Property Owner Development Permit Street Widening Exaction
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute involved whether a property owner, seeking to develop land, was required to dedicate a portion of it for public street widening as a condition for receiving a development permit under existing municipal regulations. The court reasoned that the dedication requirement, imposed without a specific determination of the public need directly attributable to the proposed development's impact, constituted an unconstitutional exaction lacking the requisite nexus and proportionality to the development, effectively amounting to a taking of property without just compensation.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Owner Development Permit Street Widening Exaction: The court reasoned that the dedication requirement, imposed without a specific determination of the public need directly attributable to the proposed development's impact, constituted an unconstitutional exaction lacking the requisite nexus and proportionality to the development, effectively amounting to a taking of property without just compensation.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision regulates the decision on court costs, as cited in the final dispositive order.
Testo completo
!"!# !$$% !&' !$$%
( )(* *+* (* +)
,- .
#% !$$&
!"#$%&'%(""(( $"$% ) %*%$ ($$+$$
"%$
,, , - !($ (%(' "%.$(%/0!#"%1123!4144 1
+157+
* /)
48 ,"9"$($:)#"(+"9($%("$'($(#%(";<( 100/: '%.( #$ )99( $'=(" #% >(+#$? @! )%($(%4$<(100/A)99(%")#"(>(+#$? @8
18 ,$ )((%'! (=' ; <( 100/! )(%'$' ((B' &"($ %$&('4$<(100134'.$1003CDE , B(%' &A#(%#!((BCDF >,CG(D@ 8 ' A.''9(($)((%'CH=?34'.$10038
38 E , %("'!$)%%%%(")#"I$'%.(11$100/ B )(%'$' &(%%$&('4$<(1001129'&$($100/!#'$("$% B&(%#$J"($!(B)&(%'%'(.'$')".(=%(" %$&($A"#%$34'.$10038
/8 12 $ 100/ 34 <&($ 1006! )(%'$' %$&(' #"$ F >,CG(D@ B(%'"."$%$(:%$:$##8
68 $'(("19'&$($1006! (%"=&"(CH=>(+#$? (@ (9"$' )$' B )((%' 4$ <( 100/ '%(% $#"$%'4$9'&$($1006!"%(9B)%$4$<(100/%34<&($1006! $&#$"&%"%(&(%'#$?F >,CG(D@ '%(% "( '= A )((%' CH= A B $(% # #$'%$! "$% B)((%(")$(%#&"($(8
