Agency Fine and Stop-Work Order Upheld on Construction Site Compliance
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellate court addressed whether a prior administrative decision imposing a fine and a stop-work order on a construction project should be upheld, focusing on the agency's interpretation of regulations regarding site conditions and work commencement. The court reasoned that the agency did not abuse its discretion by finding the work violated regulations because substantial evidence supported the determination that the site was not ready for the level of work performed, justifying the imposition of the penalty and the stop-work order to ensure compliance with safety and permitting requirements.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Agency Fine and Stop-Work Order Upheld on Construction Site Compliance: The court reasoned that the agency did not abuse its discretion by finding the work violated regulations because substantial evidence supported the determination that the site was not ready for the level of work performed, justifying the imposition of the penalty and the stop-work order to ensure compliance with safety and permitting requirements.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order regarding the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'$$% "&('"'$$(
) !) ) !
*+, % -. / '$$(
!"#$%&$''" $ (&$'')$
$
* + !' $"& $,$-.!#$//01!2/22 /
!
5/32/5
0!
26 &$$ 77& 8$& ' $9 # &$& : *6 6 ;5#< = "#>? '< 2 %", 20@@6 /A #$", /..1! $$ '< B"& (& 8 ($# $ C$ &7&! 8 "#8$ '&$ D *6 '< '"'&(#$$'#%,$D*!(B"$8 $$ $ && # /2 '&", /..1! ( B$6 ' // '&", /..1! ("#> B"& &$ ' $$ ' $% ' "#>"/..-!'"E5%$B&'(&$, 6
/6 ("#>&($$#<'(FF ( ;5#<= ?$8%"$'('"$&'9G"7'<2%/..-6 &$& $ '"& # * + ;5#<=?'#'<$$'$H8(12'&",/..-6
16 2@H%/..4!(&&$&$'#$'8C$$'% H'8 ' ( ;5#< = $ ' 8C$?6 * '&$! 9,$$D*$7>'#24%",/..1'##$"$'(#<$ '"! D $ '( 55 //-6 #&'$ &' ' D 7> F! ' " 8 &$$ 9,$,! " &$$ ' $%I!#8>#$'$"#$"#H&6%$ $&	 BI D $$ '6 * %$ &$$ ""$& F! " #&'$ 8"$ #" ' ' 6 B$ # ' "8 % ' # $ $ D $ BB$ D "" ' >6 (#$$&D$&7'8!7"$,$D"' >!(&$$$$'#20@A$$ &$$'&'200@D/..1F6#/..-!"%>$D *$7>6 * (#$! B$ &7"$ % &' ## F!##%>""$%&96
