Enforceability of Preliminary Agreement for Sale of Entity Interest
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the nature and enforceability of a purported contract for the sale of a substantial interest in an entity, where the plaintiff alleged breach after the defendant unilaterally withdrew from the deal following a period of negotiation and the execution of preliminary documents. The court reasoned that the preliminary agreement, despite containing certain binding provisions and outlining a path to closing, ultimately lacked the requisite finality and mutual assent on all material terms to constitute an enforceable contract, particularly because subsequent events and the parties' conduct indicated an understanding that a definitive, superseding agreement was necessary before obligations became absolute.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforceability of Preliminary Agreement for Sale of Entity Interest: The court reasoned that the preliminary agreement, despite containing certain binding provisions and outlining a path to closing, ultimately lacked the requisite finality and mutual assent on all material terms to constitute an enforceable contract, particularly because subsequent events and the parties' conduct indicated an understanding that a definitive, superseding agreement was necessary before obligations became absolute.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAImposition of costs on the appellant for the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
&'()*&'((* &+',&'((-
##
# " " # "
. + % '+ '((-
!"#$#"%& '$ !()
$
$
(( * )) !+,! %-!"$./0!1/11 12
$&#
!"# $%
6/3106
/
17 !$$"8#1+91!$:#) 1+527 &"$%15&1++.!$:#"; < ) $$ = &>7 "$ % & % ? /44/! "%$ #$# % *"$#%*@&#$%%%7
/7 15 & /442! %#"# %&% % "$$ "A % BCC$ % B6:%$# D6"AE F! :$ G $$"CG&$%:"C7
27 $C$ &#% #$H 0 & /442! ! &#%$$$!%8$=#%&H8'=!%"$'26.! =B"%-%$C&&$7 %=#="$#%$: %"$$#$$%"B#$#/44/!=%@$$$:%"%$: G $&" "$ :$ #'#! = *#$$ % $# % *# #$$ $$! =* #:$ $ %$ "#$ #$$ $ = "$#$$#:#7)&#%!$:$#*@>$"$I$"$ !:'H$$*&"=$""$%'8"$J$ :8#! G %$ = B $ "$A&$ $$$C @ &:&$ %B$6C@&"$$%$7
