Financial Calculation Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involved a dispute over certain financial calculations and resulting obligations, with the court ultimately examining multiple numerical comparisons and time frames across various transactional periods. The court reasoned by systematically evaluating the presented figures against the established terms and contractual periods, applying specific formulas to determine the correct resulting values and concluding that the required payment or obligation was supported by the demonstrated mathematical derivation under the controlling agreements.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Financial Calculation Dispute: The court reasoned by systematically evaluating the presented figures against the established terms and contractual periods, applying specific formulas to determine the correct resulting values and concluding that the required payment or obligation was supported by the demonstrated mathematical derivation under the controlling agreements.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive orders concerning the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
"#$%&"&''( "&$&"&'')
*+ + * +
, )
! &' &'')
!!!!!!!!!!"#$%$#&' !!!!!!!!!! &'&
%
" &%()*")+,)-./
!
(+0))(
! - 45% & 6 % & & )3 #%'6 +,,2
7 01+20+,,28 &'%%% & / !!!!!!!!!! 7(#- 9 4$8" #$%$&46&# #&-):&$'6+,,3# '-"' !!!!!!!!!!" &$#$ ; 4% &4 &$ ##% & %<.&=>'<7(#-9 8&3?$.+,,3"%( " .@% ; # . &$ & &$% % &A%.& 6?$&$&B
4%$?&&%5%B
& ' !!!!!!!!!! &$ 6 % & +)?$.+,,C&'&%;A(%%.%; 4%%&4&'%$;%%&&$#?'$&@% &$;45%&)3#%'6+,,2B
45% & 6 % & & +2 ' +,,C 7 +C)0+,,C8 &$% .6" # %&.%$" $'% &$#$ ++ ?$. +,,C # ' !!!!!!!!!!" & 4%/ *1 / 3 & #$& &'%%.&)+#%'6):*C7 8B
45% & 6 % & & )3 D. +,,C 7 +10+,,C8 D%% & 4$" #$%$ # ' !!!!!!!!!!" &$#$ ; 4% &4 &$ ##% & 4?? % & 4'# & C %6 +,,2%&A%.& 6?$&$&B
45% & 6 ?$&$ & & 2 ' +,,C 7 1,0+,,C8 &$% .6%D%$#4$;4%&45%#$%$%%'%%% 6?$&$"''6D%&'#$%B
45% & 6 ?$&$ & E D% +,,C 7+/ )E,0+,,C8 &$% .6#'%.%??%B
45% & 6 % & & 3, D +,,C 7 C110+,,C8&'%%%&4$"#$%$#' !!!!!!!!!!"%D%$ % &$ ##% & 4?? % & 4'# & ++ ' +,,C" % ( % .@% ; 4%%$ %'$ # . &$ &&$%B
$'%&4$&1D%+,,C%%5%A$%4%& &$#&4%/*:F %'%A 6%& % #$6'% &G H% ; ' !!!!!!!!!! A%$ & '&%#?'%A?$&4%/:/2 /
0)12+0+,,3 (30))( 45%& 6%& &)#%'6+,,C7 1))0+,,C8D%%$'%&4$'%?A'-'#%# &%%%=$;&A%$&'&%#?'% A?$&4%/:/2 B
