Corporation Liability Appeal for Tort Damages
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant, a corporation, challenged a judgment concerning liability for damages arising from an alleged tortious act, primarily arguing that the findings of fact and resulting liability determinations were unsupported by the evidence and constituted an abuse of discretion, particularly regarding the computation of damages and the application of legal principles concerning the underlying wrong. The court reasoned that the trial court's findings were supported by sufficient evidence in the record, noting that the legal standards applied were appropriate for the established facts, and therefore concluded that the original judgment, including the determination of liability and the quantum of damages, should be affirmed.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Corporation Liability Appeal for Tort Damages: The court reasoned that the trial court's findings were supported by sufficient evidence in the record, noting that the legal standards applied were appropriate for the established facts, and therefore concluded that the original judgment, including the determination of liability and the quantum of damages, should be affirmed.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision cited in order 1 is the basis for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.
The provision cited in order 1 is the basis for ordering the appellant to pay the respondent's costs.
Testo completo
&'()*&)+ "&++'&,))+
-"
! ".! #" !# #.
') # ,))+
/0 #1 2
". ."."!". !".3 ! " #!$ % ! & '( )* +,,- " & ""
'
4444444444 .
!"#$ % / 01+,/
."
+2 & 3333333333 45 ' 6'7#' 8 93333333333 : ; '
#5 ! <' 5 5 2 " 7 ! ! #5' ! < 5 ! #5' $ ' 55 = ! %' % ! ; ! #5 > # ; 6 7' +??@$ +??*$ +??- ' +??A2
02 6#5 > 6'' 5 << ; ''' ! 5% >$ . !' ''' 55'% B/5C . !' D$ 5 ! ! 0) # +??-$ 6 << !6 << % <<' ' '< + <% +??@2 '' ! 6 <'
6 7E' !6 ' 6<<' ' ! ' < 2
)2 " < !' 5 6#5 > ; ! #5'
5 +??@$ +??* ' +??-$ ' ; ' % ! #5' 5 +??A$ . !' ! ), 5'#7 +??A 7 ! ! ''
5 '' # '' ! 0-F@A0 <2 ! #5' 5 '' 5 ! +??@/ +??*2 !7' !%' 6='' ! '' ## 5 '! 0- ' 7 +??A2
@2 - E' +??G$ =' ! . !' $ 6 << ! 5 ' ' ! <' %/ ' B/5C 6<<D '< ##!#' ! 5> H?G 0)@,*@ ; 6#5 > 5 # '' ! 0-6*,@$*, <2 % 'I' ; * J !C + E% +??G2 !7' <' 55 ' +@ E' +??G2 +G !#7 +??G$ . !' 7 !#''< B< ' '
5!##' ## 7 ' ! D !6 =I' #% !<'% ! 6 55 ' 2 I' ! 0A % +???$ 7 !#''< !# !#!$ !# 6#5 > ; 5> ' '' ! ## # ' 5 #% !<'% ! 6 55 ' ##!#' ! 5>2
*2 00 5'#7 +??G$ . !' ! ; 6#5 > %
7 ! ! '' 5 '' # '' ! 0+FAG* <2 ! #5' 5 ''
+??-/+??A2 . !' 6'' ; % 7 5 6#5 > ; ! #5' ' 5 +??-$ =6; ' % ! #5' 5 +??A2
-2 +) # 0,,,$ =' ! . !' $ 6<< '< ; & 3333333333 % ##!#' ! 5> H ,, 0+?@++ 5 # '' ! 0@F)@*$-* <2 % 'I' ; * J !C + E% 0,,,2 # ''
/ )1+,/
5 !' ! ! '' !K )+ !#7 +???2 !7' <'
55 ' ' ' ##!#' ! 5>2
A2 +@ !#7 0,,0$ % =' ! . !' $ 5#C
5 ' '' 5#$ 6<< '< ; 6#5 > !
##!#' ! 5> H ,, ,, 5 # '' ! 0@F)@*$-* < % 'I' ;
* J !C + E% 0,,,$ 5 !' ! ! )+2+02+???$ 5 0*@$?, < ! < ! 5 ' ' +*, < ! < ! ''42 !7' !(< <' 55 ' ' ' ##!#' ! 5>2
G2 +G K' 0,,)$ . !' 7 ! !6 =I' #% !<'% ! 6 55 ' 2 ' ' ! #'$ 5 !' ! #5' ! 4 ! #5' ' +??@ ' +??A$ 7 ! ! '' 5 +??-/+??A$ !4 ##!#' ! 5> '< = % ! #5' ' ! 6#5 >
8 5# : ' 8 5 ' : +G K' 0,,)2
?2 %' ; !'# !6 0* 5'#7 0,,)$ 5 +* ' 7 0,,)$ !<! 6' 5 #<'2
+,2 5$ <' ' 5'' ! 5' ' 5$ '' = 7 $ ! 5' 8 ! ' : /5C2
."
