Contractual and Property Disputes Following Administrative Review
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses several disparate rulings regarding various contractual and property disputes, involving challenges to administrative determinations and interpretations of specific legal provisions across several instances. The court reasoned by analyzing the precise language of the governing statutes and agreements, applying established common law principles to the particular factual matrices of each situation, and concluding that the administrative actions were either within statutory authority or that the parties' contractual obligations were appropriately construed based on clear evidence or established precedent, resulting in a mix of affirmed and reversed lower court decisions across the consolidated matters.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual and Property Disputes Following Administrative Review: The court reasoned by analyzing the precise language of the governing statutes and agreements, applying established common law principles to the particular factual matrices of each situation, and concluding that the administrative actions were either within statutory authority or that the parties' contractual obligations were appropriately construed based on clear evidence or established precedent, resulting in a mix of affirmed and reversed lower court decisions across the consolidated matters.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for adjudging the costs of the appeal.
Testo completo
! "#$$% #&!#$$'
( )(* *+* (* + )
,-. & ' - #$$'
!
!
"" # $$ % &' !+, ()*&
%1-.4%
* /)
.5 & , !6 .)32 ! ' !!, & 7+! '#+8(, ' ++5 ' 869+ ' !:+ ! '#+& # 8'! !;, < !9 ,=9+! '8 #>= ' 12 !!!!!+!8#?8,,5
15 4 + .))* 4 ;+6 .))/& 8!8 @ != ' ,! @ # ! , @ ' : A 8 B5 7+ 8 +8( '!, ' 1 ;+6 122.& !! ! +! ' 6;! C D != ' ,! ' 5 & +=, 6 ;!,&,!,!98!6,8'+66'@,!!'!,D5
E5 '+' F * ;+6 1222& #, <! ' 8!! '#%;'!,;'#6!!'#!5
05 88! ' 12 ;+6 1222& & 8,! =!!,=&'<8!,'!;;!C.22G'.3E2 +.))/H.22G'.0',+6.))*!.22G'...!6.)))5 $8!!77'8,8,!!,';!'8.))4!,!!! !!5 +! '# <# #=! '# !:+ ! <5#8;'81.B;12225
