Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/348/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/348/2006 Generato dall'IA

Fraud in the Inducement of Arbitration Clause Warrants Denial of Compel Arbitration.

Numero d'incarto ATAS/348/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party sought to compel arbitration based on a contract containing an arbitration clause, but the court affirmed a finding that the arbitration agreement was unenforceable due to the opposing party's successful assertion of fraud in the inducement, specifically concerning the arbitration clause itself, distinguishing it from fraud in the inducement of the contract as a whole. The court reasoned that under the controlling precedent, a claim of fraud directed specifically at the arbitration provision must be decided by the court rather than the arbitrator, leading to the conclusion that the arbitration clause was voidable and the motion to compel arbitration should be denied.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

; PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE ; PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE SELON LA LPP ; LIBRE PASSAGE(ASSURANCES) ; DIVORCE ; PARTAGE(SENS GÉNÉRAL) ; TAUX D'INTÉRÊT | LFLP; LFLP 25a; LFLP 22; LFLP 24; OLP 8a; OPP 2 12

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
clausola compromissoria incitamento a violare o a rescindere un contratto parte contraente arbitro nullità delle intese validità del divieto di concorrenza

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed court costs on the appellant for the federal proceedings.
Generato dall'IA
A/3199/2006
Challenge to Compelled Arbitration Based on Fraud in the Inducement of the Arbitration Clause
A/3637/2005
Appellate Decision on Compelling Arbitration of Fraudulent Inducement Claims
A/1060/2004
Compelling Arbitration Despite Fraud in Execution Allegation
A/4469/2007
Enforceability of Arbitration Clause Despite Prior Defective Agreement
A/3197/2007
Arbitration Compelled Despite Alleged Post-Signing Material Alteration of Dispute Resolution Clause

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed court costs on the appellant for the federal proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               #$%&'#())& *#'$+#()),

*

 *- -*-  -  

.  (  %% / ()), 



   00000000000 

1 00000000000 

 

2-*-  34-   * 5   * -*  !"# $%&' #"(! & )$*+"'  2-*- -***-  *3  6 78 !!  !, !-,#&, $.+)& 42 .*$$/0!1

5* &112 .+&, 21&3) 

                  !"

 $53 

- 2*

)7  8#   )9  - $3&  )" 1-  !-  ,!" !   ,4  !'  : ;;;;;;;;;;;   :! ;;;;;;;;;;;&!4 )<8'!)<<+7

$7 =1!22<8# ,4! 4& !-,!"! 4  , # , ! !4  '!  ,4'> ,2! ?!    !#,@(4,@7

97 8# !' '42!! !2$$'-$3 4 4 ! A22! !-4$<'-$3,@4 !, #7

%7  !-  4  !! 4  , !     ! !  !  ,4'>& ,!  ! ,4  ! !  ! 42   ,!   ! !?      '!   , ! ?!    !#& !  )<8'!)<<+ $$'-$37

37  !' !# ! !-444 , #!' B

:!;;;;;;;;;;;B

 & 1!!  ! !&  4 4 22!!4 C ! ,! ,"   D     E       :     :  7   $A*)67<327A> '  ,,4!A22!! !  ) 8!  $3  9)  - $37   ,4! A22!! !  ) F  )<..$+8! )<<)& 4!!#&,  !,4'>'! 

4 4 244 ,"   D    E   D ==                   & ,! !-44!38! )<<%&'4, CA4 #7 ,4! A22!! !  3 24'! )<<+  9* '- $$&       ,4'>  4 4 '4  $ ! $9 C  D  =    =  G!)$8'!$+H7=! !" $38'!$+&  $$'-$3&! 4I ,!& C 9.A*.+ 27 *37  2  4!         9A+63 27 $3 , CA'!C !#&?!', ! 4I 7 2!  8'!$9 8!$3&4 41J#7

:;;;;;;;;;;;

 '!48?AC2!F $9& C?-442!!4  A 1J#& '      C  , 7  4! &  '!  '!4C ,, !?! 4'&  !4C ! ,"

    5$%6.5$3 953 

 = =  7=!!$64-$3&   A'!,4'> C%A$9<2733&! 4I  $$'-$3,!7

+7   4 4 !@, ! 6$+78!! !   !!?4 ?AC 42  A-' ! A!!  )6  $+&  I  !   -7

67 A-A-8 !4!2!@4&4 4#4C8#7

- *

)7 A 7 $3   ! 244   !- ,#   ,4'> ,2!&'!!&'!'  !'!! 4)64-)<<9GDH&  4'!#)8'!$&"#,4!'7? 8!  ,K,  ! !C, #G 7)$$  )$9  !'!( H&8#!!',4  A 7697 )!244,4'>,2!$38!)<.$GH&! C "' !- !,!)F $9&! & ,"?A22!!4 4 !G 7)%$ H&@4 A22!, # -44, ! !4 !4,8#!'.

