Document Production Dispute Over Agency Privileges
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant challenged the denial of their request for certain documents related to a regulatory investigation and subsequent administrative action, asserting privilege only on the basis of ongoing investigation, but later conceded that the investigation phase had concluded and the agency cited attorney-client privilege and the deliberative process privilege for withholding materials. The court held that while the deliberative process privilege could apply to protect pre-decisional communications, the agency failed to adequately show that the withheld documents contained policy recommendations or that disclosure would harm the integrity of the decision-making process, and the general assertion of ongoing investigation after the conclusion of that phase was insufficient; thus, the agency failed to meet its burden to demonstrate the applicability of the privilege, requiring further review of the documents in camera.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Document Production Dispute Over Agency Privileges: The court held that while the deliberative process privilege could apply to protect pre-decisional communications, the agency failed to adequately show that the withheld documents contained policy recommendations or that disclosure would harm the integrity of the decision-making process, and the general assertion of ongoing investigation after the conclusion of that phase was insufficient; thus, the agency failed to meet its burden to demonstrate the applicability of the privilege, requiring further review of the documents in camera.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to determine the allocation of costs for the proceedings.
Testo completo
$%%&&$%''( "$))*$%''+
"
, "#, -"! ,- !-#
(. -/0 %1 %''+
2222222222 ! " # $ %%%%%%%%%% "$& ' !& (!& #)&$ * +,-. $
&$
-# #"# !3- "#" " 3#4#", !/0$#&$1/23/ "$& ' !& (!& #)&$*4 $!, 5 !6$
!"#
427/24
5#"
/9 # $ %%%%%%%%%% ! /:;3 !&! ' & ( & < =& /::2 $*( !& &">!"$(&$"$ ?%%%%%%%%%%,9 9* &!@9 !& & $ $! "$ & "$6 & "$6 "$ & ($( &A 4"$BC, D&66 !E "$ & $ "$!'> FG& & & H>"$ 4" &$ A 4"$BC D9
29 , &E& &I$!("$"$ (& ' &!$& '9,!&!"$ J$H"$, * '$! &!"$&H 9
<9 $! //=&/::K(66 &($ ' &!A "$BC DI F!!6 ($& "( ' &!/33LB/$=& /::<9
09 /< 'F$ /::K , "$ ! (&$ $& ( ' &! B /$ &F$ /::K9 $ $$M& 28 /::8 $ F &$& 6 6& &$ $ F&$&1&&$& ( ' &!!&!6 1!E;;L9
