Arbitration Award Review: Scope of Authority and Omissions
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant sought to set aside an arbitration award concerning a contract dispute, arguing that the arbitrators exceeded their authority by considering issues outside the scope of the submission agreement and failed to address a specific issue raised by the appellant. The court reasoned that the submission agreement was broad enough to encompass the issues decided by the arbitrators, and the failure to rule on one specific contention did not render the entire award invalid as it did not affect the core resolution of the submitted claims, thus affirming the award.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Arbitration Award Review: Scope of Authority and Omissions: The court reasoned that the submission agreement was broad enough to encompass the issues decided by the arbitrators, and the failure to rule on one specific contention did not render the entire award invalid as it did not affect the core resolution of the submitted claims, thus affirming the award.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of judicial costs.
Testo completo
!"#$%!"$$& '!()*!#++)
, ,
- '.- ', - , .
) #++)
"/ 0 1
. .',2., 3 2 '., '. , !" #$ % &'
(!
4444444444 )* +" !! 4444444444 ( )!) )',!) -- % ((./ 0 1* 2 3 ) ! (
44444444444 55) !
44444444444
" 678"
2.'
-: 0 )!) )) ; -##< % &' ! )!) ) 5 !! ! % !5(* ( = *))! ( / ! 5!(+ 1 "5& 2: 68 ; ! -##>4 ( )!) 5! )!) + 5 ?))! ( / ! 5!(+4 (! 3 = *() 9 (@! -##> 3 !! + ( 5 3 ! 5! ( ! (:
6: -< )A -##>4 =! ' ) ' ! )*! A 5& : ( ) ) ( )5! ( (. B
" % C( DDDDDDDDDD4 !! 5) ! ! % C( DDDDDDDDDD4 !!4 !( + 5( (!! 96E-6F *:
$84 G ;(
" % C( DDDDDDDDDD4 !! -##8 % ;' -##>4 ! ! = .! (! ' % + 5( (!! <FE$68 *:
684 -# ('A -##9
" % C DDDDDDDDDD ! DDDDDDDDDD4 !!4 A))* = .! (! ' % +4 5 5!A -##H % -##84 ( ; -##< % -##H4 5( (!!
--E8<- *: -# ('A -##9 ).!:
<: C DDDDDDDDDD ! DDDDDDDDDD =(! 5 (!!) ) ( -< )A -##>:
H: C( DDDDDDDDDD *() (55( ! ( $ )A -##9 (! ) ( % (! * ): 5) ) 3 ( ! ' ! 5 * H )A -##8: 5 (!4 ! * ) ) ( ! ) ! 5)!! ( % 6$E8H- *: 984 5 % 6>E-8# *: >8 ( ( 66 ('A -###:
8: C DDDDDDDDDD ! DDDDDDDDDD (! ).! *() (55( ! (4 ! - )A -##9: +5 3! 3= (! )!) )I.) !
( -##8 1? > ; -##82: &.! ='( )!) *() 5( ! 3= )A -##9 ! )! '( 5/) 5(!)! 5!
5) =)'! % >E--9 *: 9F:
>: )5() 5& ( ( !( ( " 3G! ' ! % ') ! (55( ! ( <F )A -##9:
7-6#87-##9 " <78"
9: ;.! -< 5!A 6FF64 ( ( !( ( " () % ') (55( ! ( % ( 6>E-8# * >8 5( C( DDDDDDDDDD ! % ( --E8<- *: 5( C DDDDDDDDDD ! DDDDDDDDDD:
$: + /! )5() 55 5& A *)) 4 " ( G! ! 8 *)' 6FFH: (4 ) ;.! ( ( !( ( " !
!() A ) * 3= ( ! (!!) 3 (!! ' ! )!) ') 5 0 ( 5 C( DDDDDDDDDD ( 5()4 !
* 3 ! !! 5 ( ! ' !) % 5! 5 % 5():
#: *() A 3 ( (.4 (5! ! '! !) 5 C( DDDDDDDDDD ! * *!) 5 = 5( ! =)&'4 $ ' 6FFH4 % #E#<H *: 68:
,.'
-: (' ! 5)A 5) 3 ( .'( =(. ! ( ; 66 ('A -#H- 12 )!) ( * ) ! 3= A !( ( )!) ! !) & - (@! 6FF<4 !!! ! 34 (!! (!!! ( ! ' % ( *)) ="
' ! ' '! 6F )A -#H> 1*: !: -4 !: ! 8>4 : -4 !: 4 I: - 2: (*()! % =!: <4 : < ( -H ('A 6FF6 ( * ! 4 !) ' . - (@! 6FF<4 5)! 4 !( ! 8 (!(A 6FF-4 ! 5! '! ( ( !( ( ! & ="' ! ' '!4 )!) ! =( A !( ( :
6: ! E!: 9- ( 5() !! ' -6 5!A -#$8 1 24 E!( !) 5!4 E( ( 3G!4 (( E55 ! (! !! ( ; 3 ! 5! A EG! !) 5 E 5(): 4 ) ( ' ! (55(A:
<: =5&4 ? '(/) A ) * 3 " ' ! !! 5 % 5! 5 % 5():
7-6#87-##9 " H78"
H: ;! * 5 ()3! =55 C DDDDDDDDDD !
DDDDDDDDDD:
5 5 5
7-6#87-##9 " 878"
,'.2 '.- ', - , .
61
78 9 6 :7 "*# ,
-: 55 C DDDDDDDDDD ! DDDDDDDDDD:
6: * + ) 6$ ; 6FFH 5( )! :
<: ! 3 5 & ( (! % 5( ! ( 5( (!! ( . A ):
H: *( 5! 3E 5'! *( ( (! 5)! G!
) "+ ; & (! * ! ( 5 5 () ) A *)) 4 IJ KI(*3 >4 >FFH 4 !( +5 : )( ( ! B 2 3 +!! 3 ) ( (!
) (A! ! 5 ) ( !!3)L A2 +5( 5( 3 (! * (! ! 5('( !! ! ) (L 2 5(! .! (! ( ( 5)!!: )( (! ! 5 !( ))! ))) ( !! 2 A2 ! 2 "4 A *)) 5( 5 ! ! & ( 3E ' ) 'A: )( ( ! ( ( (/ 5'4 3 (! ;( ! )( E E. ! 5 & 5( ( (!: (! ).! ;( ! )( ) ( !!3) ! E'(55 3 )!) +5) ) (! 1!: -<64 -F> ! -F$ 2:
. & B 5) ! B
C "( M ( N
(5 (*( 5)! G! ! (! * ) + 5! 3E% E *)) ( 5 .
7-6#87-##9