$7 =A 7$$ DG' '!#,!)8'!$H& !'&,  ! !?! !# , #4 24 @ 7)$$&)$9&)%) )%$ L 79C3DA,,!?  ,#!  C 24G7)H71?8! &,  !  !C, #,C!224 ,  ! !&# 4  '!  !- ,# @!   4'       !'&    ,  !   !& # 4  '!  !- ,# @!   4'   !!#G27 7$%DH7 &8 C,  ! ! CA'!!-,#@!    !!#! 4I  !'G D )$.$9*L D)$<%%%H7

97 !& 7.A244!-,# ,4'> ,2!& '!!& '!'    !'!! 4 GH   )$  A 244   ,4'> ,2!& '!!& '!'    !'!! 4 G $H&  @ A! 4I  ,,!- C  ,  !   ! ?! ' !# %M8?A9)4-$$ 9&$3M$9&$&$3M  $%   $&3M  $37  4?   ! 4I       9A++%27$3@!  9)!)<..  C)A9))27%3G6C %M)C9&$3M&)C$&$3M ))!C$&3MH7

%7  K,"&  8#  ,!" !   4  , # , ! !4  ,  !   ! ?!    !# ,  7   

    5$%6.5$3 %53 

, !  &K, &!#&)<8'!)<<+&K ,  $$'-$3& C?8# !' '@4 !7

=    ,! &  ,  ! ?! ,   !# ,      93A)$. 27 9* G9.A*.+ 27 *3 N $A*)6 27 <3 ( %A<63 27 6*H7  &  '! !#   %A$9< 27 337 !!   !  C  @(4,      )6A3+% 27 )3 G93A)$. 27 9* B $H   (! ! !       $A))< 27 .* G%A$9< 27 33B $H&    ? K     ?! !  C  @(4,      )3A%%% 27 937    !,  @ ,   ,4'>!224 &, #2!  !" , ,! !,!2! !7

%7 24  C  8!,& ,!  8 4 !  ,  , # 8?A    2    ,  !   !    &  8!  !'4 -442!!!    ,  !  !  C  ! 4I  , !       (!7  ! 4I    4  @ !! 4#  A 7 )$  A   ,4'> ,2! '!!& '!'    !'!! 4  ). '! )<.% G $H    @ 4# !& ! !(!   ,4! G D  ,-!4  9+5*$  ). 8!  $9H

37 4 ,O&,44  # ! G 7697$  .<P7)!,4!!  !')$, -)<.3H7



QQQ



    5$%6.5$3 353 

  *2  *- -*-  -  



9:1;1   <  =11 1  >" %,( ?

)7 '!   D  =    =    ( / P C 24&, :!;;;;;;;;;;;&)3A%9927 93 C  = =    2'  : ;;;;;;;;;;;& ' ! 4I  , !    !4 & "  $$ '- $3 8?A   2 7

$7 K>  ?-!7

97 ! ?,4 # ! 7

%7 2  , !   ?A ,'  2     ,4  I    4!  9* 8 "   !2! ! , ,! 4 4  !- 244  & =1R!S12?! +& +%   &  ! @,!7  4!  ,  I  ,#47  4! !  B H !!? @   ? 4!!    4! - !  !   ,   4!! ?4L-H@,,? !2! !,'!   4!!LH, !# ,4  7=!4!   !  ,  ! 44  444    H -H   H !(&  !-244,,  !"?A! '4!'-74! !>  ,'& ?!   8! & !! ?  4!!  ?4   A',,  ?4 4@,4!4 G 7)9$&)*+ )*.H7  #22!  4! B       !! -=    

,!2,4 I   !2!4@, !!!?KCK22!244 !,#22

    5$%6.5$3