Admissibility of Evidence Regarding Undisclosed Former Representative and Prior Settlement to Impeach Credibility
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged a lower court's decision to admit evidence related to an undisclosed former representative, arguing the trial court erred by permitting testimony that referenced a prior settlement agreement with that representative, which they claimed was irrelevant and prejudicial. The court reasoned that while the specific dollar amount of the settlement was properly excluded, the fact of the prior relationship and settlement was relevant to challenge the credibility and bias of a testifying witness who had previously dealt with that representative, and thus its limited probative value outweighed any prejudicial effect, supporting the trial court's discretionary decision to admit testimony concerning the existence of the past relationship.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Admissibility of Evidence Regarding Undisclosed Former Representative and Prior Settlement to Impeach Credibility: The court reasoned that while the specific dollar amount of the settlement was properly excluded, the fact of the prior relationship and settlement was relevant to challenge the credibility and bias of a testifying witness who had previously dealt with that representative, and thus its limited probative value outweighed any prejudicial effect, supporting the trial court's discretionary decision to admit testimony concerning the existence of the past relationship.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to order the losing party to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%$&#'%%( )#*%'#'%%&
"")
)" + ) " + +
+, $ '' '%%&
! "
!"
## $ %% & 0"01 '!()&*!"+,-&.,.. ./
)) -)
!"
5,2/5 * ! 0 ,( !"!6 ,33-& 70 06 1810! " ! 100! 79$0$0""0! !"" 8:
$ 9!0" "0;0" 10 *!0007 10 <=*0"> 0? 0"0 @? ,) !"!6 ,33-& """" 7 *0"1 " ?0 " . !?6 ,. !?6 ,33-& 0! $ A!*0"0"0! ?010!"0 :
* ! 0 % /. !"!6 ,33-& B ;; 06 1 0;! 1 $ 17$>" !0& ! ?0"!"0 !0!&>*!1 0";0"!!"0;0?!71&"7$!*0100!0"0B0?0" C" 9!0":
$10.+!?6 ,33-1"10* "0D$0"1 1*! $'!;! &! *0$0 ?600"1:
! 0 %&! "0 1&1"1 "! 1B ;; 06:
* ! 0 ,16 ,33-&B ;;! 1D$0"1 1 0 10 .-16 ,33-:
$0"1 1$"*0;"1:
+ " ) ")
!;! 1" D $ "E -4 & 06 "! !0 !F"&0"07&!"""0!* 1?D$ "E-4!0;11 * "0B11 !0" !0G H4!"!6 ,333 "0?D !0;11 $ 50?00"1.(90.(-(5 :
!*1"*! 9B I*@"001"60:
$>" $ "EJ("E6H"H!0 * !1 00" "0?., *"6 .(J-G H&! ! !0"!*! " >*!10" ;0"!!"0;0?!71007!0!:
&1A1"&100!""71"*0@0?!71!"9!0":
!;! 1"D$ "EJ(E/ & 060* "0D$0"1 110 .+ !?6 ,33-& *0 .- 16 ,33- *! !;! > @B "0!1&!*0$0 ?600"1:
$0"1 1$"*0;"1:
2+3+42,33- 5/2/5
" + )- )" + ) " + +
./0 1 2 34 5&' 6
.E 1 ! 0 ?6E
,E ;! * "0 7I *?" ;! ! !" * 1" C" 10 /3 9! @ !"0;0"0! * *0 !1 1 06 ;11 & %AK0L A!;70 4& 433+ & " !0 >*0 E 10 *" C" * !!B1E 1!0 !0"M H 007 >""7100! ! "10 !6"0 0"*100! ""71: 6H >*! *! 7 !"0; 0 "0 *!?!0 "" " 100!: H *! " 0B" ! ! * 1""E %0 1!0 !"0" * " !0 11" 11 1 ! "" H 6H " H 05& 06;11 *! *" "0@ ! 7I0 ? 1 0 ?6E1!0 ! "0! ! !' * ?& 70 !" 9!0"& 00 7 100! ""71 " I?! 71"1>*101 ! "G "E./,&.34".3JHE B ;;0 * 10" N0 0
!*0!;! * 1" C""!"0;01>* "0007IDI;;0;11 !0* B ;;
2+3+42,33-