Apportionment of Damages in Motor Vehicle Accident Litigation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe plaintiff sued for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident, alleging the defendant ran a red light and caused the collision; the defendant counterclaimed, asserting the plaintiff was negligent. The court reviewed evidence including damage estimates, medical bills, and accident reports for multiple accidents involving the plaintiff and determined that the evidence, when viewed most favorably to the plaintiff, established that a substantial portion of the plaintiff's injuries and damages were attributable to prior, unrelated accidents and pre-existing conditions, and that the defendant's negligence was not the sole proximate cause of all the claimed damages, thus affirming the judgment that limited the defendant's liability to damages uniquely caused by the subject accident.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 106 al. 1 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Apportionment of Damages in Motor Vehicle Accident Litigation: The court reviewed evidence including damage estimates, medical bills, and accident reports for multiple accidents involving the plaintiff and determined that the evidence, when viewed most favorably to the plaintiff, established that a substantial portion of the plaintiff's injuries and damages were attributable to prior, unrelated accidents and pre-existing conditions, and that the defendant's negligence was not the sole proximate cause of all the claimed damages, thus affirming the judgment that limited the defendant's liability to damages uniquely caused by the subject accident.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAUsed to declare the appeal inadmissible based on procedural grounds.
Imposed costs for the unsuccessful appeal.
Testo completo
!" "##$ "$%"##%
& '&( ()( &( ) '
*+, $ % + "##%
!"#$"%%% !!" &"'"! ( )%*!"
"!
++ & (( , ! %"%$ -./
,3016,
( -'
17 $#!%1.82"%99:;)< %"=> % "*!1.217
37 !"%! % &#!% 3441 %%$ " "!#% : /4? % : 54?@31 "*!3441 !!%"$7
67 18 #*! 3441 $ $ !""% ;!, %#%%"$#;"!%;!"7
87 ( ! !" $% 5 $*! 3441 "! !%A;!$"""%"; ! %"! %""%";* *!BAB7
