Tax Uniformity and Temporal Differentiation in Liability Assessment
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns whether certain tax provisions, which applied different standards for assessing liability based on the year of a transaction, violated a constitutional requirement of uniformity. The court reasoned that the different standards applied based on the timing of the transaction did not violate the uniformity requirement because the purpose of the legislation was to address different factual situations arising from the transactions occurring in different years, and the application of the different standards was rationally related to that purpose.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; PRESTATION COMPLÉMENTAIRE ; PC ; REMISE DE LA PRESTATION ; RESTITUTION(EN GÉNÉRAL) ; BONNE FOI SUBJECTIVE ; OBLIGATION DE RENSEIGNER ; OBLIGATION D'ANNONCER | OPC24
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 4 regarding the apportionment of court costs.
Cited in order 1 regarding the nature of the decision being made (final decision on appeal).
Testo completo
"#$%&"#''( "#%&"#'')
* +!* , * ,+
- . & #& #'')
! "###$ $# ! &"&' "%&' ( $'#" "## ) ' *'& + , -&#
"'&
.. + + + +! # &"' #'#$ /0 12! %"' 3451! 6766 3
! ; 789 ;
/+
6 ! &"&'#' <&=# $ 46 ">' 697?! '
"###$ +# %# 3 & 6911 ' @$$<# ) &' + %# 699:
7 $%"$ %&A )<<# '" %&" BC$ D#;
%&A E (#' F "@'#& %&''#" "%$'#& F &' %&#& &%%"&' )G0' $'$ $'@# & 6993! "%$'$ #! & G $'$ ' 1 $@& 6991 ' & 6993 &"&' G) ' %&"%&#$'#& ) %%&'' ' '&"# '#" F ! ' ;
%&"%&#$'#& H #" F ) % "'#& %# & 6991 ' /&/ "(H %& #& $&$ ("#& "@#C'#" #'#& F )$C& A& G# (#' .& #" &'&#'
4 & $##" 64 ">' 6995! ) # "'&"I$ %&''#" "%$'#& <$$& ( <<' &$'&"'#< A 6& "'"@& 6991 ' %&''#" "%$'#& '" A 6& J# 6995
2 #' ) " G0' "' &%%"&' $'$ & 75 (&# 7:::!
) # %' "'#<#$ %#& $##" 71 ">' 7:::! "<#&$ %& $##" & "%%"#'#" 2 ">' 7::4! # %%&#' &"#' H %&''#" "%$'#& # %& #& &$$ &@"&' " 49)692 <& ?: &%&$'' %&''#" (&$ F '"&' 6& "'"@& 6991 46 ">' 7:::! ' &J'$ &#! "#$&' G )&$ (#'
#<'' $'$ (# <"#
&%%"&' 75 (&# 7:::! %"& &$#'#" G '&"# '&'#!
75 J(#&! 65 <$(&#& ' 71 (&#! <#' $'' $$' #(' K
; " F "( '#" F %"& 7)::: .. %& "# %# $@& 6999L
; ' ( %&"%&#$'#& #" M , M# F F #' $A A&! ' " %# ">';%'@& 6993 %"& 4)::: .. %& "# ' %' &($ G "'#" & F <# # 7:::!
& M /&/ F (& @# % (#'M
1 7? ">' 7::4! )&$ %&A' "''$ $##" & "%%"#'#" %&A &#@ $ ' <"&$ "%%"#'#" "'& &< &#
3 & &&0' 2 "(@& 7::2! 4A /@& &#@ $ "''$ G) $A & A& &( 73 # 6991! )&$ ' N& (#' /$&#'$ H @# #"@##& # F @"#! "#' #" O P '
& O , P! G "& %&'C! 6 J#' 6993! )&$ (#'
8795687::1 ; 489 ;
"@' %# %&"%&#$'$ '' &#A& ## GQ "' % 41)?:: ..
&#@ ## JC$ G ) $'#' <"$ F %&& "%' @# #"@##& %&''#" "%$'#&! A "' $A A& ' " % ' J"& %&'C #"
%' $ $##" & %& ) ! "'#< G #;# )(#' % $'@# $"%' $%&$ "<"&$' F )&' 79 4 Q"&" & %&''#" "%$'#& F Q&;(##! &(#(' ' #(##'$ 61 J(#& 6956 D#;%&A ; +8 E '& %&''#" "%$'#& <$$& ' '"
%& #& "#$&$ G ) )$'#' % &"#' &$& &'#''#" @# (&$ %& +&(# Q&;# D#;%&A + E
## $'$ &("I$ F ) %"& "( $##"
5 & $##" 64 (&# 7::1! ) & "( $##" &'#''#"!
