Contract Interpretation and Liability Affirmation and Reversal
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellate court reviewed several distinct claims involving challenges to various contract terms and liability determinations arising from several distinct factual scenarios concerning different transactional contexts. The court reasoned that the lower court properly interpreted the relevant contractual language, finding that the parties' intent was clearly expressed in the written agreements regarding the scope of liability and the allocation of risk, and thus affirmed the judgments below where the findings were supported by substantial evidence, but reversed or remanded in instances where the application of controlling legal standards or the interpretation of specific clauses led to an erroneous conclusion concerning breach or damages.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; RESPONSABILITÉ DE L'EMPLOYEUR(AVS) ; COTISATION AVS/AI/APG ; FAUTE ; FAUTE DU TIERS | LAVS:LAVS 52
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of costs for the respondent's answer to the appeal.
Testo completo
!"#$%!#$$& '!"()!#$$*
'
'+ +'+ +
, # %% - #$$*
. /////////// ! " ! ! #$%!$&'!(()'!(
!
0 %%% . 1. 2 . !' . 3 $*+$% ,-.!! ( !*/+$0*00-%0*
. /////////// '
.*10*.
+ 2'
05 '!' 677777777777 8 9. - '!': '!' ! ,! ( ( ! ( -% *2 ;% 0<<=5 %! >! &?!! (& ! ( >@!! '' ( ( A% ! ( ( ( B >! $ !! ! $ (!' ?!!' (! !5
*5 '!''!'$(- '!$BB' -( ( !( C'(' ! ( ( "'! ( @!! . " D 000 9. - " : '5
25 -& ,('!'$" 77777777777'!'&(! ! % ,! (%(!" 777777777779. - !:$( ! %,! (%(',!5&'!'*33*$'!'(' ? >-()(!'5
+5 B! ( !! &! '!' E' ( !! (! ! E ('!((;!*33*$!B'0/F!*33*5'!'&B!( % !;)&<% *3325 !!(! !'( '!''!' ','$ !$((!! !'E!'!'% ';!*3325 !!'!'&!)!!'G(?(!(40&0<*B 524$G!! ( !' )!5
45 '!''!'(' 'B! ;,!( >( - ! (*=F!*3325 !!(! !!(F((!!(*4&<4=B 5H3 ' ((;!*33*G% *332$'!'E!'!!!%!'$) (B ( !$(!?(!!!' I! ! 5
/5 &(! ! ('!''!'!( &BB(B!+%> *3325 ((&%>!'$.()'JK ! (*33*$ > > ( LBB (&BB ! *332 ?!! -! ( L! 1(!K5E%!++ ' $ !(B $ ' '5 !! (> !(L!()'( L($ ( &!, ! ( &')!$ / %'L ! ( ('>! (% !!(0<*&0<2B 5 (B! 5
H5 )(! ( B! '!' ( ('B! (&!B *2 %> *33+5
=5 ('(4% *334$" '' ' !((, ! !! ( *4&<4= B 5 H3$ (! G ' ( !'$B 5
12*301*334 .210*. <5 8!G&!( !(/*334$" B '(' *<;!*3345
035 ( 02 !> *334$ ! ! G &! ( ('$ G )& ! >' ' ( !! '!! ( " $ % ! ( ('5 8 %>!' ( $ % M (' * F! *334G($' (G)('!(& !52=( !,'' (( !( 9. - :5