45 88! ' .. ',+6 1222& & +,'%A7 ' ; ' A= ;, ! 86 ; ' !8!! ' AI8!:;!'9;J?K&!!!8!,'!;'.22G '9 .))3 @ B5 #, 6 '# !!+! +,' '8 .))4 ! 866+! @ ;5 #,!! ! !!5 '=!< 8,!! A< ; 8,!!+ !!& A,8!! A< ! '69! 8!% ,!& < ,! ,== !!& ' #!6!, ' =(,+5!!&!6'#,!!=,,!765 #: @ 88! ! 8!, 87& !7 < 8!!!86'!;'#+8!<875
35 .. L! 1220& ! & A7 ' < !7<& !7! '69! %<,! ! @ 8,!! !! J ': !+8K& A,8!! A< ! ,!! :%',875 #,!! ! !!5
*5 1 7,; 1224& #, ! :+, ! '#6;! ,' ' # %;'!,J%89C K'5'=!':8!& ; ,8 8!, ' !;& ! !6 :: "0.5) J8,! '8B'!K!8!,,+!+!6!(86'"325. J8,! '8 B '!K5 '=! ;! #! 8 ' ,8
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
#:+8(A!<&#:8!7!,!!'<!C
D'! #!!& !! ! 8!6,& 5 +< ' !!& ' '!&!!+!!6!5!=A,<&8!,'!! +8!!8,!,!;!,!,B!6',5
77!!8;&6<++<!=!!;,5
?+=!:,!,!!&8'!6!A(+<!77!7+ ,;'5D
J512'88!K
#:8!%8(A!9; 76' ;'+!'!,@ #=& '+! ' !I 8 ! '+! ' 8!, ' 6+!J8&,!;!,K5$88(A<&',7'!(8;=& 8B!&8=@#!&7!'#=!,!;!,!,7!8 : :8! '=! '# 8!, ,+!+! 6 !(8 6' 7! !! ' 6 !: ! ' 6' +8!+!J%89C %.2K58!,++8,' #:8!, '! 7!+! 8!A=< ! '(7!5 8,! ,=+! !6 :: < 8! :8< +6: !I ' =(,+ 77!, 8 #:8!,5 :8! ,+!!! #A(8!A9 '# + 7+ '(7! < # 8 8+ @ #:8!, ' ',;88 77++! '5 8! ,=+! #A(8!A9 < 8 ' !:< 8,! !!!; '#!+,'!5 ' 8(A<& #!+!8 86'!;'!,+<!'!5$
-./.0-1223 %0-.4% 8! @ !+8 8! ' ;+! 8!,=, 8! P! ;=,5
! #7 ' !6 #!;!, :, B<#& #:8! +!,!;!,!,&!6!,!!'77!, @ 8! ' ! ' 9=5 & D ' 8!, ,+!+! 6 !(8 6' + +8,& , @ !6 ::'#!!,+(&8!'77< 8 #'8!@;+!875 77!&!866<#:8!, +!! 8'+! 7! ; +8( ! 8 8! +!7:,8!8D5
+ ' ,'8!! 87 ! 8 ;=6 ! 8!, ' !; 8! ,;!+! P! +,,& 8 8(A<& 8 8 A= ' !(8 8(A!A,8!< ! =+!! ' !!+!+,'+!:5
/5 ; ' 14 ; 1224& $; +,' ,= AI J%89 C $K& 8+ ' & #,! < ' !6 :: 8!B!78!,'!;!!&+P+<#,#!8 ;88(A<!77'#!6',87&'#!6' =,8(A!<5',''9'+!!M;;:8! 8(A!<!'7 &8(A!&7<#',!+ 8 8!, ' !; +,'%!A,< ! :=6 ' !;!, '8!,5
)5 88!'13+1224& ',977! +! +! !A!76& 'A ' << !! !,5 !! '=! ' "3/5/ ' %.2 ! !6 8,7, ' 8!, ! ' +8!+! AQ #'! J!! !,K& "..512 $('+'',8':8,&!+!6!!&!".2512$('+ ' ',8' @ #& !+! 6!!5 #88,! ' 9;C
D- !+8!+!'5!7'+!+!!,;#6!! '#!'#%;'!,!7'!!8'#+855 +!=!!!;+!=,6'+R='#+8 <,A=<7!@88!!7;5 ;88! ;&!!!'';!'!!5!<#8,!6;! !;,5 ';! ',+!!7 ! ;'!75 !! !, ! !!7877!8!;8'#+8'8!,@!+8+8!5
- #6;! < ; 8 7 ' 5& #; !!, ' ,,+! <& ' %.2& ! , !, !, ,+!+! 6 J"325EK !(8 6' J"325E.K5 #77!;!, ' 5
-./.0-1223 %4-.4% #!8655;!!I'%+P+58,!8 '#,!' 9'!@; @'+8!+! :875 ';57!'#;88%+P+!'!:+! '+!!6,@!!AQ6+='%+P+5 # 8 ' !+! ' ;' !,5 #== 8 ' ' ! !65 +'';<#'8!,7!888O!AQ'77! 8!8,;!'6'865!!@;5