K8 #$'%'#$"'#"L! !)$'9"$'"##"(%("% 149'&$($100/!'=%B)#$? &"($'%' (('#"$129'&$($100/! )'%(% #$'%' (! "(% 4$ $ 100/! A ) (& "M 9"$($&(%'%'$#(8 )&(%#$J"#(!("(%$"%$( &(%((B'B)&(%%%$)N%$"%%'#$"($#$"8 9( $ 100/! &(% %$"&' "& #"( $ ## % $%(% )%%% )N%$ "%%' #$ "($ % (#%(% $%$ A %$ ((%$%(&8 "A)"%$"()((%'CH=#"$"( $100/%(100/8
;8 $ '((" 42 <(% 1006! ( $<%' )"##"(%(" )$'! "%(9 #$(B)$#(;<(100/9"$($(%(%':)#"(+ "9($%(" $'($(#%(" ; <( 100/: "%$(=' #$ )(%'$'8 $$"*%!N()&(%"(9($%)($(#%("CH=A% %'$($A4$<(100/!9%)&"($9"$(9"$($:((%(" #$"$':> @'(%$"("(#$'&#$"(!"$"(%A )((%'$(%'%(%8
5121451006 +357+
78 $%47"O%1006!)$'!$#$'%'#$""(!(%$<%'$"$! '=%B))'%(%.(#$'%'A(CH=(&%4$ $100/%B)9"$($!"%"#((#'%''(&$'!&(%'%'$#(8 9"%("($ ( &(% ((B' B) &(% %%$ )N%$ "%%' #$ #$844$100/! 'A) $"&% )%"$(%("'<"$"'#"%($%"$'9"$($$#(#$ "&#"I$46&$(100/8 &(%9"$(A(CH=%" "%B(('%(%'%"'#"L&(%'$(%A#($$#$(A ( $'% #(% ((%' CH= 8 )$' 9(% =$(9A()&"($99%'BN%(%$#"$&'$(9($% "($(#%("8 "%#(%)((%'CH=#"$#'$(" $100/!"(#%%("K009$840"$$#"%($.$% $'('CDF !%#"$(100/!"(#%%(")($4)/00 9$8
28 $'#" ; "%".$ 1006! ( $?& B (% L '$C "($"$%!$&(='""(B>, @$"#$ "$$($ 13 "O% 1006! B) & ''% #"("! $"$% )'%(%#$'%'44$100/%$)()(++(&% % )($(#%(" '%' "(9(' "'B8 ( '$ #$N% A #%$&$$((%'CH=A)$'?44$100/!" (#%%("=((%$'(($8,)=(%(%(=B(.(%B%A% 99%(&)($(#%("!()$%A<%(8
408 &(%'A'%$($!$"$%#$(%A"%($B))%($(%4$ $ 100/! $&% B) ) <( $J "$$($ 46 $ 100/ "&"B%#"$34$100/8
448 $(. % #$%( ( "#$%(" #$" 44 <&($ 100K8 $"$% '$' B) )'%(% #$'%' CH= %$? $#(%#$?9(""%$%%$&(129'&$($100/!"(%4$" 1$100/8 %&"($(='9"$($#$'+($(#%("!(% B(I9(=$)#'%'($(%(P$##B)(9B)(%% %(" <%( #"$ B ) %% B) )'%(% .( ($(% $ 100/%"<(8($?&B%#$'+($(#%(")%# "#'%!()!B()%'%$('8
418 ,$B"(!'%'=$'A<=$8
5121451006 +/57+
* +)
48 "(=&"($Q"$=(%("<((($>@'%'"(9('%(%(%'!? 4$"O%1003! $(.%"$"(!"#"'6<=! "% #$'(% % &(+#$'(%! 6 ##'% % 4K <= $ >$%8 4 %8$%6K @8
,(%AQ%("Q'%("4K<=$!#$ $(.9''$ 1;<&($100/> R43040K@!$ "(=&"("#%'!439'&$($! (#"(%("%$(%"($$=%#$%%% $(.%"$ "( ('=$ $ A %$"( <= %(%($! ! Q%%% Q'%(""&L<=$8
18 "9"$'% A )$%8 6K 8 4 %8 C8 7 ! $(. %" $"("*%(%(B"%%%("#$'&AQ$%86K "(9''$$#$%(=''$$"(%$"(7"%".$ 1000 > @ B( "% $%(& A "( 9''$ $ Q$+CH= ".(=%"($%Q((%'Q("&.((%'16<(4271> @8
,"#'%#"$<=$Q#?%(('%.(8
38 %$<%' 9"$ % '( #$$(% #$ "(! $"$ % A % '=$ $&.>$%86K%K0 @8
/8 $(.'$?&#$'.%B)(%('$"*%B$"$% )% .( ($(% CH= $ 100/! '%% #$'(' B )((%' #"$%% B $ "( $ % ( 100/8 , $ "$(%(=(%99%(&AB)%($(%!A&"($4$!&"($ 1$100/!"44$100/""%(%)(%('8