57 ! !"$%38C#%!3443"! $%%" $% %"! " $% "!%"" ;!$ %A"%D$ ! %"! # "!* !-"B !%D !" " !%"$ *%"$! !%$ E$! "F7 ( % %"$ "!#% $"%" 54? 32 "*!344461!344164?1!#!%1. "*!3441" 54? % 31 "*! 3441 $%7 !!D$ D % "%" "!#%%" #"A !"%" "!* "- %""% " %7$"%"$A"AG$ !!%"$*%"$!7
H7 "! $%%""""$319$#!%!3443D "%" 99!%" ; B- % *%"$! AG" !9%" " %"!""*%*!-"%99!7 !"%"%#$"%"62H?:!%""862?:AB7
/7 6%3443"!+ $%%""B%!!A%!#%, 9%%%D$D;%#%"# "%":! !%"32C%1... !*%%A%D:"!7C%" : %"% % !!%! D;% #%" !$ 3. C% 1... : "" !%@!7 ( % "%" !$"%" !%"$ *%"$! " B@ 9!;;D%$"%"9""7
27 12 "*!3443"! %D$:;99%" ;!,%#%%"$E%, !@I FD ! %"!%*%" C"%9%!% %"$"!#%:54?A!$7""9%%%D$ D;%;#%" !#;!$ %35C%3443"D$""#%" $"$!%!!"B$!%D" %!7
.7 (! !"12"1.$*!3443"! D%#%" !$>%$ ;!$ 11 #*! 3443 $"" $"%" ""%%! ! "!%""!%D";99"%!%D #%"""G"!D%9%$
0123103445 ,6016, %!7 C"%9%%" !!G" "!#% "7 "%"%" "9"!AA!#"!;$""A$$!%"%# "! !*@ " 99!%" "%" "" 99" A$$!> %$ : ;B- %7 "!%"" *$",*D" D% !"$A%" "! !-"B% ; A%" $A" ;99" %! "!%*" : A"! 9"%A " #!"%A7 !!G" "!#% """$ 54? 32 "*! 3444 61 ! 3441 64? 1! #!% 3441 1. "*! 3441 " 54? @ 31 "*! 3441 $"%" C"%9%* !%A%D ! J 99" "BA% !%D *% D %! ;C"%" > - "< A$$!> "%#" ;!!G" "!#%7 $%*" "%" 99!%" ;"! 9"! #" > %D! % %"$ "!#%7 !"% !%A%D $"%" !%% *%AA!#"% #%"G"!>7
147 ! !"12K"3446"!) $%%""A% ""!A%%%D$D "%"$"%" !%$ %;$3444" D; !%A$"%""":9%"$D"7#!"%#$"%"9%" B@ $"%" *% "$!$7 %% $9%%" %"%9 " B@ *%" C"%9%! %%"% %"$ "!#%7 &!$ %A%" $A" "!* ;$D%%*! " ;$"%" " %!7
117 3H C#%! 3448 "! """$ D %""% !%D " #%" G"! %$!$ *$%A " D; $"%" "%* # #%!""%#%"$ !9%!"!%"% "!%"" !%D7 "9% !% " : ;B- !- "%"% " - "< %""% !9% $A!$* D% #%" $! % #%!%""!#!:;!$"%#%"$ !9% "!"J !!%"$"!%!! %*,G!-"B;"%#%"$7 ;-#%" !%! !"%:99""!;99"%!%A%D " !*@ 7 - "< $A@!" #!"%A%> " ,$*!%$"$ A$$!$ ! ;B- % #%" G"! >!*$ !$ %""% $A!$*7 !%%" "%99%%;""!;#%$% D;"- ""A% %"!'!%#%%"$:54?7
137 (! * ! !" (!#% $% !$A% $ ;!, %#%%"$ E%, !@I (F %$!$ ! !" 38 9$#!%! 3448 D ;!$ !$"%"""%":"$;!,%#%%"$" D;%;-#%"!"%%"$"!%%"%" "!#% " DD !% $%7 >%"%" !"%" 9"! , $%> !> %D!%%"%" "!#%""!$7
167 !$%%5!3448; !9$:;!$""!%":!" "%9D;""%"!%D$"%" "%*##%!""%#%"$ !9% !"!%"% ;""%" %"%# C"%9%%"
0123103445 ,8016, %%"% %"$"!#%@!D;$"%" !%$"!$"" 9"%>"7
187 !;%"!$%%!%;!$9!$ %"%:""$%% ! !!%!38!3448764C%3448%D$:; % !!%!3HC%3448"!:%D 99! %""% %"!%""" ; !% "% % %%"9"%#"$""9"%A ""!7( %"$ "!#%"54?$%7