-6 &$ ' ,8 ' '& ' (FF ;5#<= ?8(&8$$&<%12'&",200J # (&$, D 7> F6 $ D #& D $ &7' 8 (& (&$$ "& /0 K$ 200J % $$ BL6 24 %", /..1! (& # % &# '" D <%6 $$ '< > &'$ ##"<B6
46 '& ' 2 B&% /..4! H$& '"' '('"$& ' (& % BB$ &$$B 2 % /..-! "$B 8 $ '($&C$ $ ' '" &$$ F6 D $ &7' %& 8( (&$$ %'$'<%8(#<8"#>%$& '&$'($#!8&#(%$H"&'&#%$
3-.413/..4 5132/5 $$'<%!8($%%&9""$&F$8( #&'$"D7>%$&	BI6)$!(##$"$ &D*$7>"#$$8(#<$'"6
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
J6 '"' ' ! (& $" 2 % /..4 ' %& ' ""$ '(&$$&! '( $ ' 9BB7 # &' ' 7> $ ##$"$ D *$7>6 H$ D % #<5%, ' $$')$ '& + !9H'#<' ,I' <%!'/2"/..4!8'#9$7#9'($&'"' 7>$'##$"$D*$7>6'("#7"$! %&8#<5%,'$$&$,#)$ + #"$$$' 8 " D 7> (&$$ $"$ # 9,$, ' "< ',!'$8(#%$#'&8(>&$$'"&6
@6 *$$'(9!9",'#"&$7'"D7> $ # $"&! #B' $ %& $ D B6 #8
3-.413/..4 5-32/5 '(77"&& $ $7 ' BC$ $ # $"& #6 '&#$$###$$&$&%&6!', ($ # B6 $ &$7 $ '< 9,$,6 $ M5'59&! $%I''9$ '$$$$$"&!D(I#$'B$6 $ ' , ' " $ # ' '&#G$ $ ' ,' $ ($ # "&7&6$$$"&D(I#$'B$6
06 '"''!(&#&&A"/..4!8$%I' " %$ '&,$& '$ (&$& /... # M5'59& $ % B ' (&/..1!'$''&"&7"$D*$7>!2&$76 $I", 7$ " D 7>! %$ #$ 8'&! &$$ #&& 8( &$$$%!$B&&'##$"$D*$7>6
2.6 *##$'(8C$'22K$/..4!(&$%$D('' '"D*$7>#'$&'2/24H$/..46$" '/K$/..4!>%$&7"$88('##$"$6(#$ %$#$&	&D"'7>'$"#>&"" %$ '8& D 'I # 8 (& > &$$ & "" &'$6 (#$ &#&$& 8( B$ % &' ## F! # ,$""$$BL!8&$&B"&#$&	# 5#&B$'I6
226 21#$",/..4!(&($'&$"&##$'(8C$!%$ 8 #& ' (##$"$ D *$7> &$$ B"&! 8 '&"$$ 8( > &$$ BB$%"$ '"&6 (&$$ # # "#& F6 $ D %&9 ""$& F! > %$ &$& ""$& 200@ '&HD!$D'$E&#I>&$$'"&6
2/6 '& ##$ ' 2J $, /..4! H$& 56 $8(BB$'(&$'&#D'5"' (&$$##$$!'"E&$$'#$'#% $$$B$6(&$$##%$!#"C""$B!'(%' $%$& $ $ ' #$ $ '($ ' B$< B57%6 $ I B$ ' ""$ '(! '(&$$& $ ' 9BB7 ' (##$"$ ' *$7> $ ' " ' 7> #'$ # (&! (##$$ # '('$ #&! ' " E $%I $# ' &' BL $ %",,"$ ""$ &7&$86 $$$'(9')$ + !5($$$$ #8M5'59&'"D7>&$$9,$,6"$B! 8 I #&&'""$ %8&! '&& 8 '" ' $&$$F6
216 $ ' 2J %", /..4! (&! # ($"&' ' ! $H$&$$$'&!$!#&#$"$!D(%$
