Procedural Discretion in Denying New Trial Motion
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged the application of certain procedural rules related to the timeliness of filings and the sufficiency of evidence supporting a motion for a new trial, arguing the trial court erred in denying relief. The court reasoned that the challenged procedural determinations were discretionary and that the appellant failed to demonstrate the trial court abused its discretion in finding the filings timely or in concluding that the evidence presented did not warrant a new trial, thereby affirming the lower court's judgment.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Procedural Discretion in Denying New Trial Motion: The court reasoned that the challenged procedural determinations were discretionary and that the appellant failed to demonstrate the trial court abused its discretion in finding the filings timely or in concluding that the evidence presented did not warrant a new trial, thereby affirming the lower court's judgment.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
&'())&*++) &*(,&*++-
##
# " " # "
% ( . *++- /0 12
% 3333333333 !"#$%%%%%%%%%%& ''(
('
44 " "5 " ')' (& ( )(*+,-&./..01*
!"# $%
4/254
4
.6 #' %%%%%%%%%%7('()'0899 ' :)(;4 )'0 < /= /,,* ( 4' 7( ( 1'( 91'>)('(((6 ((&7' ')9'' )' 4')(?? @(' A..''( @('((:B)'( )! ',//-,=*+6
/6 (((9))''B 9'(?799( ))( ? 7' (( 99( A*. ' ''6
*6 ' 7('( 7')( .= C( /,,*& 7( ' 9' @(' >''(@('((:B '( )!? 9''6 7( :( D )' C' & 1B C?7 *,)(B' /,,*& (( '& ' '' *.6
36 3 E( /,,*& ' )' 7' 7 1? )' ('(?7()' ( F 6
+6 .3E(/,,*&7' () >7(1'"41 ( 9F )'/,E(/,,*6
=6 9!:'('"41&')'( )! > 7( ' .G E( /,,* ( : 71(( > '))'6 &'')) >F')'7' &16
-6 ''7D()@('(((&7()' ( )' 1/,E(/,,*> 7)'7('(6
G6 /GE(/,,*&7' ) )()'0:''(1 )'(9&?(()'7 (B(&'(!H: (1''(B';)0=<6
56 7' >7' )''''>''I
4 /5)(B'/,,*&:()'0J%%%%%%%%%%K>'& 4 /, (B' /,,*& :( )'0 K ( 1(>('(9F /G(B'/,,*?7' 7())' ( & 4 /5 (B' /,,*& 1 1(( 7' > F)?' (9 B>7('(/G(B'/,,*& 4 *,(B'/,,*&:()'0L%%%%%%%%%%K 6
2.-332/,,3 4*254 .,6 ''' ( '1 '(' > 7& )( 7D( ) 1''& ((' ((>''6
..6 ''''/,(B'/,,*' >''&#'%%%%%%%%%%& ')'&9F '"41>7' )''/G(B'/,,* > G!*, ;)0 ., <6 ' ''' /5 (B' /,,*& B > ( ('( ( (( ( ( )'( .,1B'/,,*)' F)'(9B6
./6 /G1B'/,,*&7' )' ( '(7()'0 K ' ? ? 7' 1(I *. ' '' ;)0 =B <6
.*6 ' )((( '(7(&79 7'7' ( ''' > 7((( 4 ( 0 ' ( ' > ' ''6 )(&F'''?( ( 1D >(('( '1'('&)(7D() 1''&((' ((6
.36 G C1' /,,3& 7 ('( ( )!? 1 #' M%%%%%%%%%%&' )(K'1((&>'''*.6 ( ' ) ? ) 7F(( )& D( ('( 7B )'1(6 ('& #' M%%%%%%%%%% 1()#' %%%%%%%%%%6