157 3.C%"3448"!!A%D$"! D;% #%" !# "%" %" : "%" % $#D" $#"" $% "$!A! "!%"%! *!@# %#% DD !$%%# #!"%A7 %A%" $A" ! *! !%" !D;"%""G" "%" !B %A7%$#% D "B$!" %# ,#%@! !%" "!'" $$!"%"D%!%"$#"" C!!<$#$"D% " !$$$%"! B$-%D#-! #!"$*! ! %!,*%D: !"%! D"B$!"7$"%" %* D!"%A"""%# !9%%9%"% B$-%D"- #!"$*! "> %D!- "< !$"$7
1H7 3 $*! 3448 "! %D$ : ; D "%" 99!%" -!$A"% #!"$*!,*%%!7 ( "!#% " 99!" "*!"DE B %AF$B%"- "< !!*!!"- !#%,*!B%9%*"#!"%A7 %"%"%#%"$*%" !%:A"!7
1/7 #% $% 6 C#%! 3445 ( %%D$ D "! ) ;#%" !" !A" ! ""!%*! -!$A"% #!"*!,*%%! : ""%" #"%*%! " D ,% ;#%" ! $D"%9! %"$"!#%>%A%*;!$7 "%"! >B"%9%#%"""9%!"! ;%!"%" "-!$A"%"%,%#%"%9! %"$"!#% ;%"$!$7
127 3/ C#%! 3445 "! %D$ : ; D "!* 9"% !%D " 99!%" ;!$ $"%" "" *% "!<$ ! "!%"" *$",*D"7 " %A"% -!$A"% #!"$*!,*%%! %,% ;$"%" !!" !" D;% #%" !! D" : ;$#" !$ !% "" ""%" ! %"$ "!#%7 !%!9%!$D !*@!%D"%"%" ;!!G""!#%A!$7
0123103445 ,5016,
1.7 18 9$#!%! 3445 "! $%%" $% %"! " B$"A% !$ ! !" "! 7 "%" %A%" !%% ";"B$%":;!%"";AG % !"" %$ : %%"% ;L7 !$"%" $% A!#%"$ !" #!%* B- !%9$!"%# !-"%!7 >%"%" $9%%" "% ;$!-"B! L$"% A!$ ;* ;%99% !$7 ;@ % !!%" 9%! $#D! -"% D% ; A%"#";*%;$!-"B! L$"%7
347 ( ;#% $% 15 9$#!%! 3445 ( "! 9%!%" D ;!%A% -!$A"% !#$A$""%# ;$"%" !%D "D"!);$"%"$C: !$:C"! !" 12K"34467 %%!A" !"$ !"! ! !$! ; %"% ;$"%" "%* %9%! %! !"(389$#!%!34487
317 ! !" 8 ! 3445 ( 9%" $"" ; $% $A@! D% #%"C"%9%!%%"% %"$"!#%>%A%*7
337 ! $%% ! %"% 3H #!% 3445 ; !C"$ ,%7 "" "%#$ $%% ! 9%" D "!* ;$D%%*! $A$ ;#%" G"!*C"%#$% !"!)% !"! "D>,%;$"%" ;!%A%!%D7 ##% ( % ;- #%" ! %! % !"%! -!$A"% #!"$*!, *%%!7
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
0123103445 ,H016,
387 !!%!$%9%"$"";$#"%!D$ !"B$% 9"" $C: !$" % D% #%" " : A"! ">" ; $% D% %" !**" !!! !"@! A!#%"$ #%" % - !!"% ! ;%""7 9%!$ "! ;>%"!#%*!B%A%!%"D%;AA!#%"9"%B!A B-%D"!#%7!*%%"$ !%%$""%"%" "! A! B% !"%% % ! %"% "!#%" ; "%" "!#% "%"7
357 !$ !!3.C%3445;%"%$!C"!! !$9$!">!A"%#D$ !$$"7
3H7 !;% !"% ! !"%18 "*!3445 !!" $!$ D; %%" * "!#% D ;$"%" % "!" % %" * "% @ ! D; #%" "!#%! # !NA$"7 % %!$#%" : D7!;AA!#%" "% !#D%"> "G" !" " #!"%A7 #%" % "% 9!%" #%A%A"C*" %7 "<"$!%"! % 9%%" !9%7 ;C"%" !""%"% ;!%A$ ! #%A7 B@ $"%" !9% "!@ $%* " !%""!@%**!%"7 "9%#%!" !9%;$"%" "!@*!-"799!%"$A"* ;*%";%D%$"%" $!$"7 $"$ 3448 #%" "$ "! : %" ;%7 !D;$"%""$!"*!" !""-!B"; *;$"%"""; "!#$ !"!!D;K"" ;$"%" !%"7 ! B ;$"%" *$7 #%" ! %! #!"%A"B%"7