#'#C' '' <"#;# H%&$' %&''#" "%$'#& '" '
%&''#" "%$'#& <$$&! "<"&$' F )&&0' &#@ $ 2 "(@& 7::2 "'' 7?)622 <& 4: "' %#' $'$ &$$ F )&$ "%&#' %& #& % @# (&$ %& + '' $##" ) % $'$ "''$
? & $##" & "%%"#'#" 74 J# 7::1! ) "<#&$ &< &# <<' "#$&$ G )&$ (#' " ' (#"$ " "@#C'#" &#C& # G) (#' "'& <#' < $&'#" "& )#'&'#" " "#&
9 )&$! &%&$'$ %& *'& -&# + ,! #'&J'$ &"& 72 ">'
7::1 "'& #' $##" AC ("#& $'$ @" <"#! &$%A' G "& H '&'# 1 $@& 6991 ' 67 & 6993 G) (#' ( "@"&'& ) ! )(#' % "& G#'$ %&"%&#$'#& @# #"@##& # F @"#! A "& G %&'C #" < A& )' #'&( G %& ' 6& J#' 6993! G) )(#' ## &# ' )H#' @# #"@##&! G) )(#' @ ' @# "$ F ) G#'$ ;%&"%&#$'#& ' G) )(#' %& #' #<"&$ (' "#C <# G &@"&' " 7?)622 <& 4: %&#' #''#" <##A& #<<##
6: (#'$ F $'&#&! ) ! "&&#& 74 %'@& 7::1! &A( G )' % %& G )&$ ) #<"&$ G) $'#' ;%&"%&#$'#& H @# #"@##& F @"# 6996 G) $'#' #%$ " ("#& )#<"&'#" "&G) ' ( %&"%&#$'#& F #' $A A&
8795687::1 ; 289 ;
6991 "#C $C' G )' G) "& )G0' $ 6996 G )&$ (#' "$ )H#' H @# #"@##& <#! )' G & )G0' ##C'$ 6999 G )&$ %"& %&#A& <"# #<"&$ ) $A A& &( G'& % 'R' +)C#' "#'#" /&C '&"% "&! ) <#' ("#& G )&$ ' %&"%&#$'#& #(& @# #"@##& "' &'# "' "$ ' G) '
'#'#& H &' $'&CA&
66 & "&&#& 73 "'"@& 7::1! )&$ "##'$ %#" )#'&'#" &"& )''' )# ) $C"#'#" ( )
6& <$(&#& 7::3! #;#! I' "''$ G )&$ $'#' '"J"& %&"%&#$'#& %#& @# #"@##&! &<$ %&"%"#'#" &AC' '' %& (&' ) "'' 67)::: <& %"& " '"' "%' <#' %& )&$
(#'$ F $'&#&! )&$ )' % #<'$
67 +& ! $'$ C&$ F JC&
64 $C$ %&'# &"' &%&# '' G @"# %&'# M &"#'M G# #'
,+
6 "# C("# & Q"&C#'#" J###& DE $'$ "#<#$ ' #'#'$! A 6& ">' 7::4! &#@ '" & "#! "%"$ 1 JC!
"' %&$#' ' (#;%&$#'! 1 %%$' ' 63 JC & D&' 6 ' & ' 13 E
+#' F Q'#" Q$'#" 63 JC &! %& &#@ <$$&
75 J(#& 7::2 D . 64: 6:3E! & "# C("# "%'$! 64 <$(&#&!
#%"#'#" '&#'"#& &C' %&''' &#@ '" & "# #$C& & F '&"# JC '#'#&! ! Q''' Q$'#" "(H JC &
7 "<"&$' F )&' 13 6 ' / 4 ! &#@ '" & "# "*' #' #G "'''#" %&$( F Q&' 13 "# <$$& & %&'# C$$& &"#' & "# 3 "'"@& 7::: '&$ (#C& 6& J(#& 7::4 D E! G# "' &'#( F "# <$$& & %&''#" "%$'#& F Q&;(##! &(#(' '
#(##'$ 69 & 6931 D .E
+ "%$' %"& JC& Q%A ' ## $'@#
8795687::1 ; 189 ;
$##" & "%%"#'#" $'$ & %&A )'&$ (#C& !