""$%"#$$#$#"%$" E
6)""$% !%8!&H% 14?$ /44/ #:## %"$' C&&$ "# 26. : "# %B &"$$ ' $6"8 : % " % 2! # G %B&"$$ "'#&A C&&$7 "$ % &%##26.#8&$#$#&#:%!%&J&=%$A@ C:%B&H#$$&%###$8#7
611?$/44/! !8!""$G -%& &H '-" 8! # G $$$ % $$: 2 8'%#C$:$$C%%$8%%#:$8K% &$ "" 8% % 27 ) ! 8 C&&$! : C$! %:$ J$ @ " H %B:$8$ &"#&$ D'&$8=!&&8=$C$F7
6 %# G 1+ %#&H /44/! ! &#% %?$ G = % '8 % BLI"$ $!:#='$"8$$%"%2#$$ &"$ $ $$ G C$ # " ""$ @ $ "! $ =* @$$ $ M%A& #8&$ &"$$7 ""# % "#% G % : %8"'$G7
3/45.3/44. 623106 6 21 ?: /442! C$ : G = #&8 &$$ $% G B&#$7 % : $ "#$! ! :$ C&# B@$ %B :& ' $6"8 : "H&$ % #$ C&&$ $ %BM%A& % $$ %?$7 &#% # % B $ $$&$ % "'-$'#" $ # G &&%"$%B$7
6 C!%""$%1:/442!( !'8! :#%&H8&#=%"$'C&&$.60$%=# =$##&$#$$#"""$:$'8= $$#$%%=$&"%B"$'A": $#7
.7 %$ % 2 $H /442! C&# G B B"$# $$ % $: % "$$ %" B#$# /44/! $ "## = $$ "$# B""=$ %#& G $$ $:$#7 ) ! " $:$#%"$#B#$$:8H$&#$%B#$$%$#"$ ""HH7
07 ""$%24"$&H/442!%:%#%"$$"C %B ""#"'8%B$8%BH:$"C% 10%#&H/44215?:/44.7
97 $ %BH:$ "C % B6:%$# D6"AE F % ""$ %$ % /5 ?: /44.7 ) ! "$# "'-= % B# $ &"$H : $:$# &" $ "$=! ":#8$"$&"&$$$%*'8! G"$&"$: %&$ % 94N "A "#% % #$O&$! % $ #&= &7 )B8$ % "$# %B%"$$ $ %B""$8! ?8#&"$H:&"&"$"$=%$ #&= &7 "## = *# :$ "$$% "&$$$ % :&$"$=$"7
! $"$##%%$:%94N6$ %&$ % 94N " $&" 6 % &" "$=! #8! "&$$$%B$"$7 $$%*@&"!$#$:@GB#$H! &" % %$&$ #8 %B%6&$ "$ % '87)&O$%$8!%"&$$&$ $" "$ *:# #7 G %$ = B# $ "J$ G $"%$:$#"C7
""$#$$?$:% !&#%% ! %/.?:/44.7)&#%!B$$$%%B#!=%$$H" H8$#$C!%:$C&&$-%&&H%$
3/45.3/44. 6.3106 #$$ '=&$ $$$7 B# #$$ #8&$ $# " $$$% $%$ % $$ '8 = B%$ " ""$ && =$ %B #:$ $:$ '87 ) &#%! " %B $:$# "'-=&$ % #$$ @ $ "$8H#$$#:#"C$$"C7"$# $'#= $ " @"$ % "$ :&HH&$ J$ &## B# #$ G O$ &H$# #$$ " & =$C@H8"H7
,7 /2C#:/44.!%:%#%"$$"C%B % ""$ C! @ $& %= C@# $@ %B:%$# % B# G 0.!9N7C!$&&:%B:%="$ #$$$='&&@>$%$:$#&"$#"#$$: %B%$&C$A:%&$%94N7 $#%$ &$$%14N!"$&"$%&=% 7
57 %$ % 1 ? /44.! %=# G B = "$$ CC$ %B &% -$#&= C&&$ %B8 ! =* :$ #$$ "$#! = %#C$ C$ $ $&$'$%@#"C$%%8#%BC&&$ $=*#":$@$:7
+7 %#%2?/44.!B $-#GB#%&6$% &"G&"$%&%?/442!H#%8#%B:%$#%0.N7
147 %1,?/44.!B#B$""#G$$%#$G =B"$#$$%$:%$$$:$#$7