3/7 1. "*!3445 !%*$%D$> !"%D;%#%" ;%""% ""! O#! > !"% "%%% %%! " 9%! "!;> !"%$%:@#7!$A"$ %*%%"$ $"!%!!D"%%!:""!:;> !"7 !"%;" 9!$ *!#"%:"$A!7
327 ! ! 6 #*! 3445 !%* $ % O#! > !"%"%%% %%!"%:""9% "!&> !"%$%: @#7
3.7 32 "*!344H"!!! !"&> !"%%"!%% %%!7 P"%" %$ : "" > !"% !B"A " $%%" $% B-%D " !$ ""% !A -B%"! " A%A7 @A > !" $ %A"% # !$ !% ! %"$ "!#% !#%A% B!%D ! "!* $A$$!"%9 $!$ 6, 8 "
0123103445 ,/016, "%- "B% ,!#% E!!%" %!F ! %"% ": !9%%997 "%"!%A"%!$ !% ! %"$"!#%> !"""%$"!*>%>"$ !%9 %>"#"%" %""9!-!9%*!-A% $% B- !%9$!"%# %!@" B- % !%$ !% %"!,!%%! A"$ "!%"$ ! %"! " "!* "% !%D E* *!B ABF7 !% % "B% !#% !$%" &> !"%$ $"%" %%$ ! "NB $%"" >"% D ! "!#%! # *! $#$7 - ""A% $ !%# " >% $"%" &%"%"$ $!$ " &!$ A!%" * %"$ ! !%#! "%#%"$ !9% " * "" # @A " %"7 > !" ""%" ""9% D %"$ & ""% 9 > "!%" B-%D " -B%D $"%" !**" !$%" D& #%" 9!%! 99!" % !"" D& !#"7 $% !"%" %"$A!" " : 9%! "NB %99 G % $%"%" " ! !$ $!! B-%D"7 &"%#%"$ >!$ CD&%% $"%" ! >%A%* : !% %> B! ! C! %$"!$ !"%D"!9%B!"!">9%"!%B!7 &-#%" %%"%!"7% %"$"!#%&%34? #%" G"! % % !**" 34417 %"$ "!#% " $ CD&: !$" #%" G"! $%!$7 ! %! "" "%#%"$ $A@! #%! %99! "!%"% : #%! # %"@ B% " $%"" & ""% $% E ! %"$ %*% $!"F &!$ $%" %"$ "!#% "%@!7 ( > !" %! %" " D !"B$% "% &$"99! #!"%A %""% "!%" ! %A"% -B%D7 99" > !A%D A%A%D " !B"A%D &#%" !$#$!&!%A%!A%D,%7
647 1/#*!344H&%"%$&"$"!%$!! !"&> !"%C%%%! !#" D !!" $%" %"$ "!#% /5? !9%%99:&)< %"=>" %"$"!#% @" "%#%"$ %99 "!%"%7 $"" &%"%$ !%"$ %7
617 2 $*! 344H !!" !% %"% ! ! !" &> !"% " %" % !$$"7 !%" !!%! D ! #%" !$ : "%!7 !!%! $% > %D$D%A"% $%*%">"7""$""9%! !B"A%D D&% &A%%" & -! "9! & !**9%*!-A%7(!$"%" !$! ! ""!#%&!%A%$%D9"% %"%%$! <"$!%""AA!#$ !99!"7%D %$*"&$ 344H &$"" "$ !!" &$"%" $C!$7 " : %"$
0123103445 ,2016, "!#%%"%$D "%"$"%" *"!#%!>% " D"!B!7
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
637 !%*$)&"%9!$1.C#%!344/D -$ !$"%"% %"$"!#%:54?"!@A""D !%" > %%"$ C!%@! $"%" $ %$7 ( *!#"% & -! !!" $"%" !$ ! !*@ "$ 99%*% 99"$ #%#%"$ " -% $ %" * #"$"% !9%%""7(%$""#%"&$%!!"D ""$%!"%$"%""""$ !!"%9%"$% !!%"! !! "%#%"$"> !$%$ !$%"!%""$%H%" $%!:%9%"%&!A%"%%"!7 D"% !%* $ #%! % & -! !%" "$ 3441 D !!" %%N" "> "!#% 144 ? : /5 ? ) " !$ D&% & C% $"$ D"%3441D&%%N" %A!$">&% %"$144:/5 ?7
667 !!!%!35C#%!344/& -! !%! !$%$D%%"I
0123103445 ,.016, !" # # $ % ! & ' % ( !
) * # $ +,$ !- $ ' # ' ./ $ 0 !