- #,<6 :!!& < ! 8; 5 89 #6' ' !:+!'+&!;!A=<#6! ,< +!< < ! ,!, ,=!+! AQ 5 8,8! : '! ! ' +A, ' !;5 !! 8,8! 86 <'#P!'77@+!!8AQ5#(8P!8;!5 #! 8 +86 <#88! ' +8!+! 88 @ 7 ,A88!<#8!77D5
& 8 8(A< ! +!& +!! ! 8 , @ 77! +! 8,& #:8!& + @ +!;! ' #,& 7! <##8!;,'8'Q'#,!@!+,' !(';8'+8!6;8'#+858!,' !;!!!'+8'8!,5
.25 ','1;+61224&# 7@#,'!:8!! '#;'!,5
..5 '1E;+61224&#,7+88!@!!',5 ( B!8'#!!'.*;+61224'A5 5 +,' 9;<#!!!,P!'!;8!<+!!!!.))3!1220! <# ,! ' 89 ' ' <# 8,! ': 869+ ' !, :!P++!,;95#,!!+!'6,!<8,!8;' !! +,!6< !6 ! < +B ' 7 ' +8! '#A(8% '#A(8=(,+ ,;9& '9 < '69! 8,!8; ! 68 8 !6 < '69! ' !(8 B;,5 7! +! ',B@ ' +9 !9 =7!; 8!, 87 ' 8!!5 ! ,=+!8!';'#A,8!! ;!!!A<,!! !!+! +,'+!:5 ,< ' !!+! !9! ',6+!,!8A(<!8!,'!;5 ;' D;: ,,+!D& A5 '+' ,,;! ' !!'#,5
.15 88! 7 ' .E + 1223& $ !! < A5 #'< 8 ' ; !!! @ !, ! < :8! ' ! 8!<, :8! 8'8 +89! ! ! +8! '
-./.0-1223 %3-.4% #+9A='#,5,<!&$!+<;! 86!5
.E5 ', 88! ' 1. ; 1223& # B!! % ! @ #:8! 8'8 ' & < #,;! ' 8!,'!;8+!<5 ;A&88(A<&!! :8! 8O! 8 ;!5 77!& !6 8(A!< ' !(8::#!B+,!,!!,!+6!877++!=;8 !O8!,!!'!;5&#,;!8(A!<8 !!'!8#:8!' 5
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
.45 ,8 ' .4 B 1223& #!+, ! B! ' !! ;(!8+!;!@',88!5
.35 '+'' 6',&A5 '<, 6 ',<'69!8,!8;&('++68!7!#A,8!8!A A< ; ! ' ,8 7!5 9; <# '69! 8,!8; ! 8 '77+! =,6& #=! '# 6 !! ' 8!!<'=95,<!&#,!B!@':7 8 + @ ' ,8' '#A(8=(,+ 8!!+! (+8!+!<& + ; ,8 =< !5 7!& ! ,=+! 8 8!6:!!!7!'!,8!8,<! 8 +8@88!=,,5 ('+'+68!#!
-./.0-1223 %*-.4% '!:!'#',7!Q(+!<,@#6!'8,588! !!7 88,+! ; ' #6!! '# ,<6 '77 @ +! ! '9 ,5 ! @ #A,8!8!A ; A< ,;!;& #+8='#,!!'#!A,&!++!@'''!!+! +,'+!:5 8!A= !=! @ '8 ! A(=9 ' ; !!& ; ' +9 < +8; 8 8!!5 !I =(,+< ! , B<#@ .4 7 8 B ! ! '9 +8! !=!'!+85 <8!,'!;&A5 !+<!!!+!<8!P!+8!6; !;!,,=9&8!6'#+,=+!A!'=!,8 8 !5 $ 8!& 8!= #; ' 5 ' !& !+!!7<'=!'!P!!,=, !:! =,, ' 8!!5 9; < #:8! #!9= 8 !9 '#!6!, !! +!< < 8(A< ' %& @ ; #!6!, +!< ! ; '69! 8,!8; 8 '77+! =,6 !& 8 8(A<& ',8' ! !! 65 $ 8+!<&',@#:8!' ;86!&;!<& ', ' !!,! ,!& 8,!!+ !! +8! ,=!7<!,';!<+'','#A=' !(8,8;!6'8!,';;!!;5 ='+' 8,!'!:'+!!,!';!'12@42G&!@'+' A,8!<!+&''&'8+!'869+,@ #77 '5 7& A5 9; < ! ',;88,!6<+87'!I&'!:!''69! 8,!8;!<;!+8!'86!,<8!P!& ',!'+8!+!<8!!&<!9,=95
.*5 '1.;+61223&!8!'5