+2 % 6 ' E! B L 0 ,*D ' # !< ' ''$ !C + K' 0,,)$ 7 ' ! 2 < ##' ; 6'2 *- 2 + '2 7$ 7 M' ' = ! ''' '% ; 5% > 5 < 55 ' ''' ! 5% >$ #5 > ' >' ! '$ > #5 ! !% $ =64 5'' 5 7'2 5 !%' E!' #5''$ !#! ' %72
02 <! 5% > 5 < %$ %%' '
%!' ! 0* E +?G0 B / " G)+2@,D '' # !6 7' ! B'2 0 2 + D2
" 6'2 ++ 2 + $ ' ' #5 > 5' ! # ;
6 7' ! ' I' << ; ''' ! 5% > ' / @1+,/
! ' ! 5% > 5 < 2 " 6#5 > < # 5 ; 7' $ 6' ' ' ! % ## ! 6<< ! 4 # ; ''' ! 5% >2 645' ! !$2 6#5 > = 6 5 7'#5 ; '' E ' ' ; 6''' 55'% 5 <<' B'2 ++ 2 * D2 6<<' % <<'
' '< B'2 ++ 2 ) D2
6'2 ) 2 + ! 6! ! ' ! 6''' 55'% #'C ! 5% > 5 < B" G)+2@)@D 5% ' = 6#5 > ! '
% ; 6''' 55'% '' ! 5 6#7 ! # ; $ % <<' !C # #' N ' !K I' << ; ''' ! 5% >2 '4 ! 6'I' # ' 5 ! ; =655= (7'#' 6''' 55'% ! '! ! 5#' ! '' B'2 ) 2 0 ! 6 ! D2
)2 4 '# ! 6'2 A) 2 + $ (= ' ! '7 = M'$ !C ' ' $ ! ''' 55 ' ''' ! 5% >$ #5 > ' >' ! '2
6 5 '' ! 5 ! !6 55 ' 57 '72 E5! 5 ' = ''' ! 5% >$ 6''' 55'% 5 %' 6 55 ' ; 5 ' %#' ! '' ! 5 6#5 > 5 ! #7 ;
E#' B . ++* ?* L ! +??+ +@?D2 7 ! 5' M' !'#' ! 6 55 ' <' 5 !7' ##!#' ! 5>2
@2 ! ! ' ' !#''% <! 5 '' !#' ;
5> ## !6' ' 4' 5 % ! 5 ' 5 !'' '
'$ < 5 < $ # ; ! E#' 4' ! 6'2 G, 2 0 (2 0 ! <! 5 ' 5 !'' ' <' ! ++ % +GG? B / " 0G+2+ L 2/2 $ ##' ! $ +??? 52 +00- (2 @*D2
' ! #I# ! ! 5 < ! ' ' !#''% ' ! !C ' = '''$ ! 6 #5#' ! 'O( ! ! ' 57 ; < 5 <!' $ 55' ! ! ' <!$ # = ''' 5 !<'%#' %' ! ! ' <! P '#' !'$ ! ' ! ' 5'7 !6 !#''< 5C !6 ' ' <! !6 ! ! ' !#''< B 52 '2 52 +00A L 2 $ !'Q R7 "(!7'7 ! S T$ +??? 52 -0+D2 ' ' !#''% <! P ' 5 4' ' ' !#''% / *1+,/
' ! !C ' / $ <' '! '74 <!4 ' ' ' ' ' !5!' ! 6!#'' <! '' =6 ''' ! 6 #5#' ! 'O( ! ! ' 57 ; < 5 <!' B'2 + 2 0 '2 7 ' ! <! 5 ! !#''% ! 0, !#7 +?-G [ / " +A02,0+]D2
7 ' ! ''' !C ' ' ' ! 6 #5#' ! 'O( ! ! ' 57 5'$ = 5C!$ 5 #% !<'% 5=$ ''' < !$ !#' 5#' ' # ; E#' 4' 2 '' ' ' !6 = ! <' =$ ! #'C = ' ! '$ E ! ' <<'%#' E ! 6'2 A? ' =6 =' 5 % 55 ' ; 5 ' ''' < ! B . +,?
