Statutory Amendment Retroactivity in Discovery Non-Compliance Penalty
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed whether a statutory amendment, which expanded the scope of an existing penalty for failing to comply with discovery production requests, could be applied retroactively to a failure occurring before the amendment's effective date. The court reasoned that the relevant statute established a penalty for non-compliance, and the amendment merely clarified or confirmed the existing scope of that penalty, thus indicating that the legislature intended for the amended provision to apply to the pre-amendment conduct, supporting its retroactive application in this case.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 106 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Amendment Retroactivity in Discovery Non-Compliance Penalty: The court reasoned that the relevant statute established a penalty for non-compliance, and the amendment merely clarified or confirmed the existing scope of that penalty, thus indicating that the legislature intended for the amended provision to apply to the pre-amendment conduct, supporting its retroactive application in this case.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive section (order 2) for the legal costs calculation in relation to the complexity of the case.
Cited in the dispositive section (order 1) to grant the request for legal aid.
Cited in the dispositive section (order 3) regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!!"# #$$% & #'% #$$(
&
& ) )&) )
*+ # #$ + #$$(
! 5$5# "#$%&'#( )* '+,!-$#./0122!344+
$#5
6666666666 !-(7$6666666666 !8+40 #%9:
*+72* , -;..%%#%$<=6666666666 >%*-5&<:.<5?-5& < >%*-5& <9<5? @ ..# 85 A@%5 +443! -$5 -5:@$" -5$.%$ $)%'#$%5 < 5%: < <:.<5 $9% B =5 $)%'#$%5C
<:$9-#<-5%9<5:B<:.<5C
5:%%#%$ < $#5# -5 <9<5! 5%$ < $*-%9# < -5%9!-$5089%+442C
-$5%#%#5$<%#!#$99<9#<-"5D4288EF,4 $#%.%: B<:.<5-$59$##<80=1,F.5(04!@%#:5G#B2!+2H<& 2.:@5%5+442!,1.5(F2B#%#5<=%#:5G#-$59$%<A@%5+442!#244.5(B #%#5<.5%<'#%$!<#<3@5%+442C
;$--$%#%$$99<9#<-"5C
##< I +1 95 +44,! <9<5 %% 5%) #$ < 5 $% <= <9< 5$% < <5$%#! I% :5# J-5:9#=$--$%#%$C
$%$B$<9#%$<<:.<5-%9#<80=1,F .5(04!@%#:5G#B2!+2H<&2.:@5%5+442!,1.5(F2B#%#5<=%#:5G#-$5 9$%<A@%5+442!#244.5(B#%#5<.5%<'#%$!#9%@:< ;$--$%#%$C
<9< <=:/$9# < <## -5 <9<5! =:/' <=:5%#5I%=#%@%#!.%9#!-5$55%5<F<:9)5+44,! 5.<<9<5<=:/$9#-5$-$:C
<9<< 5%)<+4<:9)5+44,5:9#-%&B=--%< <9<!#-5$<#%$<-%&81A@%5+44FC
<:% .%J: -5 5%) B <:.<5 -$5 5:-$<5 +F .:@5%5 +44F!-5-%<8EA@%5+44,C
;)<5:-$<*%C
##<I:#:'5<:BA'5B=%<<:%(
. . I$.$59:9#B=5#(2,(8#()! 5%) #$ < 5 $% $K# %# %I < $###%$ 5#%@ B -5:@$" -5$.%$ $--$# %#%##%$ < -5:@$"! 9-$"5#"#<5$%#!"$9-5%<<%@$5!%%I;J-5:##%$