8 B($ !! - ! !! ',,5 '!' (!$ BB!$(& !((BB!GB(&'*33* ( ! % ! !! ( % ',- ! L ,5 (BB!' (&! ! ''(>5 ) !! &! (', ('('>!(&'*332$ >! ('(&BB! !! %?(B!' !! &!(B! ( E! '% ', (& 5 & '!'&)!! ((023&333B 5(!!$*4&333B 5 !! (G; 5?-!$-,&!(" )$(& !$& , ! '!' N77777777777 )& %! M (& ' ( H3&333 B 5 !$ (&! !$ & !!' ,! ( B!$ 'L'! !$ ( O , ' !! ( 0<*&0<2 B 5 ( ('>! '$ )(! '!' ( ('B! (&!B5
005 '(02!> *334$" ! ;!( 5 % (; (( >B'(' ( 9. - C :$ ! (!$$I! ! >((,5&()$BB!$)& ( ( ! ! '!' ( '!' ! !!! G &E ( $ ( BM ' ! >;!%$ )& ! &)!! (!!((' >5 $ L !I! B!$&,!(,!(B! &BB '$(& !$ !! ( ('>! ( I ) % ( > ( '!' &!'!''!>$!(&! !$ !! )&& !!G" (&, 'L'!$G&(! ! ('!'B5 B" %!(( '!,!!&'!!! (&! ! G !! ( ! ( !! (5 '! ! (( ) '((H3&333B 5&! GL! ( !! '!' N777777777775 '(! ( (, B! !!(&!(;!B'&-5
0*5 > ( ' (' ! ( ! ) &! !04%> *3345 !!" &!,,'GB ('! ,'' ' ( ( ! ( &!! ( % ! ( !5 8 )!$ ',! ()' ) " 77777777777$
12*301*334 .+10*. (! ! )$ %! ',! B! &>;! (& (' ' ! ( (,$ (% ('B!% B! (&!5 ! '!! !! G! 5
! !$?)') P(( ! !!G& ( !! (! ( &! $ ) '!! 5 (.!> ( B !$&!)%!!!%" !)&!(!! ,!5 (BB!' B- ! ! *33*5 ' ( ( !> 1!> *33* G *332$ ! ( ( ! ( (&!! >! (! !! ( )& %! ( ! &!%!'5 E %! ( ! % < ' ( &! ;)&G ! G B ( (&% *3325 ! ( &! (& ( !! ! ' !(B *332$( % ! G 5 8 )! ! &,! ( ' ! N77777777777$ ! ?)' &% B' (&! ( '( % ! ! .$ $ (& ' % ( > ( ( ! ' )&% " 77777777777 *332$%!(('(( ' '!! >5 !! ',! '!' !!' " ) ! !5 (!!'G> (!! (&>! !(( N77777777777(00&/H0B 5 ! $&% ! ()I!'!' ('5
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
12*301*334 .410*. % >? -( L!!5 G!!')$! % >?$ ! '!' ( B !!! ( ( ( ( !!! G&%$!(?,' !R5!!!B! ! ('!B ('5
!(&($'!'('('(B? ? !('H *33/ -)I!$!() !, ('G;, 5
0+5 " ('' ' ! -)I! 2 *33/5 58&E! ; (( C $) !',, (" 877777777777$(- )(BB!'(! ' &'!! (' ' ?! !'$)'!'& %' (&'%-! ! )&! '!'((BB!'$! ) ! ( ( !! (&I! $ ) '!! (!!!>( !! &! GB!5(! (!( !!(('5
045 ' ! - )I! ( = *33/$ ! (- $ ! $ % ('! ' &> ( !! ',,5 ! (BB!' ! '!( ) H $ ! '!' (' ( !! ! G !%!' )& & '!' > (&' ( - ' '!>! &>!! (& % L! !!5 !! ( ('>! B, ! ( &%! ( B! % & ! ( B! % !$ )& !! G ! ) ! (&'%! !!(,5 ! $ !!(!)!G !)> (';G?'5 ! &'!)" &! , % ! ( 00&/H< B 5 N77777777777$ %! B!! ((!!5 ( ')!5
0/5 ((*H *33/ >(' ('&( " 77777777777$!B?'(' (&'%! )03 % *33/5
&>(&' ! (('B?'$ >B ' !) '!!, ('G;, 5
+ '
05 ,% S ,!;( 9:'!'(B'!!!'$(- 0 F!*332$ >!( $'(4;,$ (! '(! ! %. '(!$ 4 '! ! 0/ ;, 9 !5 0 !5 !4/ :5
8!GS!(S'!(0/;, $ >B'(' *H;% *33+9 C02303/:$ ( ,%(!'$02B'% $
12*301*334 ./10*. (!! ! ,! !!! >!( ( ', G ! ;, !! $ $ ( S!!! ( S'!(%?;, 5
*5 B '! G & !5 4/ 5 0 !5 L5 0 $ > ! ( T!!)(!!! '%GS !54/ (B'(' (/!> *333 !,'' (( !( 9. -J : ) ! !% G B'(' S .