*+D2
*2 65C$ 7 ! '' 5 '7 =6 =' !6#5 > 5' ! $ !<! !%' 7' #' I' << ; ! 5% > 5 < $ = ! ' 6 E# ' '' 5 ! !C = ! !6<<' ' ' < 0) # +??-$ / 6>' <' 6 7E' !6 2
%' 5 !6!#'' = ! #5' ! . !' 5 '' +??- ' +??A ' 4'2 <<'$ ' ! 6#7 ! 5C 5 !' 5 !#! = !<! ' !# !7' !6 # '' ! 0@F)@*$-* < 5 !' 4 '' ! #5 > ! )+ !#7 +??? 5 2 '$ #5 5%' ! !7'$ / 6>' 4 ##' ! . !' $ ; ! 7 ! $ ' #5I( . !' !6 ' ! ' ! 5 ! ! %#' < !6 7' ! ! ' B 2 ! * 5'#7 +??*D2
= < ! 5 '$ ' !6 << 55 ' 5 !7' = 5 ' 7 '' B! +?A@ )0D2 'I' ' < ! 5 !<! ' 5 5% ; 6'2 ) 2 0 ! 6 ! ! ' ! 6''' 55'% #'C ! 5% > 5 < 5' ' ;
6'2 A (2 )$ @ ' - ! !' !6<<' # ; 6#5 > ! ! !6<<' ! 0) # +??-2
' # '<$ > !6!#'' !#! ' ! 5 #% !<'% ! 6 55 ' ##!#' ! 5>2
-2 = < ' !5 ! $ 6'2 A) 2 0 5 = ' ! %' 5% 5 ! #5$ 5! '$ 55$ ''2 / -1+,/
6'2 G?U 2 + ! 5 ! !#''% ! +0 5'#7 +?G* B L * +,D 5% ' =' ; = 5 ! ' '' 5 5'2 '< $ !7 ' # #' 5%' I' # ; ( ! 5' = ' ! #C '# '# ! C'2 <<'$ = 7 <! ! 6 !#$ 5 7' ! #' '' ! '# 'E' ; C ' 55 ! 5 ! 5% 5 ' ' 7( ! B . +0- +*+ !2 @7D2
E5! 5 =6 % ; 6( ' I' # ; 5'' 'C ! C' ! '#'2 <' =6 ' !5 % ! ( ! C <<' 5 5 ; ; < ' 'C2 <'/ =6 #' P '=7 P 6E ' 7E'%#' 5' V 5' ! ' % '# 5 ! =! 7 #I# 5 %' ' ! #5'$ ' ! 6''' = 6 5 %' 7#' 4 !6$ = '' !5 % ! ( ! C B'= " +??G 52 +?@D2 ! ! ' 5 '' ! '' ! 5% > 5 < $ 5 ' ! % 5 C ' '# ! ' I' '( 4#' #' #5 '#' ! !7' ! '' ! 5 ! E!$ # #' #5 '#' %' 5 C B . +0@ 0G*D2
7 <! ! #' 55 =6 > ! < !<< '$ !6 5'$ ' '' 5 # ! < ! 5 ! ; ( !6 5' = ' 5 C' ! #C '# ! 6'2 G* 2 0 '2 ! <! 6/% ' %%' B " / " G)+2+,D B'#' '2 -+ '2 ! <! 5' ! [ / " G),2+ L % !5 + E% 0,,)] '$ !6' 5'$ ! ' 4 !5 6'2 G* 2 0 '2 < " ['#' '2 -+ '2 ]$ ! ' = 655 'C !% 55 E' ! 6 ' ! !5 ; 5' ' #!' B'= " 0,,0 52 -+D2
4 = 7'' ! 5 ! ' ' ' 5' 5 % ' $ !6 ' #C$ 5 5 =<$ 5%' 5'! ; ! !5 = 6!% 5' 5 C! ; C ! #C '#2 67 !6 ' 5'' $ ' !'