K9 $ ! N !F$ /::K &$>! E $! $& ( ' &!B/$&F$/::K"$&&/(2NK6$9;3 &E *I ' &!"!/<&F$/::09
;9 0$/::8$$!' ( $! &$ &I$!E 4$& B/$ /::89I$! &$O&!$$&$&&! &N '$ /::8"$B &$$& B$ ,7 9
89 , &E & $&I$4 ' &! "$!'> !'$&B $/:::& 6$!I$!*(! $&&$""$@$ &"$ 9
N9 &0O /::: *!EI$!*((!& &(' $" !&! '$& " /::; $ H 6& $&&'$&$& ""!& $!&JH& && 6 9 /; O /::: I 6$! * $ & (' & " " M&$ &&! 6 & & "$ I$! !!&"$& &9
:9 $ ! <3 O /::: & $$ ,4 $ "!&&$!'$&($&& B$( ' &!& &&1 ( ' &!E";; 27<L9 &&$&& B$&'(O&$$&
7228872330 4<7/24 & B$"!& $"$!"B/$=&/::;&$&& B$ ""$6&B/$!F$/::;9
& OH& ( $"$ $& & '$! $& '&C 3/93N9/::<</9/29/::0C/(2;<6$9 3/93/9/::K</9389/::;C/(<306$9 3/93N9/::;<39//9/::;C/(;:K6$9&<:/6$9"$O & 3/9/29/::;</9/29/::;C2(2/;6$9&<:/6$9"$O &&K2/6$9 "$(6& 3/93/9/::8</9/29/::NC2(28<6$9&03/6$9"$O &&K<K6$9 "$(6& 3/93/9/:::</9/292333C2(2:;6$9&03K6$9"$O &&K036$9 "$(6& B 3/93/9233/C 2(<K< 6$9 & 0/K 6$9 "$ O & & KK0 6$9 "$ (6&
/39 B O &/::: $"$ '$&"$' $EJ&$ K336$9$&&(&&&6 1& !6 & '$& &, 9
//9 /0 $ 2333 , "$!! E ' $& && "& JH& ""$&! E $& I$4 ' &!9 &&& *I > ' & $ & , 6 & ' $ "$B ( "& 20(;NK 6$9 '$& $& >& !OE !&! 66&! ( "$ ! $& && &/8 233/" ! $ <"&F$233/9
/29 & 23 $ 2333 $! E I$! 1 ! $& & & $"@& N !F$ /::K &$>& $& '&"$B$ & C 3/9/39/::K</9389/::;CN80836$9A"!$ "$ "& $& && "$ "$!'>DP 3/93N9/::;</9//9/::;C;/N836$9 3/9/29/::;</9/29/::;CN8:;K6$9&/82:36$9"$(6& 3/93/9/::8</9/29/::8C02N<K6$9&/3<<K6$9"$(6& 3/93/9/::N</9/29/::NCKNN:K6$9&/306$9"$(6& B3/93/9/:::CKN3:K6$9&/32K36$9"$(6&
7228872330 407/24 '$&EJ&$0<(3;N6$9!OE66&!$&"!$ /$=&/::;</$2333&$""$@/;(N30K36$9!& &""$9 !E$!$& &$&&"$$$ $2<$23339 *! &$ $ '$& $& " '$ 2333 O*(E "& "B&9
/<9 22 2332I$!'$&& $ F &$& 6&$ &"$ "&" &($&( ' &!/33LE"&$ ('$ 23339, $ & !& &$$!9" &$' &"$ J &&!OE'$!& "' & M&$& E$& && 9 (' &&&!, &( (!&&$'& 6$& "$&& &"$& &$$!!9
/09 $!"28O 2332 " &&!F&& $9 &&$ &"B&&$!$F!&F$2332& '$&$&$"$$ &B'F$23329 ' &'$!$& E &$ $BH& & (' & " "$ 6& $ &" ' !!& "$& & "$ $ & 9
/K9 $ $$M& 2N O' $ 233< $ F &$& 6 !$! $$ "$& & $'F & ! E '$$ E I$! && /0(;8/3K6$9*& & H "$& &$$ & 9, & 1$! !"$ $ F ""$ &*$&"$&& 03(:<0KK6$9$ &M&$'$!$$&$* 4 ' &$@ 0<(3;N6$9 ' &"!/;(N30K36$9'$&B /$ '$ 23339 B $ ' & '$$ 66!$ &$ && $& & && = $& && "$ $$& & /0(;8/3K 6$9 $ $" & I$!"!& & !& &$" 9
/;9 286!'$ $233< &$O&!$$$ & &$& 6"$4'& $ F6!!$$A 4"$BC Q D&$OH&& !I& 9, &E'1 ""$ &*$&E '$$EI$!&$/$=&/::;&</$2333!& &28(023NK6$9 && 66& '& '$! I!'& E 0<(3;N 6$9 E & &$ $& && !& & /K(;08/K 6$9 >& !OE "! /;(N3KK36$9&& &' $E$!&&/(/K8<K6$9*I '$$ &"$J &9
