Negligence and Liability in Traffic Collision
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant sought recovery for damages sustained in a collision involving a vehicle driven by the respondent, who contested liability by claiming the litigant's own negligence contributed to the accident. The court's reasoning, based on the evidence presented regarding the circumstances of the incident, concluded that the respondent was solely at fault for failing to maintain a proper lookout and adhere to traffic regulations, thereby rejecting the claim of comparative negligence and affirming the full liability of the respondent.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Negligence and Liability in Traffic Collision: The court's reasoning, based on the evidence presented regarding the circumstances of the incident, concluded that the respondent was solely at fault for failing to maintain a proper lookout and adhere to traffic regulations, thereby rejecting the claim of comparative negligence and affirming the full liability of the respondent.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
&'()*&'+++ &,-*&(..-
##
# " " # "
% ', (..- ,/ 01
2 34 5 2 * 3 !"#$%&'%()
+!
% 6666666666 ,-!-,.+ "/ -2 0 1 0"
!"# $%
"&3#"
2
%6 .+ 7777777777 8,+ !- + + ) ! 9 !+%:+;!%#4$+< 9 =>?6 <!, -!- * @+ -!-> !&4A !%##4/<,, <! 2! , 2 + ) 6
&6 <*,+B -!- 22 - @ +*,! + !,+2 + <") ! ) )! 0--! + +* B ! ,!+8 C!*! !,+2 + 0--! + !, +* ",(0 .D%+;!%#4$ :%+!+E%##46
:6 ++", *!+! ! ++ 0 .; ! ,+ !@<+!.+ 7777777777-E !@<-9"
/ +! E+! @ - ) <! -2! E ,( ,+ +! ! + + ,B- A A ! +!+E +)*E ! -*E %##F / ,+ *+ A) @ +;! %##46 0 . -9*! ; -++9--,++!! ++! ! +!&A ! %##4!%$*%##56 !@<9*!, *!+)!-E !! - ,+-,-+!-!-,6+), !,- -!- -,+- % ) %##$ ! +) , *! +!+B- ! @ <,!! +,0 .<,, *!,* !-F''26
G6 2 !,+.+ 7777777777-!-,++-,A9*! E,* ( !& 2-) %##$ ! / ! +,:% * %##$6 A9*! E ,* ( ! %# * %##$ 2 !-!-H!- !+!!! +-2!<! 26
F6 2 ! .+ 7777777777 -!- ,++- +) 2+ &# ,!*E%##$6 / ! ++ -!-++-%'+)*E%##$! - ,+,+! +2 8-%$-*E%##$6
46 % -*E %##$ 0 . ,+ ! - FGIF#4 26 %' +,+!+;,++! ! + )-!A %##F !+;!%##46
56 ! &F A) %### - ( +! 2 - -E ! - + -,! ++9@J!G&IGG:26F' ++", *! +! ! + , ! 3 3 3 ,- + A A ! +!+E @ -*E%##FA) @+;!%##4+*,-*!A) @+!+E%##4!,,+! +!H-%##&@%##46
$6 + G2-) %###-E !<!+,,+-@!!- +-9! ,+- 2+! )22 !,+ ,*!!,B*+!!