3-.413/..4 5432/5 '(8C$$#$!D$$##!#&&'$!$ ''"$7"$$$&6#!'8& %&$&'"&#($"&'2%12'&",/..-6(>%$# '9",D9'$M5'59&'"D7>$$ ' $ &$7 %$ ' '&#G$ $ ' ,'6 (I$& ' " $%$#'%"9'9$6$BB$$% &# ##$ ' $%I ' &%$6 < '&,$ ' $%I 2 &$7 B /..1! " &$$ '% 9,$, ' #<! ' &"$ $I8! ' #$ $ ' ! 8 (, ' B$ ;$""$(,'9BB7$%$7?6B$%&7"$8!' #"$"#!$&#%$9$&"',$'B' B"6 $! (&$$ $$B %&& 8( #%$ # % '(B$6'$!(&$$#"$%	,$$$" $#$'$%I'&%$(%$#'($,$8%$6 ! (& %$ B$ ""$ 'I<" %&9! 8( %$ '(8&!*22$,/..46
2-6 &# ' 2 '&", /..4! ($"& H$ ' ! #$7"$$$&6 $B$%8 %&9 ' $ ""$& D <% %$ /1 '(N7 $ (%$ H" &$& % D *$7>6&#I $$'"&''&HD%$' (##$"$ D *$7>6 ! B$ ' * ' /2 $, /..- #'$ # $! %$ '8& "" "& ' $&	 #%& "& BL6 #9$ (%$ &$& #'$ ' M5'5 9&'"F$>%$&7"$%'H' '56($"&($&$&8!'<8$(%$#'$%! " '%$ 9,$,6 $! "C" ( %$ '" ' $"# $"# D <%! B$ '& 8 (&$$ # ""'$& # ##$ I 'BB&$&$#'&%$'"6 7B$#8&#I %$ # $$ $B&& $ '($&C$ *6 &$$ B$ %",, 8 &#I #$$ %% D 7>! B #$ ' $%I9%&6%$&(##$"$D*$7>',$'$9 9G"7*$%$#$'!'<8(%$&$&#&#$"# $8&$$#%$7I#B6&#I(%$#B$ ' 99 # $% ##$"$ #'$ "I D ,! '<8(&$$$&D($,$'$E$%$'$%' (&# ' $6 *( 9$$ &"$ %% D <%! $ &7"$>&''&#''"'#7"$,%$&6
246 '/.B&%/..A!$#$&'6 H$&8!#<%#'(#'(%'B$!&#(&$$"D 99"#$8!#B!&$$#'"$##8'$ 99 $ # B % '" *6 '& '(,'"D7>("#$'&7"$#'$
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
2A6 '#8'1"/..A!($"&#$&'6
2J6 4%/..A! &$&$'$$8$&"6 '&&8(&$$%'$$8(9,$$"C"#8 56 $ &$$ ' , %6 %>$ &7<"$ $$B""'##$"$D*$7>!8$" #'$OP5'67$8(#&'$&7"$"D7> F6!$&$$"$'"&D*$7>6
2@6 "C" '$ &7"$ &$& $' $$ 8 $&" '" 6 5'&&C$%'$6$ '&#$ # ' , %76 $ $ $ &# B&8""$' &'("",!8 $"#'$
3-.413/..4 5J32/5 OP5'6 ! &#I &$$ '"& D *$7> $ 7$ 8(#&'$"F6
206 4 % /..A! , ' & $ #&'& D ('$ ' '" !$$8$&"6 5$('H$'"$$%D" '7>$'&&8!%",/..1!$(&$$'D" # '& 8 " ' $$ "" $ '&%$ 8"$ % ' &' ' $ 8( $ 9,$ *6 %>$ #8 H" D 7> $ 7$ ( &$$ %$ ' " ' $$ ""6#!B"&'&$&$'2JH%/..A6
/.6 $'"#$#D"C"'$8$&"!$ '&& 8 &# (%$ # $%&! $$ 8( %$ &$& '"& F!$8!'#"7!%$$%&##"<B!D#$ ' 2/ H% /..-! *6 &#I %$ #%$ 'I 96 #'$!#<'&"&7"$D*$7>!%$'K(&#! "I '&7$ $# %6 $$ ' , (%$ # &$& &$, " ' &#! ' " E &7 (%$ # '"'& $ 8 &#I (%$ # % &$& ' B6 B! B$ $%I ' &%$7'#$I5"C"!8I#8$'&6
/26 ('(''"#$#!&$&7'&DH76
!