/89 $$$M&2K&F$2330 Q "$& & $$&$'>! $ F ! "!&& " /$ =& 233< "$ &$& "!& $ & ' OH& !$&9 $! !"$ Q &E * $ F &$& 6' &6 1! B$ $$! && $ & 9 $& "$
7228872330 4K7/24 "!$ !$!I!' &E2;(0<2<36$9$* ' &'$!0<(3;N 6$9 F * &$" "$@ !& & /;(;<K83 6$9 &6 !!& 6 & "$&&& &&$ && $ "& $* 6 &!6&B$* $!& &&$ && $'& 6$&I$!&6 9$&&$ !& &$'>!"$ "!&I &$& &'OH&9
/N9 /3O' $233KE $ F!I$!"$ & '$ " B"$&&&I!&F $ && 6 B$9
/:9 0 233K $ F '*! "$& "$& "$9
&& "$ & &F $!" && 6 $& &$* $&$ &&&02<236$9E"$* !$ & "$M& E $$9 "& I!& & J'! <3 'F$ 23329/(/2K8K6$9' &!&!'$!EI$!2/'F$2332& &$/(/K88K6$9&<$233<9 $""!*I$! I!& &""$!$"& &R' &!&!! !$ *I >' &!&!1"$!& ' &!9
I$! & ! " ' $ &$&! I"$& "$ ">$ J$H " /$ '$ 2333 I' & "$6 !9 ' & 6& " /::;&!' &6 !"!/:N:I"$!!&$ H9 "B$&$ F &"EI&$& &&$ B$&I$!"$' &" $& "!& $ "$ 9 "$! & * 6 & I' $ ! && $ F &$& 6 "$B "& !&$ & E I!' *I && & && "$ " * &&9 $ F ' & &$S$ "& !& &6!$H$ && 6 B$ 6 9
239 & 2: O 233K I$! &$ $ F ! '" B$& && 6 B$9
2/9 $$$ $K=&233K $'!*I$!"' & '*$ && 6 B$6 "$&&$"& $*I I> !& &"""!EI!"*9 &$ $&E*I 66 $ & I' &" ! && $ F &$& 6 I' & 6 & 1 " &$9 I!"*"& && 6 B$6 I$!!& & 9>' & $& $* 4 ' &$!E&&$ "& 9 &&!&& !& &O$IJ &$"&$"$6 $9
229 &!&!H$!EOH$"$ $ F!9
7228872330 4;7/24
!#"
/9 H' $I$H & O $AD!&! 6 !& & &!B /$=&233< $ F&$ "!KOH & "$! & & ' 4"$! & K ""!& & /; OH $ A$&9 / &9$&K; D9
, &EI& I!& /;OH$"$ $ F6!!$ 28O' $2330A Q/<3/3;D$ H' "&!/<6!'$ $ " & &$ & $$H&"$&&& $ F&$ !H$ $ E &$ OH & & $ I&&& I!& '1OH$9
29 6$!& E I$&9 K; 9 / &9 F $ F & $ )& & * &&& $& ' E "$!'> "$6 ""& & && "$!'>">$&>&$ & > "$ '$ *I1"$!&& $"F &!A$&98<9/ 6!!$ $ "$!'> "$6 ' $' '& & ' &!2KO /:N24D9
,"!&"$OH$I"B& !&F 9
<9 '<&F$233< 6 &A/B$$!' D&&$!' H$ /$O' $233KA$!$'$& " & &(&$!' H$ !&! 6 1! /$ '$ 2330 & /$ O' $ 233; T 2330 /833UD &$)& 6 & F$ " & !H "$!'> "$6 A 2330 /;88D9 "& ("B $& $!H "$ " & ' H$O*(</!F$2330!H$"$ " * $BH "" F & ' H$ & R 6 & O$ *&!&$ &&"$ &A Q/280;8 9/D9
09 "$!F !&$ $ * & IFO& & H "$& !&& !$$" &9 66&I$! $ F"$$$ "$ ""& $H$ && 6 $* & &*"$ "$ &M&$$ O$IJ 9
$ F!& &E$' $ F6!!$ $ * && & $ $$ 6$! "$ &$ $$M& $ F &$& 6H' 9
6$!& E O$ "$ $*( " & 6 & $' $!6!$&1"$!&1 !$&OH&4* &("B4 14 ' & "$& &!H$& & * B$& 6$ J OH!P &$(&$ &! 6!$ $E*&$'>!A, $ &!
7228872330 487/24 $ & &$& 6 JG& /:N0 "9 N;:P Q "F ! N "&F$ 23332:/7::D9
!$& $ & "$ * $ F 6!!$ $ & ' $' ( 66 $ E (&$ &! 6!$ $ & F (&$ &! $' * Q 4M*$ &$' $$! E( ($$F!*&A Q/232<8 9///820/ 92//< /K: 9/P # /:::V<</"9/28 92D9