3%&453%### ":3#" -*-!,)++ , ) -9 - -! *!!6, -9- / <-! ! !! +*! , -9 9 9) /< <) !,,B-+! ! +6
#6 + %52-) %###<22 ,+ !!2 ! )"+ ! ) -0 .-,H!<-!!++! +2 !< !-- 2 ! / - -! ! * :(* ,+ + FGIF#4 26 %' ! /< ) <-! !,-) E,+- J +9,J 6
%'6 %%*%###0 ./ + +!++ *! (<") !) )!C ",( + ++D * )-<+,,+ ! +2+*-,< !--@+G&IGG:26F'6
%%6 - !&4) %###-2 //2 !,++- ,A9*!&#,!*E%##$<!!+A+, / -6+!/ - + 0 . ! ,-*!- +) A9*! ) ! !) !+)8!-2!E ) !K!- )-6
+!!, *+!!!, - ( + (/ *+!! -*- @ ! ! -,! + +9 + ! , 9+E !+ 2 ! !-K!/ -+!+ !<,(%'I%G426F'6
-2 () + / * %# A %##$ - + <+!+ ! ! / !+! ,+- @ + +!-! !,!!/< J++ !,, *!6! */< *! -,! + +9 0 . ! ) !-*! - + + *K* /< ,B ! -9 (*! *+!! +)6 A %##$@) %###< !--) !-A@,B-FIF''26
2 ,+ ! + !- &5 A ! %##$ - ! E ,* ( ! , / *- / 2 ! ,+ + ! ,++-6 ,- ! /K! /< ) ! 8,+ !- > ,! , ) 9!/,!@J ! (-22 <-! !-!- +- +! /< ) ! ; ,,+! 2+ ,+, ,+ +! + 8,+ !! + +!! ,+ ,B ! /<@ 2 %##5 ) ! A!- + ++E--2 )!* +F'I'''26/< ) !-!- +! !) < ) !,@2 28J9JB,+!J- 6
+!)!/<,B!,!,-<*+!!%&I'''26FF -*+!-/< ) !2 !+,+ E,+,B,! !!6
%&6+ &&A) &''& + +++-- %# 2-) &''&@0 .,+ 2 ,!+E)! +A! -,+-26
3%&453%### "G3#" %:6 - !%%-*E&''&*+! !/+! + -,! ++9<-! !,,-*!-, /-!-A+ *K* 2 ! < !-- /< -! ! ,+ + <! -2! E - )- !8,+(")E8+!!!+")*!9 ! /,+ !<) !,-!-, ,++) 9 2 ! /-E !) !-!---2 !6 ,- /2 !-!-H!- !/<!-2!E -!-- )- ) <B!-!-)- 8- ++/-:(*6
+2 */-E !) !+ !-,, *! !@,+- ,- ! - ++", *!+! ! + 3 3 !8 - +! ! + -9 * +! + 2* / +! ! + ! 8 - ,+ ,-)+B + + +)! + +! ) !) < + 9)+ + 6 +! -2 ) ! </ !! J/ *+ ,( <22 ,+ ! *+!! 2 8- , ,+(")E + ! %I''' 26 + <-! ! , 8-!- ,+(")E +!!! +")*! 9 ) ! -!- - )- @ * +! @ 8 (* ,+- ,-6 -E ! <!+/ !!--9*!,+*,!,!,-6
*,- /<9*!) !-!-+))!- + -,! ++9!/<+-/+*,!)-,-E ! )! !- +) !-!-, +*,!6 )J B - +*,!)-,< !--,(<)+ - +&FA) %### + ! !+! + %'I:'' 26 FF +! %I#F' 26 %' +! -!- !! E- 8 +! ! +-9 *+! +2* !8+! ! +,-)+B + ! 8 - + +)! + +! ) !) < + 9)+ + *+!! / <-! ! , -,! + +96
*+!! +9 ,-! + * ( )!L %FIG$F 26 F' ,+ +! ! + " " M $I:4G 26 F' ,+ +! ! + JH*9M 5':26 &' 2 * !! 2M 4I$&: 26 $F < !-K! *+!+ M %I 26 2 ,+ !!G&'26!8+! +6
2 0 .()/< !--<!22! )*!/ !!-// *+!! +)! ,! ,- ,- + A @ -*E %##F +! %##5 * / +! ! + !! %##F ! %##4 + ! E )!/-2- )! E--2 )!* +6