26 7%Q7$H';?&$&"'B&$$$&!'< 2K$/..1! ,$'!"#&'4H7! '$#&'$$%5#&'$!4##&$$2AH7;$62$6 $4A ?6
*$DQ$'Q&$'2AH7!# ,B&'& /JH%/..-; F21.2.A?!' 7%'#$&!21B&%! '#$$$7$#"$$$ ,$' ' &7 D $ H7 $$! ! ' Q$$$ ' Q&$'%IH76
/6 B"&"$ D ($6 4A 6 2 $6 96 @ ! , $ ' )$$8'$$$#&%DQ$64A 'B&'&#$7&&''$''A$, /... ; ? 8 $ $% D B&'& Q59G"7 ,7$$Q'"$&'Q%,$&'/4H20@/; ?6
*"#&$#H7''Q#<$&$,6
3-.413/..4 5@32/5 $H$& ' '& $ B" #&% # ! '$ C$ '&& %, ;$6 A. $ A2 ! # % ' $6 2 6 2 $ @0 ' 7%#&''"$$%'2/#$",20@45 ?6
-6 * Q$6 41 6 2 ! '& $ '& ##$ B""$ #& B $ " D &%! Q& Q '&%#$'B$%I"#$$$%'%I"> '#%8#%$C$#'$#%$6
(! ($"& '& $ ' '"$& ' 9G"7! ##$8( &$$'"&D<%6$!$$B'$ 8$ D '" $! , ' $$$ ' (#$ 97& ' '! $ %& D 8 $ &$$ &$& $H '"& F6 (7$ '( B$ "#$$ #%$ ' D ##&$ H'8 'BB&$ $ 8 &$& '&%$ $&"$6 &8$!$#&'("$B'&%#&'; F2//21@ '6/'?!#"$$$D($"&'%!&9&$!'&$ '($'#$$6
46 I$"'Q$6@62$6 !Q&'$DQ'"$&'9G"7! $$'$!Q$'"&*6
(##8 &7"$ ( ' ' /2 H 2000 $ B&'&$ !'(#$!$ ""$&#&$ $$"",!'($#$! , $ ' # ; ?! $& %7 2 H /../! 8 <7"$ I8 $ B$ &B&6 BB$! #&$$ $7 $ #$& D ($& %7 ' $ '6 $$ &7"$$ $ ##, D (& ' #$ ' % #! '< 8($$$'( $$"",$'$C$'&&""$% 8$&$&"D&7$'('# $$"",;$6/ #6 2 ' <7"$ ; ? R 2-.@3J2 ' ' 2- H 20J2 $B D (##$ ' &7" ' &$& I $% &! I $%&$I"",'B"8'&#$D($& ' ""$&55#<<7"$R2-.@3J2?!$'#$'%"$&! <7"$R2-.@3J2(##8$D&7$"$<'(59G"7 ;$6-#62$67''$<7"$?6
*,&'($6J2#62$6??'<7"$R2-.@3J2!S$% B$ 8 $ 9G"7 "#$ ,&&B ' #$$ '#$ ' &7$ ' Q $$ "", $$ '8 &'! ""Q%$&$&"D$$&7$''"#T #$$$%#Q$$$''&'$D97S6
3-.413/..4 5032/5 '&'$'&B#($62$69'<7"$6 $"7B &H 9,$! # ##$ &H $"# 8 $ '&7& ' <7"$#$"S&HS;$62$6?6
%'$$'&B$!>''&8$"'&' ( $<7"$%$''"''$!$8($ '&B I $6 /1 ' ' ' ,7$ ; ?6 %$ ' '#$! '" $ E # &' % ($$ ' (> &$,E$$'$&C$; F2/44-?6 $$'&B$ $$DB&&"$,H$B;&'&H!$"7 '( ?$&&"$,H$B;Q$$'Q&$,?!'I&$$$$B ',"$ & ; 3J1@3/..1' J $, /..1T 32423/..1 ' 2@ " /..1T 65+6 * + : 3 65+6 * ! #9>8 $ $$! -<" &' /..2! #6 22/T UVF 20@/ #6 -4?6 #$ % # '";$6/16/ ?6 $#% BB$'" 7$"#8(($#&&%;$6/-62 ?6B'' #% ", $ '$ &$, "$ 8( "# % #&&'$ '"! " 8( && % ; 3/J/3/..1'A"/..1T 3J@23/..2'/J%",/..2?6
