Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/316/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/316/2005 Generato dall'IA

Defective Service Cured by Subsequent Proper Service

Numero d'incarto ATAS/316/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Spese processuali a carico dell'autorità / Stato
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The reviewing body considered whether a ruling regarding the application of a procedural rule concerning the service of process was correct, where the service was initially deemed defective due to an incorrect address but was later cured by a subsequent proper service. The court reasoned that the initial defective service, absent any detrimental reliance by the opposing party or prejudice to their defense, did not automatically void the jurisdiction obtained by the later, proper service, as the purpose of the rule is to ensure notice, which was ultimately achieved.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Defective Service Cured by Subsequent Proper Service: The court reasoned that the initial defective service, absent any detrimental reliance by the opposing party or prejudice to their defense, did not automatically void the jurisdiction obtained by the later, proper service, as the purpose of the rule is to ensure notice, which was ultimately achieved.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
notificazione di atti norme di procedura sanatoria del vizio procedurale organi di ricorso garanzia per i difetti della cosa obbligo di controllo

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the final orders regarding the imposition of court costs.
Generato dall'IA
A/3669/2012
Enforcement Proceedings Defect and Subsequent Rectification
A/3882/2005
Defective Service of Process Invalidates Enforcement Order
A/3709/2007
Service of Process Interpretation and Precedent in Appeal
A/2668/2016
Defective Service of Payment Order Validated by Subsequent Action
A/1576/2021
Defective Service of Summons Cured by Subsequent Knowledge of Seizure

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final orders regarding the imposition of court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

 

              



       

   !"  # $% 

 !"

&! ''''''''''#$%!&$'()*"+")%&,",&$%%"  '(-" ./ #*&)#

") ,"$," (!

&()*$" ''''''''''+ 

&)("

,     -   .     ,-+ 0& "*(, ," +(&"!  1 2(%0& (3#  ")   ,      /     0  1&+ '// 4"5%)) !!&%)"! 6# *" " ,& (, 0&%!1" .7)"# 

       

 

 ")

   ,     - & ,+="," (! + 2&,)%&,"%0("'!!3"8$"'%%"(#9"(,$ "."'): 1;<(%./

$23)4 5 & *%% "($*+  2*$!)4+ &* ( $* 6- 4 7 $) 7+ 8"3*9

      > 

 ,



/ ( ? 3"$") ,  @ !"')"$0(" >#  8$" .$0(" ,  (%0  ," '("$%8(" %!)"  '(&&+ " ,%*&(" ," -,$" AAAAAAAAAA ") -&!%" ( AAAAAAAAAA#$(%+!",)", *(%B/

/ 6"&".%==(", ? 3"$")'(+%)+#"(%0 ,"'("$%8("%!)"&(,&+ " '()3" '( $&%)%+ ,"! *&%(! ," '(+*&C" '(&="!!%&"" D %! '( " ,"$," (, ()"$(%3"#,"$,"("!!"EC)'!&)%!+1'(+*&C" '(&="!!%&"""(%!&,"!&=%0"("*" /

>/ " ? 3"$") ," ,%*&(" "!) ,"*"  ,+=%%)%= " "( &*"$0(" ># ")  +)+ &$$ %D + (%0 ,"+!",)", >$% /

/ " (%0  ," +!  !&%%)+ ,  ,"$," ( " &$ ," !& %!)%) )%& ," '(+*&C"#'('%, $% #"*%#' %!E%=&($+,"!&!+D ""! '&!!%0"!,"!&%)%&#!& !$"","E()/, &,"'+! %!!"#'( '%,  !"')"$0(" #)& ?& (!"*%/

F/ (%!&, !%"", ,"$," (#'& ())?&%)'("!"*&%!, (%0 #" ,"(%"(,G")("'(",(","$ )%'"!,+$(."! H=%!,E+)0%("$&))," '("!))%&1'()3"(#")(""*(%B")""(&*"$0(">/

E"!) %!% D " " (%0  !E"!) ,("!!+ ! "!!%*"$") 1      -  # "  ? %  # 1  66  6  - 6 "   !"')"$0("  # 1 E")("'(%!"  I2E6 6 "!  &)&0("   ") > ?*%"( F# 1  2 8$"   66 "! F &*"$0(" ")  ,+"$0("   %!% D " " @ =+*(%"( F# 1 E")("'(%!"  2 6  6 " > =+*(%"( F# "=% 1  2    66       2  # " @ =+*(%"( F/

B/  ("!!&(),"!%*"!)%3)%&!, (%0 D " '("!))%&1'()3"(!" $&)"1 @J>BK =(/  !"& & ((%"( ,"  2    66    2  , $(!F# HD "!!E?& )"" $&)),"=(/B"$%!,"28$"   66#!"& ))"!))%&, @=+*(%"(FL==%%)%&,"' %!"$&%!,"!"')"$0(">M#!&%) "$&)),"@JF@@=(/@/