%%#@ '#A& %&''#" "%$'#& <$$&! # "& &'#''#" %&''#" "$ (' 6& J(#& 7::4 '#'& #%"#'#" '&#'"#& ! )&' ?7 6 %&#A& %/& %&&#'
G #%"#'#" '$&# %&$' "# "' % %%#@ H %&''#" "& ' H &$ <#H$ (' " '&$ (#C& '&(H %&$%&'"#& ! )&' 71 D"& &' 47 %&"J'E! &'#< F &'#''#" %&''#" #>' '"/$ ' %$#' '#"$ " H% ) #%"#'#" G# &#' % %%#@ F %&''#" $JF (&$ (' )'&$ (#C& "# D.. 6996 733(E &(/! " - + D +;-"'&K -"'& S C'S T@& C# # +"S#(&#/&C&/' (" 3U'"@& 7:::! V&#/ 7::4! 9 &' ?7E! & "W G'#" &'#''#" %" %&A 6& J(#& 7::4! "( &"#' ' %%#@ A "& G)# ' ''$ & &'#''#" %&A " '&$ (#C& ' G @# 0 &'#''#" %"&' & %&''#" "&$ '$&#&'
G'#" &"#' %&'#' &'#" '%"&# &(0' '"'<"# % #%"&' $##( )"&&! "' G %&##% %%#@ F &'#''#" " "' # &$C''#" ' J&#%& '$&#& D- + ! "% #'! 9 &' ?7E
4 E '#A& %&''#" "%$'#& <$$&! $##" & "%%"#'#" "' J'' F &"& $# 4: J"& D&' 13 6 ' 3: 6& L < $C' &' 9 "# '" 62 "'"@& 6931 & %&''#" <$$& "%$'#& F Q&;(## ' &(#(' ' F Q&;
#(##'$ X .YE %&A '&#@ & '" "## Q&$ D&' 1? 6 E $# <#H$ %& "# "&' % 61 J#'
61 ">' ##(' D&' 4? 2 E
@E +QC#' %&''#" "%$'#& '"! Q&' 24 "#
71 "'"@& 693? & %&''#" '" "%$'#& F Q&;
(## ' &(#(' ' F Q&;#(##'$ D#;%&A K E "(& 0 ("# &"#'
E Q%A! &"& $'$ $%"$ <"& ' $# #%"$ %& "#! "&' GQ# ' &(@ D&' 9 .! &' 4? 2! 13 6 ' 36 6 L &'
24 E
2 )"@J' %&$' #'#C ##' F G'#" &# )"@#C'#" &'#'& F ) " 7?)622 <& 4: $##" 64 (&# 7::1 <#'
#' F )&&0' &#@ $ 2 "(@& 7::2 ' <#H' %&##% ' "'' &'#''#" ' <<' '&$ <"&
8795687::1 ; 389 ;
1 +" )&' 75 ! %&''#" "%$'#& #>' '"/$ "#('
0'& &'#'$ %& @$$<###& " %& /$&#'#& %&&#%'#" "# <$$& 7: $@& 6923 & Q&;(## ' &(#(' 0 +E "'
%%#@ %& "C# F &'#''#" ' %&''#" ' F #@$&'#" )"@#C'#" &'#'& #%"#'#" #'#G <#C& F )&' 72
+" )&' 25 6 + D71 6 E! &'#< F &'#''#" &' #>' '"/$! &'#''#" %' % 0'& $ "&G )#'$&$ $'#'
@" <"# ' &#' # #''#" #<<## )&' 59 6 &AC'
46 "'"@& 6925 & Q& (## ' &(#(' D +E %&$# G "&G) %&" ' F &'#''#" " " &%&$'' $C %"(#' @" <"# ''& ("#& &"#' '"/& &'! # "#' # 0'& <#' &# )"@#C'#" &'#'& '"' " %&'# "'' #>' '"/$! # '' &'#''#" (#' ''& #''#" #<<## &#" "#'#" )H#'
3 )%A! ) &<$ )"&& &# F )&$! "'#< G "#'#" @" <"# )$'#' % &$#$
) &%&"/ F )&$ )("#& #<"&$ $A A& &(
73 # 6991 G & )G0' $ 6999 ' )("#& '! %&''!
G) $'#' ( %&"%&#$'#& #" M ,' /"M
+" )&' 72 ; +; ! )I' &"#' "#' "#G& &'& F Q"&C '" "%$'' '"' /C' #''#" %&" (#"'#" )"@#C'#" )"& " &#C& )H' %' % @" <"# <<'! "&G )' " )"##" <'#< &%&$' G) (#"'#" $CA& '' "@#C'#"! )&$ %' '"J"& #("G& @" <"# ;# )' H G "&G <#' G# "#' F )"@#C'#" &'#'& "' )H%&#" ) "%"&'' ""#< " ) $C#C C&( D .