687 !$!%"!.9$#!%!344/!!" !%"$%7 !#$ D !$ ) 9%" D 9%!! *%,9$ > %"%7!%!!D&AA!#%" " !#D%" > "G" " #!"%A &"" D& #%" 9!$D" & ! ! % "" " B% $7 ( %"$ "!#% "!@ !"!%" $"%" $A" 9%!$ ! #% "" $% "!%""7
657 &%"%$$A"%"% !!!%!61C#%!344/7
6H7 (!$"$A!$:CA!7
( )'
17 " "!$ #%A! 1! C#%! 3446 "!'" %9%"% *!% %"%$A%&!,%#%%"$7!D ""9% & >% !%" $#" : !" &%#%%"$ ! $!% !$$"&"!$#%A! %-%& %D! !%% A$$! !%""!%"%!D,GBA"*$A, !@A %* " #%A! " J 9%" C!%%D" $"!%" " !%"7 % !%" : !" %",% G"! >%$ !A!&%!%" ! $!%CD&61$*!3443"9"% #!$A""%$A !@"""E +164866%71" !$9$!F7
D% ! !#B !$! " : $9" !@A "!%"%! "!%! # !%" & %D !$!# @ C! "!$ #%A!E +11/.6%7H*F7 &" !D% !$! "1!
0123103445 ,14016, C#%!3446%"!%" !@"""#" !%*" $"" "%@! &! % " !$A% ! # !@A !$! " : " ! % %"% !$! " %99$!"% $%%9%$ ! 7
37 "!C"$$%"9! !!%" !%!!"!#*E!"75H F7
67 (;!"78 ;%#%%"$"%%"% %"$A% !$$ !" A !$ D% !$" ; ""%" : "$ B-%D " !#" ; %9%!%"$ A$%" ; % ; %"7 ;""%" : "$ ;" : $"!%" " ! !% %$!"% D ! J "!' % %"$ "!#% -" 99" ! %"$ A% ;!$ EQ, ( A"M R*!%#%#!%B!AS!%B1../ 72F7
#!"C!% !"%;%#%%"$!%"! % " "% $%D " $%T " $D $%D*C"%#;% %"$9"%D;%% !";$#!E + 114 3/5 %7 8 145 34/ %7 3F7 !D; !% ;%"%#%"$ ;!$ $ $%D 9" $9" % - % 9! ! $;!!$%!J !""";$#! %"$ "!#% ;%"$!$ "%#%"$ !%*" >%A%* E + 115 166%73145152%71F7
"%&%#%%"$"&% %"$A%"D$9%% % "! " ! !% C!&B% ! !"7 / " 2 %9%"%"%7
87 >"!;!"73271 #%A!CD&61C#%!3446;!$ !%":!""%@!;%"%#%:HH306?%:%,!";% " %#% : 54 ? % : D!" !" ;% " %#% : 84 ? %T $%*;!$ "; !@;!"73271*% !$"! %,!";%"%#%:84?%7
&"!$#%A!8@!$#%% %9%$"!&!"7327 1 !"%9 : &$B" !" "> &%#%%"$7 ! D& !" "%@! $"%" !$ !#" : !$ @ D A!$ &%#%%"$ ""%A%"HH306?""% %"% !$#%"$!%&"!-!"!%,D!" !" : !$ !$"" A!$ &%#%%"$ & % H4 ? " !" "%@!:%"">" $!%!:/4?%"%!"%#:&"!% & D!" & %,!" !" %BA$7 !#B !%% $# $ CD&! ! C!% ! "%@! &$#"% &%#%%"$ !#" ! #%%"$ D %" & %! 8@
0123103445 ,11016, !$#%% E +164682%7678T + *%$1/%3445 /045%73H "*!344838.048%78F7
57 !"$#"%"$!$E !> %&%"&% %"$ "!#% &%#%%"$ &""%" : &%"$A!%"$ B-%D "F " &%"!"% 9%" &!! $%7 "NB $% %" : !"! CA" ! &$"" "$ " : %%D! D ! " ! D "%#%"$ &!$ " : "%9 % * "!#%!7 "! $ $% "%"" $$" "% ! $"!%! D "!#> " !!%*">%A!&!$E +1353H1%78115168 %7 3 118 618 %7 6 145 152 %7 1F7 $ $% !"""A$$!" !$%"%*C"%#7& !""! """% D% #" G"! 9%" : &% & "A &*!#"% !9% D " "%* &G"! %9$ ! $$" *C"%9%$ !""&!$ ""AE + *%$H %3446/H3043F7