4&%&%5%&.& 6?$&$&B
4%$?&&%5%B
&'&&$.&5%& 6%&& )3 #%'6 +,,2 % +2 ' +,,C &$#$ # ' !!!!!!!!!! &.% &% 6)2%6+,,C%%%.%9
I$6'%9
( $.6/
( & 6 &J % &'& & D 9 &'& & $. 7$'%8 & 5% 0)+C*0+,,C % 0+2C*0+,,C8 % &'& &4%#$%%&45% 0+2C*0+,,C/
( & '' #- 7#.8 &'% &$ 6 % &&%%&4'#<'%&D/
( J'%?%$%%%/
( H%" 6" !!!!!!!!!! '' '&% #?'% A?$#&%4<%/
#'%9
( %% A4 @ &$ & D% %%% # &'& &4&'%$%&?%4&%#&4??4&'%$<<%/
( %%4&'%$%?&; !!!!!!!!!!IB
'%?.A$#' !!!!!!!!!!"%?%A 6%& ' & %% # & '$' & .%;4%&4&'%$"&4%/*,%/& "&% ?KA4%''&$&D%?'B
6%&4%#&G%%&'&& +)?$.+,,C''$'%'6''&'&&$.& 45%&)3#%'6+,,2B
5% & 6 % & & 3, D +,,C % ) #%'6+,,C%%%&?%'@&#..J%'#%%
0)12+0+,,3 (20))( & 4%/ *, %/ 6 &- A4 J#A% &% & &% ; &'%$B
4 4<%#;%%&'-'6 ;%%&'&% @%&%; $'$%B
4 D<% &. &'% %%%% & A%$ & '&% #?'%A?$B
4<%'%&&J&'&&$.'$ 0)12+0+,,3% 021,0+,,CB
&'&&$.&5%& 6%&& 3, D +,,C % ) #%'6 +,,C &$#$ #- &&% 6 # ' !!!!!!!!!!)2%6+,,C%%%.%9
I$6'%9
( $.6/
( & & &'% D% ; %% & )2/),/,C 6 % & " & &'& %#$%% & 45% 0+2C*0+,,C % & &'& & $. & 5% 0)12+0+,,3 % 0+2,0+,,C%D&6/
#'%9
( &; !!!!!!!!!!4&'%$&.%&4%*:F"/3 /
( H% !!!!!!!!!! '' '&% #?'% A?$ #&%4<%/
6&'%9
( &$%%&'&&$.''$'%%45%& )/:/,CIB
'%?.A$"%?%A 6%&4 # ??''% %% A% & A?% #? A 'J'&4??46<%;?B
' !!!!!!!!!!"J%&?%&'@&#..J% '#%% & 4%/ *, %/ 6 % A 45% & 6 % & %%#'#%&?%.A$%$%6##- & 4%/ *, %/ #A4 4 # ?% $%%" # J'#" & < .< %?A & $%% & #$& L 6 4 . ; 4M. &# $B
0)12+0+,,3 (C0))( 4%/*:F "%'%;4%/*1/+ "4%#'%I#%I' #$A4&'%$%$%A6%%<&B
4J< & D%?% $'A #$ # 6 % & % # & %J% $< % &% # 4##A &% %B
4$A"&'%$%"' !!!!!!!!!!"&;4$B
4 ?% ." A4 %% A D%" $%% #$$ & A% &4%#$%%&&%%&B
" '' 4.% & %" 4J%% %$5% #6 ; ?%%&'&%#?'%A?$B
4<%'%&&J&'&&$.'$ 0)+C*0+,,C% 0+2C*0+,,CB
&'& %#$%% &<$ % 45% & 6 % & & ) #%'6 +,,C %D%$ # ' !!!!!!!!!! )2 %6+,,C%%%.%9
I$6'%9
( $&'&.6/
( & & &'% D% ; %% & )2/),/,C 6 %&"%&&J&'&&$.&D% D&6/
#'%9
( A%.&%J#A"$=$%"A?$&$ %'#%#&&%&'%%? N /
( J#A4%#$%%&$;4%/*:F A4$%&%J%& %%/
( J#A A % '#$% I%=AI % ID&AI $ # 5% '' '&% #?'% A?$ '%-&&%&=>'<I/
'%?.A$"%A4J%%&%%45%&+3'+,,C %&)#%'6+,,CA%;4&%&.&&-A #'4&A.&&%A&'%.& 6?$&$&%'5'A 6?$&$&"
0)12+0+,,3 (E0))( &5%&2'+,,C#$$A4&&%&'%%?4%.% AA4?$&$$%%##A$B
' !!!!!!!!!! 6 % & &.% #'%.&B
6%&%4%/*:F &'-$ %.A$%$&4D%?%$'AA-.&&%?$&$B
?;6%$" 6%&&.%J#A #'%%#$%%%%.&4%/*:F/3 %%''&.% J#A#'%A4%&%#A?%%=A'%-& '&% #?'% A?$ % #A ##A% & '- %- %%.B
%%&'&$%$<%$'5''$A&'&&$. %45%&)#%'6+,,C"% 0+2C*0+,,CB