117 0P$/44.!B#&$:#""$:$=% "%$ " @ $$$ C$ % $8! %=B:$?&$$$%&$%94N"$&"7 CC$! $&"%$:#%$!%&$B#$$$#$.2$09N!%$ =B$%#"04N"$&"7!C$:=*- :$ % "#% G #%$ ""#&$ % /0N % : %B:%7
1/7 %#""$%//"$&H/44.!B C&#%# $! &$C =B B:$ " % % B#$ % ""#$ % $% !H?$:&$C%#7 $G=$% #%$ G ""= : %B:%! @"# = 'CC % 14N "%$G?"%%&$A" HC#%#7 C! BCC"##=B$$%"#G@&%$%B#G% "&$%&%#$$&$:#%"$7
3/45.3/44. 603106
127 $%11$H/44.!B#$?$#$$$%#"A % H$%7C$:=% =$ G "$# % $: "%$ " G = :$ #$# H:#%$$8$*#$$$$8H=%$" C:H!=*$$"7%&%#GH##C% &%#$O&$$:$G=*$$"#%#G% #:$ C % :#C : ""$: % 7 ! &C$#&"#'%:$*@8%*%&%#$$&$:# " % "&$ ""$ =* $$ % 8% %CC$# : 8 C> #$7 #8# = *#$$ G BCC % C$ $ &'# % B&"7 B# G = % & % #$O&$ $: $ & " $ G = "$# % $: #%$##:#GB%67
1.7 #"%15$H/44.!B ?$%!&$C ="$##%%$::$&$"J$%#C"&O$ %#%"$$"C7*$#C##G*:% ! = %&$ % 94N " $&" $$$ &&& &#H%&QB#:$H#:$$$$&$$7 "! BCC * " $$# = $ " : H %B $ % "&$7 @"=# = B@8 %B %&% #$ $ &$:# :$ G B % # :$# % *# % ## % $"C!=$$%#&'$:7
107 #"=%/:&H/44.!$"$#% :$ G = % & % #$O&$ $: $ & " $ ="$#%$:#%$##:#GB%67! %&%# = % & %B% "&$ $ ""# $&" ""$$%$"#H7
197 10:&H/44.!* ""$&$"$7
1,7 %$ % /2 C#: /449! $H % # "#%# G B%$ % =$#%$#&7 %%=#B:$# "$$ =BG %@ " $ : > " $ ""$ #:=$ % % @ #"7 8# =* ":$ % " " % &A "# $ $C= & =* ":$ "%$ % $% "$ % '8 $ %B#:$ "$ "$6G6C@7 #$$ %CC % " : $$% #:$ "$# #% % $:! & $&# =* $:$# $$ " #8 &H $ %$"H78#='%"#$#"$ #$$ &"$! %B ' =! $ =* *#$$ % " $ =* " $: ?# $A7 #$O&$ $: $ = "##" #$$:8H7
3/45.3/44. 693106
157 %#$&$ % / & /449! $ :# = B&8 &"$ % ' % @"=$ % $ = B&"J'$ % $: %$ ?# $A7 ! C$ : = % @ #" %$ #8&$ "HH&$ % &$$ C$ ""#&$7 &"$ $ % #: C&# " ! #8# = B#:$ C % "$# % $: %:$ #8&$ $ :$ &#%! " $ &"$ % B#:$ % 7
1+7 $GB !"$#%!$&$=!%&Q "$$$=$B#$$"&%B@$:$# $=#8A$=B:$#$#H:#$$A$!B-:$" %B#$%%""$%$8% 7
/47 %$%1.&/449! H%#$&#$@"$$ 8%#G?87
#
17 8:B8$?%DF#$#&%C#$$$#!%A 1P$/442! H$%!&"#%0?8! %$ "#%$ $ :6"#%$! 0 ""#$ $ 19 ?8 D$7 1 $7$09 F7
)$GB$%B#$%19?8!" HC#%# /,?:/44.D (124149F!% 8:%"$#!12C#:! %"$$$8$"&$$$ H$% % #8 G $ ?8 $$! ! % B$$$ % B#$%:@?87
/7 C&#&$ G B$7 09 7 1 $7 '7 / ! H O$ $ =%$$$"#:GB$709%C#%#"$8## % %$ % % 9 $H /444 D6"AE F $: $&&$ G C#%# B6:%$# % 1+ ? 1+0+ D6"AE F7)&"#$"?8%%B"A$#$H7