.+6 /* C1' /,,3& ' )' )) ' ( )! ? )' 7' 6 # $%%%%%%%%%% ' )6 7 ) ( '( (B7' :(!"9(?' )('''' )'('(('6
.=6 '1?@(7 ( ( 9 (''7'F( 7' 6'))'(7?@( (B=9 1''/,,3&''(?'' 7( ) > '' *. ( ? # $%%%%%%%%%% ' '..& ' :''N('1(6
.-6 /* C1' /,,3& 799 ( 7) ' ?(' )'O()'(>7('#' %%%%%%%%%%)' 9('!'!)'7)6 &=C')( ( 9: )'7B7)/,,*&+C')'7B'!'! C/,,*&.5C')'7B'!'!E(/,,*(.3C')' 7B'!'!C(/,,*;)0-<6 ((' 9'6
.G6 '))'(7?@( ( (B=9 1''/,,36 ( (( ? 7' 9:'()'BP(F(('7B*.''' ;)0.-<6
2.-332/,,3 43254 .56 ' /, 9 1'' /,,3& 7 ' 7' )( )( > )('.'9 1''/,,*(9?7)' (()'!'!7) (?77 ((C:B)'''')'( )!6
/,6 .. ' /,,3& '1 ?@( )' > 7( 7' ( # $%%%%%%%%%%6 ( (B ' '0(( ? 7' (( !"&>''6
/.6 7? 7@(')79'')'1'!'! )'7)7( ' ) ')(>7'4!H: /=/,,*6
//6 ?C')('&.G'/,,3&7' 9' ' ((' 7 '()()(6' 1'(C'' :!(9'''!'!7)61()')'19(? '(('H( ( ')6F)(7()'()' C((E(/,,*6 ( :'&F)? ?9''1( ( 'B '7:'6
/*6 7' )'( '(9( (B /= ' /,,3 (((( 7 )( ('1)0(0/9 1''/,,36
/36 ' '))(/-C(/,,3&:')' (9' ((( 7)(( )( 7' 6 ( (( ? 7' D( )( ('1)0(0/9 1''/,,3&D 1('P(')(()(BC(11(((((? ?( 7)(( )( BC(1 (( > F'6 ( '1 ?''((B':)?(?7' 7( )' ( >7('(('H& )(9(?7( 9()'1'!'!7)6 ( C: 1'BB?7 ( ) )'' D( (?( ( 9'' ? 7' 99'( 1' '6 ?& ( '( ? 4 7 (( ) ?(( B:( (''99'(9')''('1')&() ')(>7'4!H:6 )(& ( (( ?771( ) 9' ' 1B )'((( C' 7 C' 6 ') ' ( ( ? 7' 1( 9 0' 9(1>B:(6
/+6 ' ''' .G E( /,,3& 7' ('C( '' (' (( 6 7('': ' 9( ?7 ) '1' ( /= E( /,,* *.C1' /,,3 C @(' ) ' @ ? 7 99' ?7 7 C''!'!7))(!(699'1'' ' :0'( 9 '!'! 7) > !? (B':& F)( C((E(/,,*&'1( ( 1(6K7:('& F)??''' ( > @('('9 ' > ''''
2.-332/,,3 4+254 ?71((')' '! ')'!:(7')'0 )( ( ? (( ''' ( ) )(B6 99' 7@(' )' ( ' :0'( ('H *0 !? ( 71' ) > (( 1''&#'Q%%%%%%%%%%&(C'B(&')' ? ' 9 '!'! 7) > 7)D :!(6 9& ' ) @(' 1( C:B )' ( )! 9( ? '' ( ) >)'')'61''(B' :: ' N '( E )' 1' 7 !:( 7'(!'!'>C')'9(1'? :: )1(C(9') ( &7D)7(''?7'( )()())(B'/,,*6
/=6 1( >)''&7('( ( &' ).*)(B'/,,3& 'C(''6
/-6 ()'()'.G9 1''/,,+&''( : 1' '(9'''!'!7):!(&'): )' ('H& )'0 1' (( 1 '('' ' )(6 (1'!'! >)'')'>C'4&0& R ( )' ?7 1( )S6 ' F)? 71' ) '1 ) ((' ('6 ( > 1' )'? 7 ) (( ) ( 9( 7BC(& F)? 1' ( (1'E)'' ()()')':' )>76
# %%%%%%%%%%& B'(' 7('( ( & 9( )' )'( ''?' ? )'( :!( 7 (( ) F ''& ? ''!'!7)7 (()()'7('('H ( ?7 7)0& F 9'' '!'! 7) 9:'( ';F B'/,,*(C1'/,,3<6
/G6 #$%%%%%%%%%%&(>(('( &? ?''( (( !"(?71(9( ')'0)()'? ''' ' ' '' ( ('9 ' ' '6 ? 71' )(( )'(''''(('?9(?? ''((( 'BP(F(('6
2.-332/,,3 4=254
#
.6 :1 ' 7':( C' ;< ( 9 ( (( & 0 .' E( /,,*& 'B ( ' & ) +C:&()' ((14)' (&+)) ((.=C:' ;'(6.(6'(+= <6