#- D% J &'& #$%$" % ' .% & ' !!!!!!!!!!" %6 & '%- &4 .< %%$ I N %%. %I & ' !!!!!!!!!!" %%%% & ? !!!!!!!!!! & +: #%'6 +,,C A ' !!!!!!!!!! %.$ & & &4 #%%'#7 8&#';?%$&&%"&&'& $%$ " %%%% & " .%" & )) %6 +,,C A .% %.'% 6$ . ' !!!!!!!!!! & & & &$? & #%% % & $" ( &.% 5% &$$ '' '&% #?'%A?$&%&"%''%( =>'<" %%%% & OO" .%" & 2 %6 +,,C" A' !!!!!!!!!!&#%&??%#5%&' %% A '&% #?'% A?$ &.% 6 % & " %%%% & 4% P F Q A ' !!!!!!!!!!%%4%&%.&&$?D&A&# ??%&%6#@=AB
4& & '#% # & )2 .'6 +,,C & A ' !!!!!!!!!!&$$9
I # $ 6 N$&$ & '' &A$ # A <??-& '4&A$A4'%?%.&$/4@% #KD'&'&$D#.$' 6N$&$& " A D4 #66'% ?%/ .=" % .% % #?6AD4%$'4%%&$$&?&&% #6 6N$&$(&$6%R@%$'%A'%%% %#$%%%- %%.& A% 6%/=%#&. #@&?&#$& 6N$&$.&=%-'&-
0)12+0+,,3 (10))( &-A5%& ##A%&%%/"D#A ' ? % &$6%$ &4 &'& &4% &4% D&A" &- A A44<%&4#%%#@=A$#&@%$'%A'%A4# & =&-/"%?$;.%&4??%; '('5'/#A4 6N$&$4%#&&%'#%&4<%% A'4%A#&=&-/D#&& 6 &'%%? %$ # #& # ; ' %%/ ' &- ''D%'5'D4#&%%%&D%4%# #%$<$/4<#%AD&AA4?'%/4.$'$'% & D&A/ # A #6-' &.% 5% $ . % 4<%&%/# 6&%%$A%$IB
4& & 6 & $ & +2 .'6 +,,C # A 021,0+,,C" 0)+C*0+,,C% 0+2C*0+,,C%$%$D%; 0)12+0+,,3B
&' !!!!!!!!!!&)2?$.+,,E?'% 6&$ A4.%&4#%%D&A& &$%A4$%%# A?$A##%&'&%A4%B
! .A<.S<%D&78$%$'&?$ %%%$"&-)G%+,,3" 6%&"'#$ & CD<"&%#$&%%.(#$&%"C##$%%)ED< 7%/)%/%CE 8B
%;S%&S$%&)ED<"# 6?$&$ +1D.+,,27 N)3,),E8"& <.&#%$")3?$." &#%%% <% #'%%% 6 % & & $< ; % D< %%" " & S%%% & S$% & .JD<B
?'$'% J %/ *, ; *2" *1" *: % *: " 6 % & H% & #$& & $. % %?% & ## 5%A&#$&&$'%B
'#$%#D<&&S#-%$%6B
4%/*:/3 "4%/*, 4##A'%-&$.# $;4%/CE/+B
% % 6 4#- 4<% &45% & ##% & %'%-&=>'<&)).'6):*37 8"7?/%/CE/+%/ 8B
4%/*, " @;$.A"&??$<$# &$&$?%."##H%9
0)12+0+,,3 (*0))( 8A4'&$%"$%6##$&#$&4%'-" ?$&$B 68A&?%&'@&#..J%'#%%J%%"A %#.%H%.A&#$&#$$&%B 8A"#&.%"&$%%#'#%&?%.A$%$%6# #-B &8AD&%4#%%$%&#%&'-; ''%%&$&D%?'B 8AD&%A%%$4$%%#'#$''4&A &#%$%%$%$.$B
4%/ *) #$ A &'& & $. &% 5% &$ # $% ; D&%A&&$&3'&-&$.%&'%?&$. 7/)8/&'&&$.&%5%%%?#$%$#%&&), ;'#%&%?%&&$/&$.&4%*,"%%"% $.$/"$.#%.&4??"%''%''% & # <$$ 7/ +8/ % E2 % EC % ##6 # </ &'&&%"#%"&A'%?&$.%%& A$%#L$.%&'%.&$#7/38B
4%/*2 ";&'&&4#%"D&%A%%$%#-% &$"A4%%&6%$&%&%&&#%? % &#%? % &$% 7/ )8 &'& &4%#$%% &% 5% #$%$&&$#$.;4%E3#7/+8/.&$ &'';&-4%#$%%7/38B
&$&&4%/E3 %&3,D44<%&4&$? 7%/E3/)%/ 8B
4%?%$<-#%%H#$D&##%7%/21 8B
/!01 -. " 4#-" %D%$ & ?' % &$ #$. # " &'& &4%#$%% & 45% & 6 & $ & ) #%'6 +,,C % .67 0+2C*0+,,C8B
4 ??%" &$ & 3, D 7%/ E3 8 $%$ #%$" &'& @% $%$ &$#$)2%6+,,C"%45%#$%$%?$E#%'6+,,CB