68 ,")$%84;81 !&"#%!)$'%%#$'%$ A""(("A)%"$(%'"#'%%(%H%B#"(.!( # %$ #$($ <"$ #"$ B ( #$'% A )((%' CH=P ( "(% (%"9"$$L#$$(#%(""%$H'(%'#$ "(9''$8
"9"$'% A )$%8 42 8 3 ! " " )"99( "#'%% " "9($%("A)$'%AB()%#$'%' %(B)( C"((8%"%$#".(("'"%$HB("(&% N%$ (( #% <"$ A "#%$ % A B ( )% #$'%' A )"99("#'%%8)%"$(%'%"#%#$""=$'(<B)AB(D<"$ L(! "%% ((% "%(98 "$ " ($(#%("!)$'"(%#$'%$(&$"%%)"99("#'%%(%$"(% "')($(#%("I%?(9"$%(B%(?$#%%
5121451006 +657+ $C'%$&(> , @%$%A)$'"#(%('A(>98 $%81084A3 @8
K8 )#?! ( I ( $&$ #$($ ( B "' $%(& A $"$% )"% # '%' (( I%? (9"$%(B , (( B )L#(B ($%$( ) "$$($ $' / "%".$ 1006 A )'#"L$"$%!?"$B))'%(%##$'%'A"&"%(" 34$100/>98#(?"8/K$"$%@8#%"'B%($$ (9"$%(" 9(C($ (9"$%(B , B% A % )($(#%(" CH=$"$%8
$"$% "%% &"($ $J "&"%(" 46 $ 100/ #"$ 34 N"(!$?&B)($(%'%'"(%'$N%)I"$(%!%%(=%( 9J""%""($'%'%$(%'#$)((%$%("8
$"M +()%#AN 9"$($#$&)&"( "&"%("! $(. ' "(?$ B)( "&(% 9"$ $ '$%("%(%($ %)%%$B))#$J "&"%(" 46$100/8
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
$(."%%A%'=$B9"$($#$'($(#%("A) (=' #$$"$%"#"$%%B(#%($L9J"TC(99$ <"$"(#%N%$"(%C(99$:44:!(&("(C(99$$"(!"(% C(99$ C(99$ $"( >98 #(? "8 K (@8 "&(% $&$ #%B%(.$##"'$(%9"$($%("($%% 44 $ 100/ % B "&"%(" 46 $ 100/ 9(% '=% $'9'$ A )($(#%("44$100/>98#(?"8/;$"$%@8
5121451006 +K57+ &B(#$'?! $(."(?$B)()%#'%.(A%(9%(" $"(%B$"$%'#"')((%'4$"1$100/P $&C!%44$100/%((%.!"$%B)$"(%A ((%' CH= ? %% %! " '%(" =( (%$'(($ $'('$%(100/8
;8 $"$%!B(".%(%#$%(%=($"(%A((%'A%(%$ '#8
5121451006 +;57+
+)/ )(* *+* (* +)
01232 4 522 2 67 #&! + 8
32
48 '$$"$$&.8
32
18 )%#$%(%8
38 ")(%('A&$$((%'CH=A$"$%?44 $100/!"('$%8
/8 ")(%('A#I$A$"$%"R$87008+A%(%$'#8
68 9"$ #$%( BQ #&% 9"$$ $"$ "%$ #$'% $$N% '( 30 <"$ ? "%(9(%(" #$ #( $"' $' $(. 9''$ $! ,CG(D$C"9B( K! K00/ ! %$"( L#($8 '( #% N%$ #$""='8 '"($ "(%T @ ((B$ L%%B'(("$"$%'($".%($(%#'((" %%B'P .@ L#"$ #"$ B "%(9 ( %( #"&"($ $ %% %$ '(("P @ #"$%$ (=%$ " " $#$'%%8 ,( '"($ "%(% # %$"( ''% ''$' " %%$ @ .@ % @ (+! $(.9''$$#"$$#%$$%(?$$$"$BQ( &$'$$($$&.8'"($$"$%("$"$"I #$&! B( $"% <"(%! (( B '((" %%B' % Q&"## B'%'L#'('$"$%>$%8431!40K%407@8 =$99($T $'(%T ( U(
5121451006 +757+ "#("9"$ #$'% $$N%%"%(9('L#$%(%,$'%$(%Q %%A Q'""(#$=$99
5121451006