%! %%!(*3('> 0<+/9. -J 8:5
8'! ;, ((S-!'!>5
25 ! ! ' %, 0 ;% *332$ ! T! (B! ( > (! ', ( ( ( S 8$ !! ) S ! 4* 85 ' $ >!' ( SE E ! ','(- ('!')S %!! !=0!=*( -,! S .% ! %%! ( 20 !> 0<+H 9. -J 8: ! '!' > ,'5 S) (S-$ ( I ) % (!%, $', ( ) -,>! %, !OB!; ()!('! !! (!
9 C 0*H +/H (50:5 $ ( (, ! !! '( )%!!' 0 ;% *332$('GS ,( !,(!!(4% *334$( !)(!', !!'( %! 5
+5 5S !5=*50 8$) ',!BB!(! ' ' !((,$'!'> ,'G!(S! '%, ( 5 )!!(' ',' S !54*52 858!!(!$ ( ! G ' ! ! ! (? - ) ( ! '!!((,!$(!$) - % ( (,5 (' %! I! ! 5 SE ! G %) !5 S,! ( (' ( !$ ( ' !$ ! ( !?! ', ! ( ! %? ' ! ( 9CC0<<+5</+%5$0<<<5++$!' C (23%> *33+ #</132:5
> B'(' ( 9 C : ' )S ( !U((,V((! '!'$G ! (!O(! T! $E I!!S!!!)S!( ! (S!!( (S ! !! ! ( !)$ ) ! !!!( % !!$ !;!B >,! ( ' (,9B5 C00/H4$(52>W0020=0$(5*W00* =$(5+(W 0<=2$503=:5B!('! !!((!! )S SE U (! ! B!$ G (! > V 9B5 C 8 # J
12*301*334 .H10*. 8L(>! >,(XR $(?-'(!,00*:$(SO '! ! ( '( 5
8; ($(,! '!' % )!!( %!I! M$ (!B; ()(B!9B5 0<=2$ 5+HHW 0<==$502H:5 )!!( !E' (S%>!'(SE 9 :$(,! '!' % ! O ' ( !! ! '% >$ S!.G.( ! O$ ', ( G S%>!' ( SE $ !! %! I! M '( ( 5 9B5 " J 8LYZ L 8Z% L ,L !$%$5/<:5
', ( ( >( !' ( >!' ( , ( $ ( ! ! %) ' ! (& (,G&! (?.) )('>! (!! ' ' ! %(&>!'$ (%>!'$(% !!G L ,5(&B!$!!%>!'!!!'!( >!(&'!!(!9 0<<*543*:$( ( )(! ( B! ('B! (&!B$ ( >! ( !! 98*3321/5+24:J&!G!) ( ' ' ! ( (, ! )$ !P!$ >! (, ! (.5
>5 S-$(' !((*2%> *33+5(' ' ! ( (,$!B'4% *334$! ')!! %((' ' ! ((? ! S !54*52 85
S!' 'B '!/*334$!(23; G! ( !B!(('5! M(' !*F!*334 !! ;!' 02!> *3345
!! B ! (' ',? 9 !5 2= ! /3 5 0 : ! %>5
45 : ?! (S !54*50 8$SE )$!!! ',, , %$ S> % ( ! ! (, G S $ ! ! G ' !5 ( ( ) ! ! ! (!'9 0<=<$500H:5
%! (S !54*50 8%, (0 ;% *332 (& !54* 8)!(B!5! U( !V ! ' U V$ ) S! T L,!)(?(!( >!'(SE 9 C0*< 02 %5 (5 254:5 C (';G BB ' ) S %! B' ( , ( B'(' ! 00- '% ( S 8 ( ! %?
