Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/306/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/306/2007 Generato dall'IA

Waiver of Right to Arbitration Through Litigation Conduct

Numero d'incarto ATAS/306/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party appealed a ruling affirming the denial of their motion to compel arbitration, arguing that the opposing party had waived their right to arbitrate by actively participating in litigation, including filing motions and engaging in extensive discovery over a significant period without asserting the arbitration clause. The court affirmed the denial, reasoning that the lower court did not abuse its discretion by finding that the appealing party's extensive and deliberate participation in litigation constituted a clear waiver of the right to arbitrate, as this conduct was inconsistent with an intent to rely on the arbitration agreement and prejudiced the opposing party.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Waiver of Right to Arbitration Through Litigation Conduct: The court affirmed the denial, reasoning that the lower court did not abuse its discretion by finding that the appealing party's extensive and deliberate participation in litigation constituted a clear waiver of the right to arbitrate, as this conduct was inconsistent with an intent to rely on the arbitration agreement and prejudiced the opposing party.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
arbitrato rinuncia al diritto compromettibilità autorizzazione ad agire decisione incidentale impugnabile preclusione per tolleranza

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to impose the costs of the federal court proceedings on the appellant.
Generato dall'IA
A/1319/2004
Waiver of Arbitration by Litigation Conduct
A/1925/2004
Waiver of Arbitration Through Litigation
A/1792/2002
Waiver of Arbitration Right by Litigation Conduct
A/1257/2007
Waiver of Arbitration Through Litigation Participation
A/1949/2003
Enforcement of Unconfirmed Arbitration Award and Waiver of Procedural Objections

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to impose the costs of the federal court proceedings on the appellant.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



               #$%&'#'(() !#*()#'((&

!

+ !"+ ,!   +,  ,"

,-./  0  '( .  '((&         !"""# $  % &!&'    !'&      % ()  (  ( #*"!(" "'"# ! "&"+&,  (  

            !" 

   %0-.%  

  1 2 3& #""!  0 !'!4& 0112   ((    $     5"%3&6"7&##8&4!&' !09:,2;&<=1 &3&#''""'#>&#8'!&'!'";?% "9&"'3#&#*""'&#""&@

A2!>4&01129&##3!#&"3&6"  #*'>!"&#'#4!;!"@

3&#""!0,!>4&0112 "&;#9'&&'"6&&"'  !"#&'?9#'"''&">@

 9&#  ""  &"4 ""'&'";  '!    , #4& 0112 !  ""'"!  >!"  &!& ;"*&'   #""! ''?#@ ?9  !3&33!&?&"!&"&"''&"> 3"?" >"'B3&#'3&#"##""!?''>"'C'&3&#'#3& #&"' 8  " :1 D!&  3 '& 8 !3'&  9'&#  ;!&   #""!  &'"''"!@

&#3!A=#4&0112 "!&D'&!&@

3&&&C'01;#>&"&011,  &"4""'&'";'!#"# !3#'!;!&#'89&'<E=<:!";##&&3&'"*##& &!"'  & !"  2 !'!4& 0111 5 7  "  &'"! >  &'<A11 < :  !" ;##& & F&%+G* !4"*'!"& ' F""'#   F"!>4""'#  0E D" A/=0 5 7  AA/ ' A0=  9&! & F&% +G*5 7''&" &"4#@

  !&&"&  A= #4& 0112  #'# '&" 8 9&# '   *&# 8 D*&@



,      2  !" *>!" & F!&*"'"! D"""& 57  #'# !";"#'"'"'# 6A&!H'011:  &"4'!&!"  !3!#  E D*  !'  3&#"' '  >"%3&#"'  E 33#' ' A2 D* &5&'<A'<&'E2 7!";##&&3&'"*##&&!"' &!"2!'!4&01115 7

"'8F'"!F#'"!A2D*& 3& &"4;##& 0,D>"&011.5 IA:1A127 & !"*>!"!3'# A:;#>&"&  "3!"'"!'&"'!"&&*'3&''' &"4'!&!"  "#*&  & 8 '&!" D* '"'"&     F'''  F#'"!  !>BD*&@



-./,0-0112  %:-.%    !;!&#' 8 9&'< E2  < A '<  +< =    &"4 '!  & !" !J'  "' "?  !'''"! 3&#> 8 F&'< E2  ?"!'&'">8 @

!3#'3!&D*&F36'""#'4"@

 3&#""!0!'!4&0112 "&##89&#&4!&' 3&''"!>&# 8 '!&'@?9"""?#?  &4!&' 3!>"';"& 9!4D'9&"'!'!3&'"@?&">"'"C'&3&#'# 3&#&"':1D!&3'&8!3'&9'&#;!&#""!&'"''"!@

9 ;;'  ! 9&'< 0E    3&''"! "H' '!+# !">' C'& &'"'#@ ?  &# 3>' '!';!" &  &"  9!4"*'"!  &'"'&!&?&'"''"!3&''"!!#"H' "&K4! ;!"  ''&"'   "''"! ";;""@ ?   !"' C'& #&"'  !'">#  !3*#  3"6 #"& ' C'& #3!# 3&6  9'!&"'# '! !3#''  3 '& :1 D!& 8 !3'&  9'&#  ;!&   #""!  &'"''"!5&'<.<. 7@

9936 #""!&'"''"!''&#;!&3'G'A&!>4& 0112 ;'9!33!"'"!;!&##"#*:1D!&5&'<E0 7@

9&##3!#&"A2!>4&0112@

 ;!& '  !''& ?9  #3!#     #"  :1 D!& 8 !3'&9'&#;!&#""!&'"''"!@?96!&*"'3 '"@

9"D'";"!#?9''&&!&'&>!L&8" ;" ? %" '&  '"6& &    &" ' !'";"  !> #""!89&#@







-./,0-0112  %.-.%    ,  !"3  !"+ ,!   +,  ,"



45 1 .. 6  7        8 9 0)'  :

  1 .

A< #&&!&&>4<

 1 

0< 9''#""!0,!>4&0112<

:< >!"8"3!&!>#""!<

.< "'?3&!#&'*&'"'<

E< ;!&  3&'"   ?F 3>' ;!&& &!& !'&  3&#' &&C'   #"  :1 D!& 6  !'";"'"! 3&6  &"4 ;##& 5(+M"N&+!;?"2 211.  7 3&>!"&!&'"6&&!"' 34" !;!&#'B&'<=0!";##&& &"4;##&A, D" 011E 5 I7@  #!"&  &!& !"' ""?&  !"!  !'"; ' !L3&>'3!&'&"*'&&!&'!!'"&@"!"' C'& &#  &"4 ;##& 3& >!" 3!' ! 3& >!" #'&!"? B !"'"!  9&'< .0  I<  3&#' &&C' '  3"6  3!"!  &!&' ">!?#!!L3&> !">'C'&D!"'89>!"<  *&;;"6&  &#"'P     &"%!"  O !&"Q   

 !3"!;!& 3&#' &&C''!'";"#B3&'"'(&#'&"'F ''8 F#!!"3&*&;;



-./,0-0112