5 6 ' ! !5 ; 5' 5' ! %' I' ! $ ! ; '#' C' B . +0G )0)D2 " 6 . ++, +)@ !2 @!$ 6> 5 !6 ! !5 5 < ! '% 5 ' 5 %' $ < ' 5'C2 ' '' !645' ! ' I' !# = !' %' '
/ A1+,/
#'%#' V <' =6 6 !6 << #5= % % ' %2 <' ' = %! ! 'I' ! 5' =' '' ! ='' ! '% = !5 ! ! = 6 5' ##' ' 7#' 4 ! ==6 5 6 5 ! << 5 L <' ! # ! '% = I ! #C #5 '' 6 5' # B5 4#5 5 < D2 <$ <' =6 > ' 55 ' 7 ' '% < ' '' ! %! ! 'I' ! 5 B . ++, G0 !2 A ' +)* !2 @7 L '= " 0,,0 52 -,D2 7 '' C' ! 5' = # ! !5 5 E !% !' ' #5 #'%#' B +?G? 52 0A@ !2 *D2
A2 65C$ %' ! !'# 5# !<! % C' '#'$ E'<' 45' 55 ! '' ! 5 !$ 5$ <'$ ! !5 5%' I' ' > ; !#!2
% ! 6'''! ! !<! %' 5 C =6 ! 5 ! E!$ C' ! #5 '#' ! ' I' ''2 <<'$ 6'
E# << ; = = ''' ! 5% >$ = # . !' ; 6<< !6 << < ##' 4 !5 ' 2 <'$ 6' 5 ='' 5#C < ! '' ! 5 +??@ ' +??*$ < W' !#! ; !5 =I' #% 5 5# # '' ! 0-6*,@$*, <2 5 = 7' ! 5C ! 7 !#''< !' ! 0A % +???2 & 5# 5 C$ !<! 5' ; 5 6='' ! '' ! 5 %'$ ' +??- ' +??A$ = ! 5' '2 '$ 55 ; !'# ; !4 5 5 7 ! $ 6 5 ! 5 !$ =6 6%' !E; <' ! 5# 5 C2
% ! !<<' #'$ 7 ! ' < !$ #5' ' ! E5! 5'$ ; # # #' ; '' ! < ! 5 !2 <4 # ''$ 7 ' ! '' ! #' '7 5 C#' ! !6 ''2 < ! 5 ! = 5%' I' # ; ( ! 5' #5' 6# #'
!6I' ' !7 B'2 + ! C#' <$ # #' '
!#' 5 ! !#''% L * +,2,)D C $ 6# #' !6I' 64C! 5 +,F,,, <2 B'2 0 2 + ! C#' 5'D2 7 !# !C !<! ; 5> # #' ! +F,,, <2
!<! >' ! #C C$ ' ; 4# =' ! !52 7 '' = . !' #!' 5 < % 2 6 $ 6' 5!' 5 !6 << #54 / G1+,/
% ! <' ! ! ' ' '% = 6 5 !5 ! ! = ' ##' ! ! 2 !' $ ' > !#' ! !5 ; !#!2 / ?1+,/
# ". ".! #" !# #.
5
+2 %7 !#! !5 +G K' 0,,) 5 . !' ''' "55'% ! ' & 3333333333 L
5
+2 F!#' L
02 !# & 3333333333 ; 5> ; . !' ''' "55'% # '' ! 0@F)@*$-* < % 'I' ; * J !C + E% 0,,,$ = 0*@$?, < ! < ! 5 ' ' +*,2/ < ! < ! ''4 L
)2 #% !<'% ! 6 55 ' ##!#' ! 5> H ,, ,,$ ; ! # '' #' L
@2 !# !<! ; # #' ! +F,,, <2 L
*2 7 ' !#! ! ' ' ' 5 #5 L
-2 < # 5' ! =F 5%' < # ' 5' I'
! ! ! ), E !C '<' 5 5 ##! ! 7 <! ! $ "(XQ( <= -$ -,,@ $ ' 4#52 ! 5' I' 5 2 ## ! ' V D != 4'#' =F ! ' ! 7' ' 5 ! ! ''=L 7D 45 5 = # '< '# 5 % !#! '' ' ! L D 5 ' ' ! 5''2 " ## '' 5 ' #' # '' D 7D ' D /!$ 7 <! ! 5 5 ' #'C =F !% ! %72 ## ! #' # > ! 5%$ = ' E '$ = ! ''= ' F% 55 ! = ' 45! ' B'2 +)0$ +,- ' +,G D2
<< V !' V
Y! & / +,1+,/
'/E' V . &
5 < # ! 5' I' ' '< 4 5' =F; F << <! ! 5 <<