27 $ $# :8 1 ?: /442! $O$ % &H &%C$%%&%B6:%$#7%#G*8% #$#%2?/44.$C$%#$&$$%##"A 1?:/442!%$= $""H%B"A7
.7 #"#%C&$%#&"#"!"#$$:H! :$%$709 7
3/45.3/44. 6,3106
07 ) B$7 5 7 1 ! $ #"$# :%$# B"$# % 8 $$ "$=$"#&#"&$%8%#7)B$7.71 ! B:%$# "$ #$ %B C&$# 8#$! %B &% %B %$7
97 -%"#=?"%!$%B:%$#!% %$%!$$#&=$&#%R$ #= #&= H?$: % B"$# C$ =B &"$ %B#: D ( 114 /,0 %7 .R 140 /4, %7 /F7 =B %B$:$#%B#!%##&=C$%#C$!-% C% %# %B% &#%! % & Q "&$$$ %B#: "$# % $: % B$## % % $:$# H&$ @8HD (110122%7/R140105%71F7
! ""$ % #:$$# # D" @&" &%! *%$! *"$# % $:! *:%$#! *$$$ G *$#8$# "'-= &$F ""$*$$%C$%*%&#%7!"":#$H%$% *#G%"$$!*%&$$?8H%%&$= &#% %$ C7 *""#$ % %# &#% :J$ &"$%*$$"8%%$@$7?"%%"## $S' % &#%! " @&" % *#:$ % *:%$# % *$$$ G *$#8$#! % *@& % % $# $ $ *#:#&$%$$:%%&&8D (1//105%71H$ #C#R) !":%$%!E#8 *'%L6H$)'T"H'!S!/444!"7/95F7
*6:%$#! *$$ % C$ %*% &#% C% ""$ % &#% $$$ %$# G *CC ! @"$ % &#% %#"%$ % *$$$ %*! @& "$=# " $ %*H:$&#%%* D (1/21,0F!@"$"%$" "$ = @"$ &#% %# " ?8 % "&A % %A $ D) 1++,! "7 215 %7 2HR ! "#% %&$$: 6:%$#! $'A (H8 1+++! "7 1./F7 % *#:$ % *:%$#! $S' % &#% $ G "$ ?8&$ *#$$%$#$G%=%=&$"=$:$#*#$ "H%$:7 $!%#&#%$$$##&$$ "%#$&=$:@"$! H&$!@8%*# D (1/0/91%7.$#C#F7
,7 %$C#%#C@""$&A%B""#&- %":!""%H""#$%":B""=$&$A %"#%%&$$:7
3/45.3/44. 653106 ?8%$@&%&AH?$:$&-%":!==* $":!"%#%%&$G%"$"&$$$%"$ ?8&$ :H %$ $8@7 ) ""$ &#%@ $ $%$!"$=%*CC""#*&H%":$ %="=C%"&#%$ "$7 *$=*&"$!"C#":"H$G ""$ &#%! = "$ $8@ $ C$ *H?$ %* #$% $#! = ""$ C% % @& &"$! =* " #8&$%#$"$@"&#""@&#!=* $#$##$H"%*&A!=%"$%$@$ &#% $ *""#$ % $$ &#% $ $ C = % *@"$ $ %P&$ &$:#7 %&$! *##&$ %#$&$ " : "H$ *$ *8 % &- % ": %#8$ && ""$ && @"$! & H $ H $ D (1/0 20/ %7 2 $ #C#R ) /441 "7 145 %7 2F7 ""! %#:""# G "" % *6%$! $ ""H G *$$ % C$ %*% &#% % $$ H' %* D) !"7$7!"7/95F7
8 %*H:$ "C $ " C$ % &"#$ %# &#% @&$ A$&$ % = & *# $ G &J&%&$$:"$#%$:$%8&'#%$: D:! G "" % I % " *#:$ % *:%$# E *$$ % "H$# % 8 % " "#$%$ $! &"$6% %* # % 14 :&H 1+5+ # @ "HA& % *@"$ &#% $ "C! E 1++4 "7 0+ R U ! " %* *$:$# % $ %*H:$ "C % * V W! E 1+50 "7 /.9 F7 "$!=*""#$%* %:8H&$% % &#%%* $%BH:$&#%%B D F!&HG *%&$$!%!?8%C$%@""#$! H =#$ &"#&$ %*$$ % "$ % % D%7.72!"H#%X%-/44.32"79.!%*J$7%/.$H /442!20342F7