I"B$$M&2K&F$2330"$!& Q 6 & "$&$ & H $ W $ & E $ & F& $ $F$& "$' "& &&'$!&$"EI$!/::;E2333X9 & !&$ ! * !& & && $& "$!'> "$6 "$ "!$ !$! " *! * $ & I!' & E /;(;<K83 6$9 6 $'! * W !!& 6 & "$&&& &&$ && $ "& $* 6&!6&B$* $&&$ && $'& 6$&I$!&6 9"!&I &$& '$$! $ '1!!&I 6$& '&'OH&X9
"& & * "$!B > &&$ * Q "$!! $ & & $* $ F ! *I 1 *& "& *& &F IFO& & H9
K9 * I $'! Q $BH "" F & B$ $& && "$&& $ &"& &!&!1"!"$OH $ F &$& 6$&*I > $'>$E$ !$&$" &9
O&$*"& (&" F*$*1F H& M "B 1 && $! "$*& &$ 1 "$ & * && ' * $! $ & 1$$ "& & 1 H F & 6! $ &9 , $ "$B !F &$ && (1 & $! ""$& & $! $ * & 1$$ "& "$'$ A Q "F ! 2: !F$ 2333 & /$ 2332 23733 & 2/73/D9
'$& ($&9 ;< 9 /$ * '& $& 6 & &&$ F& "&1 H$$& && *( "$'' $$"$$$$*( ' &*( ">! A Q /2: ;0: '9 9 <92 & $!6!$P & &" $$ C 5 Y7+ & $ $ F H& 8 $&9;< D9($$$ &M&$"$ &$ &*((& "$! !&(""'$ &R 6$ &"$&& 9
7228872330 4N7/24 (>" E$& && $R * $@ =&!&F &*( (&"$ J $$!"!& & PE "&*( & ' 6 *( $@ *( ( & = ' $ & *( "' &M&$&E$& &$A$&9;0 D9
;9 $ & $ && "& & "$ " O$ *9 $& "! $BH& $& "& $! A1C$&92392 ,T Q//K<02'9 92FU$&9K3 $&9K39< D9 (F ( $!H&& "$& B$ "$ " "& $! $ & "F & $BH H!!$ A Q///F/KN 9<P- $! $ & &$& 6/::/V8<N"9 /;2D9 " & * 6 1& & & "" F"$H A$&9/239 P,/::0"92/8 9<D9
&6 $ &$ $! * & O & "$ $!6!$ E ($&9/2K J9 2 $! ( & && !$ &! "& M&$ "!'"$&& E$! 6 &$$ 4 & 4 ' & A Q /2N K3P //K <0< 9 2P , , 2333 "9 K00P # /::8 V 2;N "9 <: 9 <P # $ & &$& 6'T& &$& 6&$&$SUV/9<9<"9K89& $!69D9
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
89 I"B Q !OE &$J! *& && $ & &$& && 9,I$$M&2K&F$2330 ""$)&
7228872330 4:7/24 * '$! E I$! && /;(;<K83 6$9 &$ /$ =& /::;&</$23339 $H$$BH& ! & I $!"!& & &$" " *I&$ ! !!& ! $$ & *"$&& &!&!'$!E&$& "$ 9
$$& I$$M& 2N O' $ 233< $ F &$& 6 $ "& "$!' $ I$&9 ;0 " *I $ & = ' $ *I "' &M&$&E$!"!& & 9 66&" B $"$&&&$& $ * 4 ' &!&!'$& "$ !*$ & & !& &!H& $&6 &*$& !& &O&&E 6 & 9 $ $ I' &! JH&$' && 6 !"$ F H& & $I & && "$!'> 6$! $ & $' E "$$ "& A69 $&9 <0 9 2 & 20 9 0 I$ $ "$!'> "$6 ' $' '& & ' &! /N'$ /:N042D9 I&"$&&$ * $ F &$& 6' & !OE$O&!$ I$!9
, " B $ *& ' $ !& & $ & "$ $!$& && ( '$&!J9 *II' 4 & "& & " F E & *I "$& " && & ' &I &!$!9
($$ > '!$ 6 $ * "& $! $& && /;(;<K836$966&!"$ E"$& $ 2333"$ '$&$&!J"$&"&& & ' & I$!9
$ J$H E "$$ !$& $& I! 2333 "$& (F$ && F /(KK3 6$9 A69 H $&$ "$ (1 & & B$ "$ & T ' &U($&9:<20'F$2333!&F "$ 6!$ "$!"! 1 66 "$ & & 6 & , A,J- 233/72332"9/:D*"$6$ "$I && 'M&&& H > "$ $ &$& $"$ & &! I&$& H& 6$ &$ * !" "$ I! $H $& !&$ *HZ"$ 9
,(> O& && ;33 6$9 $& 6 E (&$& 1 6& GH! $"& '&0&//2333 *>$66& 6"$H& 0" B/(/;N6$9 A69!$& 6 233/4 DM*"$ ($4 N2//K 6$9 A:INK07/2D "$ 6 & & & I&&8N6$9A:<K7/2D9 &$ *&& "S& $ & M&$ "$ "& $ ' &