#"&'&&$.&%5%&$$.6#A45%& ) #%'6+,,C4$%%#&$?%?&4%/*, )2%6+,,CB
4<% & &'& & $. & 45% & 3, D +,,C 7 0)+C*0+,,C8" %?$2D%+,,C"'#%%&#&&$&4%/*: "%%
0)12+0+,,3 (:0))( &'&&%$<'%5%&$$.6#A&$#$&&$&% '&#%?%&45%B
4 %" $'% % 45% & ) #%'6 +,,C &% 5% &$$ .6&-A4%$'%&$D;$%$%D%$%45%&3,D +,,C%A4%5%&$#$;."@%'5'6D%A@% &$;45%&)#%'6+,,CB
A% &4 $.% %' & %% $'% & &'& .6&$.#$%$ 6N$&$''6D%&'#$%( %%&%45%&)#%'6+,,C(&%5%%=$$<%.'%&- A ' !!!!!!!!!! '% &$$ & & '#% #A44%&%# 6N$&$B
4?"&'&&$.&5%&)3#%'6+,,27 0)12+0+,,38% & +2 ' +,,C 7 021,0+,,C8" &- A4 ?&%" '' '%?" %''%&45%&)#%'6+,,C& 6&$".A$ %%&'@&#.."%A4%$%$&$#$&&$&% '&-%%"&.%5%&$$.6B
4.="&'&&$.&&J5%&%5%&$$.6 %%A&'&.A4'# 6&$&%% & ; 4% &4 &'%$" '%? $%% & &'& &# # & % '" % &# %?% & 45% & )3 #%'6+,,2B
/!0! -. "&'&&$.&.%5%D%$#A.%9
&'& & $. & 5% & )3 #%'6 +,,2 % +2 ' +,,C ?&%"'''%?.6"5%6$A%& 6&$&3, D % ) #%'6 +,,C A %%% &'& & ?% .JJ#A%&%&&%;&'%$"#%?& H%' !!!!!!!!!!'''&%#?'%A?$B
?%%%%#&%#&?%'@&#..JA &'&#.%H%.A&#$&#$$&%& 4%/*,%/6 B
4 &4 A 4% &4 &'%$ %% # #$%% # A#'-"&$#%++?$.+,,C$'%"D<$ %&.# 6&$+2'+,,CB
4%'%A 6&$%&G%'%-&'& &$.%#&4$'%"%&G%%%5%#-& 6N$&$B
0)12+0+,,3 (),0))( 4$A"&'&&$.&5%&)3#%'6+,,2%+2' +,,C#%A45%D%$B
&'& & $. & 45% & 3, D +,,C ?& ?% A 6&$4%#%'#%&?%$%6##-"%%''% .< %?A& ' !!!!!!!!!!%$%%&#$& <<$# &.% 6%&#' !!!!!!!!!!B
&'& #= $%$ 6 & $ &4. #$&$ ; '. ##$% D&A & ?% $%6" %A A % . & %$."A4##6%&#'%%$J'&% D&A%#45%&%%$.7?/4<%&$.#$& ?$&$" N &+D%+,,)"+ /+*10+,,)8B
'5'4&.%&'%%A&'&4##&&#-&.% 6 % & & 4%/ *, %/ 6 " ?% .'% .A$ # &'&" % .< & ' !!!!!!!!!! %%$ I%%. %I A4 J#$ & ( &4%% &? !!!!!!!!!!&&&4'#%'#%&AA ' ; 4.%$ & -." %% '' J#$ %%%$ # " OO % P F Q A #$& %D%$ # ' !!!!!!!!!! # &.% 6 % & % ''%& 0 %%H&$&??$% &&)#%'6+,,C#'5''%?J#$&%5%B
4 $A" &'& & $. & 5% & 3, D % ) #%'6 +,,C#.%A45%D%$B
&'&%#$%%&%$<'%5%D%$&-A45%&) #%'6+,,C%%#&%&%&&#%?%&#%? %&$%B
4 @ & ## A4 &% $ &4 . & &% A'% # $A A4 % %H #$D& # #% $ 7%/21 8B
4<%&.%;6%J#%A%;4%#$%% &$# 6&$;4%/*:F %;4%/: "4<%$%$& <?.%'-&%&% 6##A$&J%"A &$#&&&'&%#$%%&4%/*2 #$%$B
&'&%#$%%&D%$B
#$& $%% <%%" $''% ' ; =< & &'&B
0)12+0+,,3 ())0))(
* 2 + *+ + * +
! 34.-. 1 5.. . 67 #)& + 8
-. )/ $.6&&$%&'&&$.&5%& 6%&&)3#%'6+,,2%+2'+,,CB
+/ $.6&'&%#$%%&45%& 6%& &)#%'6+,,CB
3/ $.6$'%%&'&&$.&45%& 6 %&&)#%'6+,,CB
! -.
2/ D%%&'L%.6B
C/ %A#$&%<%%/ <??-9 $&%9 @ $
#?'&#$%5%%%?$&'&";4??%& 4'#A4 $%%&S %%;S$'#<??
0)12+0+,,3