./5 .',+61223&#!+,+!!,=+!5 7!& ,79 88! 7 ' $ ' .* ;+6 1223& ' < % ',!+ =+! ++<, 8 A5 5 ;&8+'5 &!!<'8'' '=! +!< ',B@ ! 7! 8 ; < !6 +!< 8+!!! 8!, ' !; +,'%!A,< ' !;!, '8!,&++#!!!,9=' 5 8!+8! !68(A<8B!78!,'!;&!'A+8' +8,!!;#!886!8!5$9;8 < ': :8! 8(A!< ! 8 !'! B! ' #:+ <& 8<# +!!! 8 ,;' 8(A8!A= =;5 $ ! ';=!5 $ !+ '9 <# ;:8!#!8,5
.)5 $&!=',@B=5
-./.0-1223 %/-.4%
* +)
.5 =;S=!B'JK,!,+'7,!!!,&'9 .L!122E& 6!'&+8,'4B=& '!8,'!!;%8,'!&488,!!.3B=J!5.!5 !43 K5
$!@S!'S,!'.3B=&8 67,', 1*B;1220J ".E2.23K&' =;'8!,&.E7,;& '8!!!=!8+!!! 6!' ' ,= @ ! B= !!& & ' S!!! ' S,!';:B=5
15 7+,+! @ S!5 43 5 . !5 A5 1 & 6 O! ! <'!!!8,;@S!543'8!=,,''! ' ' 3 !6 1222 J K !; !++! @ 7,',S%;'!,'.)B.)4)J%89C K5
$+8,!8B=''S89!,!65
E5 ! !, ;= . B; 122E& !O! +'7! ' +6 '8! ,= ' '+ ' 5 $ 8+!,&8!';<'!#88<'!P!!A,@+9 '88<9=886!;=++!R 7!B'<+!',!+!!8'!J ".E21E2'5.5.H EE4'5.51H ".1)0'5.51H ".1*03*'5.&.13.E3 '506!,7,K59='8,'<!@#88<! ,;'9B'!,;=J "..*)E'536&..1E32 '50H .))/TE*85E.3'5E6K5 S88<' 'S895
#&'!:8!!8!O!8!I!.)))&+8!! '',8I!''+';+61222J75!50/51 K5,<!& '8!,=#88<!'!!!!, '%'<!5
05 !B!,'7+ !',,=:&!;6J!543&4)!32 K5
45 ! != #& <! ' ; ! 8,! ;'!,5
-./.0-1223 %)-.4%
35 $S!50 &S;'!,!'+!'8!,'=&8,+, 8+! ' = ',& < ,! 'S !!! @ !, 8A(< +! 8;! 'S 7+!, =,!& 'S +' 'S '!5 S!!! @ !, S! ' 8 @ ',!+! ! 8 ',! < ' + R !O 8!, ' !; (! ' 77! 8!, ' = ' S, J U % $ & '=!Q V6';';A=&WA.))*&85/K5
;!'B8'&!'S;'!,&''!' & ! ! ,+< ! +,'H ! ,< ,+<6B!;'S8!,7!<S+8!'S,;J " ..2 1*4 '5 0& .24 12* '5 1K5 <S ' S!;!, ' S,& ', ,+< 7! ',7!& ( ' 7' ','S'+,'&'+R8+!!!'S,;8!, ' !; ' S!,, ' ' !;!, 6+! :=6 J " ..4 .EE'51&.24.4/'5.K5
!'#;'!,!'#8!,'=&!<',7' ' !& ! 8 B'#A 8 !5 * ! / +'7!!5
*5 ;! ' S!5 1/ 5 . J' ; !, . B; 1220K& S,'!@!!9S!;'@331-EG+&@'+ ! S ! ;' @ 42G +& @ <! ' ! S ! ;' @ 02G+H'8,6&S,8!&'S89S!51/5.6 & 8,!' @ '+%! S ! ;' @ 02 G +5 9 . B; 1220& S, '! @ ! !9 S ! ;' @ *2 G +& @ !%<! ' ! # ! ;' @ 32 G +& @ '+ ! S ! ;'@42G+&@<!'!S!;'@02G+5
/5 $ 88 ' 6 88,! ' 8;& 8+! ;6 8,'B''''+'J75!53. !5 K&B=#!8,8'9=7+&+'!:+' +96B!;!+('8;&<<#!8;&8 ',''+!@'8!8+!!!'8!B=+!;6 '! !=:5 ' 88! +,': !'!& B= 8! !A#7788,#+6'8;!'< 8 < 7' 8 +,' ! 8 !5 #,,+! ',!+! 8 ; 86! '# 88! +,' #! =&',=!&+!5 !,='&+8!<8! !=:+8!!!7!#6B!'#,!'7,&<88!7' ' :+ +8!& <# 8 ,=+! ',! 8! :8+,&<#!,!,,!68''J+9K&< '8! ' !7, +,' ! ! 7 < '
-./.0-1223 %.2-.4% #:8! ! 6 +!;,5 $ +!! 88 ' 6 88,! ' 8;& 6 7,', ' 8, ' = '!<+9'#88,!!(8'#:8! '88!+,':J ".14E41'5EK5