12*301*334 .=10*. ' ! ( ( ( S' ! ( ; ( !! !%GS !54* 85
>: S-$ (, ! ! ( ' ( !! 81 1 1 ! "> ( !' ((0 ;!*33* 23% *332$E !' I! ! !!?(!!*4&<4=B 5 H3$!!)&!!!' !5
/5 :& !50+50 8 '!% !52+!%! 8$ ! &>,! &E (('( L) !!( '! ( % . G ( ! % !!5 E (%! %E ? $ ' ()!$ - !> ! % ' G '$ ( - G ) !! ! !I! '!B &>;!(('5
&>,! ( E !! ! ( B ('! !$ &E $!@L(( !> ! 5 !', ($ > B'(' ( (' '$ G '!' ' $ ) >!' ( &E (& !54* 8!'!!!(( !>9 C00* 044$(54W 0<=H$53:5&E )&)!!(!!!@L !%!( !(& !54* 8$)! T &>,!( ' !- !(,'9 C000 0H2$(5*W03=0=/$(50$0<*(5*W 0<=4$5/+/$(5 2:5
>: ) &E ! $ , '(! ( !$G!! >( $((,' .$!!)( &?! ! O >!' ! ,,' 9 /332(( !%(SBBB'(' ( !( !!$. -JW C00+H<$(52W002*4/$(52W 0<==$502/$(52W C0000H2$ 0<=4$5/+<$(5*5:5
K ,K$ B! !( !! LE) ) '! G&?!' )!? B('% !! (.9/33+:5 )&!((&'!'E$ C &!!; 'B' 'G& !5H4+50 $ '!%& !5H4<0 5 B '!G !$!! L ,'(&(! !$( ,! ( ! P$ '(!$ G &', ( ( '!'$ ( I )&% L)! ' $((,)& )! !!! ',,G (% ! ) '(! (& I (, ! ! ( !5 8! '!' L ,' ( &(! ! ( ,! ( & !5 H4/ K ! , ( (' (',' ? '! !$ ',! ) ! BB!%! ( (' %! ( ,$ )
12*301*334 .<10*. ! ,! ! (! ! ! ! '(' ! G B !(%!'('!'K9 C03H242$(54W C00* 0<=4 ! & I! ( *0 % 0<== W C8 "8 $ R! L!L !Y !LR!$ *- '(5$ 5 *3< ! :5 '!! ( !$)'!! '! ('!'!( ! $ >(,! !('!! (,! (%(5
H5 :&>,!',( ' (,(!I! )( O (, !(F G%!!! ',, , %$ &E $ ( ! ',! & .% ! %%! 9 0<H=$5*4<W 0<H*$5/=H:5(!)!!)& > (, ! ( .> %! ( ! ! (!! ) &E %' . !!! ( ',, , %$( O&?!(&(B! G',!!'( !! G &> (& B! 9 C ( *= ; 0<=*$ 0<=2$ 5 030:5
; ( !!$ C )S E ',, , % ) &E B G)!I! >!?,'(!! >(( !$(!!(!)!(I !9B5 0<H*$5/<3:5 ()&!( !(&?, G!', ((!(I! '%'(& -)&! ( !!!( $ !- (!>!'!(,!$(&E (I!', ) &!' '.5 )S S,! (S '!' E$ !$ $ (?,'%- ) S!!!)S(! ( ! ( !9B5 0<H*$5/<3W 0<H=$5*/0:5(BB' ! >> S ',!$ )S S,! (S ' >!' >( ( ,(SE 9 C03=*3*(52W 0<=4$5 40$(5*!5/+=$(52>:5
!%, )SE (,G(! %! !!! ! !- (S 8 ) S! T !!>,!( ' ';(5 ! ) S> %!( ! T!%( !',! !B!%9 C03=0=/(50>W 0<=45/32(5*$/+H(5 2:5 ! % )S ! (! ! ( !!$ SE %G! ! %$ ? (S('! ( ! ' 5 " B! $ )S ! !! !> !' ! ( S !5 4* 8 ) S (!! ) SE %! ! O (' ( ' ! >;!% ( )S ! S)!! ( !! ( ( (' > 9 C *HH130 ( *< F! *33* (5 *W C03= 0==:5 ; ( S(! '!' ) ( - ! - ?! )S E ('( ( ! ( !(!!B(!