57 %B"A! B %#$&# "$# % $: H$ @:&$""$% %/5?:/44.7)$&% ""$! "$# "'-= % B# $ &"$H : $:$# &" $ "$=! ":#8$ "$ & "&$$$ %* '8! G " $&" $ : %&$ % 94N "A "#% % #$O&$! %$#&=&7
$ % ""$! $$ = $ $$$ % %&$ "'%94N%B#:$"C7 !%$"&A =Y! =B CC$$ % $:@ # "$ :
3/45.3/44. 6+3106 "H$#%B$"$!%&$#$#%09N%?#% 0'247 % %@A& =Y! % % $:@ %$=! %&$ &-$%%G.2N&-%9'!&#$$@"H ""8%&"@$#%$S'$C$8 C>8! %&$$$$94$54N&"%$B#$$"$? @"$H7&O$%#%"$$:$H#$!= %%&$$$&"%#$"C$H:"$=7)"% &$$! 8$ $&&$ % % &:&$ $ $&"%B""$887
=B B : 6%! 8 %*H:$ "C $ " C$ % &"#$ %# &#% $ % H$$ G 7 $$ ! %&%# G &#%6 % % ""#$ "$# % $: $ %&$ % $7 ""$ % /. ?: /44.! 6 " % &O$ % #%"$$"$#%$:$%&$7?$#=B$$$%% B#! = %$$ H" H8 $#$C! %:$ C &&$ -%& &H %$ #$$ '=&$ $$$7 " %B$:$# "'-=&$ % #$$ @ $ "$ 8H #$$ #:#"C$$"C7 "$#$'#= $" @"$ % "$ :&HH&$ J$ &## B# #$GO$&H$##$$"&=$C@H8 "H7
%*$$&!*&#$%"$#%$:#$$"H%&A $'#=! H = $$ *$ " " J$ &$ ?$C# " &#%7$=B$"%""$!%&$$!= "$$$#$#$%@&#" 7 #=! ""$ $ : O$ " C "H$ $ CC$ " " $$"$##%%$:%$7
B8$%%B@&$""$&#%@C8$%!$@ %&#%$$$$%"#$$#G%&%%%7
"&$&"!0&/442! !&#%$$$! %8$=# % &H8 '=! %"$' 26.! =B "%-%$ C&&$7 ) ! "$# % $: #$$ %" B#$#/44/$$=&>$B#$$%$##$$$$7"$$:$C$ %@ $$$: % " G $&" "$ = :$ #'#7 $:$# "$I$ ! : ' H $ $ BH % "$ % '8 $ $$C :8H! G %$ = B $ "$A&$ $$$C @ &:&$ %B$C@ &"$$ % $7 - :$ % C #:$ % $$ "$#7
3/45.3/44. 6143106 C%$ $&&$ B: % ! %8! = :$ %8$=# 14 ?$ /44/ %"$'C&&$"#26.:"#%B&"$$' $6"8 : % " % 2! # G %B&"$$ "'#&A C&&$ % " % 27 "$ % &%## 26. :$ #8&$ #$#& #:%!%&J&=%$A@C:%B &H#$$&%###$8#7
:$ #8&$ $# ! "#$'87)""$%%#&H/44/$?:/442 %&#%!:#%=#&8%"HA&%B#:$$% G B ' $"8 $ $ % " % 2 #$$ &"$ $ $$ G C$ # " ""$ @ $ " : M%A& $ #8&$ &"$$7 % : $ "#$! !C&#B@$%B:&'$6"8 :"H&$%#$C&&$$%BM%A&%$$ %?$7 ' #$$ H $$# : % &&$ @ = $$$H$##&$":$H##C%B%'8% $@$ =7 C$ B $ G $$ % $$&$ % "'-$'#"$B-:$"%&&%"$%B$7
A&%B$H/442! &%C#"$%: $ %=# = "$# % $: % "$$ B#$$ "#?#E 6 "#$$%#&"$#$$%$$$:$#7 ?/44.! &#% $$$ = "$$ CC$ %B &% -$#&= C&&$ %B8 7 #8&$ C$ &$ %* "H :$$%=#=%#C$C$$$&$'$ %@ #" C$ % %8# % BC&&$7 C&# "##%$""#$!CC&$G:=B#":$@ $:7