< 88! ,!6 8 +,' !!!& B= 8! ! '! ! +8! ' 7! <& #:8,& +,' !!! ! =,,+!&''!&@8'8!88!!' !'7<#!@'J ".14E4.'5E6-66!K5
)5 + !!! @ !, 8(A<& < 8;!& ++ !!! 8A(<&8;<;'!,'#!505. ;#!5 / &'!+!%@8!+'+!88+!'!% +8(A<<,<;!@'+'5 '98++ ' ,< '# ,!! 8(A< +'7& ' 8 ++ ' 77! @ 8'A=8#%;'!,&'+!'8!,'= <#,8!+8PA7!8;'6;!,H+' <!:=6'!P!',!+,6B!;+!<8657!' ,!6 ! ' < + , 8!& +=, 7+!, +!& :!;!,<+A,'!;77&+8!!'8!!'5 8! ',!+! ! ' ; < !;!, 8! 6+! P! :=,'5'+!!#:!'#8!,'=,8 !!! @ !, +!& #! ' 8 ',7 < #, : !;!,!;77!H7!68!I!'+'#('#'+!! < + @ 87! ' 8!, ' !; 8!& 8!<+!& 8 P! 6+!:=,'&<#!+P+88!68,!, J ".21.34H$122.85110'516!,7,H75 ".1* 1)/'507K5
.25 #& #!+, 8,', @ :8! +!'8 8 5&+M;:8!8(A!<<,!,77!,8 5 &'8+8 5 " & 8,! +,' !& ! 5 & 8,! 8(A!%8(A!A,8& '9 <& 8 ' !+! 8(A<& ! #! 8 + ' !; ' ! ,+< !'!5 !! @ !! ' '=! (! ,88!,'!;!6::"0.5)!8!, ,+!+! 6 !(8 6' "325E.5 #:8! 8,! +,' ! !+ <& 8 +!<& ! 8,! 8 8!A= ;'!5 !7& #:8! ' 8 '#7+! ! :8! =;!, ' 77! '! 77 #:8!, ,8 <!, ' ; ! ,! 8A(< ' +9 =,,5 9; 8 8 '77!, ' !! #A,8!! '! ! !!!
-./.0-1223 %..-.4% !5 ! '69! ! #A,8!! & !! 6! ' 7,!!'',6B!;78!5
!!'=!8(A!<':8!' ! !! < '=! ' "3/5/ ! !6 8,7, ' 8!, ! ' +8!+! AQ #'!& "..512 $('+ ' ',8' :8,&!+!6!!&!".2512$('+'',8'@#& !+! 6!!5 '=! #! 8 '#' 8!, ' !;&'#;'+,'5
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
$#=!'#8!+!<&88!&;':8!',!,', 8 & < #:8! ' ! ! ++5 %#!!!78!'!;#;' 8!&'9<&'#8!&88=;!,6B!;' !!! ! < ' +8! +B ! <& '#! 8!& '+! < '69! 8,!8; ! #A,8!! ! ,+ 8 +8!6 ; #: '# !;!, !; !9 ,=95 & 6 ' , #!+ 8 , '#,' 8 :8! B',8'+'+!<8!,'!;' !&'=!#,!!8!!,5
!7& ; & '! P! ! < ! !& '# 8! ' ; 6B!7& ',6+! '+, ' !, 8A(<5 6',#77!'+!!'!:8!'
-./.0-1223 %.1-.4% +,'!%!88+8#!+,5 ;' +6 8,!! ; A8!! '8 .))3& < ! 7+! 6!@8,!!+!!1222&!'!!+!'#A,8!! < !O, +=+! ! !A, +8!!& 88! ! <# 8!, ' !; !! ' 77! 8A(< '! P! ! B<#@ #!8! ' !!+! ' #A,8!! 1220 ! 7 ' !+8 ' ,8,!,&!B<#@',+612205
! @ :+ 8!, ' !; ' ! '9 1224& !++! !68(A<,@'!!!+!<!68+!!!8 '#:='8!8'#!;!,!;5
$ 8 8(A<& :8! ' ! ' ! !'!5 !':8!,++9!':+ +8!5'8'!';< '!8! '=! ' !6 :: 8!! ! 8 5 #:8< !++!88<#88, '=!5$8!&:8! '! '9 P! ',, ++ +89!5 :8! @ B! ' #:8! ' 8! 8 ;!& 8, '# !I < 6 ' =(,+ 8 ! ! ' 8, ' !:+8'!',&<866+!!!,!!!;'#!% +,'!5