K/ "! ,& $")! &) +)+ )(!$%!  H '()%"! " ,)" ,   $(! F/  ? (%,%)%&" (%,%D +D J1,+= ),J&0!"(*)%&!,J%% K*(%F# ((N) !"(%)(", ! ("))"0!"/

        

@/ ('%, "(*(%F#"(%0 "&("!&%%)+,","$,"("!!"D E"" & *(" &$')","'(+*&C"")"&$$ %D ""!&&(,&+"!#"D E"" =%)'('%,  *(%F/"'(+%!+E*&%('!,"("$(D "!#.&($%!"=%) D E"" *%) .3+ ," '(+&$# !"&  )&(%!)%& ,   $(!  # ,"*") %!%AAAAAAAAAA/

/ '(8! )(!$%!!%& ," "! ,& $")!   ,"$," ( '( '% ,  K *(% F#   !"+)+3(,+"1? 3"(/

 



/ J()/ F ,"  &% =+,+(" ! ( " %0(" '!!3" ,!  '(+*&C" '(&="!!%&""#*%"%"!!"#! (*%*)!")%*%,%)+, K,+"$0(">L2 M# ")(+"*%3 " (""(?*%"(#(83"'(&+, (""!,",%*&("/&(!D " "!&?&%)!"!&)'!,E&(,! ('("!))%&,"!&()%"1'()3"(L()/") >&,"%*%M#"? 3", %" , ,%*&("&$'+)") !"!,"J()/K>/ ,"&%=+,+("! ('(+*&C"'(&="!!%&"", F? %@L M#!&%)1 "8*""(%0 )&,"!!! ("!!&%"!,"' %!""(&G)>#,&%)# '(8!D "J==%(" %+)+)(!$%!"L()/ M#"H+ )"(,J&==%""'()3"! ( 0!","+,"(+'()%)%&,+)"($%+"'("? 3", ,%*&(".

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

>/  E"!'8"# " ? 3" ," '("$%8(" %!)"  &(,&+ " '()3" '( $&%)%+ ,"! *&%(!,"'(+*&C"'(&="!!%&""D %!'(","$," (, ()"$(%3"#  ,"$,"("!!" EC) '! &)%!+ 1  '(+*&C" '(&="!!%&""/ "! ,)"! '"()%")"!!&)#,E "'()#"", $(%3"#"*(%B#,E )("'()""( &*"$0(">#,)"1D """? 3"$"),",%*&(""!),"*" "H+ )&%("/

      F 

6"& "! ,& $")! '(&, %)!#  '("!))%& 1 '()3"( !" $&)" 1 @JF@@ =(/ @# !&%) @J>BK =(/   '(8! ,"  2    66       2   ")  =(/ B  '(8! ,"  2 8$"   66# "! %)+(N)! C) ,+?1 +)+  +! '( "! %!)%) )%&! ," '(+*&C" ,+=","("!!"!/ %!% " ,"$," ( ,&%) 1 !& "H +'& !""$&))," JK =(/ =(/

/ &=&($+$") 1  ? (%!'( ,""# ,"' %! " ?& ( ,+)"($%) '& ( " '()3" ? !D J  $&$") ,  )(!="() ,"  '("!))%& ," !&()%" &  ,"  ,"$" ("# " &?&%) ,%*&(+ 0++=%%%(" ," "))" '("!))%&  ,(&%) 1 ,"! %)+(N)! &$'"!)&%("! ! ( " $&)) ," ""%/ "! %)+(N)! !&)  +!   ) H $%%$ $ +3 !"& J()/  ," J&(,&" ! (  '(+*&C" '(&="!!%&"" *%"%"!!"# ! (*%*)! ") %*%,%)+ ,  @ *(% @  L  M &  !"& " ) H (+3"$")%("# !% " %% "!) ! '+(%" ( L2 & ' 0%+  >B ,  @ ? %") >M

F/ "D %&"(""!=(%!,",+'"!," !"#E()/K>/ '(+%!"D " "!)&!,&%*")'(+*&%( "'(&+, ("!%$'"#('%,"")#"'(%%'"#3() %)"/ E()/ @4 /  ,"  &% ! (  '(&+, (" ,$%%!)()%*" ,   !"')"$0(" @F L M'(+*&%)D )1 %D "'(&+, (""!)3() %)"'& ("!'()%"!/& )"=&%!# "!,+0& (!") +$& $")'" *")N)("$%!1.(3","'()%"D %3%)," $%8(")+$+(%("& )+$&%3","+38(")+/"==")#%!%D ""(%0 =+,+( ,"! !! ("! E ,$%!#  '&!!%0%%)+ ," %$%)"(  3() %)+ " ! ," ("& (! )+$+(%("& %)"(?")+1+38(""!) '(%%'"3++(,"'(&+, ("'(+* '& ( )& )"!"!0(."!,"!!! ("!!&%"!L2BF&!%,/ 0M/