12*301*334 .0310*. ! % (S('!(! ' 9 C 04+133( F! *333 (5 *:5 I$ ! I! ! ! ( & '! ,'' ( $ ( B! )& ! - ! ' ( ( !! E' ! 9 ?! (& C0*0*+2:5
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
=5 !G? () E !( '( G '(!( (, B! !! ( 5 ! '(! ! BB! >&(! !%'(% $!)!!%!!!' (')! % '! &,, %! ( (, 98 0<</ , 203 W C #0+*1*332!#</1*332:5
! %) >!' ( " $ G (? !! J (& !$ &%! '!> &BB ( B! B! '!! ( ('>! ( 0<*&333 B 5$ ) ! (F ,! % (,$ $ B! ( '!' !'!',' ' &BB(B!!F!'!'( >!' (" ((' !5B!(!, ( G& !)!! ( '(B!&'!''!>5&(! ! %!BB!
12*301*334 .0010*. (' ' ! !! ( '$ 'B' ! !!B G ( B! 5 B!.)('>! !%>$) >( ', $!)B! >!, G ! 5 >I! %()(!(B! ('B!(&!B5&()%,!(B!5 ! !! B! !! )& >,! ', &'!! B! G ( (' !W&,!(&>!'$BB !G! ' 5&E G ( %! (& >,!$ ( ; ( !'5
&! !$ ! (- ) %! % &! N77777777777$(! '%!'!''('GL! (&% H3&333B 5$ (, ! %5
8 !!LE!L-(%!I! !$ E !(!. >!'( $ ! ! ( ( !' ! !! ( ! ! % ( (,$ ) ? ! !! >!' 9 C 00< +3H W 0<<* 5 */<:5 ! &!(! ! ) ! ! ' !! ( '$ ! ',! ) (( %! '!'B ' &!'$.!!!B!!',!! % M ( ' (5 ! % (& ! ) ! !(( '&! B!) &!!? !!( 9% !5 0/+ ! ! :5 $ B, ( ()() B " (!!( '5 ! ;! $ (&! ! ) &!' &%! >,! ', (&! ( '$ ! )& F! ! ! ! (&! ( '( !% ('>! '! !5 B$ !(( )&! )!!!(% ''$ !(% )&!!(& ( (00&333B 5
<5 ')!$!B(&?!!I! !$ '(! ((,BB!'5 ;!'5
12*301*334 .0*10*.
'2 '+ +'+ +
56.7. 8 1.. . 9: %*# ;
7.
05 ' %>5
7.
*5 ;!!5
25 !) '( !, !!5
+5 B ! ( )S %! B ! '! I! ( (' ( 23 ; (- !B! (' ( ' > B'(' ( $ 8LYZ LB) /$ /33+ $ ! ? 5 (' ! I! ,'5 ' (!J : () ?!!)(' !(' >! !((' !!)'W >: ? ) !B ! % (( !! ! ('W : ! ,! ( '!!5 8 ' !! ! ''! '' ' !! : >: ! : .($ >B'(' ( ! !- )S (% (' %>5' ( ! E ( %$ ) ! ;!$ ) (' !!)' ! S% ( )'!'?'(' !9 !502*$03/!03=:5 >> BB ,
B ( '! I!!!B'? !)SGSBBB'(' ( , BB
12*301*334