7228872330 4/37/24 A Q :K 02 9 <D9 F!!6 * "$!B && && !"E"$$"& ' &I!B'E 0(2/8/K6$9 &6'7+'+ 899
,$"$'I$!&!"&"$@$I!2333 &&:8(K:26$9E& &$$& ,4 */:(:<26$9"$& , 9 &&IO&&"&*$'$! EJ&$ /(K336$9M*& 6 2(3036$9B$&& $$'I&!'!$I! !$!A2333DE 9%9:'+( 8;
!* "$!B* ' &I$!$ & ' $ !&! &! 6 & "& "!$! "$ $ I!2333' && 6 B$6 $&&&!9
"& I!&&!$!O*I<3'F$2332 >$ '!$ 6 $ && &!H&'F"$!233/&23329
&$&6 H$& $ ""$)&*!"E"$$ !$& $& I! 233/ & & * * $ &&F&>$9 $&&$ F& EI&$& 6& > & $ "& I && 8K3 6$9 I & && "$ I$4 E ;;;9/3 6$9 A8I::<7/2D & & & I!'& E //2;3 6$9 A/I<K/7/2D9 !" "$ && ! & !'!E6':1+'(' 89A0(20;831/2D9
,$"$'I$!&!"&"$@$I!233/ &&K2I:2/6$9E& &$$& ,4 *23I0;36$9"$& , 9 &&IO&&& 6 0IN336$9 $$ '$!233/9B$&&$$'I& !'! 233/E&*79*9 8;"&&"& 66&!9
' & $$& I " " !&! &! "$ "& $I!233/9
6 "$ I! 2332 && F & >$ & !H& $&! JH!9 $ &$ && &$ F& E I&$& 6& E "$$"&I!B'ENK36$9& & E:/6$9A/I3N:7/2D& & & I$4 E N02 6$9 * !* '& E !" (17699 89 A0(K3/ 1 //D "$ "!$ $ * "$&! "& E ' $O' $E'F$23329
,IH &$'I$!&!"&"$@$Z"$ $ I!2332&&2KINN<6$9A//12(<K<DE& &$$& ,4 * /NI8KK 6$9 A// 1 /(83KD "$& , 9 &&
7228872330 4//7/24 IO&&& 6 2I2336$9&&&/(/2K92K'$!"$ 2/'F$23329B$&&$$'I&!'! 2332E(&71+);%6 89
$!&* "$!B*I&E&$&* "! N(0;3/36$9&$ O' $&'F$2332$H$ &&
6 B$6 $"!$ !$!9 &&"&6 & * I$!$ &="$' $"$& &&N(0;39/36$9 A//18;:9/3D&&$'$ &=I!'$EK;(02<9<K6$$& "!$ !$!9 B $ && ;(:/29<K 6$9 "' & M&$ "! &;2N9036$9"$ 9 $ &="$"& """$ $$&8;:9/36$ $! $E/039836$96 " &$ ' & $$& & 6 9 $ ""$ &"$!!E"& 1!&/(K089836$9*I !& &$ &6 $9$R'$!** "&$A< $233<D&&""!& $/(/K89<KA69$'!F $$$&D "$B' $$' !*I&"$!& &$& &! ' &$$&EJ&$<:39<K6$9*I'$ & !*M&$!E $& &$9
&6 '$& O$ "$ & ! A /:N; "9 <3/D ""$)&*I!'& &!I"& $$&&66&!O*IE $$ I && " 6 F && $ & !OE !& & & I &$& $! ! "$ $ F !9 66& 66!$ <:39<K $ & O$IJ !& & " " $ ! R $ & "!$!$$&&"& $I!2332$! &$& E/039836$9 *! 49 E&$ O$ "$ Q & B$ & * ' & I & $E"& 66& '&"!$!9
$&&$ $$& &M&$$O&!9
7228872330 4/27/24
- !"#5 "#, -"! ,- !-#
<=8 > ? 7; 9+% ! @
8
/9 !$$'F9
8
29 $O&&9
<9 &*"$!$&H$& &9
09 6$ "$& *I "'& 6$$ $$ &$ "$!& $$M& ! <3 O$ B & 6 & "$ " $! $! $ F 6!!$ $ ,J[ Z$J6* ; ;330 &$ 1" $9 ! "& M&$ "$H!9 ! $ &C D *$ 1&&*! $$&! $F& $ &"! &&*!P FD 1"$ "$ * & 6 & "' $ $ && &$ ! P D "$&$ H&$ $"$!&&9 , ! $ & & " &$ !!& !!$! &&$ D FD & D 4 $ F6!!$$"$$"&$$& B$$$$*I '$!$$ $$'F9! $$$& $$> "$' * $& O & * ! &&*! & I'"" *!&!1"! !$$&A$&9/<2/3;&/3ND9 H$66 $ $! & + # $!& $4O$ &C #$ 5 ##
" 6$"$!&$$M&&& 6 !1"$& *IEI66 6!!$ $ "$H$66
7228872330