"(%0 =+,+(,"!!! ("!+3"$")(''"+D E%C%" ,"=%(" " ,%==+("" ")("# ,E " '()#  !)%& &!)%) +" '(  $%!" ,"! =(%! ," '(&+, ("1.(3",E "'()%"D %3%)'(+38(")+& ,"$%8(")+$+(%("  !"!,"E()/@F/")/,"&%=+,+("! (E!! ("*%"%"!!"")! (*%*)! L6M L) ""$") ()/ B ")/  ,"  &% =+,+(" ! (  '()%" 3++(" ,"! !! ("!!&%"![ #"*%3 " (,"' %!""(?*%"(>]")#,E )("'()# " ,(&%) H,+'"!!"&E()/@F/")/= 6[) ""$")()/ B")/3  ]#,(&%)D %!E''(+%"!"&"!(%)8("!,+*"&''+! ! ?"),"E&)%& ,",+'"!1 "'()%"3%!!)!!$,)%("L ()%D "6'/BM/

" (%0  ," +! &!%,8(" D "# !% E&)(&% ," ,+'"! " !" ? !)%=%" '! " E"!'8"# E))%) ," ,  ,"$," ( ? !)%=%" " ("*." D E% !&%) &,$+   '%"$") ,E  +$& $")/ 6 '!!%*%)+# !& $D " ," &0&()%&# &) &)(%) " (%0  1 ," &$0(" !"! ,+$(."! D % " !!") +)+ +*%)+"! !% " ,"$," ( !E+)%) &=&($+ 1 !& &0%3)%& ," ("!"%3"(# ,&)  *%&)%& "!) ' %!!0",E%" (!,"!((N)!& ,"E$","!"&E()/KF /E+$& $") !"(=%H+"E& ((""1J=(/

      B 

   & , +         5

44")4

:();( 2)4 < % !$*=(*$4$() 4 )*$4($  ! %1 49  >?

 2%%)4 5

(,&"  (")%=%)%& ,"  D %)+ ,"  ,"$,"("!!" D % ,"*%") -,$" AAAAAAAAAA/

% ;$4 5

/ *%)"28$"   661)(!=+("(#, &$')","-&!%" ( AAAAAAAAAA#  !&$$" ,"  =(/ @     6 66 2    66-  "=*" (,"-,$"AAAAAAAAAA#&$')" AAAAAAAAA/

/ *%)"2  66  2  1)(!=+("(#, &$')","-&!%" (AAAAAAAAAA#!&$$" ," JB@> =(/ B =(/     6 66 2    66 -  "=*" (,"-,$"AAAAAAAAAA#&$')"AAAAA/

>/ "!%*%)"1*"(!"(#"' !,""$&))#,"!%)+(N)!&$'"!)&%("! !"!,"! &!%,+()!#,8!""(&*"$0(">? !D J $&$"), )(!="()/

/ "!C&,$""))D ","0"!&%/

F/ &,$"-&!%" (AAAAAAAAAA '%"$"),E +$& $"),"E=(/

B/ =&($" "! '()%"! ," " D J""! '" *") =&($"( ("& (! &)(" " '(+!") ((N) ,!  ,+% ," > ?& (! ,8! ! &)%=%)%& '( '% ("&$$,+ ,("!!+   (%0  =+,+( ,"! !! ("!# 6.5"%:"(.&=D % B# B    # " )(&%! "H"$'%("!/ " ,+% " '" ) N)(" '(&&3+/ " $+$&%(" ,&%) P M %,%D "( "H)"$") D "" ,+%!%& " ("& () ,+!%(" &0)"%( " %"  ") '" ,"  ,+%!%&))D +"O0M"H'&!"('& (D "!$&)%=!%"!)%$"'& *&%(,"$,"("))"  )(",+%!%&OM'&()"(!!%3) ("& "","!&("'(+!"))/6%"$+$&%("





      K 

" &)%") '! "! )(&%! ++$")! + $+(+! !& ! "))("! M 0M ") M %,"!! !# " (%0 =+,+(,"!!! ("!"'& (('!")("("$)%8("! ("("& (!D J% ,"*(,+("(%((""*0"/"$+$&%(","("& (!$")%&"("&(""!$&C"! ," '(" *"# D % !"(&) ?&%)!# %!% D "  ,+%!%& ))D +" ") J"*"&''" ,! D """"+)+"H'+,%+" ("& ()L()/>#B")@M/

    (+!%,")"P "3("==%"(P   !0"" 0&%! %"((" %"!               

"&'%"&=&($", '(+!")((N)"!)&)%=%+" H'()%"!%!%D E1E==%"=+,+( ,"!!! ("!!&%"!'("3("==""