*&8,00,$! C9 8 ! % '!' !!' %> + ?! ,00.$
1+2021,00, 32143 !!!!C$!&&!!!!-'*H9!.4 %!-!!!%'@GB&:% %!$ % +4 *&8 +667 ;: !5 +$ !5 $ ! 2/$ 5 ,$ !5 %$ <5 :&'&! H 9!5 .$ 5 . % %-! !! % &%:! $!%!*!9!'*(%-'!!-%! %*! &&!%&!>%-!!%'@ GB& : % %! ! '!' !& %9:: 8 ! % 5>$&-'!% 8%'!'!8- =(%-'!!(5
,5 :&'&! H 9!5 .4 % -!! ! %' @ GB& : % %!$ % +4 *&8 +667$ !' *( + =* +662 ; # R , ,2<$ 9!'' 9!& '' - %' '&!%'%!% %9%&!!%9"-(''$-! :& $ - '! ! % .0 = C *! !:! % %''&!->% &&!%&!> #1 ;=%9G 8!%<5%'-' - 9' . =! ,00,$ ! %' '&! % , & ,00,$ !:'7=,00,$!*8:&5
.5 98=!%-'!!(!H%'!&!-!8'':% &$!!-!$%&!!%!9!&''&'!!!5
75 !%9!5,0$5, #$8'':C'!!%8:!!H !!!$!!-!$%&O!-&%:!% !! %::5 # =-% % 8 :'%' % $ 8 : % 8'': % -!! ! @ %9&8' C :! C %! H 98(! % !! ;*! % %* %9 % (< ! &-!8H&-!&!%:H'(((*;# #+666.47$ %5.!':'!'<$!C%P!%!:&-H C-!I!@('%9--8%%&!% !! %!C!%&I&!; J+,+72$%5.8$++4.0/! *!$%5,!':'<5
25 < 9->$!'!8C%>&%9?!+66/$!::!' !*!' &-! -> % 9! A 5 :&'&! H 9!5 ,K$ 5, #$ !! !*!' :! 98=! %9 *! % 8! ! 9"- ('' ! E $ (' +. ?! +66/$@!&%C9'!8&!%9::!!9((!H- 8'': % * &&& ! %9% ;:5 -> &-'&! #<5
1+2021,00, 3/143
9!-!$!!!:H9@%9!*!'&-!'!'(' 4=!+66/!8'':!*%*&&&! %9% ;: -> ! @ % +, -!&8 ,00.<5 @ !& % !!$ ! %*! @ !*!' % !! :&!C->%E $*%A $H% ,0 G G8%&% &@&&5 % %@ !! -'!' :! ':' H %&! CC5 9'!! - :! -%($%9:G%:5200535
8<9!&'%>C!9!-%8:$%&O 9 - :&' #* % # % &!! C9 -*! % 9! -> % C ::!! !3-!!5 ! --!>(C&!!C9-D%9!%'-%! % A '!! '!' % &8&! - : $ -C9!*!%=&&%!$!C9!!C!$9*!-H 5
8 % ' >* H ! '(% C %> %'-!$ !3-!! ::!'-!(&!%'-'%%,0GG8%&% &@&& :@' - !! !: H 9@ % 9!*!' &-!5 ::!$ % -& &-! % % !3-!! % +, * +66K$ !(!%'=H!*+2G-=!-:-$%=&& % !$ % % % !3-!!$ (! 9&-! % !* C9 ::!! - 9! A ;: -> !<5 8!%*% #G(%%&!!%!% ,2:'*+666C!'!!!=!>!!%!3-!!! C9P!*!!=!!5&I&$,+*+666$'!!*'C !-!8-%!!3-!!!C3*!-!! !&-%&$:!-!C&!%-!&-59!&' !''!!!!!9!-!*->%9!:%9!! !!!-!%,0G%!*&-!-&5
%%--C-!! #(!!@GB&:% %! * &&&$ : % '*! %9* H 9! -8C5 'G($8'':%-!!::!!3-!! :&%9!*%9!!'-8C5'(!*-''&! '*!C9!*!'&-!--%9*'!8&-C! '&'' - -!! % #5 !3-!! *! H !! ! !&! %9!!' ! -! % : C !! % &8@GB&5:!-%!*HC!*!'9&->!!- % &- @!! ! ! I! -'!@! %'*--&! %9&- -' ! 3-P'5 ;:55 '& % %3 $ +667+S$ -5
1+2021,00, 3K143 20K7R20K2$2+++<5 9->$:!%!!C!3-!! %*! '!' &- H - !&-) &8! #* % # % -% !! * 9! ! %9@& &%!' %9 ((&!'*!5$&!#*% #9!-!*$ & $ H GC :$ *' %! @ -!! % ! -8>&$ C ! % = % 9!&' %'&! ;:5 = % 9!&'$-> #<5
!! !! -%' =C9 :'* ,000$ %! H C J% !B'%!9!-DC!-*!%%&!'C9 %'' &&% (!&'%5 +0:'*,000$ 8! %9!&'&!!C!-*!J520053%%!3 -!!$--:C9:!%@!;:=$-> #<5
* % C -'>%$ &-! ! % :! C * % # ' 8! !! !! C %'-! (&! % % !! :@' ! -!$ ! % :! C ! %'!$ H !! H $ C9 9(! %9%&!' - : $ 8 % ' !& C9 =!: %9%&!!8:%!=C9:'*,0005!!-'% ! '!! H 9'*% '!8$ & !! %' - -'% %9?! +66/ H :'* ,0005 *G$ %> +0 :'* ,000$ ! C %&!' '&'! C9 -*! % A -!-8>&5--!!'C%>!!! %9:& &&'%!&! ! '(>&! * % # % &!! C9-*!GC&$C99-!:!5%!$8 :-!-I!%&H&-!%&%:'*,0005
/5 #9(!%&!!H!!$ 8%'!%&!!!!% J5,+9K26$K253$!C9'!%%'%!!!!':5# !8'-!!:'!8-*% #$!--D9'*!H: =*,000HJ5+.9446$2053;:->T+.G(' #<U&!!% &!! ! %' !5 ! &!! % J5 K94K0$,253 ;J5 ,+9K26$K253 & J5 +.9446$2053< C ! %! !! * % #5
1+2021,00, 34143
! % ,&#+ !#"$ %$&$ "!$% &%#
-./0/(( 1 2// / 34 & 5
0/(
+5 D!5
0/
,5 V%&!-!&!5
.5 %!&%&!!%J5+.V446$20!:@%&!' -D%!-'%%%'&8+66/.+=*,0005
75 =!!&-%!!%J5)
25 '8!-!%!!!!5 (:: -'%! S% -:&%-'!I!!!:'@-!-(::
1+2021,00,