7880+7+44, *072* 5-$)%%#:>5#(008B008<$<<$)%'#%$C5#(2+!2,!%:8! #5#(F0<$%.:<:55-5:@$"-5$.%$!@%%!5@%@# #%@%<%#:<+2A%8E1+C5#%83+$<%@%?C
$9-:#-$5A'5<<;-&#%%:#)%C
$% .:<:5 5 -5:@$" -5$.%$ @%%! 5@%@# # %@%<%#: < +2 A% 8E1+ >? %#%# 5:'%9 <=5 $)%'#$%5 < 5%:>5#(+(8?#I$=5#(88(8!#$#9-$"5$-# < 5%: $9% B =5 $)%'#$%5 <$%# G#5 ..%%: B %#%##%$ < -5:@$"%5%#<5'%#5<-5:@$"-5$.%$C
$ $#5# $ # .%'5# <$%5! =9-$"5 <$%# @55 -5%9 -:5%$<%I < -$5 =9) < 5%: <:)# <=:! 5-#%@9#B=<9%%$<=$@$)$5#5!#-#5<< 04A$5I%%@#5:/:C
=B<:.#!%#:5G#<:)%#5#.#5:!$#J.%J:-5<9<5 $$<%#%$<95/:>5#(2(3<$#5#?C
!<9G9!9$##<244.5(-#G#5.#5:-5<9<5%< -$5%#$#:%5!$5&'9#9#%&5<.5%<'#%$>5#( +(8?C
<:%%$<#$5%#:<9%%#5#%@.:<:5-$5##$<9#%$B -"5$99<=5'#$#J:#:-5@$%<-$5%#-$5<### $#!.$%-:.$5!%9%:B<A'9#J:#$%5< =5#(14(+/(+<$%.:<:55-$5%#-$5<###.%%#<88 @5%811E>C(*( ! $99#%5<!8EEE-(8++,/(32?C
;%#<9G9<<:%%$-:.$5<#$5%#:<9%%#5#%@ #$<<5%&5%#I%###!<=$9-%9#<#L/< <5$%#-)%B$.%:-5 $.:<:5#%$!--%#%$<<5$%#.:<:5! 9%I%###-<:.%%#%@9#@5#<<5$%#.:<:5M#59#<%#! <$# <:%%$ $# -#%) <= 5$5 <9%%#5#%. -5& <= #$5%#: .:<:5 $ <= 5$5 < <5$%# <9%%#5#%. > $-( %#( -( 8++FC ( ! <'#N O)5 /<)#5%)' < $P5! 8EEE -( ,+8?C I -5 #$5%#: <9%%#5#%@ .:<:5! # -5 J#%$ #$5%#: <9%%#5#%@ #$ < <5%&5 %#! % .# #<5 #5%)J .:<:5J##5#$5%#:$$5'%#%$%<:-<#<=<9%%#5#%$ .:<:5##I=###<=$9-%9#<#L/<<5$%#-)%
7880+7+44, *372* B$.%:-5 $.:<:5#%$>5#(8(+#()#<$%.:<:55 -5$:<5<9%%#5#%@<+4<:9)58E,1 ?C
5%) #$ < 5 $% ### <5%&5 %# #$ # < =$9-%9# < #L/ < <5$%# -)% -#! $ I% -5:&<!-5$$59%@:<:.%%#%@<=$--$%#%$B$99<9# <-"5-%I!###.$<!$<9#%$-%9##%9%:B A'9#J:#$%5> 84E28?C
;=-&! 5%)<:#%#-$5:#)%I=I%#:<=9-$"5 $-# < 5%:! <:.<5 <@%# $)%'#$%59# G#5 ..%%: B %#%##%$<-5:@$"-5$.%$!I%<5#=#-$##:C
;%$@%#-5%5<=<9##5I<:$9-#$#J#CI=..#!% 5$5#<=9)<-%&-5$<%#-5 <9<5I! B <#< $99<9#<-"5!<:.<5#<95:<:)%#5%<=9$##< 80=1,F.5(04C
; I% $5 .5% < -$5%#! % $# <=$..% --$5#: -5 <:)%#5$5I-$5%#)$#%#>< 8EF30+?#I.5%<'#%$ $#-5:@-55&'9#-5$<%#C
-$5 #$ 9$#%.! % " % <=<9##5 <9< # < -5$$5 9%@:<:.%%#%@<=$--$%#%$$99<9#<-"5C
/////
7880+7+44, *272*
& 0 & ) )&) )
12.-.++ 3 4. . . 56 !%# 7
-.+
8( :5<9<5@)(
-.
+( $<9=6666666666 B-"5B $99<80=1,F.5(04!@%#:5G#B2!+2H<& 2.:@5%5+442!,1.5(F2B#%#5<=%#:5G#-$59$%<A@%5+442!#244.5(B #%#5<.5%<'#%$!%%I.5%<-$5%#(
0( 5$$9%@:<:.%%#%@<=$--$%#%$.%#$99<9#<-"5 -$5%#D4288EF,4 (
3( %#I=%=#--5Q<=:9$9#(
2( .$59 -5#% < I; -@# .$595 5$5 $#5 -5:# 55G# < <:% < 04 A$5 <& $#%.%#%$ -5& < 5%) .:<:5 >/R%N5/$.I%,!,443 ?!-5@$%<5$59#%&5<<5$%# -)%!$.$59:9#J5#(1+<$%.:<:55 5%).:<:5<8F A% +442 > ?C 9:9$%5 < 5$5 <$%# %<%I5 $%$! 9$#%. # 9$"<-5@#-$5#5%'#5<5$5#$<$9<#%5C%<$%# G#5 <5: 5%) .:<:5 -5 @$% -$# $ -5 @$% :#5$%I J $<%#%$ < =5#( 3+ ( -5:# 55G# # -%& -$%$ < 5$5#!%@$I:$999$"<-5@!<$%@#G#5A$%#B=@$%( '5..%&5 5:%<#V ST U )
$-%$.$59<-5:#55G##$#%.%:J-5#%%%I;B;..%.:<:5 <5$%-5'5..
7880+7+44,