%#&''%($$'(>&$,!8 "#$ ($ # %$& $ ' $$ #! " $ , # ' $ 8 #"$$$ ' '&' 8( $$ $$ ; F0J2'61!#61T F20@4##62A/52A4?6%$'(I" # 8$ B$ ' E $% $ ' $&C$ # $ %$I $ > $$9 # &$$ ; W6 ' J '&",20@@!#,& F200/#6--4T 6'@H2001T F2.@ /4-T0J15-$&B6$6T F6'24H$20@4T65+6 * + :365+6 * !#9>8$$$!-<"&'/..2!#622-?6("#$ ' $ '( # % '& '&$" # B$'(&&"$B"!"'(",'$<$; F 224/2A?6
A6 (#<!$($$&%",/..1%&#D*$7>! '$8(%$'('"$$8'$'&'$&$,6
$ D '&$" E $% $ '($&C$6 $ '&, 8 $ $ $$ ! 8( 7'! % $& $ B"$ #B D <% $ 8( > $H $%&6 ! > &$$ '"& H8( 200J6 H'(9! &# $% &7"$ D <%6 #'$! %& " D 7> E &$$ '"& '# 200J6 5B$$$B(,H$'("#$$$%I'&%$'#B/..1!' $8M5'59& "#$ !!'9$ ' $$$ $ 9,$,6 ! 'I % ' $ $'
3-.413/..4 52.32/5 $$8$&"$'&&8(%>$$$&#B&8""$ '##$"$D*$7>!8$"#'$OP5'6 7$$8&#I#&'$"F6 (#$ ' ($"& &7"$ $$&! #'$ $$ '& '(,%$! #&'$##$"$6 $D('H$D'7>!'" ! '&& 8( %>$ #8 H" $ ' $$ ""6 %$ # '&& %", /..1 8( $ '&"&7*!'$8"D7>$'%&' '6
*,'&&"$! ,'&'<8$$ &#$$'($&C$#$#BD<%'# '&"&7"$%",/..16$%8%$&'&&'$ &$$ $"$ ' $9 '"$& ' 9G"7 *! 8( '&'& ' (> &$,6 #'$! ($'$ ' $ ($ 8 "#&9,!'($$#8$#$,&&BF'( % ' #"$ BB # 99 $% D <%! E "# B"$ $ $H $%&6 (##$"$ ' $ $ ' &#$$$<#$$6("#C98(",$#($$$$ ' $ # $$ $ > &H BB$%"$6 $ D %$ 8 &$$ ""$&F!$D%8$&$$'"&F ""$'(""$$'%&96 B$#"$'<# '8($&'$##'F6<!'&#$'$ '8#$B#8$$'"&F!> ''&8!%",#&#'&$!$($#$ 8##$"$D*$7>$$#'B$%6 ,' & '"$$ ' 8 $ $ '"& D <% $ 8( "#$ '$$%'"#,&&B''"$&'9G"7' $6
J6 % ' 8 #&<'! '" $ '& $7 &6 ($"& $ '"& D $> $ '"$& ' 9G"7'<2H%/..4!&%'&$'$'$ &786
@6 $,$$7'!'"$&'2(4..B6$'&D $$''
3-.413/..4 52232/5
!0 !) ) !
12343++ 5 633 3 78 -(' 9
43+
26 &%,6
43
/6 ('"$
16 '&##$'2J$,/..4'($"&6
-6 $ $ ,&&B ' '"$& ' 9G"7 '< 2 H% /..4 H8(D B ' '&5' '('"$! &% ' #$ ' $ '$&786
46 %D($"&#I"$'$&7%$ '$I'"$&'9G"7$&&!$%'&6
A6 '"($"&D#>$""'2(4..BD$$''
J6 $8#&'$7$$6
@6 B" #$ ' 8Q #%$ B" $ #&$ C$ ' '& ' 1. H '< $B$ # # ""'& '& , B&'& ' ! *9OM9B8 A! A..- ! $ I"#6 '& #$ C$ #7&6 "&" '$= ? '8 I$"$8'&$'&,$$#''& $$8&T ,? I# # 8 "$B $" #% '"' $$ $ '&T ? #$ 7$ ' #&$$6 * "&" $$ # $ &&"$ &"&& $$ ? ,? $ ? 5'! ,B&'&'##$"$<8Q '%'&%,6"&"'"$">
3-.413/..4 52/32/5 ' #%! 8 $ H$! 8 '& $$8& $ Q%## ' 8&$&I#&'&$;$621/!2.A$2.@?6 7BB< &'$= XY U >
#B"' #&$ C$$$B&I#$$*&$$'Q $$D Q&"#7BB
3-.413/..4