667 6:4! "# 7E )' G)( &' G)" ''& %' G $C#C %%&# %&$"%'#" @" <"# D 695: % 425E C#' %& $C#C C&( I' &"#' G# "<"& % F G# %' 0'& H#C$ ) %&" %@ #&' #''#" #'#G ' 0 #&"' D . 676 21! "# 4@! 66? 4:3! "# 7E )#C"& %& @$$<###& <#' G)# )(#' % &"#' H %&''#" <<#'
% %"& ''& G)# $'#' @" <"# <' @# %'R' G)# "#' & "%@ " ' ) #''#" ## # # ) $C#C C&( @" <"# "#' <#& )"@J' ) H #'#H /G %&'##& "#' "'' 0'& #$ "&G (&' # %&''#" %"& "&#C# "%"&'' #''#" " $C#C C&( %&" ' F &'#''#" "&G <#' "' $'$ ' " #<"&'#" #H' "$ #''#"' F #' ) $C#C C&( ( 0 "&G) "@#C'#" )(#& ) % $'$ &%# '%
8795687::1 ; 589 ;
'# #''#"' " F #' ) $C#C C&( I ## <' C&( /G <"# G $#'$ )"& /C' &( ' $(#' D 69?3 % 33?E
5 )%A! )&$ <<#& ("#& "$ )@$ )H#' @# #"@##& # F @"# ' G#'$ ;%&"%&#$'#&! ' ("#& "&'
#<"&$ "@"&'& ) $A A& &%% G %&'C #"! F )# G ' ( %&"%&#$'#& #" , )' #'&( G) J#' 6993! "#' $ %&A $A %&$# <# G) ) % G$ $&& F ) G) (#'
( @# 7:::
? ' (&# G )G0'& &($ F %#& &%&# G )&$ <##' %&( @" (""'$
%' "%&& G) ) &$' "%&# G) $'#' ( %&"%&#$'#& G) "' %&'C! "#' J#' 6993! G# %"&&#' H%#G& G) ) #' % %&$ "&G) $'$ ' & 6993
"%& "# &(/ G) '' "( G0' ) $ 7::: %"& $&&
AC ("#& #<"&$ ) (' )#@ M , M 7::: ."& ' "''& G) &$#'$ H%#G$ F )G0'& G "'#& #" M , M %&'#&#' # 7::: ' G) /&/#' F (& @# % (#'
&$' %& #& %#A <#C&' "#& GK
; " ' ) "$ $A A& &( 73 # 6991 G) 7::: D% '& "#& ) %% '$$%/"#G <<'$ ('E!
# ##G H%&$' "&G) $%" " %&''#" "%$'#& 66 "'"@& 6991! G A& ' F /&C '
G) # (& %#" #'#& 6)9?7 <& %& "#
; &$' &%%"&' $'@# %& '& G0' ) 73 & 6993 G)#(#'$ F <"&#& ''''#" (& &$' "&' '&"# '#" ' %%&'' F "' $'#' %&"%&#$'#&!
'#$ %& $' "'#& F 39:)::: .. '"'! ' G# )$'#' % "$ %# "# & 6991 ' )'& %&'! @# #"@##& F @"# "' $'#' ;%&"%&#$'#&! (#' &<$ $C' G # "#"&#' <&# G) %"(#' &
; %%&' "( G0' &$#$ 6999 ' "' &%%"&' $'$ &
75 (&# 7:::! G )&$ (#' %&= "I& 7)::: .. %& "# %"& )
8795687::1 ; ?89 ;
'#" ' G) $'#' ( %&"%&#$'#& #" M , M %# $A A&! #" "' "'#" # &%%"&'#' 4)::: .. %& "#
9 ."& ' "''&! ( G# %&$A! G @" <"# )&$ &#' 0'& # # $##" # &<' &# "#'; 0'& "<#&$!
$'' %&<$''"#& )H#& "#'#" /&C '&"% "&
8795687::1 ; 989 ;
,+/ +!* , * ,+
012 3 4 56 &)# ,7
2
6 $& &"& &(@
2
7 &J''
4 #' G %&"$& ' C&'#'
2 #' G %"& G# '&#' H %&''#" "%$'#& <$$&! %&'# %(' <"&& &"& "'& %&$' &&0' $# 4: J"& A "'#<#'#" %& %# &"$ &$ &#@ <$$& &!
+/Z#S&/"<G# 3! 3::2 ! '&"# H%#& $"#& "#' K E ##G& H'' G $##" &"&' $#& "@'#& # ' % $##" ''G$L @E H%"& %"& G "'#< &"&' '# %"("#& & '' '& $##"L E %"&'& #C'& &"&' " " &%&$'' +# $"#& "'#' % '&"# $$' $$&$ " ''& E @E ' E #;! &#@ <$$& & %"&& % '&& '#A& & &"& GQ# (& $&& #&&(@ $"#& &"& '#"& "& "I %&(! G# &"' J"#' $"#& Q# QC#'
%#A %"#" &"&' +&"' $C' J"#' $"#& $##" ''G$ ' Q("%% G $'$ H%$#$ &"&'
D&' 647 6:3 ' 6:?E
C&<<#A& &$#' K
&#;"# V "&# [
"%# "<"& %&$' &&0' ' "'#<#$ H %&'# ## GQF Q<<# <$$& & "# %& C&<<
8795687::1