3%&453%### "F3#"
#
%6 + 9)+ <+9 ! +A CD-!-*+ 2 -! ! !-( % +;! &'': E !+ + 6 +2+*-*! @ <! : -: ,+ ! +! !+ !+ !)!<!- ) 9+ !,!)! + +!+++!-!- !* <+22 E !+ + !!! ! /C26! F4D6+*,-! E-! -!E ,+A9<,(6
&6 + 2--,! 9--+ !+ 4+!+E &'''C D!!-) 9%A) &'':!N!*+ 2 ! + +*E ,+ ! +-9+* I +!!/ +I!6F& 6-+* ,+E !-I*,+B!-9- * (,-! -/I,)!@I!6F& !!6$%!$& +! -!- E+9-6 I,( ! !+!2+ -9 , ,+ ! + ) 9 A/I:%-*E&''&-9, ,+/(9,, E +! ) 9 *+*! +O 2 ! A /*! -!* ! +! ,+ !C 0%&5G45+ 6%D6
:6 <!6 $% C ) 9 A/< :% -*E &''&D -+ (9 ,! ( 8/ ! +* ,+- -,! + +96 I,(!! ,+ ! + +*,! +- -,! +I +9 - , I*,+B + ! +! 2 @ " - + +! / ,! 2+* +,,+ ! + !! A+ ,( C6 % !&D6 +*,! +* ! !- ++ !!! A+ -9*! ! + , -J- + ! ,+! )! I!+ !- + !+ / I*,+B + +* C6 :D C 0%&&45+ 6GD6
G6 /! + @ -+ ,-E <,( ! )+ -E ! ) ! + 2 ! ) / !- ,+ )+ - + -,! + +9 ! ,!! ,+ 2+* +,,+ ! + , -2 ,-!,+-6
F6 22!I+)!2 !2 !,2 "2)I* !! + 2 ! C + ! ,+ !! 2 ! ! ++! : -6 %##:,6&#'J6P%D"+ ! ,+E ,,!!@ * C!6 &'G 6 % M 0 %%G 4' + 6 &E ,6 4% ! -2-D6 E ,,!! @ * 2! ! I*E --*! ! 2 ! , 2+!/ *!, )-9*!2 + !, !A /,,+!!@-+! CQ +! 6G!6&'GD62 ,,+ !,+-+!M I *,*!,/ !-,+9 ,+(+!E * CQ +,6 !6 6 F !6 &'GM 0 + ! ,+ ! : -6 3%&453%### "43#" ,6J6D6, !-I!A! I* !! +2 !C!6&G' D+*,+!,+,!+ !2 !+!-*JA // , / ! ++!!+ !+N!,-!! +++ @ " +* * C +,6 !6 ,6 ::' J6 M 0 1 R 3S JE! E9 T+U J JV W J* J!)+:-61 J%##:PG$6:D6
46 K!,%##5,655+ 6: E2-- + -- / 2 ! +! / + 2 ! -2 <,(-! !))!!@/< ! *-) !- + -,! + +9 ! --*! / + ! - *! K! , + -! + ,+ - @ ! ! ,-E < ) ! + / !- ,+ 2+* +,,+ ! + @ - + -,! + +9 )+ ,+ -2 @ * -,! + +96 + A , +/< - !+) 2 ! <* !! + 2 ! ! JE !- @ ,-! ,+-*! (< C 0 %#F%,6%#'+ 6%!-2-X %#F% ,6 :GFD6 <JB,+!J( +O - + ,+!! , *! +! ! + -- -!- ,( <+)! 2 ! -E !" -E !<!,JE !-@+!!!!- +C %##:,6%$&+ 6%ED2 + !)! +*- / ! +2 !6
56 +A ,! ! < ++ ) ,!2 <+EA!<! +-,! ++9<!6F& E /< B ! ! !- -E ! +! ! + ! ,+E +9 2+*! - ! !+! @ 2 ! 22-! , / - + +)! 2 ! <*,+B + +! ! + -J ! / ,-!! + -,! ++92+,+E !-! /<!-2 @<!6F& C26 0%&:%4$+ 6:D
$6 --,! ++90 .8 ! !-A@*+*! <+)!8 (*2 !-E !&#,!*E%##$2 ! ,! *2 !6!!JB,+!J(- +0 . -,! + +9 ! ; K! +! 2 - @ <* !! + 2 ! ! ,+ ! 2 ! -E ! -! ! E ,,!! @ *!<) !,/ !-,+)+ !- +6