CA ;$!" !%% "%9 % $!"%9 % ; > !"% C%%%! $% "NB ;> !" $"" !$%$" ""! % $%:% %"% !!%9%! "$%>;$"" 9%"$7""%"!!%;$!"!;> !"%C%%%!9%" D ,% "%" "!%"% D; !,> !"% !$ ! "!%* %9%! % %@! #%"7 "! !D ;"! $%%"$""" %%"!%! ":""!$!%" " !"%$"%;> !" ">! %"! !$""% %#!A" % !%! ! CA *% %"!"% $"%! 9! ; # > !"% $% E +135653%76*FF7
D%!#! !*";! !"$%D%"$"!%" ;" D %" %"%A%> %" 9%" ;*C" ; $" %!"%$ D ! !" 9 ! > " D;% ! $A" %$!"% %"> !%$ ! !>%$D;%%"$"$$"*% % % ;@ D !% "% ">" $% " ; !$%"%%""%$%%"%!"9%D% ;> !" %" K" "%#$7 !" ;$$" $"!%" ! #! !*" ;" % ;!%A% - !# % $%A"% ! !"> !"%%*"*%"E +135653%7 61331H4%71"!$9$!F7
(&A%" ! !" $"*% !$%"!%""CA "" %""%! "9%"D&> $!%$%"!%"""A$$!"% " : !! !"% ! "%" !% !"% 9%D%&%":!%!E +135651%76*0"F7
0123103445 ,13016, H7 &!! % #%" &!! : &> !"% "%%% %%! "! &> !"% $% % #! !*"7 ! %" 99" " !%"@!$$!$ !C!% ! !$%"$7
( > !" !!" !$" %"$ "!#% /5? "%#%"$""G144?""D%99"!%"% "" " "" 99"% B-%D " -B%D " " ""%"7
!" &$#"% %"$ "!#% ! > !" C%%%! " "!%"% # ! 7 " !$ & > !"%"%%% %%!D% !%%$!"%&*99"% !!" " $"$ $"*% % % %! $% %" $A" &#% $% "!%"" % #%" ! !$9$! > % & " > !"% &"" D&% 9" $A" "%! " !#$ %, D & !$%"% $% "!%"" " G"! !%" & !"% *C"%#%"$ ! J % " " !! !"% ! "%" !% !"% 9% !"%%@!7
"#!%D& -!""$A"D!!" %"!#%!: "> $!%! : 54?7 ( C!% ! !$%"$ & !$%"% $% & !" ""9% !%% ! """% !@" %"$ "!#% !> !&"A&*!#"% !9%7*!#"% & -!#"G"!%%$:99"$!&""A " "!:""!"%&> !"%C%%%!7
!!" & ! %! % $#% $"!%"% 2$*! 344H "!%"% !!"" &> !"% " & 9%"$""&#%&"! $%%""""$!%"" !"% % %$ " & %% %#!A" $% "!%""7 !%* $ #%" @ ! "%9 ! &$!"! &> !"% "%%% %%!C%%%!7
/7 !" A% !!" &" @ ! $!%! : 35? "%#%"$"">D%"%99%" !#!%!!%":!"7 !" ! %! D !!" !!%" : "! A"! "> "!#% !@ ):/5?7 &" %% $%!&$"*%!%! &%#% B- "B$"%D BM "! -! " $"!%! !" A% ! !%"!%!"%D&!%"!$%$>):144?7
27 #D% !$@!!!!C"$7
0123103445 ,16016,
)'- '&( ()( &( ) '
./010++ 2 300 0 45 6" )7
10+
17 $!!!!#*7
10
37 !C""7
67 %"D !$!"A!"%"7
87 9! !"% D; #" 9!! !! "! !$" !!G" $% 64 C! @ "%9%"% !@ !%* 9$$! E(BU%M!B9D%HH448 F !#%!!"%@!!%" *%9!$">!"723%9$$!! !%*9$$!1/ C% 3445 E +FT $%! !! %" %%D! % "%9 " - !#" !"!%A"!!!""%!T%%" G"! !$ !%* 9$$! ! #% " ! #% $"!%D > %"% &!"7 83 +7 !$" !!G" " %@ % !!"%#D$- !#%#"G"!C%":&#%7 A!99%@! !$%" %! ) ( -
%9! !$"!!G"""%9%$> !"%%%D;:;99%9$$! !% !A!99
0123103445