';=!':88,!8(A!<8,!,8!! '=! ' 8!, ,+!+! 6& !(8 6'5 #:! ',! < ! ,; ! !I %+P+&8,!8'#,!'9'!@;@' +8!+! :875 9; ,=+! <# ! ' ;& # 8 ' !+! ' ;' !,& #== 8 ' ' ! !6& 7!8'77!8!8,;!' 6'86! !!@;5!!<'!!!,5 ! &8 '=!'8!,6'!(86'6'',7' !(8 ;=& 8B!& 8= @ #!& 7! ' #= ! ,!;!, !,5 :8< < !(8 ' 8!, 8 @ =, ,+!+! :!!& +! 7,<++! 7! ; ! ! +! '77+! '65 #+9 ' ! +! 6 ,;' !(8 ' 7!+! '9 #>= '!& '9 <# # 8 +! 8 87!6!8O!=9+'7+::= ' ! ,+< +5 !! < 8!, + +8,'#:8!,'!7!+!8!A=<!'(7!5
#88!!8 6'8'8!'=!8,@!' !!!;!8,!5;!!!7';< !!& @ #:+ <& < !! ; ! ! 8!6,& <#
-./.0-1223 %.E-.4% +< ' !! ! ' '!& !! +!! 6!5 !! !, ! ,=+! ;, 8 5 % !!, #!6!,,+!'!'!!&+P+#!+<# #=!8'#;6!,,+!&+'+8A=+!'#A+5 #!!!''',!!77!!9'77,!''!!; 5 <##,!!+!,!A(+<8+'Q%;& ,!! 8!9+! !' ! 7+, %+P+ ':9+ 75 #! '! 7': ! !!& ;! !+! ' ',=+! B! ' #;& #+8 '#; ,A, ' ;& ,!! ',F ' %+P+& !! 8 !7!'<<!&!!86&;!8'!!!,P!8 !&';!777!8!8'<<!!,!!7!=65
8,'!:+!#!6!,87!!'!',!! 8 '(7!+! 8(A +7!5 #!8'!8+!9!!+9!!8A<&7'!! ' #:8< 8 8(A!<5 +6 !!+! 7 6!! ' !!+9!7'<+!#:+<5
'8!'!7,+,''#:8!' 8!'9P!',,++5!!&!!:8!#+8!8 ;!' 6',5
! @ #:8! ' & ' ' = <# ! 8'8& !+!@' 5!@!,='@88<6! '#:8!8'8!'8+!!6!!'77,! 8! ! '#,;! !'! < 8! !O ' :+ !8 8,,& +, ',8'++! ' !5 & <# #=! '#88, '# ! :8!& ;! ' #!!A @ ' =6 +, 8 :8! 8!I! <#: 88! ! +!, ' '77,! 8,! !, '#:8! J " 86, ' 0 B! 1224& 11/-20& '5 EK5 #88,! ! 89'!'8'B:!8!'8:8!+,'!!: ' #8!, ' !; 8' 8 @ +8 ''! ' ': !: '#8!, ' !;& '#= +!< ! 8(A< J & :8!+,''#%;'!,&' $$XE4-1224&8541K5
:8! ' ! 8,,+! 8 ',! #+6 ' 77!8A(<!8(A<'!8;@< !#!88!'!;'!'!;+5 +8!! '!!!+!<+8!!!!6<!'!6 6%P! ! #=! ' ; ' !& +P+ ! 8 ;'! @ & :8! ' & ! ' ! @ ' !6 8(A< ; ' ,8 ',6 7!+! 8(A& 6 ' , !+ < !
-./.0-1223 %.0-.4% 8,! 8 8(A< 8 7 7 @ 7 @ A'8 +!< ! ! ' +A, ' !;5 8!, ' !; !!&+P+'!;!,'8!,&'!'9P!'+5
..5 !!&! +8!'!86,,7'# !'#;'!, !95
#;'!,:!'8.))3& 5 !7&'9< '+'!!';&8!!,!!;8;!P!,<8 'Q + 8,,'! ',8I! ' '+' ;+6 1222& ! '9 ;+6.)))&88!'#!50/51 5
.15 ;'<8,9'&'+5
-./.0-1223 %.4-.4%
+)/ )(* *+* (* + )
01232-- 4 522 2 67 %# +8
32-
.5 ,;65
32
15 #'+!5
E5 ',88!'1.;1223!'1;+61224' #!+,5
05 !!!'#;'!,!9@+8!'.;+6.)))5
45 !<8,'!=!!5
35 7+ 8! ' <S 8;! 7+ ! 8,! P! ' ', ' E2 B '9 !7! 89 ' 6 7,', J$AYQA7<3&3220 K&8;'+!9''! 86&7+,+!:!5/1'7,', 67,','.* B 1224 J "KH +,+ ' '! '< & +!7 ! +('8;!8!=!'!'+'!H'! P! ', 6 7,', 8 ; 8! 8 ; ,!< : '! ' #!5 01 "5 8,! P! ! 89 8 ' !&;<,+++('8;&';!P!B!@#;5 =779 8,'! ? $ (
87+'8,!P!!!7,:8!<S@S777,', '8=77
-./.0-1223