$%"$H%#C#:/449! 8# =*":$"""##&$"$##%%$:7 "%$ # G *# % $% "$ % '8 $ %B#:$ "$ "$6G6C@ $ #& *: =* "$$ $:$# $$ " #8%$&H$H:!":CC&=$ "$$:?#$A7 !#$O&$$:$ ="##" "$H#:$$#!&&#% %##=*$Z""$=$$%#&'%"#'Z7 "## = BCC$ % %= %$ CC$ $#$$#:A$=BB8$"%B'=!" =:$&% !"#$%"HA& %7
3/45.3/44. 6113106 $%="#A%!%$$$=%#&#%!$" "$A&$ #&$ % "#$ $# " &#% $$$ % B#! &A$ G = % %" %B "$# #% % $: % "$ %"$#7 &#% *$ :' " #:"##&$$$"$#7%$!*$ %"#%G @& "$= "&$$$ % %#$& : " % "# $@ % "$# % $: %B #7 B@& CC$# " $&&$#"=#%"$$%B#&H"O$ @#$H7 )*8$ % ! ( %* ""# =B B8$ %* $$$%$C$$"##&$%&"#$%#&#% @&$A$&$%=&*#$G&J&%&$$: "$#%$:$%8&'#%$:D ( "H#%/4 "$&H/44.//434.!%7.7/R ( "H#%/.$H /44220342F7
*"A!GB%@&! $="$#"'-= %B##$$&"$H:$:$#&"$"$=!":#8$ "$&"&$$$%*'8!G"$&"$:%&$% 94N "A "#% % #$O&$! % $ #&= &7 )B8$%"$#%B%"$$$%B""$8!?8#&"$H :&"&"$"$=%$#&=&7"## =*#:$"$$%"&$$$%:&$"$= $"7 ! $"$##%%$: %94N6$%&$%94N"$&"6%&""$=! #8! "&$$$ %B$ "$7 $$ %*@&"! $# $:@ G B#$H!&"%%$&$#8%B%6&$ "$%'87
% %$! %* %=# = $@ % "$#%$:#%$" "$:&HH7A ! % & Q *""#$ % ""O$ 8H&$ @$ $ CC&&$"'%% ="$# % $: #% % B#! =B $ &$:# $ $$ G C$ :$! *@$&$C%*#$7
"""=&'#%$:CC8#:$%*$:$# &" $ #"#$$: % $ % "%$ $ % :! "& = C8 &H 8C$C %*&" :$ $7 $ @ $:$# $ " ! $ %## " &#%7 B$ % G ?$ $$ = B $ &"$ %B "$# #%%$:$A:%&$%,0NC%BCC$% $@%B:%$#%$7$G:#CCC$#7
3/45.3/44. 61/3106 +7 #:$@%B:%$#!:=B#$"H$BB#$$ ":%$&"#:=B"$H$@>$B$:$#= "$ H&$ J$ @8# % "A $$&$ $ & % #%"$$!&'#%$:#=H#D$719 F7
*$%$ % D$ % *$7 19 "$F * " ""$# % &%C$ @ $ %*"$# % $:! %*"$# % 8! %*:%$#! % &#$'% % &" % : $ =* $ #$# %#:""# " ?"% *&" % *$7 /5 7 / D ( 124 2.2R ( "H#%/5%#&H/44./+434.F
)$ %#$&$ " "#% G $ &" $ = "#:$&&$%#:$%%$G$!= &%C$#:$:?=*&&$%%#$8= $%#=%$G$$"$$D (1/+///%7.R1/5 1,.%7.R ( "H#%/.?:/440540342F7
#=!G$%?"%"#$#!B#%#$&$" &"B#/442!$#"A%#H$%B"$#% $:%#C$:%B#7
147 B###%$%A#%$:&"A$D/441F% 9.*,./C7#$#"H%B%%&@"$#8 % $: D'&& :R /441 [ /B4./! /442 [ /B144F :%$#/442#$$%99B051C7D9.B,./@/1443/4./F7
$:%*:%!%$!?"%!J$#:#:$$$ C$ % $$ "C A$ % *$##7 *H %* :CC$:&$##6$=*#!"A:%*$$$ G $#! * " " %*$:$# $:$# %"$#! &&$ @8H 6! : %*:% %$ J$ #:# H % $$$= &-DC7 (1/9,9F7#CAG$$$=% H$ $%%#! C%$ $? &#% : $ D (1/.2/2R) 1+++"715/F7!?"%%A= $&"J'&$""G"%*:%@8$=*#% &$$%$$%$$$=7 $C!%$%#%$ %:$ " J$ CC$# % &A '#&$=! & $ &"$ % *&H%$%"$!$%H$%%#$&!G "$%%#$$$=!:%*:%="#$&@& :#&=@8H%$:$#&"$H:"$#%$: #% % *$##7 %#%$ %$ " J$ "## $&$=&$! & &$ =* @$ % % =* %* % " C$! *# "$ &$$ : "$# #% % $: &'# % $: =*: #$$ #&= C# G &-7