#6 +) !+-!* @/*+*!!---,! + +96 + I!6 F& I*,+B / !! +*! + , -9 9 9) I+E) , , ,! + ! +9 @ +*,! + ! ! @ -,! +6 *! ( +! ! + / ,-!J*,I,, ! +, ,!! ,+ ! +-9+9 ,+ ! +/ I*,+B - , @ I !+! + ,! /I ) @ *,+B- ! / +! ! + +,+! !+)! !- *! 2,,- ,-*,! + + I!6 %4 6 % M + +/
3%&453%### "53#" +! ! + *! *,B- + I +)E !- I*,+B C 0%&%:$G+ 6:EE:$$+ 6:%%:&F5)6%%&%F5+ 6&D6 ,* ( -)! !- +9 ! -,!- ) *+*! I)(*!,-*,! +C 0%&:%&+ 6FE%%&%F5+ 6&%'$ %#G+ 6&!K! !-DM+*+*!+O+! ! + ,)!,K!,Y+,+-+ -9@I +)E !- -E ! C 0 %&: %& + 6 FE %&% :$G + 6 :EE %%: &F4 %%&%F5+ 6&D6
%'6 +9) !(/I++ !*!!/+! ! +,)! ,K!+)-,+*+! 2A /+*+! 22 !C 0%&4 GGG+ 6:%&%:$G+ 6:EE:$$+ 6:D6 2 ! +I *,+ E !-,+ -,-+! ! +,+- + +)*!+9E , !-,!-K!) A+ 2 !M A+ ) +9 */ --,! +C 0%&#%#:+ 6&6&M 0%&:%4 + 6FD!!@,! /+!- FI!6$&6%
2 C2 ! +9ED6 +! 22! *! !8! <!6 F& 8 ,+ ! + -9*! <,, ! + C!6 $% $& ! %:$ D / <8 ! < - -,! + +9 -, < - + +*,! + + < * 2!! + )++!- /+/-*!<* !! +< 6 !!+! 9 / , 22-*+*! -A/<@/ +! + !,2)+E!/!+@* 2+! ,+/<!JJC 0%&:%&+ 6FD6
%%6 <,(2 !-2-!-,++-&2-) %##$6 <!+ A+"@/+2+*-*!@A ,!--0 . -,! ++96
%&6 2 ! / 2 ! ! -!- , + -2! <! 2 < , < ! - * *! -!* ! +*+*!+ +9*+*!@,! / - ,-*,! + < - + @ + ! / !) ! (9 9--*+*!, +2 !C 0%&#%#:+ 6&6:
2 D6
%:6 -! , ( + / 0 . ,+ ! 2 ! -2 ,++- , A9*! E ,* ( ! &#,!*E %##$ -- +! ! + )- , <*,+B* +,--,! ++9/) !, *+*!A9*!2 !&2-) %##$6
%G6 * ! + ; ,+ - -,! + +9 2 !-E !+)!&#,!*E%##$!+! 2 - +
3%&453%### "$3#" -,! + +9 &F A) %### @ <* !! + 2 ! +*,-!! ,+ )+ ! + -E ! / ) ! , *+*! <+)!2 !+ ! ,+E ,,!!@*6
%F6 +-/ E - +!! !- - + &FA) %###+! 2 -@,+/ <) !,/ !-,+)+ ! A!!** )-<+,,+ ! +0 .6
3%&453%### "#3#"
# 2 " # " " # "
%
04 7 3 89 ')( "$
%6 +!! !-- +0 .&FA) %###6
&6 A!!** )-<+,,+ ! +%%*%###6
:6 2+* ,! /< ,)! 2+* + +! ,-! K! - :' A+ ( +! 2 ! + , , +- - E 2-- JV WJ+2/ 4 4''G !+ 8*, 6 - ,! K! ,++9-6 *-*+ + !L D / 8!*!/- ++!- +E! !,- + !!/-M ED 8,+ ,+ / *+! 2 ! * ,+)+ * !! ! - +M D ,+! 9! + + ,-!!6 *-*+ +! ! , !+ --*! -*-- + !! D ED ! D " E2--,+,!*! (+/< )- )E6*-*+ +*! ++*+B ,) / +! A+ ! / - + !!/- ! <)+,, /-!-8,- -+!C!6%:&%'4!%'$D6 922 (L - !L 00 T T 922 ("A !L !J
+, +2+*,-!K!!+! 2 -8,! /<@<22 2-- + ,922
3%&453%###