K( > 7( 7 ( C: '& )' 'B 9 ' /-C1' /,,3 ; M .*, .,=<& ' :1 )( & .*9 1''&)(('('':()'((( 'B( ' :' ' > (' C: (('& & 7(((7 (1FC:'6
/6 9' ( > 8'(6 += 6 . (6 !6 G & 'B ( ' P( ( ? ((( )' 1 > 7'(6+= '(1 > 9 ' ' 7'4!H: B:(' ( 7( 71B( /+ C .5G/ ; <6 K ) ( )' C:'7)0( (B6
*6 ('C( ()(&''('1B;'(6+=(=, <6
36 ' '( F ( !H: 8 ')( '( B' ( (1& ( )'(' 8@(' )( )( ;96 '(6G <6K8'(6.+6. &(' )( )(> @(') &!H' ?() >)('('11B(('('( 9'6' &?&)'(9)'9F&)(1( )99''>)D'(()B( '(F:B&)(@(' ' )( > @(' ) ;96 M ./+ +G 6 =& ./* /.= 6*(' 9 '<6
K' ('( 7 (( > 7 ;K < ')) '(1 ;96 '''(1>7( !H:T''K UV!6.=+<? 1( 7)('(1( ' ( ((7)(( )(6 7' ( ((' > )( '1 7) ( )(' (( ('1 ' )( 1B ? ( 99'(6 ( :( )D' ( 99'( )' '!'!' ) ;'(6 .- <6 '!'! 7) (( 99( '9 ' ) ( 7) 1B(((: ('(?7' 7()) >@(' ) 6K ((9'1 ?7)1('>)(( )('((BV9(99(?7D('(?9 6 ()' ('?7' D(B)'()'(> )'!'!');!6/*=''K <6
2.-332/,,3 4-254 +6 7)0& 7 7B' ' 71' '('1 9'' '!'! 7) ' ''(6 B'(' 7('( ( )' (>77?@()(?F9'' 1( 9( ( '('1 6 ( > 7B 9'' C( ( E(//,,*&7F)?)'9(?7( ( 'B >7' &?7 ((()() ?7 ) (/GE(/,,*6
7 ' ) ? )' 9'' ?( '6 )'P( '( ) 1'BB ? ( ( ) )'' 7 ( B > 7' 7))'(' )'1 99'( )D )' '('1' )6 7 7' (' ? 7)( '( )' ) '(6 ?( ( 1' & 7''& ( C(9 7 ('' (' ? ''( ( )()(6
7( '))' ?7 (0' '!'! 7)& 7('( ) (( ( ( 1 '9' !? 99'( 9' )' 7' (& 7 ( 99(& )' '( > 7( 1'( 7'(6 *, 6 . (6 6 ( :'& K )''( 7' '' ;!6 /*+< ? '? '!'! 7) 7' ( 99(& 7('( ) (( )'& )' !? ) ' ('H& )'(>7( (?7)(((' :' )' ( )'' ) 7(( ) 10'& 1' '((' 7)(()(?(6K&)'01'B)'(> 7( &7' 9))'((&' ) ' ' )': 0' ))')' 6 ( 9( )' 1 ? )' ? 7))' '('H99'(7' 1'@(' )'!'!7)>9)('+ 1()''C'1'B1((((;/*+<6'?7 (' 1)' )H('!'!7)77() ) '!'! 1 7' ?7 ( ? C' > )(' ' )( 71 ( ' )' )' )' F)?' ' B6 )' :( ? 1 )'( (' &)'(>7( )''!'!7) 99(')' 6
M' ( ((' ? (( )' ' 7 ) ( ')( 7)06 7('( ) (( (( C1' /,,3 )' '' ?(' )6 '(& :( '(& ')( : K ?( > 7('( '' )::'1 6 7)()')( 7)'(&' N7' 7)79')'(()'01''O )'0'(6 )(& ?7( 1(?7('( ' (B('):6
2.-332/,,3 4G254 'B ( 71 ?7 )( 0 '& ('' ? 7' ( )'( ( )( )( )(& ' N 7) ( ' ( 9')'((6
:'F '(?)' 0(&''(6
2.-332/,,3 45254
# 4 " # " " # "
% 16 7 8 59 ',* ":
6
.6 ''''1BV
% 6
/6 7(( /,9 1''/,,3(/-C(/,,3V
*6 (?)' '(:'((V
36 9' )'( ?7 )1( 9'' '' (' )' ( ''@( *, C' 0 (9( )' ) ' ' 'B 9 ' '& K!W"'!9? =& =,,3 & (' F)'6 )( @(' )': 6 ' (I < ?' F((? ''( 'B('() ((? V B< F)' )' ? (9 ( )1' ' (( (' V < )'(' :(' ')' ((6 K ' (( ) (' ( ' ((' < B< ( < 4& 'B9 '')'')(''(0''''?7 1' ''''1B6 '''(''D )'1& ? '( C(& ? ((? ( 71)) ? ( F) ''(;'(6.*/&.,=(.,G<6 :'990'I ' (I MM X'K X
) 9' )' ( ''@( ( (9 F )'( ?7 K' ('( 7 ((>7 )':'99
2.-332/,,3