3/45.3/44. 6123106 ! *- " % "#% G % %#%$ %$$ " ' % C$$$%#$&&&$$#'%"!*S8! #%:!$$#$#8 %"&%#?! $@ %*"$7 C$ H "$I$ "#% G #:$ 8H! % &$%":%*""#$!%CC$%C$:%*:%! &"$ $ % *&H % $ % $7 C! "$ "#%G%#%$8H"#G/0N7 *%&$$%$&$: HA:&$ %#%$ "##7 $ ?8! "$! &$C "$$! H$$""#$G%*%&$$D (1/9,0R)/44/"7,4F7
*! &"$ $ % B$:$# #8A % H$$$! $$$=%#C#$=":$"#$%'&&CC$$ % $:$# &" $ #"#$$: % %$ &C$A /44/! G :.*544C7"&D =J$$$%/44/!$H 1R \ 1062,! : % =C$ .F7 && H$ $%%# $$ &"$ %* ' % $: % =$ '! $ %# 'H%&%C#G&-%$"D.1!,' /44/R #&=! 116/44.! "7 59F! &$$ %$ J$ "$# G 0B44. C7 D.544@ .1!, 3 .4F! = %$ G % 94*4.5 C7 %"$# G %&$%94N$=B#$#$%%%"#$"#%! : :%$# $ #:# G 29B4/+ C7 D94B4.5 @ 479F /44/ $ G 29*02+C7/4427
%#%$ G ""$ G &$$ "$ J$ C@# #C#$ G ?"%% HC#%#%7 !%%B" C&$ "C! B-$ " @# %B$:$# %" " # $ CC$ % %: $$$ G $# D&"$$ %#%$&$ &$%6:!$H%&"$&$!"$#H%! $H%%$% ''F!H$$&$ %14N #$#$D ( "H#%5?$/442+342F7
C!%J$%/2$H/444D ( "H#1,,344F! HC#%#%=#=BB-:$"%$H$$&$%14N %&$$G%$:$##8A%%%$:$#&" $ #"#$$: = :$ $ % "%$ $ % :! 8% % 8 #:$ %*$:$# ""# " $$ $#8! %$ : =* &H 8C$C %B$ $ #8A $ "&$$$ *$ % "$ $ $ % %"$# '%" % # = ":$ " CC$%$:@%$%:$#:$"$$$="8#7
B"A!#%$""#&$%14N%%&$$"B &H " $$H! H = %&$ % 94N C@# " $ "##&$"H$%$&"$%&$$"#$#"B#7 $$#$$
3/45.3/44. 61.3106 %!#%$"#G14N$J$%&!%$=B#$ :%*:%%2/B550C7
)B&"&$$:::%$#!H$$%8#%B:%$# %04!9N!%$=%#%B "J$"CG$=7
C!$=*:%$#%$B$&%C#%&AGC %$G$!$H%*"#:%%%*%&%%#:G B%"#$"#%7
117 %$%J$?$#7
3/45.3/44. 6103106 # / " # " " # "
%
012 3 4 56 7-' "$8
2
17 #:H7
% 2
/7 ?$$7
27 $="#%$8$$7
.7 C& "$ % =B ":$ C& $ "#$ J$ % %# % 24 ? %A $C$ " " &&%# %# H C#%# % ! )']Y'C= 9! 944. ! $ @&"7 %# "$ J$ "8#7 &#& %$E F %= @$&$=%#$%#H$$"%%# $$=#R HF @" " = &$C $& ": %&% $$ $ %#R F "$ 8$ % "#$$7 ) &#& $$ " $ ##&$ #&## $$ F HF $ F 6%! HC#%#%""$&$A=B %:%#:H7&#&%&$&- % ":! = $ ?$! = %# $$=# $ B:"" % =#$#@"#%#$D$712/!149$145F7 8CCAE #%$ (( U) U #$6?$E L
"C&%"#$J$$$C#@"$=BGBCCC#%# %"8CC
3/45.3/44.